Intra-Individual Dialectical Tension Group Analysis

368 Words1 Page
bulb-icon

Recommended: Race diversity in a classroom

From the data they collected, they acknowledged two intergroup dialectical tension categories and three intra-individual dialectical tension categories that highlighted Black and White cultural identities. The three main dialectics within the individual emerged from the data are: Blackness-Whiteness, Talking-Silence, and Past-Future. The Blackness-Whiteness dialectic specifies that some African-American students struggle to sustain pride in their Blackness, while at the same time, adopting and learning the White culture. Therefore, this tension may force students to question their own abilities in trying to adapt to a culture they do not understand. Talking-Silence explains that African-American Students because frustrated when they became

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of Schooltalk By Mica Pollock

    996 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Schooltalk: Rethinking What We Say About - and to - Students Every Day, Mica Pollock provides readers with fact-based information to “flip the script” of the misrepresentation of students in the education setting. Pollock demonstrates how race, gender, and ethnic labels can be detrimental to student achievement. She, then, dives in to 600 years of myths regarding social race labels and how they continue to affect humans today. By correcting race, gender, and ethnicity label myths in our minds, we can effectively advocate for these students. To conclude the book, Pollock focuses on how to devise a plan to correct our own misconceptions and foster a supportive environment for diverse students. Throughout

    Read More

  • Analysis of Why are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria by Beverly Daniel Tatum

    1313 Words  | 3 Pages

    One of Beverly Tatum's major topics of discussion is racial identity. Racial identity is the meaning each of us has constructed or is constructing about what it means to be a white person or a person of color in a race-conscious society. (Tatum, pp Xvii) She talks about how many parents hesitate to talk to their children about racism because of embarrassment and the awkwardness of the subject. I agree with her when she says that parents don't want to talk about racism when they don't see a problem. They don't want to create fear or racism where none may exist. It is touchy subject because if not gone about right, you can perhaps steer someone the wrong way. Another theory she has on racial identity is that other people are the mirror in which we see ourselves. (tatum pp18) 'The parts of our identity that do capture our attention are those that other people notice, and that reflects back to us.'; (Tatum pp21) What she means by this is that what other people tell us we are like is what we believe. If you are told you are stupid enough you might start to question your intelligence. When people are searching for their identity normally the questions 'who am I now?'; 'Who was I before?'; and 'who will I become'; are the first that come to mind. When a person starts to answer these questions their answers will influence their beliefs, type of work, where they may live, partners, as well as morals. She also mentions an experiment where she asked her students to describe themselves in sixty seconds. Most used descriptive words like friendly, shy, intelligent, but students of color usually state there racial or ethnic group, while white students rarely, if ever mention that they are white. Women usually mention that they are female while males usually don't think to say that they are males. The same situation appeared to take place when the topic of religious beliefs came up. The Jewish students mentioned being Je...

    Read More

  • Is Racial Identity And Flexibility In Hua Hsu's The End Of White America?

    1491 Words  | 3 Pages

    However, there are occasions where labels could hinder a person 's opportunity. In fact, culture is the newest label that society takes into account the most, and to a minority, the main goal is to embed the roots of the old generation into the next generation. Unfortunately, not everyone is able to be versatile today, as a matter of fact, often times white Americans find themselves complaining about the lack of culture that makes other’s diverse. Hsu points out that “to be white is to be culturally broke. … They feel disadvantaged, and they feel marginalized. They don’t have a culture that’s cool or oppositional” (505). What Hsu really means by this is white individual’s envy not coming from a diverse background. An individual has a diverse background when they inherit multiple cultures. This allows for flexibility when choosing what culture to identify with. Although this may be true for some individuals, white Americans today tend to believe that it’s more convenient to identify themselves with the group that appeals to them based on styles and cultural backgrounds. Thus, being culturally broke meant finding the niche that one is accepted into in order, to obtain a diverse identity. Hsu emphasizes that culture is a necessity which in turn allows seeing the flexibility of racial identity throughout his examples. Hsu overlooks what can be considered as an important perception of how racial identity can be inherited, which is seen throughout McBride. Having a white Jewish mother and a black father proved to be a huge challenge for McBride as a child it can be seen thoroughly when he mentions, “I-thought it would be easier if we were just one color, black or white. I didn’t want to be white. My siblings had already instilled the notion of black pride in me. I would have preferred that Mommy were black” (McBride 419). McBride is constantly categorized into two different groups black

    Read More

  • Essay On Microaggressions

    1062 Words  | 3 Pages

    Eduardo Bonilla-Silva and Sue both demonstrate from their research that Whites do not comprehend the impact of their unconscious biases. These biases towards students of colour in a white-based post-secondary school environment can result in stress and weak interracial relationships. This is an issue since the significance of these everyday actions is not fully recognized and acknowledged. I will elaborate on a variety of examples, specifically the influence of the peers, and faculty.

    Read More

  • Brent Zuercher's Letters Across The Divide

    2697 Words  | 6 Pages

    Each voicing outlooks, opinions and beliefs on a myriad of concepts related to the racial divide between blacks and whites. At times wrestling with conflicting views on racism and racial issues; occasionally drawing a fine line between the two. The contrasting standpoints are a result of elements encapsulating their cultural identities. Components such as race, education, upbringing, socialization, and social economic status. These same elements cause a racial divide among blacks, whites and other multicultural groups. For some blacks the emotional scars of slavery have not healed over time. Instead, it is a gaping wound as fresh today as it was almost 150 years ago. The emotional fallout from this era of American history has caused bitterness, mistrust and inequality for blacks. David and Brent's conversations probe delicate issues ranging from; "Why are blacks so angry?"and "Racial reconciliation." Topics many might hesitate mentioning in mixed company, much less to engage in a personal exchange. The primary assertion of the book; racial reconciliation, affirmed interaction and relationships with diverse individuals is the way to support reconciliation (Anderson & Zuercher,

    Read More

  • Cultural Autobiography Essay: My Personal Cultural Identity

    1328 Words  | 3 Pages

    One’s cultural identity consists of their race, gender, socioeconomic status, age, religion, and so on. Being aware of your own cultural identity is just as important as being aware of other’s. People’s cultural identity defines who they are, the privilege (or lack of privilege) they receive, and how society views them. It is important to understand that White individuals have more privileges than individuals of color. White individuals do not experience detriment and difficulties due specifically to their skin color and instead receive advantages. White privilege is defined as benefits that white individuals have that people of color do not (Kendall, 2012). The following walks through my personal cultural background, how it was shaped, defined, and developed, and limitations to my personal competencies.

    Read More

  • Paradise by Toni Morrison

    1824 Words  | 4 Pages

    Black and Female: The Challenge of weaving an identity.? Journal of Adolescents July 1995 19. 466.

    Read More

  • Comparsion Of Kincaid's Girl And Walker's Everyday Use

    1594 Words  | 4 Pages

    Everyone is raised within a culture with a set of customs and morals handed down by those generations before them. Most individual’s view and experience identity in different ways. During history, different ethnic groups have struggled with finding their place within society. In the mid-nineteen hundreds, African Americans faced a great deal of political and social discrimination based on the tone of their skin. After the Civil Rights Movement, many African Americans no longer wanted to be identified by their African American lifestyle, so they began to practice African culture by taking on African hairdos, African-influenced clothing, and adopting African names. By turning away from their roots, many African Americans embraced a culture that was not inherited, thus putting behind the unique and significant characteristics of their own inherited culture. Therefore, in an African American society, a search for self identity is a pervasive theme.

    Read More

  • Part Time Indian Stereotypes

    1421 Words  | 3 Pages

    Racism, stereotypes, and white privilege are all concepts that affect all of us whether we believe it or not. If an adolescent of a minority can distinguish these concepts in his society then we all should be aware of them. These concepts are all clearly demonstrated in “The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian”. Anyone and everyone could clearly understand this novel but the intended audience is middle school to college level students. The novel’s goal is to help white students understand the effects of white privilege in an easier, more understandable way. Concepts are easier to understand when someone feels like they are connecting to someone they have things in common with, which is exactly what this novel does. I, for one, was always

    Read More

  • Community Cultural Wealth Theory Examples

    1140 Words  | 3 Pages

    “An array of knowledges, skills, abilities and contacts possessed and used by Communities of Color to survive and resist racism and other forms of oppression” encompasses the main idea of Community Cultural Wealth. It is vital to understand that students will step foot into the classroom with a variety of cultures zipped up in their backpacks, and it is our job as educators to make sure that equality is instilled/taught in our classrooms. The second a student feels a sense of discrimination, whether from ourselves or their fellow classmate(s), is when the safe and comforting environment of the classroom begins to diminish. Here I will discuss just how important it is to see the differences amongst students as an advantage

    Read More

  • The Complexity Of Identity Essay

    1339 Words  | 3 Pages

    Black people, especially those who have to merge into predominately white spaces such as schools and work environments, have to develop their identity with not only the need to satisfy themselves, but with the need to satisfy other people’s expectations of themselves. In “Dyaspora”, Hyppolite delineates her experience of being a Haitian while growing up in America. Referring to her experience involving people within her high school and community questioning her identity, Hyppolite states, “They do not see you” (Hyppolite 99). When black people create their identity based upon their racial interactions with any race group, or as seen in the previously mentioned text, culture group, black people lose their sense of true self. Black people, then, either assimilate into the prevailing culture of the society and become “one of them” or become a stereotype-fulfilling the prevalent society’s want for comfort while coexisting with black people, due to their own ignorant and racist claims of what a black person should be. Overall, racism has a negative effect on the identities formed by black people within their respective culture and

    Read More

  • Tripartite Framework

    544 Words  | 2 Pages

    The model led to the development of an assessment instrument to measure the white racial identity. According to Helms, developing a healthy white identity requires transition through two phases, abandonment of racism, and definition of a non-racist white identity. The two phases are characterized by six distinct racial identity statuses that are equally distributed. They include autonomy, contact, disintegration, immersion/emersion, pseudo independence, and reintegration. I find this model detailed, informative and helpful in understanding the white racial identity (Derald Wing Sue,

    Read More

  • Ethnic Identity Reflection

    746 Words  | 2 Pages

    (2014). In this article, Umana Taylor et al. (2014) discussed the development of the ethnic identity. They suggest that during adolescence as the child reaches cognitive maturity the ethnic or racial identity becomes more salient. I thought this was interesting because I tried to think back to the first time I thought about my own race. As the article suggested the only reason I noticed my race was due to the fact that people were starting to segregate themselves. Many of the people I went to school with were white and so many of my friends were white. As I progressed I noticed that I was the only one that looked like me in my "group". In turn, I noticed that the other black children at my school were in their own group and weren’t treated like everyone else. The article states that most studies on ethnic identity are conducted in college, while I think it’s important to look at ethnic identity in this context the formation of ethnic identity happens in a variety of environments. I think it would be beneficial to look at ethnic identity at predominantly white schools with very few minority students. The children that don’t have peers from the same background may have unique experiences and struggles that need to be researched in order to better serve the emotional well-being of all

    Read More

  • Self Identity In Othello

    1676 Words  | 4 Pages

    Self-identity is linked to racial and culture identities. By being perceived as dangerous, a black man is taught to associate himself with ugliness and fear, conforming to the culture of the white society and in turn destroying his social identity. Racism subjects the victims as “immoral human beings, which challenge the humanity and social racial identity of African Americans” (Cowhig 157). For examples, Brent Staples is a reputable and educated man, attending the university of Chicago, but people are quick to assume that a “youngish black man-a broad six feet two inches with a beard and billowing hair, both hands shoved into the pockets of a bulky military jacket seemed menacingly close” (Staples 314) to a woman one late evening in an impoverished section of Chicago. As a black man, Staples understood “that being perceived as dangerous is a hazard in itself” (Staples 310). Therefore, he accepts his treacherous conditions and conforms to white values and beliefs. He destroys his self-identity, becoming a white-face, in exchange for security and safety. For examples, Staples waited to leave a building or enter the subway until the nervous white people around left, walked in the daylight rather than at night, started wearing business clothes rather than jeans, and sang songs depicting white culture such as Beethoven and Vivaldi. The black man conforms to white culture, seeing

    Read More

  • Self Reflection About Racism

    2143 Words  | 5 Pages

    Before, I had a sense of how I identified in terms of many different factors. With this class, I was able to realize that my racial and overall identity is composed of a mixture of the factors not considering these factors independently from one another. I believe that my strong sense of self has always remained the same, the great difference is that I now know why I think the way I do and I am now also able to see why people think the way they do. My story tells a lot about me; it says that I have always had a strong sense of self and have always tried to live according to that sense of self. It also says that I have not always known how to interpret myself or make sense of why I am the way I am. It has definitely shown that I struggled with understanding other people’s perspectives, especially when they conflicted with mine but I am now working on maintaining an open mind instead of becoming immediately defensive. My story also shows that although I have always been well aware of racism and have always felt against it, I have not done what is necessary of me to stand up against racism. The resources I can rely on within me to fight against racism are the coping skills I have internalized for so long. Some resources I have outside myself include the skills I am learning in my Master’s program at Simmons as well as some local community outreach programs that strive to advocate and end racism and other oppressive

    Read More

More about Intra-Individual Dialectical Tension Group Analysis

Open Document