Humor In Elie Wiesel's Night

1558 Words4 Pages

People often shudder at the thought of the Holocaust. During this gruesome time nearly six million Jews, and an additional five million non- Jewish victims, including gypsies, homosexuals, and handicapped, were inhumanely murdered by the Nazis. There was no escape from the brutality of the German dictator, Adolf Hitler. The Holocaust was Hitler’s effort to exterminate any person he believed to be inferior. Anyone deemed fit for the title was lugged away to concentration camps, then sentenced to obligatory labor or demise. Now, imagine this as a comedy. The notion that such an event could be portrayed as a comedy seems unfathomable. However, director Robert Benigni is able to take this occurrence and apply a comedic sense in order to set the …show more content…

Joshua and Guido are abducted put on a train to the concentration camp. Immediately, he begins the attempt to protect his son by telling him the train is part of a surprise for Joshua’s birthday. Guido continues this adlibbing as they arrive at the camp by constructing a game. He tells Joshua that everyone in the concentration camp is partaking in the game, and the first to reach a thousand points is the winner. The winner of the game will receive the grand prize of a real tank, Joshua’s favorite toy. Guido knew this was the only way to preserve his son’s life. Guido’s role is not only to protect himself, but his son as well. An applied comedic section begins when several guards enter the room, and yell something in German. Unable to understand, Guido asks Bartolomeo, a fellow prisoner, what the guard said. Bartolomeo says the guard asked if any one spoke German. Guido’s hand shot up right away, even though he of course did not speak German. This contributes to the humor of the film. Pretending to understand, he “translates” what the guard had said into the rules of the game. Joshua giggles at the rules his father proposes, when in actuality this was destined to be a serious moment by the Germans and prisoners of the camp to explain the rules of the camp. In fact, however, this is another attempt to save his son from the monstrosities of the encampment. Later, Guido finds Joshua in the room after he had ran away from the group that was heading to showers. He tells Joshua to return to the group and go take a shower. Little did they both know, the showers were actually gas chambers. Guido’s fatherly advice is indeed a death sentence. The dramatic effect of the irony closely portrays an essence of comedy. Joshua’s childlike stubbornness essentially saves him. The enormity of the situation strikes the comedic effect. This scene reflects the

Open Document