More handpicked essays just for you.
Debate questions hamilton vs jefferson
Debate questions hamilton vs jefferson
Hamilton and jefferson compare
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton held very different views on almost everything in regards to American politics. While they were both wealthy, well-educated men, they had dramatically different views on the power of the federal government, the economy, and their general view of Americans. Hamilton believed in a strong federal government that would be led by the well-educated elite. He even stated, “Give therefore to the first class a distinct, permanent share of the government. They will check the unsteadiness of the second, and as they cannot receive any advantage by a change, they therefore will ever maintain good government.” His supporters, who were generally Northern businessmen and bankers, reflected these opinions. Jefferson, however, believed that the future of the United States was in farming. He believed in a limited national government and a strict interpretation of the Constitution. The biggest argument between the …show more content…
Jefferson was right to place focus on farming, given the fact that Westward Expansion was only just beginning. While the financial sector of the economy is of vital importance in modern times, farming was by far the more important and profitable portion during the 1800s. Farming would continue to be a significant portion of the American economy as Westward Expansion continued all the way to California. Also, Hamilton held a very elitist view of the government. While it is imperative that a capable, intelligent leader is chosen to be the president, the United States is built off of the idea of a democratic republican government, where at least a portion of the federal government is directly elected. Finally, I agree with Jefferson that a stricter interpretation of the Constitution was needed at the time. These distinctive viewpoints all lead up to Hamilton and Jefferson’s opinions on the national
John Adams and Thomas Jefferson brought many different viewpoints and strengths after the establishment of the Constitution but they both put the nation’s stability first and wanted to preserve the wellbeing of the people first by Adams ending the Quazi war and Jefferson making the Louisiana Purchase.
Jefferson’s presidency was to a certain extent a “Republican Revolution” and to a certain extent it was a Federalist Continuation. Jefferson proclaimed his “Republican Revolution” to help the average farmer and reduce the Federal debt the United States had acquired due to war and to reduce the power of the Federal Government. Jefferson had based the ideals of the “Republican Revolution” on his strict interpretation of the Constitution and did not believe in loose interpretations, opposing Hamilton’s proposal of having a Federal Bank. Jefferson would largely focus on helping the average person, as he would try to support the common man through his decisions. He would try to lower the Federalists control as well as power and give equality.
“It’s not tyranny we desire; it’s a just, limited, federal government.” Alexander Hamilton. When Hamilton said this he was expressing the way he felt about central government. Hamilton and Jefferson both had very different views on government. Hamilton wanted a strong central government and Jefferson wanted all of the power to belong to the states. Alexander Hamilton’s views on government were better for what the United States would become.
Thomas Jefferson has an amazing role in our lives today from the hard work and time he spent to make an easier future for all of us. There are days that some of us could not thrive as the people we are without the appliances he made to make challenging tasks easier for us. Some people look up to him because he never stopped doing great things and never stopped showing unselfishness. Thomas Jefferson revolutionized the world of the 18th century and centuries to come. Thomas Jefferson was one of the most influential people of the 18th century because he was one of the founding fathers of America, he was the founder of the University of Virginia, and he was the creator of many life changing inventions, which drastically changed the world.
Alexander Hamilton exerted the most influence in the new Federalist Party. He believed that only an enlightened ruling class could produce a stable and effective federal government. The government therefore needed the support of wealthy men. Thomas Jefferson and the Republicans defended more the rights of the common man and an agrarian society with little power from the federal government. His basic principle was "in general I believe the decisions of the people in a body will be more honest and more disinterested than those of wealthy men."
During the period 1800-1817, the Jeffersonians to a great extent compromised their political principles and essentially “out Federalized the Federalists”. While traditional Jeffersonian Republicanism advocated a strict interpretation of the Constitution and an emphasis on an agrarian economic system, the actual policies of Presidents Thomas Jefferson and James Madison were markedly different from their theoretical principles. This obvious compromise of Jeffersonian principles is evident in the Federal government’s assumption of broad-based political powers and institution of capitalistic Hamiltonian economic reforms, both of which stemmed from Jefferson and Madison’s adoption of broad constructionist policies.
Your name Your teacher Date Hamilton and the Economy Since the birth of the country, there have been many influences on its development. The economy in particular is an area of great importance. Many people have been factors in the growth of the United States’ economy. Perhaps the earliest and most influential of these was Alexander Hamilton. As shown in his effective policies, such as assumption of Revolutionary War debts, practical taxation, formation of the National Bank, and views on manufacturing, Hamilton was a dominant force from the beginning.
He was bold and persuasive and his philosophies quite extraordinary for his time. Jefferson’s agricultural viewpoint was vastly different from Hamilton’s manufacturing perspective. Though they both envisioned a great and prosperous nation, they had contrasting opinions on how this should occur. Hamilton, a Federalist, believed the rich and powerful should be the central government for all people, as they knew better how to foster and protect the em... ...
Going hand in hand with his detestation of large, extremely controlling national governments, Jefferson was intent on having no national bank present in the US, but Hamilton was certain the country would benefit from one. For example, in a personal letter written by Alexander Hamilton, he wrote, “Mr. Madison, co-operating with Mr. Jefferson, is at the head of a faction, decidedly hostile to me, and my administration; and actuated by views... subversive of the principals of good government, and dangerous to the Union... Mr. Jefferson... [displays] his dislike of... funding [the] debt.” (Doc 2) Hamilton implied that by not advocating a national bank, Jefferson did not want to help the country pay off its debt. Jefferson, however, was dead set against having a national bank because he wanted the common people, such as the farmers, to have maximum influence on the government. This way, a strong central government could not have supreme political, economic, and social power, all of which together would open the doors for future corruption, even if the government was set up in the manner directed in the Constitution. Jefferson defended this judgement to the extent that he formed a political party so it could develop into a well-supported suggestion. Thus, the perspective on national banks could more efficiently progress into the point where it impacted the whole country and prevented the formation of a national bank. Equally, the excise tax proposed by Alexander Hamilton and carried out by Congress, factored in on Hamilton and Jefferson’s feud on having a national bank. In a letter written by Thomas Jefferson, he manifested his reaction to the excise tax by commenting, “The excise tax is an infernal one... [the public’s]
The growth of a new nation can be a great struggle. Our founding struggled to form a perfect nation through the enactments of The Articles of Confederation, The Constitution, and also The Federalist Papers. They struggled to make a document that they could depend on in times of need, and the constitution was the one that really set the line and challenged the government to near perfection. Something can never be perfect that's why the federalist papers were created to enhance the constitution and make it something very close to perfect. All of these essays under the federalist papers were very important building blocks that helped us become the great nation that we are now.
Alexander Hamilton had a huge impact on the development of U.S. He proposed that the government assume the entire debt of the individual states therefore giving the power to the federal government. His debt plan was successful which made other countries to take interest in U.S. He also created the national bank which collect taxes, hold government funds and lend money. This was the first bank in America and was better way to organize its economy. The first step toward building nation's economy. He proposed excise tax to raise revenue to pay debt off. The major one was whiskey tax in which the producers were taxed not the consumers and people reacted to this aggressively leading to whiskey rebellion but government successfully collapsed the
Jefferson’s beliefs in local self government created differences between himself and Alexander Hamilton which created the Federalists (Hamilton followers) and the Democrat Republican’s (Jefferson followers).
The idea of political parties alarmed many Americans. Even the most influential political leaders despised the concept of these parties. Citizens feared that the parties would create chaos and division in the country and would abolish the hard work our leaders did to create unity. Americans also feared that “factions” would develop, like the very hated ones that formed in Britain that would use bribes with the government for personal gain. The leaders of the trend were Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton. These men had many differing views of government, economy, and allies and because of this, they often could not reach fair compromises. In the end, they needed to organize supporters who agreed with them. Defying the opinions of many
There are different ways to think about Thomas Jefferson’s thoughts about power in the government. Some people thought that he was in favor for a more powerful state government. Others believe that he thought the federal government was more powerful. I believe that Thomas Jefferson altered is philosophy after entering the White House.
Jefferson had a positive look for the country. These are the gathering enterprise to put his disposal into collision. The most important risks to a republic were first, high population and the social remarkable it created, and second, the convergence of cash and force in the hands of a pair. Jefferson needed to lead America far from the large scale which this was important to Hamilton and toward an economy established on yeoman grangers—men who demand their own area, delivered their own nourishment, and were beholding to nobody. Jefferson could accept the agreement on political choices build individuality in light of spotless reason and great sense. (2015, 185 Para # 2).