Frank Smith Whole Language Summary

590 Words2 Pages

Throughout chapters five through eight, Frank Smith continues to support his ideas about teaching whole language, rather than phonics. A concept central to his argument is tunnel vision. Smith believes by concentrating on the words or letters too much, students will limit their view or understanding of the whole sentence. He proceeds by discussing how this could be detrimental to short-term memory. The text defines short-term memory as everything we are paying attention to now. In other words, as long as we are paying attention to it, we are able to remember it. Therefore, if a student is reading one word at a time and not taking into account the full sentence, they are likely to forget the word after they read it because they moved on and are no longer paying attention to it. It would be easier to remember the whole that makes sense rather than the individual parts that are nonsense alone. As a result, comprehension is lost when a student is worried about getting every word right. Frank Smith also discusses long-term memory, or a structure of knowledge, a network, to which new information is constantly accommodated. In order to memorize new information, it must make sense. …show more content…

He goes on to say readers give meaning to the written language. Furthermore, sentences give meanings to words; words do not give meaning to sentences. For example, a word could have multiple meanings; one must read the sentence to understand which meaning is being used. Students are able to predict as well as give meaning to sentences. Prediction is a natural way to make sense of the world by asking questions. The human brain predicts and organizes information constructed by experience, not instruction, constantly. Everything we know about the world is a summary of our knowledge. Finally, this knowledge, or when a book is relevant, increases the rate at which a student can

Open Document