Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
The impact of the continental drift
Evidence of continental drift theory
Traditional evidence for continental drift
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: The impact of the continental drift
Continental Drift and Plate Tectonics
Throughout history the continental drift hypothesis was questioned and criticised until a valid theory was agreed upon by the consensus, now known as the Plate Tectonic Theory. The scientific method is a process involving data collection and research on a set of principles to test ideas or hypotheses such as Continental Drift. It is through these set principles where any form of subjectivity and bias is avoided which could potentially distort the results during evaluation. It is also ‘self-correcting’ and flexible as current theories can be altered according to new research and evidence such as the Plate Tectonic Theory. It is what makes science reliable as this approach provides a scientific explanation, hence distinguishing it from the ordinary subjective approaches (Understanding Science n. d.). The scientific method can transform a belief or superstition to a scientific opinion. For example, the Continental Drift hypothesis, with a few alterations, is now in the name of Plate Tectonics.
The Continental Drift Hypothesis began to arise in the early 19th Century after geologists noticed similarities in the earth rock formation. Continents were also a geographical match; fitting together like a jigsaw puzzle.
Austrian geologist Eduard Suess proposed a theory explaining the similarities in the fossils and animals around the world through Gondwanaland, a supercontinent believed to have covered much or all of the earth. As the Earth cooled, it contracted causing a decrease in the surface area and thus developing mountains through the ‘wrinkles’, conveying the image of the Earth as a ‘drying apple’ (Oreskes 1999, pp. 4). Suess also believed that the earth was made up of a large continuous crust, b...
... middle of paper ...
...e hypothesis holding much promise at the time.
With our increased knowledge of the ocean floor configuration and the concepts of seafloor spreading, it has supplied us with evidence for continental drift. The plate tectonics theory came to a gradual acceptance through the evolution of scientific thought and acceptance whereby the idea of mobile continents increased understanding of earthquakes and thus technology to minimise the effects.
It was clear that as Wegener had put forward his theories, most of the geologists had deferred his statements calling them vulnerable as his commitment and dedication had somehow prevented him from accepting the impossibility of his thoughts (Lake 1923). However it was his persistence that had encouraged the birth of Plate Tectonics, embracing both continental drift and seafloor spreading.
Word Count (excluding reference): 1452
Earthquakes are a natural part of the Earth’s evolution. Scientific evidence leads many geologists to believe that all of the land on Earth was at one point in time connected. Because of plate tectonic movements or earthquakes, continental drift occurred separating the one massive piece of land in to the seven major continents today. Further evidence supports this theory, starting with the Mid-Atlantic ridge, a large mass of plate tectonics, which are increasing the size of the Atlantic Ocean while shrinking the Pacific. Some scientists believe that the major plate moveme...
could be used to explain and illustrate that previous theories were not entirely correct (Merali and Skinner, 2009, p.253). Through the analyzation of arrival times of these waves, Oldham had drawn an conclusion that p waves and s waves react differently in terms of being refracted, reflected or absorbed depending on the state of the material as shown in Figure 1.(Tarbuck, Lutgens, Tasa, 2013, p.143). Oldham had developed this theory of the Earth not being the same state due to these effects of seismic discontinuity which are shown in Figure 1., consisting of refraction, reflection and absorption. The changes that are displayed from this idea are; the speed of the waves due to a refraction occu...
Evaluating the Evidence for Continental Drift There are several pieces of evidence certifying the existence of continental drift. They include mid oceanic ridges, fitting of continents, similarities of fossils on different continents and rock matches. The mid-oceanic ridges rise 3000 meters from the ocean floor and are more than 2000 kilometres wide surpassing the Himalayas in size. The mapping of the seafloor also revealed that these huge underwater mountain ranges have a deep trench, which bisects the length of the ridges, and in places is more than 2000 meters deep. Research into the heat flow from the ocean floor during the early 1960s revealed that the greatest heat flow was centred at the crests of these mid-oceanic ridges.
Charles Lyell was a British lawyer and one the smartest geologist known in his time. He was known as the author of the Principles of Geology, which helped popularize the theories and concepts of uniformitarianism. The Principles of Geology was the first book written by Lyell and explained the changes of the earth’s surface. He used the research and information in the book as his proof to determine that the earth was over 6,000 years old. The central argument in his book was “the present is the key to the past”, this meant that to find out what happened in the past you had to look at what was happening now. It explained that changes which happened in the past, were happening in the present, and will happen in the future. Lyell’s book was later published into three volumes from 1830-1833. After the publication, it gave him credentials as an important geological theorist. His book later influenced a young Charles Darwin. Lyell’s influential book led Darwin to follow his principles and they later became friends. Darwin began to explore the changes that happen on the earth and develop his theories of evolution, though Charles did not completely endorse Darwin’s theory of evolution. Lyell was a devout Christian and Darwin’s theory of evolution did not line up with his Lyell’s beliefs with natural selection. Darwin continued his research and beliefs of his own and became a scientist working with his theories of evolution.
About 20 million years ago the last part of the Farallon sea floor plate subducted under the North American plate. This put the North American plate and the Pacific plate into contact, but unlike the Farallon sea floor plate, the Pacific plate sheared against the side of the North American plate. Because there was no plate subducting, the North American plate was in direct contact with the mantle (Tierney, 29). Heat from the mantle made the continental crust more ductile, which allowed the crust to extend and thin.
731‒732). Besides that, until the 17th century, most Europeans thought that a Biblical Flood played a major role in shaping the Earth's surface (Kious & Tilling, 1996). This way of thinking was known as ‘catastrophism’, and geology ‒ from the Greek γῆ (gê) meaning ‘the Earth’ and λόγος (lógos) meaning ‘knowledge’ ‒ was based on the belief that all changes on Earth were sudden and caused by a series of catastrophes. However, by the mid-19th century, catastrophism gave way to ‘uniformitarianism’, a new way of thinking centred around the ‘Uniformitarian Principle’, sometimes also referred to as the ‘Principle of Uniformity’, proposed in 1785 by James Hutton (1726‒1797), a Scottish farmer, chemist, and naturalist. This principle is nowadays well known among geologist and often expressed as ‘The present is the key to the past’. Hutton published his ideas in Theory of the Earth (Hutton, 1788), among other publications. Hutton’s work ‒ notoriously difficult to read ‒ did not become widely known until it was published by John Playfair (1748‒1819), a Scottish scientist and mathematician, in his book Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the Earth (Playfair,
In 1785 James Hutton could no longer credit what the biblical inscriptions were stating about how old the Earth was, so he decided to try to find out the history and what the true age of the Earth. This breakthrough took two men to complete and justify; uniformitarianism is a “theory that processes that occurred in the geological past are still at work today” (Larsen 2017 pg25). With evidence that Hutton collected, he came to the conclusion that the Earth’s surface changed due to natural forces which include the wind and rain. These changes have been recorded from the multiple layers of rock or the strata, that have been discovered on multiple mountains and canyons. From the different strata’s that Hutton gathered evidence from he was able to, “… calculate Earth’s age in the millions of years” (Larsen 2017 pg24). Although this discovery was forgotten about, it remained and became the work of Charles Lyell, he made it his mission to oversee and confirm that uniformitarianism was accurate. Lyell gathered evidence and personal observations that tested Hutton’s idea in order to prove that it is a theory, which he was able to accomplish.
After the Second World War seismometers were installed into the earth and showed that
...t of laurasia, just like most of the other plates. North America,Europe, and Green land all used to be connect because of Pangea ( as mentioned earlier). But when everything started to separate, first europe, then green land, and lastly the North American plate. After pangea was no more and the plates all started moving, the continents started going their own ways, there fore putting the continents where they are today.
The disaster theory, Gould claims, is an example of good science. It has testable evidence and has an impact on studies in other fields of science, it develops further and explains why the extinction of dinosaurs occurred simultaneously with other events. This theory suggests that a large comet hit the Earth sixty five million years ago, causing the cloud of dust to rise into the sky and to block sunlight. As a result, world temperatures went down significantly, the ice age bega...
However the fossil record is one of the strongest lines of evidence for evolution. It provides Paleogeologist a unique view into the history of life by showing the features of life in the past. Paleogeologist usually discovered fossils near the earth’s surface, “if a preserved fossil escapes destruction by geological forces, it may become exposed by erosion” (text book 103). Forbes Quarry Neanderthal may be brought to the earth surface by the forces that uplift segments of th...
Author Holmes was brought into the science community by his interests in physics and geology .Author Holmes got a job as a prospecting job in Mozambique when he was 21 years old. Author soon became a scientist in rock study and proposed that convection occurred in the mantle. in 1919 Holmes suggested the mechanism: that the continents are carried by the flow of the mantle on which they sit, and the mantle is flowing because it is convecting. Author Holmes didn’t use a lot of modern technology since he first studied rock dating over 100 years ago.
Thomas Kuhn, one of the most widely recognized contributors to the discipline of the philosophy of science, raises the argument within The Structure of Scientific Revolutions that advancement within the field of science occurs in a revolutionary manner as opposed to one more progressive or cumulative. Kuhn makes the observation that scientific research is conducted cumulatively where every piece of evidence contributes towards gradually understanding a specific scientific phenomenon (Kuhn, 96). However, lasting scientific advancement only transpires when previously accepted scientific theories are overturned with entirely different, more suitable theories. Kuhn makes reference to the Copernican Heliocentric model as an instance to validate his assertion (Forster). Applying Kuhn’s argument to this revolutionary theory will provide clarity and further understanding necessary to demonstrate how this philosophical approach can be applicable towards relatively modern scientific theories such as plate tectonics.
At the very dawning of the science of historical geology, James Hutton developed views on the earth’s geologic processes and ow they affect the planet unlike any other scientist before him. His idea that the planet’s processes revolved in a cyclic fashion were the cornerstone of uniformitarianism. Although he did not coin the phrase himself, an honor bestowed upon William Whewell, he did form the basic idea that the history of the earth can be explained by what is happening now.
Beginning with the scientific revolution in the fifteen hundreds, the Western world has become accustomed to accepting knowledge that is backed by the scientific method, a method that has been standardized worldwide for the most accurate results. This method allows people to believe that the results achieved from an experiment conducted using the scientific method have been properly and rigorously tested and must therefore be the closest to truth. This method also allows for replication of any experiment with the same results, which further solidifies the credibility and standing of natural science in the world. Another aspect that allows for the reliability on the natural sciences is the current paradigm boxes, which skew the truth to remove anomalies. This affects the outcome of experiments as the hypotheses will be molded to create results that fit the paradigm box.