Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Thousand and one nights compare and contrast
1 thousand and 1 night story
“the thousand and one nights analysis
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Thousand and one nights compare and contrast
Oh Great Jinnee! “Aladdin” and “The Fisherman and the Jinnee” were both taken from the same story. That's why they are so similar.Both are taken from “A Thousand and One Nights”. They turn from being the same when the ginnie's come out. The one in Aladdin is very nice while the jinnee from The Fisherman and the Jinnee is dead set on killing the fisherman.There are many similarities in these two stories mainly because they came from the same folktale.
Aladdin has a nice ginnie. His genie comes out and gives him his three wishes. He also gives him advice and everything he wants. It all goes in the hole when Javar gets the genie because he starts wishing for bad things. Then Aladdin has to stop him he also tricks Javar into wishing him into wishing to be a genie so he has to go in the lamp. Kind of like what happens in “The Fisherman and the Jinnie”.
In “The Fisherman and the Jinnee” the fisherman gets the lamp by fishing and he catches it in his net. He also had no idea what was in the lamp. But in this story when the jinnee comes out the jinnie says his only wish is to pick the way of the fisherman's death.The fisherman tricks the jinnie into going back in the bottle . The jinnie doesn't think before he does and goes back
…show more content…
In these stories they both trick the genni’s, they both praise allah, they both have bad vizier’s and they both are poor. When they trick the genie in Aladdin the first time is when he first gets the geni and they are trapped in the cave and he doesn't wish to get out but the genie thinks he does and gets the out. the second is when Aladdin tells Jafar that the genie is more powerful then him so Jafar wishes to be a genie and gets trapped in the lamp. when they trick the jennie in The Fisherman and the Jennie the fisherman says he doesn't think he can fit in the lamp and the jennie acts before he thinks and just does it. There are many more than this one but I think that is the main
Jafar steals the genie and uses it to make himself evil. Aladdin tricks him and Jafar makes his final wish to become a genie which trapped him inside the bottle. In the end Aladdin keeps his promise and wishes the the genie free and he marries the princess. Although very different stories Fisherman and the jinnie have many similarities.
In both stories there is a cat and a rodent of some sort, traveling accosted a river to get somewhere, the cat ends up in the water, the cat attacks the mouse/rat, and the cat falls asleep. Some things that are different are there is a rat in one and a mouse in another, in one there going to a race and in the other they are going to a village, they ride a buffalo in one and a pumpkin in another, in one the rat seems like the bad guy and in the other he seems like he just made a mistake, in one there is only the cat and mouse and in the other there is more
Like in the France version the god mother said “Go into the garden, and you will find six lizards behind the watering pot. Bring them to me. She had no sooner done so but her grandmother turned them into six footmen” (Perrault). Then in the Iraqi version “Just when the queen arrived with the golden clog but a cock flew into the yard crowing Cock-doodle-dow Let the king’s wife know They put the ugly one on show and hide the beauty down below” (Iraqi). The reason why these magical transformations happed is because of the god mother figures and the animals blessing Cinderella for her kindness. Now that I have told you all the similarities of both stories it’s time for me to sum it
Since these two stories are very different there is only on similarity for text structure, they both have pictures. Each picture goes along with the text that it is by. One thing both authors did very well at was stating facts. Both authors stated the facts differently, but each fact is described with detail. Both authors
The way the two stories were written, it leads to them having similarities between them. Two such similarities are the main characters being are not satisfied with what they have, and they value their pride over anything. First, the first element is the characters
Characters in stories can be very similar and very different. The characters from the book, 50 Great Short Stories, Midge and Alan are both very alike. Midge, one of the main characters in the short story, “A Standard of Living” by Dorothy Parker, and Alan, one of the main characters in “The Chaser” by John Collier, are similar in how they are greedy, selfish, and they both focus on materialistic things.
In addition to the theme, the crafts of the two stories are different and alike. Similarities in the craft would be they both use foreshadowing. (Add evidence for We are Liars, explain, repeat for
You can see from the tales themselves though, that the amount of similarities is what brings them together, and represents the way that the tale of Cinderella itself has traveled, and evolved, orally through generations, all over the world.
A big similarity from both stories are that they are visited beings from the other side, an angel for George Bailey and three spirits for Scrooge. It is also at that point which they are visited they characters undergo a major change in there lives and experience sorrow. After this visit, both change their views on their lives before much worse could happen. Scrooge had a wife that he loved dearly, but she left Scrooge because of his lust for wealth and power. Similar to Scrooge, George has a wife that he loves dearly, but George is in a similar path like Scrooge because George’s job is causing issues with spending time with his family, hurting his relationship with his wife. At the end of the stories, George and Scrooge managed to see how they have changed peoples’ lives since they changed their views on life. Those were just three of the major similarities that make the characters very similar and relatable to each
The Lady or the Tiger and The Monkey’s Paw have similarities more than differences, which even gives more reasons why they are close stories. The theme crime and punishment is what the Lady or the Tiger uses, and fate and greed is what The Monkey’s Paw uses. The stories are similar in their point of view, sensory details, and the symbolism. The stories both go around the development of events that is controlled by character/character’s. These stories are frequently not following the same events, but do have events that are similar. These stories are also not made to be similar, which is pretty obvious, but share the same elements that make the story similar. The symbolism in these stories are shared by one character determining a fate of the after events. The symbolism connects the two stories, because the symbolism leads the theme and story. The point of view are the same view, which is 3rd person omniscient point-of-view. If one story has a different point-of-view, then the stories would be completely different, and would be hard to compare. The sensory details are almost the same from both of the stories, because they both build suspense in the story. All of these literary conceits contribute that these stories can be similar from the splot, but from the
Fairy tales and fictional stories are full of mystical and exciting adventures, but most of these children stories have important lessons tied into them.The stories of "The Golden Fish" and "The Greedy Dog" both share similar themes about greed but are not exactly alike. Both the characters and the plot have similarities and differences, making them their own lesson learning stories about greed.
One being the fact that both genies were discovered. Obviously there are a lot of differences between the two genies, like the fact the genie in Aladdin is nice and actually grants people three wishes, and the other jinnee does not offer his three wishes and is very mean and intimidating. Both genies though did not like being genies and wanted to be freed. They were both in their bottles for a very long time. Another comparison is characters pretending to be ones they’re not. Aladdin would pretend to be a prince, and in the other one the jinnee himself wasn’t exactly performing the right actions of what a jinnee should. Both stories have to do with muslim culture, considering the fact that Allah came up in both of them. A big similarity happens at the end of both stories. In Aladdin, Aladdin himself tricks Jafar into the bottle when jafar is an extremely evil genie. In “The Fisherman and the Jinnee”, the fisherman tricks the jinnee into the bottle as well by saying that he didn’t think that the jinnee could fit his body into the bottle. There are many similarities and differences between them, and many more that I haven’t
In both stories the word Allah is used a few times; the word “Allah” is known as the Islamic word for God. Both stories include a government known as a Monarchy (king or queen). Betrayal is a nothing well known element in both stories; such as the vizier in Aladdin and Duban the Doctor in “The Fisherman and the Jinni” Another thing stated in both stories is that both the fisherman and Aladdin are poor and have to scavenge for their food. Whether it be the fisherman scavenging the sea or Aladdin scavenging the marketplace, they are both poor. A big difference is that Aladdin falls in love with a princess, and as far as we know the fisherman does not. King Yunan also betrays somebody who had helped him, Aladdin does not, he actually ends up setting the Genie
We compare and contrast these to see those similarities and differences easier. Both have the same theme and conflict. Yet in The Irish Cinderella the main character is a boy who has huge feet and in Katie Woodencloak the main character has dainty feet and is a princess. In addition they have the rule of three somewhere. For example Katie Woodencloak has tree trolls, three forests, and three wishes and in The Irish Cinderella there are three step sisters. You might have never have thought as Cinderella as a prince nor as a princess that was already born into a royal throne. It may seem ridiculous to some , but why would the author make Cinderella already a princess or a boy that has huge feet not tiny. Could it be to show their culture, politics, society, economics, language,or agriculture. In conclusion these two stories have some similarities and differences like all stories
Cinder and Cinderella are basically based on the same thing, yet are very different. Although cinder and Cinderella have many similarities like,they both have a stepmother, they both go to the ball yet they go for different reasons.