Comparing Death in D.H. Lawrence’s The Horse Dealer’s Daughter and Katherine Mansfield’s The Garden Party
Controlling the movements of the short stories, death is a regnant theme in D.H. Lawrence’s “The Horse Dealer’s Daughter” and Katherine Mansfield’s “The Garden Party.” Death brings forth consciousness and it excites the need for an epiphany within the protagonists. To a lesser extent, death creates tremors in the worlds of the antagonists. Death furthermore makes the indifferences of the secondary characters more pronounced. Affecting the lives of the protagonists, the antagonists, and the secondary characters of these two short stories, death plays an integral role in the themes of these works.
Lawrence’s “The Horse Dealer’s Daughter” was originally called “The Miracle,” marking the protagonist’s rebirth of love out of death. Mabel, the twenty-seven year old spinster, is revived physically and spiritually after her submergence in the “dead cold pond” (2337). For a decade, Mabel played housekeeper for her “ineffectual brothers” and although she was not happy, the “sense of money…kept her proud, confident”(2334). After the death of Mabel’s father, the family’s horse-dealing business collapses and Mabel becomes “mindless and persistent, [enduring] from day to day” (2335). Distant from her brothers and receiving no visitors other than dealers and “coarse men” (2334), Mabel concludes that her life is like a barren field. Even though Mabel reassures herself that she “would always hold the keys of her own situation” (2335), she has already died a spiritual death – a death that is mirrored by the imageries of the desolate house and the “sloping, dank, winter-dark fields” (2334). Mabel does not have any hopes for ...
... middle of paper ...
... resonates throughout both short stories and it spurs the growths of the protagonists and antagonists, characters who reach new heights of understanding about themselves and others. These characters are also able to resolve the peace with death, the purgative process that transforms them. The secondary characters in these two stories are unfazed by death, thus uncovering their insensitivity towards the loss of others. Albeit tragic in many ways, “The Horse Dealer’s Daughter” and “The Garden Party” reveal glimmers of hope and humanity in the shadow of death.
Works Cited
Lawrence, D.H. “The Horse Dealer’s Daughter.” 1922. Norton Anthology of English Literature. 7th ed. 2 vols. New York: Norton, 2000, 2: 2330-2341.
Mansfield, Katherine. “The Garden Party.” 1921, 1922. Norton Anthology of English Literature. 7th ed. 2 vols. New York: Norton, 2000, 2: 2423-2433.
In Alistair McLeod’s collection of short stories the Lost Salt Gift of Blood; death seems to be a constant companion. Death is important and perhaps even symbolic in this collection of short stories. It is important because it has the power to affect people and relationships, invokes freedom and even predetermines ones future, through the death of animal’s people and the impending death of others.
For this synthesis, I am choosing to write about “The Minister’s Black Veil” by Nathaniel Hawthorne and “A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner. I am choosing these specific passages because of their tone and narratives. These two short stories are written near a century apart yet still share an unceasing ominous and sepulchral tone throughout. The focus of death surrounds each story but the purpose of writing each is different and is obtained with different and quite contrary narrators and narrative voices. “The Minister’s Black Veil”’s purpose is to leave the reader questioning while “A Rose for Emily” has a purpose of surprising the reader. It can be argued that Hawthorne’s use of narrative voice is more effective than Faulkner’s when it comes to telling the story and this is what I intend to prove throughout this essay.
In regard to Telemedicine, Bashshur (1995) stated the target populations and the major beneficiaries of telemedicine are the geographically remote, the institutionally confined, and those otherwise medically underserved, including inner city residents and the elderly. The substitution of telemedicine for person- to-person encounters should reduce the need for travel and the related opportunity costs and other inconveniences encountered in the process of obtaining
Huebsch, Russell. "Positive Effects of Media Consolidation." EHow. Demand Media Inc. 2010. Web. 15 Sept. 2011. .
Approaching the tele-practice roleplay, I was hesitant, with limited knowledge of tele-practice and not being a qualified practitioner, I had little faith this would be an effective form of therapy. There was no scaffold to approach the task so my partner and I used facetime as our medium. I quickly realised the lack of physical contact was a challenging barrier, especially with the roleplay patient requiring physio for their progressive condition. This lack of intimacy made it difficult to interpret the clients’ discomfort, as I couldn’t physically manipulate the body. I found it to be a very rigid experience. Reserves I had towards tele-practice are shared among practitioners spanning out into the world of telehealth. At first sight telehealth
Christine, Darrohn. "Blown to Bits!': Katherine Mansfield's 'The Garden-Party' and the Great War”. Ed. Thomas J. Schoenberg and Lawrence J. Trudeau. Vol. 81. Detroit: Gale, 2005.
Miller, Arthur. Death of a Salesman. Literature: An Introduction to Fiction, Poetry, and Drama. Seventh Edition. X.J. Kennedy, and Dana Gioia. New York: Addison Wesley Longman, Inc., 1999. 1636-1707.
In the short story “A Rose for Emily,” death plays a major role in developing the story. It also shows how the death of one person can change a city as a whole. However, if this story is compared to the life of the author, William Faulkner, people can see how death in his life can contribute to why he wrote the story the way he did. The death of the people is used to add to the meaning of the work altogether. William Faulkner’s experiences add meaning to his work, “A Rose for Emily,” through several deaths and Emily’s ultimate demise.
As humans, we have innate and strongly held feelings regarding what we consider fair. This idea of fairness is held in high regard by many people and can greatly affect their satisfaction in life. Fairness is fundamental to our ideas of justice. There are two concepts of justice that people hold. These are retributive justice and distributive justice. Retributive justice concerns the distribution of rewards and punishments based on what people deserve. This type of justice is applied on an individual basis. Distributive justice, on the other hand, is applied across society and is the type of justice that directly appeals to our sense of fairness in life. Distributive justice concerns the distribution of benefits in society, as well as the duties that come with these benefits. It specifically entails that resources in a society should be fairly distributed to all members of society. Distributive justice is a highly debated topic, especially in ethics and morality. Despite people having very strong feelings regarding what is fair, and how fairness affects our lives, moral theories can not reach a consensus regarding what method of distributive justice appeals to our sense of fairness and why. One popular moral theory that has
Specialists are using telemedicine to connect with patients and other providers that are in rural areas where it’s difficult to have a specialist onsite. For example, there are two hospitals in my area, one is 25mi away from where I
Today telepsychiatry is the most popular applications for telemedicine through videoconferencing (Cash, 2011). It is the providing of health care and the exchange of information to provide psychiatric services across distances through any form of electronic media (Wootton, Yellowlees, & McLaren, 2003). Mental health services via videoconfere...
113- The Norton Anthology of English Literature. 6th ed. of the book. Vol.
Concentration of media ownership is very recurrently seen as a problem of modern-day media and the public. When media ownership is concentrated in either of the ways cited above, unexpected consequences could result such as commercially motivated, a situation where mass-market media is principally loyal to the sponsors. In my opinion, I think it is imperative to elaborate upon the problem of media consolidation and its upshot on miscellany of information reaching a particular market. Critics have raised the issue as to whether monopolistic or oligopolistic control of the media market can entirely be responsible and dependable serving the interest of the society.
Dermot editor of “The Garden Party- Katherine Mansfield” on The Sitting Bee short stories reviews examined the depth of story and said “The Garden Party by Katherine Mansfield we have the theme of connection of isolation....” He goes on to say in “The Garden Party” the story is narrated by an unnamed 3rd person, as the narrator is reading the story the reader knows that Mansfield is exploring the theme of isolation. Also, the Sheridan’s house and gardens shows that the Sheridan’s is disconnected from the rest of the world around them. For example, “Mr. and Mrs. Sheridan tend to isolate their children from the harsh reality of the mundane, workaday world. Entry to the estate is open only to the upper-class acquaintances of the family–the guests at the garden party” (The Garden Party pg. 2588) by setting the Sheridan’s house on top of a hill that could suggest not only they live above others but also but they are detached from the world around
The organizational justice refers to employee perceptions of fairness in the workplace. The decisions and actions and how these influence the employees own attitudes and behaviors at work. These perceptions can be classified into three categories distributive, procedural, and interactional.