Charlotte Perkins Gilman's Kitchenless Houses And Homes: Optimist Reformer

906 Words2 Pages

Review of a Critical Essay
About pp.120-122 in Charlotte Perkins Gilman: Optimist Reformer
The Yellow Wallpaper is discussed by scholars all the time, and Yvonne Gaudelius is one of them. In her Kitchenless Houses and Homes: Charlotte Perkins Gilman and the Reform of Architectural Space by Yvonne Gaudelius, she comments on the feminists’ attention to the separation of domestic spaces from public spaces and domestic economy from public economy. She uses The Yellow Wallpaper to further illustrate her ideas from page 120 to 122. In this article, I will summarize this extract and then discuss to what extent I agree or disagree with this extract.
In this extract, there are three layers of opinions. Yvonne first illustrates that the action that John prisons his wife in the nursery shows that John treats her like a child and that it is a presentation of …show more content…

At the end of the story, the woman says, ‘I don’t want to go outside. I won’t, even if Jennie asks me to’. The woman’s mind is restricted by this house and her husband’s support. Even if she gets a chance to escape, she won’t. Because comparing with the unknown and bleak reality out there, to be fed and took good care of sounds safer and more comfortable. Although she finds part of herself and her inferior position in the marriage during her discovery of the wallpaper, it is undeniable that she lacks the ability and courage to really leave the masculine family. That inability defines her partial sense of individuality and her tragic future life.
All in all, Yvonne gives me a new perspective to read the short story. She provides me a new way of thinking to inspect the architectural space, the furniture, the decorations in the house. I become really curious about what they represent and how they reflect the social reality of male superiority at that time. Also, her article reveals the positive effect and the restricted part of women’s protest and

Open Document