Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Criticism Of Erik Erikson'S Theory
Criticism Of Erik Erikson'S Theory
Erik erikson the first five stages (essay)
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Criticism Of Erik Erikson'S Theory
Movie Review: Breaking Away Erik Erikson was heavily influenced by Freud but while Freud was an ID psychologist, Erikson was an ego psychologist. Erikson stressed that the development of the ego depended heavily on personal and social aspects. “According to Erikson, the ego develops as it successfully resolves crises that are distinctly social in nature. These involve establishing a sense of trust in others, developing a sense of identity in society, and helping the next generation prepare for the future” (McLeod, S. 1970). His theory focused on personality development through eight distinct stages. He believed that personality progressed in a stacking or pre-determined manner, this is referred to as the epigenetic principle. One must …show more content…
Role Confusion is the main stage that can be observed. Identity vs. Role confusion takes place from around 12 to 18. The four boys in this movie are all around 18 or so and are trying to figure out where to go from high school. Ego identity is one’s self-image, it integrates our ideas of what we are and what we would like to be whereas the identity confusion is looked at as failure to bring together previous developments into a consistent self-image. This confusion often results in feelings of worthlessness. Out of this stage of Erikson’s theory comes the virtue of fidelity, or the, “faithfulness to a person, cause, or belief, demonstrated by continuing loyalty and support” (Dictionary). On a more refined level of Erikson’s theories, James Marcia’s four levels of ego identity are observed. The four stages are; Identity confusion, when there is not crisis or active commitments; foreclosure, still no crisis but starting to form beliefs, goals and values; moratorium, active crisis and actively trying to seek a way to resolve crisis, and finally, identity achievement; one has gone through and resolved crisis, and now has firm beliefs and …show more content…
For each of them, the victory had a different meaning. For Moocher, it was standing up for a friend, he knew the race was important to Dave. When nobody else jumped in after Dave fell, he took action. The victory for Cyril was proof that he could be something important after all. He was not just a somebody drifting along without a purpose. For Michael, the victory was a way to stick it to the man. He felt the need to compete to show that cutters were not less than the university kids. Although for him, the victory may have been to spite the kids from the university, he knew it was important to Dave as well. As for Dave, Dave lost the big city race but won the small-town victory. His parents showed up to support him in doing something he loved, and his friends had his back all the way through. He never gave up, he did not need to pretend to be anybody other than who he was from the start, and his determination helped them win. If any of the characters reached identity achievement, or fidelity, it would have been Dave. After the race, nothing more is shown of his friends, but it shows Dave on campus at the university with a group of friends and meeting a girl who speaks
After their parents broke the fight up, they were sat down and punished. Their punishment was they would have to get jobs. Brennan and Dale started to realize their parents are right. These two both went through identity development at this point. Identity development was when one begins to realize who they are going to be, where they are going in life, and how they define themselves. According to Eric Ericson, one must endure eight different steps to truly have gone through the process of identity development. These stages are trust vs. mistrust, autonomy vs. shame, initiative vs. guilt, industry vs. inferiority, identity vs., role confusion, and intimacy vs. isolation, generativity vs. stagnation and finally, integrity vs. despair. Ericson believed one would experience these issues before the age of ten, but would go back to these topics throughout life. At this time Brennan and Dale could be going through multiple of these things. For instance, they were having to make a decision on whether they wish to mooch off their parents for the rest of their lives. They were also taking the initiative in realizing they need to get jobs. A specific stage they were experiencing was identity vs. role
Everyone is unique and not every person needs to successfully master each level to gain a previous ego skill in a future stage of life. Erik Erikson’s theory is derived from primarily an environmental influence. There is data or analysis conducted that offers insight to biological factors that could alter the stages during psychosocial development. While the environment has a strong influence over human being’s development, I believe our genetic makeup can sometimes be enough to overcome previously failed stages. An example would be a person who was raised in a poor environment, only to rise above the pain and suffering to become successful in all stages of life. I also like to think of myself as a good candidate for somebody that failed earlier stages of psychosocial development, only to gain previously lost ego skills in future stages of
Identity often refers to a sort of desperate quest or a deliberately confused search through both a mental and moral experience. However, Erikson approaches this idea as an experience that will almost be a surprise that sneaks up on one, rather than something that can be found. The process of identity formation is located in the core of an individual, and also in the core of ones communal culture. This process is ever changing and developing, but reaches a crisis during the stage of adolescence. At the earliest stage of the identity crisis there is an important need for trust in oneself and others. Adolescents, at this stage, look passionately for ideas to place faith in, and additionally, ideas, which seem worthwhile to prove trustworthy. Erikson explains, “at the same time the adolescent fears a foolish, all too trusting commitment, and will, paradoxically, express his need for faith in loud and cynical mistrust” (Erikson, p. 252). This stage of identity formation is very confusing to youth because of the pull between childhood and adulthood. The adolescent undergoes and inner struggle of whether they wish to follow certain morals and beliefs, and the fear of committing to a specific identity. The second stage establishes the necessity of being defined by what one can will freely. The adolescent is now looking for an opportunity to decide freely on one of the available or unavoidable duty and service, and is at the same time terrified of being forced to engage in activities, which may expose one to ridicule. This further adds to the confusion of adolescents and identity formation. An adolescent is torn between acting shamelessly in the eyes of his or her elders, out of free choice, than to be forced into activities t...
Erik Erickson was an ego psychologist who emphasized the role of culture and society and the conflicts that can take place within the ego. He developed a theory of psychosocial stages where he believed a crisis occurs at each of the eight stages of development. Erik Erikson was influenced by Sigmund Freud, who emphasized the conflict between the id and the superego, but unlike Freud, Erikson believed that the ego develops as a result of successfully resolving crises in eight distinct stages that expand a lifetime. Successful completion of each stage results in a healthy ego, however, failure to complete each stage results in an unhealthy view of one’s self. “Erik Erikson maintained that personality
Erikson believed that people develop in psychosocial stages. He emphasized developmental change throughout the human life span. In Erikson's theory, eight stages of development result as we go through the life span. Each stage consists of a crisis that must be faced. According to Erikson, this crisis is not a catastrophe but a turning point. The more an individual resolves the crises successfully, the healthier development will be.
Erikson developed the theory of psychosocial development. Erik Erikson did use Freud’s order of life span development. The predetermined order of life stages is called the epigenic principle. (McLeod, 2008) Erikson’s theory is in eight stages. (Potter, Perry, Stockert, & Hall, 2012-2014) Erikson believed that individuals need to complete and master a task in one stage before they can move on into another stage. (Potter, Perry, Stockert, & Hall, 2012-2014) Mastering tasks in stages are significant because there will be future times when mastered tasks are put to test and ch...
According to the Exploring Lifespan Development book how the outcome of these conflicts turn out, shows “the person 's ability to learn, to get along with others, and to cope with anxiety (Berk 12).” Sigmund Freud and Erik Erikson were the two main contributors to the Psychoanalytic Theory. Freud 's psychosexual theory indicated that how parents deal with their children 's drives, sexual or/and aggressive, heavily impacts their personality development. His theory had three major parts; id, ego, and superego that each came to surface in five stages of a person’s lifespan. Erikson’s psychosocial theory is defined as eight stages which happen throughout a lifespan. The theory indicates that iside from trying to maintain id impulses and superego demands, to be an active member of society that develops skills, ego is a positive material to
Human development is a highly complex lifelong process. Identity is a self-definition or sense of who one is, where one is going, and how one fits into society. It relates to our basic values that dictates the choices we make in life. It is considered that identity formation is a means of finding oneself, by matching one’s talent with available social roles. Crisis is a vital part in one’s development. It occurs in every stage of finding one’s self and without resolution, may lead to tension and role confusion. Dedicated and influential theorists such as Erik Erikson and James Marcia have contributed significantly to the broadening and understanding
The psychodynamic theory encompasses both Freud and Erikson. Freud believed the three components of personality were the id, the ego, and the superego. The id is responsible for all needs and urges, while the superego for ideals and moral. The ego moderates between the demands of the id, the superego, and reality. However, Erikson believed that personality progressed through a series of stages, with certain conflicts arising at each stage. Success in any stage depended upon successfully overcoming these conflicts. The advantage to psychodynamic is that it encompasses the individual, meaning that the theory looks at personality from childhood all the way into adulthood. The disadvantages of this theory are that it cannot be tested validly. Therefore,
His belief was that each human developed their own personality through a series of stages and these stages developed due to the social experiences that one experienced through life. According to Erikson, there are eight stages and each stage centers around a conflict that has to be resolved. Under Erikson’s theory, if conflict or crisis is not resolved, then the outcome will be more crisis and struggles with that issue later on in life (Domino & Affonso, 2011).
Erikson’s stages of psychosocial development were complex, but simple. It is something everyone will go through and experiences will always be different. The lack of reinforcement to the positive aspects of his stages can lead to quite a disaster. Surprisingly, previous stages are highly influential to the proceeding stage. The lack of reinforcement to the positive aspects of his psychosocial stages can have a very devastating effect on a person. This is because the effects built up rather than taking the place of one another. The effects are quite horrifying, but with the right environment, experiences and beliefs, everything can go well.
Erikson’s developmental theory was very detailed as compared to Freud. His theory describes the influence of social experiences in one’s life; however Freud described development based on sexuality. Another major difference between Freud and Erikson’s developmental theory is the end result of the stages. Freud believed that when fixation occurs in one stage, the problems occur associated with that stage would be permanent. However Erikson claims that the outcome of a particular stage is temporary and can be altered by experiences in later years.
It is the stage where an adolescent re-examines their identity. To be precise, the individual tries to find out exactly who they are. According to Erikson, there are two identities involved in this stage. They are; the occupational and the sexual (McLeod, 2017). The adolescent may be uncomfortable with their looks or body, but with time they adapt to the bodily changes. The experiences of this stage result in the virtue of fidelity. The meaning of fidelity is one’s ability to commit their self to others by accepting other people despite their ideologies being different (McLeod, 2017). In this stage, the person explores the possibilities and starts to form their own identity basing upon the outcomes from their explorations. However, a failure to determine a sense of identity in a society does lead to role confusion (Kroger & Marcia, 2011). The adolescent has not established what they want to be when they grow up. Specifically, role confusion entails a person, not sure about their place in society or even themselves. While responding to the role confusion, the adolescent starts to experiment with various lifestyles such as education, work, and other activities. Notably, pressuring someone with identity crisis can lead to a rebellion that can lead to he or she forming a negative identity. Additionally, the confusion and
Erikson explains that a person’s personality grows in an automatic order through eight stages of psychosocial development from childhood to adulthood (Holt et al., 2015). If a stage is successfully completed that results in a healthy personality and the accomplishment of basic qualities which are characteristic strengths which the ego can uses to solve on-going crises (Holt et al., 2015). “Identity versus Role confusion” is the most important stage in the process of forming a strong identity and developing a sense of direction in life (Holt et al., 2015). The stage occurs during adolescence from about 12-18 years, teenagers explore who they are as individuals, and seek to establish a sense of self, and may try out different roles, activities and behaviors (Holt et al.,
James Marcia’s theory of identity formation was based on Erik Erikson 's “psychosocial stage theory” (Diessner, 2008) identity versus identity confusion. The foundation of which he used to identify, and divide one’s