A&P a story by John Updike, and Araby by James Joyce both share obvious similarities and differences. These two stories main theme is focused on teenage boys who are discovering the differences between actual reality of woman, and images of fantasy woman that are constantly floating around in their minds. A&P and Araby may have been written at different time periods, but they still share similarities and comparisons of both the protagonist’s in each short story. Some of the similarities and differences are found in the conflicts each character faces, use of dramatic irony, and the setting in which each story takes place.
Both of these stories share some type of conflict whether it’s real or perceived by them. Sammy in A&P experiences conflicts
…show more content…
The settings for A&P and Araby are similar in some ways. For example, one way the settings are similar is because in A&P it said “three-real estate offices and about twenty-seven old freeloaders tearing up Central Street because the sewer broke again” (Updike 594). In Araby it said “North Richmond Street, being blind, was a quiet street except at the hour when the Christian Brother’s school set the bus free” (Joyce 327). These are similar because the setting takes place in lower income neighborhood for both stories. The difference between the settings in both stories is that in A&P it takes place in the year 1961, while Araby takes places in 1914. This could be a contributing factor to the way people dressed in A&P and the way they dressed in Araby as well. Also, the settings could have triggered Sammy being in a fantasy world of woman, and even Jimmy doing the same, but having it under control with his religious …show more content…
An example in which irony is apparent was when Sammy said “I quit” to Lengel, because he wanted to be a hero to queenie and the two other girls who were walking out of A&P. The irony here is that they didn’t even care and when he came out of the A&P they were gone. “I look around for my girls, but they’re gone, of course” (Updike 596). Sammy even stated at the end “I felt how hard the world was going to be to me hereafter” (Updike 596). An example in Araby of irony was when Jimmy wanted to buy a gift for Mangan’s sister to give to her at the bazaar she still wouldn’t care for him because all she did was ask him if he was going to it. Jimmy said yes and asked her she should go to, but she had to go to church so she couldn’t make it. That’s when Jimmy told her he would buy her something if she went, which to him made it seem like he was being a hero. In other words, Sammy experienced a different type of irony when he realized he was immature and hadn’t fully grown into a man. “Sammy, you don’t want to do this to your Mom and Dad” (Updike 596). The irony that Jimmy faced was at the end of Araby when he wanted to buy that gift so bad for Mangan’s sister, but only had a few pennies. “I allowed the two pennies to fall against the sixpence in my pocket” (Joyce 331). This is ironic because he wasted all his money buying tickets to go to the bazaar just to see
Irony is the contrast between expectation and reality. There are three different types; verbal, situational, and dramatic. Verbal irony is when one person says something, but means the opposite. Situational irony is when an event happens that is the opposite of what was expected to happen. Dramatic irony is when the reader knows something that one or more characters do not.
A person’s life is often a journey of study and learning from errors and mistakes made in the past. In both James Joyce’s Araby and John Updike’s A&P, the main characters, subjected to the events of their respective stories, are forced to reflect upon their actions which failed to accomplish their original goal in impressing another character. Evidently, there is a similar thematic element that emerges from incidents in both short stories, which show maturity as an arduous process of learning from failures and a loss of innocence. By analyzing the consequences of the interaction of each main character; the Narrator in Araby and Sammy in A&P; and their persons of infatuation, Mangan’s sister
A&P by John Updike and Araby by James Joyce are about young men who are attracted to women they meet based on the their physical appearance and nothing else. These men, however, are being portrayed unrealistically. In A&P, the protagonist Sammy makes an unintelligent decision based on his misogynistic manager 's behaviour. Araby portrays it 's main character as sacrificing heavily because of the influence of an attractive woman. Both characters are depicted unfairly and unrealistically as simple creatures with untrained and impetuous minds. Updike and Joyce have both fictionalized the actions of these males in unrealistic ways that lead one to believe, unjustly, that teen males have no mental capability outside of lusting after females.
Irony is the expression of ones meaning by using language that usually signifies the opposite. There are three different types of irony; verbal, dramatic, and situational. Edgar Allen Poe uses verbal and dramatic irony in The Cask of Amontillado to depict a deeper meaning of Montresor’s hate towards Fortunato.
John Updike’s “A & P,” Richard Wright’s “The Man Who Was Almost a Man,” and James Joyce’s “Araby”
For example, on page HUGH, Red Pollard was afflicted with blindness in his right eye, yet he never told any of the other characters, so that is then dramatic irony. Dramatic irony is when the reader knows something that the character does not. The reader knows that Red is blind, however characters such as Tom or Howard do not. Another example of irony is found on page HHJS, when Red is hospitalized and he can’t ride Seabiscuit, so he gives the new jockey, Woolf, advice. This advice is later determined to be the reason why Woolf lost a very big race. This is situational irony because Red’s advice was supposed to make Woolf win, however it caused the loss. One more example of irony is on page HFG, when Howard replaces the horse as the primary transportation with the car. Howard later comes to living on a secluded ranch with a love for horses. This technically falls into the situational type of irony.
The two stories I chose are A&P by John Updike and Araby by James Joyce. Both stories tell a tale of social and philosophical differences of middle class adolescent boys, when compared to the adults in the stories.
One example of irony found in A Midsummer Night’s Dream is when Bottom is turned into a donkey. He was turned into a donkey by Puck but he is unaware. The audience knows though, which makes this an example of dramatic irony. Dramatic irony is when the audience or other characters know something that a specific character. Bottom is making jokes about being an ‘ass’ because he thinks his friends are making fun of him but he actually is an ass.
“Araby” by James Joyce and “A & P” by John Updike are short stories that follow the social and romantic differences of middle class boys. Both boys change due to an epiphany along their respective journeys. In “Araby,” the young boy realizes his vainness through his epiphany about love and infatuation while, in “A & P,” Sammy realizes after quitting his job over a girl that he too has been affected by vanity and infatuation. Although they are different stories, there are similarities present. Three elements that can be compared and contrasted in these stories are character development, point-of-view, and the role of language.
The main characters in “A&P” by John Updike and “Araby” by James Joyce experience an epiphany. Sammy and Araby’s individual quests gave them a perception of the harsh actualities that come with adulthood. Epiphany helped Sammy and Araby gain experience and knowledge. Overall, epiphany is significant to both “A&P” and “Araby”.
In “A&P” by John Updike, the protagonist Sammy struggles for freedom. He fantasizes of breaking free from authorities and his working class position in A&P. He becomes smitten when he encounter with a girl he calls Queenie, who becomes a symbol that represents his longing desires where he sees an opportunity to escape through her. On the other hand, in “Araby” James Joyce shows an inexperience narrator who looks for an escape since he is always alienated in darkness so he seeks for a "light," in which, he sees it in Mangan’s sister. He instantly became captivated with her, ultimately thinking of going to the Bazaar to give her a gift will grant a secure relationship between them. Despite the differences, the role of romance comes into play when both
An example of this is when Susie talks about how simple it was to sync the watch to a person’s iPhone. This is ironic because Susie mentions the setup process which involved multiple steps, in order to sync the watch to the phone. This use of irony satirizes Apple’s design to the consumer. It is effective in showing how Apple’s innovation is not so innovative because of how complex their products can be to the consumers. The use of verbal irony can also be seen, towards the end of the video where they talk about privacy. In this last segment of the video, Jim the “CEO” of Apple talks about how they take privacy serious. However, this statement is ironic because afterwards he mentions, “we granted a live-stream of your location to the NSA.” Matthias use of irony in this section targets Apple's issue with privacy amongst their users. This is how we see irony be put to use in Matthias’s
Sammy was indeed caught between the two worlds that collided one day in the A&P, and he chose to pursue the one that was not his own. He was able to do this when others were not because he understood both worlds, his attitude toward each were completely different, and his actions were drastic enough to cut him free from the bonds that his world had on him. With two paths to choose from and only one to follow, Sammy took the path less traveled in that small town by the sea. He was, to use his own analogy, a wolf in sheep's clothing.
One example of dramatic irony is when Oedipus is looking for the killer of the king Laius-his father. The irony here is that he is looking for himself because he is the murder of his father. Oedipus knows that he killed someone, but what he does not know is that it was Laius, the one he murder. Oedipus wants to punish the person who killed Laius, but we, the audience know that Oedipus was the one who killed Laius. Also Oedipus married Jocasta without knowing that she is his mother. We, the audience knew that he was Jocasta's son, but he was unaware of that.
An example of this is, Beth says to Sally (who is covered in mud), "Oh Sally, you look so nice today!" The comment from Beth is made out of spite, simply rude and unkind. Sally understands that Beth's real meaning is not what was said. The second form of irony is situational, this form is often confused with cosmic, the difference between the two is minimal. Situational irony is a contradiction between what is expected to happen and what happens.