A Literary Comparison of Robert Browning’s Texts My Last Duchess and Porphyria’s Lover

856 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Porphyria's lover and my last duchess compare and contrast

Most people have fallen in love at least once in their lives. I too fall in this category. Just like any Disney movie that you watch, people fall in love with each other, and they get married and live happily ever after right? Wrong! In real life, there are some strange things that can happen, including death, divorce, or other weird things that you never see in Disney movies. Robert Browning’s literary works are great examples of “Non-Fairytale Endings.” Not only does Browning have endings in his stories that aren’t the norm in children movies, but he also has some twisted and interesting things happen in the story of lovers. In Robert Browning’s works, Porphyria’s Lover, and My Last Duchess, the speakers can be both compared and contrasted.
Initially, both speakers in the literary texts are similar because they killed their lovers. In Duchess, the duke that is the speaker says blatantly that he killed his last wife. As the speaker says in lines 45-46, “I gave commands; then the smiling stopped all together.” These lines mean that he told her to stop smiling, but she didn’t listen to him, so therefore he killed her, thus the smiles stopped all together. He explained that he did this such action because she smiled too much. In the same way, the speaker of Lover explained that he killed his lover too. The speaker grabbed his woman’s hair, and wrapped it around her neck three times, and strangled her to death! “I found a thing to do, and all her hair in one long yellow string I wound three times her little throat around, and strangled her” (Lines 37-41).
In addition, the speakers from Lover, and Duchess, both have mental disorders. Because both of the speakers killed their lovers, it is pretty obvious that they must have been me...

... middle of paper ...

... her! As for the other speaker, the speaker of Lover, he just randomly decides to kill his girl. This speaker was just sitting at home, and although he was upset, he wasn’t planning on killing his girl, until all of a sudden he decided that to make her happy he would kill her, so he did!
Obviously, Robert Browning’s two texts, Duchess, and Porphyria’s Lover can be compared and contrasted. They can be similar because speakers in the texts killed their women, they both had mental issues, and they were both jealous for one reason or another. Also, the speakers in the texts were different because the speaker in Duchess wanted to replace his wife, while the speaker in Lover didn’t. The Speaker in Duchess was also very rich, and the speaker in Lover was not. Lastly, the speaker in Duchess committed premeditative murder, while the speaker in Lover just murdered his girl.

Show More
Related

  • The Role of Insanity in 'Prophyria's Lover'

    731 Words  | 2 Pages

    As the reader examines "Prophyria's Lover" by Robert Browning, one recognizes the complete effort of the speaker to disguise his feelings toward the murder of his wife. The speaker goes through different thoughts in relation to the life he has with his wife. Many thoughts include the positive and negative parts about her and their relationship. Throughout the monologue, the speaker tells the readers of his struggles of coming to the conclusion of murdering his wife and the reasons to do so. In “Prophyria’s Lover”, the speaker is faced with many types of insanity before, during, and after the murder of his wife, Prophyria because of the love he has for her.

    Read More

  • The Book of the Duchess as a Chaucerian Consolation

    2014 Words  | 5 Pages

    Fichte, Jeorg O. "The Book of the Duchess - A Consolation?" Studia Neophilologica: A Journal of Germanic and Romance Languages and Literature 45 (1973): 53-67. Print.

    Read More

  • Comparing Sappho's Fragment 16 And Bridal Ballad

    690 Words  | 2 Pages

    Though they were written thousands of years apart, Sappho’s “Fragment 16” and Edgar Allen Poe’s “Bridal Ballad” each show how infatuation can often be mistaken for true love. In order to do this, each author depicts a character who is tormented by regret. In “Fragment 16”, Sappho points out that power can often become synonymous with beauty. Sappho is quick to disagree with this notion, instead arguing that love trumps power every time when it comes to beauty. To prove her point, Sappho uses the story of Helen to show how a desire for true love can lead Helen to abandon all that she knows. Similarly, “Bridal Ballad” depicts a woman who has made the fatal mistake of assuming that love should come with marriage, not the other way around. By contrasting this woman’s husband with the man she

    Read More

  • Comparing Males in Browning's Porphyria's Lover and My Last Duchess

    1732 Words  | 4 Pages

    The death of the female beloved is the only way deemed possible by the insecure, possessive male to seize her undivided attention. This beloved woman represents the "reflector and guarantor of male identity. Hence, the male anxiety about the   woman's independence for her liberty puts his masculine self-estimation at risk"   (Maxwell 29). The jealous and controlling males in Robert Browning's "Porphyria's  Lover" and "My Last Duchess" possess a fervent desire to fix and monopolize their unconstrained female beloveds. Due to a fear of death, both speakers attempt to achieve control and deny object loss; by turning their lovers (once subjects) into objects, they ultimately attain the role of masterful subject.

    Read More

  • Interpretation of Robert Brownings My Last Duchess

    741 Words  | 2 Pages

    I read a critical article on Robert Browning’s “My Last Duchess”. I confess it was harder to find something in the NCLC’s than I would’ve thought. There was a considerable accumulation of critiques on Browning’s work, but very little on “My Last Duchess”.

    Read More

  • Chaucers Use of Courtly Love

    853 Words  | 2 Pages

    The courtly love tradition brings a powerful romance to "The Book of the Duchess. " The Black Knight has found his true love; however, she has died. Her death is his deepest sorrow.... ... middle of paper ... ... Arcite has suffered and has expressed regret for his suffering.

    Read More

  • Comparing My Last Duchess 'And' Porphyria's Lover

    831 Words  | 2 Pages

    Starting with “My Last Duchess” the main character is talking to someone about the painting of his late wife, the first line of the story confirms this when he says “look at my last duchess painted on the wall looking as if she were alive.” as he goes on we learn that he keeps her painting behind a curtain. It may seem odd that he’d have a curtain over the painting of his wife but it has a purpose, he seems to be the only one who is allowed to open the curtain or people are afraid to open it, this is because when he is talking about the curtain in an aside “(Since none puts by the curtain I have drawn for you but I)”. This makes more sense as the Duke starts talking about what kind of person his wife was, he describes her as a kind hearted

    Read More

  • My Last Duchess Poem Analysis

    1008 Words  | 3 Pages

    The themes within the poems are very parallel. You see the theme of Self-importance or pride and Jealousy contained in both poems. “The Last Duchess” the pride and jealousy stems from the Duke himself due to the Duchesses supposed lack of attention to him. “E’en

    Read More

  • An Analysis of Kate Chopin’s The Story of an Hour and Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s The Yellow Wallpaper

    1045 Words  | 3 Pages

    During the era in which these stories were written, marriages were an economic arrangement which had very little to do with love. In both stories, the couples seem to have an ideal marriage, which eventually turns to aloofness. This could be that ending a marriage during this time was unheard of.

    Read More

  • Women In The Wife Of Bath's Tale

    782 Words  | 2 Pages

    All three literary works seem to depict the struggle between genders. However, as Marcia Adair in The Young and the Restless pointed out that it is hard to interpret these historical love stories without looking at them through the lens of modern day perspectives. We need to take into consideration the time, culture, and society they were written in (6.12). These literary works are primarily concerned with love, courtship, affection, and desire. These themes are timeless and ever-popular because no matter which century we live in, we all have a desire to love and to be

    Read More

  • The Cask Of Amontillado And The Tell Tale Heart Analysis

    857 Words  | 2 Pages

    There 's many minor obvious aesthetical differences between both the texts, like how both killers where men or how both killings where done during the night; But the main focus point many readers may not have noticed was the heart. In both stories the heart is mentioned which

    Read More

  • Love in Lady with the Pet Dog, Anna Karenina, and Pride and Prejudice

    2508 Words  | 6 Pages

    Love has always been a controversial issue throughout centuries. However, it was, and is, still one of the most popular topics in literature. One cannot help but be reminded of Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet when that particular topic is brought up, which is one of the finest examples on this topic. Despite all the literary works written about love, love itself remains unexplained. The questions “why” and “when” is often asked –it can usually be answered vaguely or deeply, but sometimes it remains unanswered. In Pride and Prejudice, Jane Austen makes Mr Darcy, who has captured young girls’ hearts for decades, say “I cannot fix on the hour, or the spot, or the look, or the words, which laid the foundation. It is too long ago. I was in the middle before I knew that I had begun.” which is both very informative and a vague answer, when asked by the love of his life. It is vague, because it doesn’t exactly answer the question “when”. On the other hand, it is a perfect answer to describe the mysterious nature of love. It proves that in order to be in love, some time for each part to contemplate on the nature of the emotion must pass after two people meet. In other words, if it is described as that romantic “love at first sight” it’s not the love that brings a happily ever after, but merely a form of cursed obsession that leads to disappointing endings.

    Read More

  • Compare and contrast Robert Browning's My Last Duchess with an

    1642 Words  | 4 Pages

    only is he a member of the aristocracy but he lives in a mansion and

    Read More

  • My Last Duchess Essay

    764 Words  | 2 Pages

    However, the Duke did not like the uniqueness and independence the Duchess had, for example, Oh sir, she smiled, no doubt, Whene’er I passed her, but who passed without Much the same smile? This indicates the way that the Duchess acted towards other men, and the Duke did not like it because she treated them the same as

    Read More

  • Comparison of ‘Porphyria’s Lover’ and ‘My Last Duchess’

    1236 Words  | 3 Pages

    In conclusion, both poems are very similar on many subjects, but there are also some very strong differences. In both poems, a similar structure, rhyme scheme and meter play pivotal roles in their respective poems. In both poems, differences in the settings, the characters and the tone help us understand what message Robert Browning was trying to convey to us in his poems, ‘Porphyria’s Lover’ and ‘My Last Duchess.’

    Read More

More about A Literary Comparison of Robert Browning’s Texts My Last Duchess and Porphyria’s Lover

Open Document