A Brief Comparison Of Annie Dillard And Luis J. Rodriguez

1023 Words3 Pages

Annie Dillard and Luis J. Rodriguez are two award-winning American writers. Although Ms. Dillard—Pulitzer prize winner— writes in the female perspective and Mr. Rodriguez in the male point of view, both display a similarity about a childhood event that happened to both of them. Even though the grew up in America, each has a unique style which gives us, the readers, a glimpse of their environment, along with its color, sound and culture. Each wrote about an event that occurred in their childhood, during the cold days in winter. Ms. Dillard was seven years old, and Mr. Rodriguez was ten. Ms. Dillard related her experience in her book (released in 1987), An American Childhood. Mr. Rodriguez told his story in his 1993 best-selling autobiography, …show more content…

He writes, “We were constant prey, and the hunters soon became big blurs: the police, the gangs, the junkies, the dudes on Garvey Boulevard who took our money, all smudged up into one.” Dillard describes an open, clean and order way of life while Rodriguez portrays a tough, boundary inflicting, chaotic environment. Both writers want the reader to understand their culture. They achieve their objectives by directing the reader’s attention to the specific details of their …show more content…

Seven-year-old Dillard and a friend were chased relentlessly by an adult—a red-headed stranger—whom she and some boys had thrown snowballs on a cold, winter morning in Pittsburgh. Dillard explains the thrill and fear she felt as she ran from the stranger. She implies a euphoric happiness “for nothing had required so much” of her since that day. On the other hand, Luis Rodriguez’s account is sad, painful and life-changing. The ten-year-old can’t trust anyone in such a tough culture. “Sometimes they were teachers who jumped on us Mexicans as if we were born with a hideous stain. We were always afraid. Always running.” These two writers, though, don’t differentiate much in the way they write their chasing scenes. Both use short choppy sentences when they both want to push the action forward. Such as like when Ms. Dillard writes, “Wordless, we split up. We were on our turf, we could lose ourselves…” The shorter breaks in-between punctuates and creates a faster-paced tempo and quick beat to the chase. Rodriguez does the same thing, “It never stopped, this running. We were constant prey, and the hunters soon became big blurs…” He too includes those quick breaks and puts shorter words to make the story flow more

Open Document