Analysis Of The Essay 'Critical Thinking' By Howard 229nnesch

719 Words2 Pages

In his essay Critical Thinking: What Is It Good For? (In Fact, What Is It), Howard Gabennesch explains the importance of critical thinking by drawing attention to how its absence is responsible for societies many ills including, but not limited to, the calamity in Vietnam. Yet, at the end of his essay, Gabennesch also mentions that, despite “the societal benefits of critical thinking, at the individual level, uncritical thinking offers social and psychological rewards of its own.”(14). Similarly, it is these rewards that, like the bait on a fishhook, often make individuals hesitant to engage in critical thinking despite the resulting harm to both them and society. However, before examining some of the rewards of uncritical thinking it would …show more content…

A shibboleth, according to Gabennesch is “a belief that serves the purpose of identifying the believer as one of the good guys, prominently planted on the side of the angels.”(13). Similarly, indulging in these “shibboleths” showers individuals with various psychological rewards such as the sense of always being in the right and the comfort that, regardless of what decisions they make, they will always be practically and, especially, morally good ones . Moreover, these rewards, especially in our current world where the majority of choices, rather than simply being black and white, are various shades of grey and where the definitions right or wrong can change in a heartbeat, can be exceptionally appealing, particularly to those those in legal, military, and government professions whose lives revolve around making difficult decisions. However, these rewards come at the price of an individual’s ability to examine one’s actions and determine, based on facts, whether they are really acting as one of the “good guys”. Likewise, individuals willingly paying this price have caused some of the greatest tragedies in human history, ranging from murders to massacres to even holocausts. Yet, despite the fact that I personally believe that a some of these tragedies could be avoided if the individuals in question had taken even a moment to think critically about their actions I also do not doubt that it is difficult to turn away from the rewards of uncritical thinking. After all, rejecting uncritical thinking, especially when it is related to such concepts and shibboleths, puts an individual in an awkward position where they again have to constantly question their own motives and actions as well as the motives and actions of others. The world around them, which had previously seemed so neatly ordered and structured, suddenly becomes chaotic and jumbled. However, from this chaos emerges an

Open Document