More handpicked essays just for you.
Comparison of book and movie great gatsby
Comparison of book and movie great gatsby
Comparison of book and movie great gatsby
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
There similarities and differences from the film and the novel of The Great Gatsby. The characters, settings, and events vary in some ways. They are also very similar in some ways.
Nick Carroway Gatsby’s best friend, was pretty much the same in both the novel and in the film. He just did some things different. In the book when Gatsby meets Daisy at Nick’s house, Nick leaves and goes to town to leave them alone. In the film he just goes out on the porch and leaves them inside. In the film Nick is in love with Jordan. In the film he doesn’t have much to do with her, he seems like he doesn’t really care about her.
Gatsby does not change very much either. He is a good looking rich man. He made his money in both the film and novel. He came from new money. In the film he is more unknown about his life in the film. He is very much in love with Daisy in both stories. He is a nice and friendly person and there isn’t much change in him from the novel to the film.
…show more content…
I think she is selfish in both, but more so in the film than the novel. She acts like she is higher up than others, she doesn’t have manners and she lacks self control. She didn’t really care about Gatsby either. If she actually cared Gatsby would have never been killed. She was also heartless in both, she claimed to have loved Gatsby, but then didn’t care when Mr. Wilson killed
In both the novel and the film, similarities can be made between all of the characters, especially Nick and Gatsby. As stated by the character named Nick in the novel, “I am one of the few honest
Fences and The Great Gatsby both have many characters that plays a significant role in the story. Both stories also have characters in the story that has changed due to the past or are changing throughout the story. There were many character changes in The Great Gatsby and Fences. For example, Troy leaving his family as a kid due to his father kicking him out the house at the age fourteen. This was a major change for Troy, because this act made Troy treat his family an unusual way people would usually treat their love ones. Troy is the protagonist in the book Fences. Troy is the father of Lyons and Cory, and husband of Rose. Switching to some examples from the Great Gatsby is when Daisy loved Gatsby during the war, then started to love someone
Never before have I seen or have other characters told stories of Gatsby showing such feelings, towards anyone or anything. He had always seemed to me just a man who thought nothing personal for the people around him. He had money and he wanted to show it off, or at least that is what was portrayed to me. It was surprising to me to see him feel nervous and worried about what Daisy thought about him.
Although most of the characters were portrayed the best that they could be, Daisy was not. In the book Daisy is said to have “The voice of money” (Fitzgerald 127). However, in the movie she talks more sweetly and not at all how I expected her to be played. In the novel, Gatsby’s father shows up to the funeral and shows Nick the journal that Gatsby had had when he was younger and talks about how proud he is of Gatsby but unlike the novel, the movie does not have this scene (Fitzgerald 180-182). However, the movie shows that no one came to Gatsby’s funeral except all the paparazzi that showed up to take pictures of him in his casket (The Great Gatsby). I feel this should have really been included because it showed a little more insight into the life of Jay Gatsby. The last and final difference I have about this comparison is about the scene where Daisy is going to visit Nick for tea. The book really did not include many details about how Nick’s house looked after Gatsby had sent everyone over to “get it ready” (Fitzgerald 89-90). When this scene occurred in the movie, I was really thrown off because of how decorated it was. Especially all the flowers that had been brought over to Nick’s house. It was filled to the brim with flowers which made the scene more awkward than it should have
Dreams are goals in life where people aspire to execute their passionate desire to an extent where it motivates them, allowing many to grasp their objectives (Dictionary). However, the dream can consume someone’s thoughts and acts, altering their persona. The nature of each protagonist in the novel, The Great Gatsby by Scott Fitzgerald, and in the film American Gangster by Ridley Scott, were very similar due to the fact that their dreams destroyed their character. The protagonist in The Great Gatsby, Jay Gatsby, first aspired to become a rich man. In efforts of fulfilling his desires, his own dream destructed his emotional conscious. Similarly, the main character of American Gangster, Frank Lucas was destructed, but by immorality and wrongdoing
The novel’s main protagonist, Nick Carraway, came from a sophisticated family; however, they didn’t have enough money to be labeled as “Old Money”. Still, in the book, Nick was more stiff-necked and at times, pretentious than his film counterpart. He shows his pretentious ways when he constantly refers to blacks as “Negroes”. He was also very observant, and he wasn’t very playful. His film counterpart, however, is far more playful. He literally jumps on top his cousin, Daisy! “Novel Nick” wouldn’t do such a thing. Also,“Novel Nick” was very judgemental. His film counterpart, however, isn’t as judgemental. In fact, we hear Nick’s inner thoughts more in the novel. The film calls for more spoken interaction between characters, so “Film Nick” doesn’t get the chance to be as judgemental. Lastly, the most striking contrast between the two appeared within the first five minutes of the movie. Nick is obviously adjudicated insane, and he is talking to his psychiatrist. On his psychiatrist’s paper, it says that Nick has a slew of issues, such as being “Morbidly Alcoholic” and having “Random Fits of Anger.” He is telling the story of Gatsby to his psychiatrist. In the novel, there was no reason for Nick telling the sto...
A small change that one can catch is the color of Daisy’s hair. In the novel it is described as brown while in the film her hair appears to be blond. Not only is her hair changed, but her personality seems to come off tepid in Luhrmann's work. Rather than carrying a “voice like money” she follows a “damsel in distress” role. In the book she is shallow and selfish and the audience feels no sypathy for her character.At one point she cries about missing out on Gatsby’s wealth and says, “It makes me sad I have never seen such beautiful shirts before”(Fitzgeralrd 92).In the film she is portrayed less materialistic and more romantic with Gatsby.Instead of crying because she missed out on Gatsby’s wealth, she cries due to their missed time.Her athlete
Nick Carroway is not a very judgmental person, in fact, he himself states that he withholds judgment so that he can get the entire story out of the person to whom he is listening. To say that Nick is both approving and disapproving is not suspiring, for Nick rarely looks at things from only one perspective. Nick finds Gatsby to be ignorantly honest, in that Gatsby could not fathom the idea of saying something without really meaning it. He respects Gatsby for his determination to fit in with the East Egg crowd, though Gatsby does not realize that he does not really fit in with them. On the other hand, Nick sees Gatsby to be excessively flashy and, in the words of Holden Caulfield, 'phony.' Gatsby's whole life is a lie from the moment he left behind the name James Gatz and became Jay Gatsby. Gatsby lies about his past to try to have people perceive him as an 'old money' guy when that really is not necessary. Gatsby's valiant efforts to lure Daisy are respectable, yet they show Gatsby's failure to accept reality and give up on his long lost dream.
Though there is an exception to this, Leonardo DiCaprio did portray Jay Gatsby properly. The only problem with his character in the movie was that when he died no one shows respect come to the funeral, but in the book, his father comes and gives Nick some insight to the real James Gatz. The book was thoroughly quoted, but in times the quotes were cut and replaced with other translations of the actual line. That removes a lot of depth from certain quotes and scenes. Nick says he found Jordan “frightening” at first, which is not a word he uses to describe her in the book.
An example is when Nick proves his non- judgemental attitude by not judging anyone in the movie. For example when Tom brings up the book about white supremacy he keeps his mouth shut, and his thoughts to himself even though he knows Tom is a fool. Just like the book he is a modest character with good morals and treats everyone with respect to a certain extent. Although in the film Nick isn’t as big as a narrator as in the book so it takes away from Fitzgeralds portrayal of Nick because it is not truly Fitzgerald speaking as Nick it is more Nick the character talking about his opinions. As for Gatsby he is exactly the same in the movie as he is in the book and clearly depicts what Fitzgerald envisions himself being.
is Nick. In the novel Nick is a man who comes from a poor family who
Nick Carraway (Toby Maguire) helps reunite lost loves Jay Gatsby, his neighbour (Leonardo DiCarprio), and Daisy Buchanan, his cousin (Carey Mulligan). Only in Baz Luhrmann’s adaptation, Carraway tells the story from inside a quarantined hospital, where he is taken to writing it all down as a form of therapy. Fitzgerald’s Nick refers to Gatsby as “the man who gives his name to this novel”, so the form of The Great Gatsby text written by Nick is almost the same as Luhrmann’s film and he expresses deeper into the story than Fitzgerald. In the film, Luhrmann showed us how Nick was writing the tale by hand, then typing, and finally amassing his completed manuscript. He gives the name Gatsby at first, but then changes it to “The Great Gatsby”, which adds embellishment to the title.... ...
Movies can enhance the experience of a story, but they aren’t always completely accurate to the book. The movie, The Great Gatsby, by Baz Luhrmann, is a good representation of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel; however, there are quite a few differences between the two. Some differences include; the portrayal of the characters, the importance of symbolism, and events that were either added or taken out of the movie.
For example, Leonardo Dicaprio’s character of Gatsby was focused on emotions. I enjoyed that Redford was very calm and cool about everything and the way he approached the character but, Dicaprio made such an open and outgoing character which made the movie more entertaining. DiCaprio captured Gatsby’s intensity and charm and brought out the crazy mood swings and took his character and the audience to a more emotional place. Both Robert Redford and Leonardo DiCaprio had their own way of approaching the character and really selling Gatsby but Leonardo DiCaprios was better. Another reason I prefer the 2013 version of the 74’ is because of the bond and friendship Nick Carraway played by Tobey Maguire and Gatsby had MaGuire was able to bring a true and strong meaning to their friendship that made his and Gatsby’s bond feel organic and real and you were able to see that clearly unlike with Waterston where you just saw the friendship and didn’t feel any emotion. But I felt much more of a connection with his character than I did with the ’74 version. If you have read the book and seen the original film, then you understood where Nick was coming from in the scene where he was furious with Gatsby, after he believe he killed Myrtle only to find out that Gatsby wasn’t the one driving the car that killed Mrytle, MaGuire, did a fantastic job in showing his emotions and how what happened to Myrtle and the person that killed Myrtle affected him. I loved that Nick was a lot more real in this movie. He didn’t hold back and he gave the audience a reaction that anyone in life would have had if they were in his situation. Nick had the major issue of being dragged into situations because of people he knows. I thought Maguire did a great job of showing ...
Benjamin Disraeli once said, “the magic of first love is the ignorance that it can never end”. In similar ways, F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel The Great Gatsby and the film The Notebook directed by Nick Cassavetes both share a similar love story producing the idea that first love never dies. Both the novel and the film present the idea of a lower class man falling in love with a wealthy woman. Neither of the men are able to stay with the women due to disapproval. When the men finally reconnect with the women, they realize they are already in a new relationship. Although the women are in different relationships, they know they are still in love with their first love, leaving a conflict for them in the current relationship