Comparison Of Loom And Spindle: A Summary

747 Words2 Pages

When envisioning what factory work is like today, the picture we paint in our minds eye is often not a pleasant one; it is one of back-breaking work, loud and dangerous machines, child laborers, low wages. A sweatshop. A job only taken if one has no other choice. However, taking a look into the formative years of the industrial factory system shows that this was not always the case. Through Harriet Robinson’s Loom and Spindle, which gives a firsthand account of life as an early factory worker, it becomes clear that the Lowell mills in Massachusetts and its workers were often at the forefront of both industry and academia. Despite this fact, the Mary Paul letters present a much more similar image to the factory life that is seen today, in spite …show more content…

By this time, in 1845, the Lowell mills had long since gained a reputation as a favorable place to work for women, who at the time were excluded from many other occupations. Mary Paul had evidently heard of the prosperity the mills had granted other women who had gotten their start there, like Harriet Robinson, and believed it would provide her with the same (Paul 9/13/1845). Although her optimism remains - even if it does dim slightly - throughout her next few letters, by 1848 Mary Paul resolves to leave the mills as she cannot stand working long hours while taking a pay cut in favor of living and working at a Phalanx that promised equal pay between the men and women there for more reasonable work (Paul 127-131, …show more content…

Harriet Robinson, who worked at the mills from 1834 to 1848, began working at the Lowell mills at the age of ten after her family had migrated there out of economic necessity so that her mother could work at a boarding house there; Mary Paul was attracted to the mills as a young adult by the promise of high wages and individual economic gain (Robinson 28-29, Dublin 122). Harriet Robinson, although having to work longer hours than Mary Paul, worked only a quarter out of every hour. Mary Paul was expected to work the entirety of her time at the mills each day. Robinson was given the rest of the her time to play or learn with the other girls in the factory, while Mary Paul did not indicate that she had time for leisurely or scholarly activities. Perhaps the most significant difference was the environment of the mill itself. In its early days, when Robinson was a worker there, the mills advertised better pay than most other occupations for women and a safe and pleasant environment so as to attract workers to it and dispel the prejudices against mills that came from the way they were run in England. The mill owners encouraged their workers to pursue their education and cultivate an enriching setting for themselves. However, by the time Mary Paul came to the mills, this atmosphere had dissipated and she, like the other workers, were seen as only

Open Document