Carral's Argument Analysis

738 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: How technology leads to social isolation

Héctor L Carral, a multimedia engineer wrote an article titled Stop Saying Technology is causing Social Isolation for The Huffington Post. The author of the article has a biased option, therefore does not include any research that would refute his argument. Carral states “it’s only obvious to blame them [technology] for some of society’s problems. Carral also states I believe that accusing technology (and, again, especially smartphones) of ruining social interaction and even all kinds of experiences is, to say the least, quite wrong and misguided. There was an obvious division between the commenters who agree with Carral and those who disagree with his argument. The demographics of commentators. From observing the occupations that the commenters listed, it was apparent the people who were against Hector Carral’s article were parents and educators while the people who agreed with his …show more content…

It is noticeable that many of the comments are being ignited by personal experiences rather than looking at the argument globally. One commenter by the name of Ed Vandyke (comment posted on11/06/2015) said “Technology is isolating to those who haven’t integrated into a technological society “Another commenter by the name of Jiban Ligar argued that “real life interaction creates empathy; tech doesn’t support real life experiences.” An immense amount of comments was similar in light of the fact. They all utilized watch other’s comments to make their argument stronger. Richard Hazel, a New York State Licensed Acupuncturist at Range of Motion Acupuncture said “Can your social media interactions cause a release of oxytocin (the bonding hormone)? I don't think so. If it can't create the emotional bonds that humans need to feel connected, then they are distractions and only imitate true human connection.” Jen Nielson replied to his comment asking “Do you realize a true statement can lead to a false one?” (Masked-man

Show More
Related

  • English 111 Argument Analysis

    591 Words  | 2 Pages

    On December 2,2015 I went to to the Lynnhaven building to receive some feedback on my agreement paper for English 111. It was a very rainy day after running through the rain when I reached the writing center room. There was a yellow note saying that the writing center was in the student center until December 4,2015. After reading the note I ran back in the rain to my car.It was to cold to walk it was raining. As I approached the student center I was told by a security guard that the tutoring lab was located on the third floor. I had walked up three flights of stairs. When I had finally reached the third floor,I walk into the tutoring lab. There were about eight tables, but only four staff members and one student. Amen had approached me asking what did I need help with today. I replied saying that I would like some feedback on my paper for English. He then pointed to the writing table and said “she can assist you with your paper”.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Stop Googling Let's Talk By Sherry Turkle

    1276 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the world today, people are constantly surrounded by technology. At any given moment, we can connect to others around the world through our phones, computers, tablets, and even our watches. With so many connections to the outside world, one would think we have gained more insight into having better relationships with the people that matter the most. Despite these connections, people are more distant to one another than ever. In the article, “Stop Googling. Let’s Talk," author Sherry Turkle details her findings on how people have stopped having real conversations and argues the loss of empathy and solitude are due to today’s technology. Turkle details compelling discoveries on how technology has changed relationships in “Stop Googling. Let’s Talk,” and her credibility is apparent through years of research and the persuasive evidence that supports her claims.

    Read More

  • Critique Of Alex Lickerman's Article

    114 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the editorial, Alex Lickerman claims that technology can separate people and pull them away from the physical world. He argues that people use electronic media to make confrontations with others easier. Lickerman points out that using the media blocks negative emotional replies that argumentative messages can make, and convince us we are not doing harm. He claims that internet users favor electrical relationship above a real relationship. Using an electronic system, you cannot receive the same emotional connection with someone if you cannot hear their tone of voice or read their facial expressions therefore receiving the connection in hiding. Lickerman points out the importance of never trading a real relationship with electronic

    Read More

  • Tannen Argument Analysis

    405 Words  | 1 Pages

    According to Tannen (1998), the argument culture pretty much urges us to discuss our different ideads in debeate form. We use our topics and live our lives by pretty much having a winner and a loser for everything that we do. One current issues that is shown today is different athles protesting the nathinal anthem for support of black lives matter. People are either saying that it is right for them to express there first admendement rught of freedom of speech while oher people are stating that it is wrong because it is disrespectful to the history of the nation. Another current issues that people have to choose between is Trump Vs Clinton during this political time. You have to either agree with one or the other with no midddle ground. If your

    Read More

  • Hidden Cost Of Technology Dbq

    509 Words  | 2 Pages

    Social media might help some people express how they feel. However, it makes us a self-centered culture. Technology made us more selfish and we have become more separate from people because we are shorthing texts and taking selfies all the time (Doc 7). We don’t even look up when someone is talking to us we don’t even look up from our phones and then we don’t build empathy from them. (Doc 3). It has also weakened our ability to focus on tasks because there are engineers programming your phone every minute to keep you on it (Doc 12). In overall technology is making all of us self-center by not noticing people when we talk to them and we can’t even focus on one task for long amount of time.

    Read More

  • Intuitive Photographer Essay

    844 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this 21st century we find ourselves bombarded from all angles with data and images. Information is now so pervasive that it has created the need for a new code of conduct whereby social media and instant gratification are close second cousins. We are more involved than ever with people, especially people who are not physically present, yet on one level we are in danger of becoming permanently detached from those who share our physical environment.

    Read More

  • How Does Computers Change The Way We Think Essay

    1144 Words  | 3 Pages

    Technology Is What You Make It The articles “How Computers Change the Way We Think” by Sherry Turkle and “Electronic Intimacy” by Christine Rosen argue that technology is quite damaging to society as a whole and that even though it can at times be helpful it is more damaging. I have to agree and disagree with this because it really just depends on how it is used and it can damage or help the user. The progressing changes in technology, like social media, can both push us, as a society, further and closer to and from each other and personal connections because it has become a tool that can be manipulated to help or hurt our relationships and us as human beings who are capable of more with and without technology. Technology makes things more efficient and instantaneous.

    Read More

  • Hook Up Culture Essay

    676 Words  | 2 Pages

    Dr. Emma Seppälä, the Science Director of Stanford University’s Center for Compassion and Altruism, provides insight on how exactly social media negatively affects relationships. One harmful effect of social media she talks about is that it is addictive. People tend to focus on seeking pleasure from their phones over real people because there are constant interactions and posts on social media sources. Dr. Emma Seppälä also explains how social media causes people to be lose their sense of reality. By virtually posting one’s friendships, vacations, or whatever else it may be, it causes that person to disconnect from their reality and the people that it consists of. Living in the moment is when we’re the happiest, but what people don’t realize is that they lose the true meaning of the experience when they virtually praise it. Why focus a meaningless amount of likes when you can share enjoyable experiences with a companion who actually cares? The final aspect Dr. Emma Seppälä discusses is that social media damages communication. Communication is arguably the most important aspect of a relationship, but how are people supposed to do that if they are constantly on their devices? Social media was created to connect people, but it ultimately separates us away from reality and into the virtual

    Read More

  • Social Work In Australia

    1239 Words  | 3 Pages

    Studies have found links between the excessive use of technology with loneliness (Odaci & Kalkan, 2010, cited by Vangelisti, (2013), the more you use technology the lonelier one is likely to be. Chronic loneliness can lead to many health problems including anxiety, depression, cancer, and cardiovascular disease. In fact, it has been known for many years that people who are socially isolated have poorer immunity to those who are ‘connected’ (Corporation,

    Read More

  • My Social Relations Before the Internet and Instant Message Era

    636 Words  | 2 Pages

    Slowly we have misplaced our personal touch with each other through social media like Twitter, Facebook, or instant messaging. These sites have made our life stories conveniently cheapened. We have been pulled farther apart over the high speed connects of the Internet. My personal relationships before the Internet era had stronger community connections with friends and family members through physical bonding. On the other side of the coin, take daily behaviors with occupational networking; professional social websites can have greater effects to job opportunities.

    Read More

  • Technology Causes Social Isolation

    1017 Words  | 3 Pages

    How much can technology impact your social life? Who would of thought that technology would affect life in such a major way? Little did people know that technology can impact the way humans interact with each other. While listening to music and playing games on their mobile devices, how many people actually get to know one another while standing right next to each other? A small ride on a metro or bus ride will show you just how little interaction goes on in a humans life do to the amount of use on their mobile devices. The role technology plays in socializing has a great impact on people’s interaction. People can be standing right next to each other with out saying one word to one another. While waiting for the next class to start or even during the class, people tune out the rest of the world and this can lead up to social isolation. Technology has had a bad impact on the way humans socialize because it causes people to be less interactive. Social isolation is a health condition that can become very severe and lead up to depression, anxiety, despair and many other things. Social isolation can be avoided if technology is limited to use at only appropriate times as when bored, alone or incase of an emergency you would use cell phones.

    Read More

  • Effects of Technology on Today's Society

    1143 Words  | 3 Pages

    The opinions of many people vary on technology and the effects it has on today’s society. Some say that it’s more beneficial than anything, others completely disagree, and some have mixed emotions. Would you rather read out of a book, or play online learning games with a possible risk of eye problems? It’s about taking matters into your own hands. 71% of people believe technology has improved their lives. 76% of people completely disagree by saying that technology creates a lazy society and that is distracting and corrupting. Daily life with technology is also another huge issue in society. According to a survey taken in January 2013, people feel their work productivity has dropped 8% in the last year. They also felt that their relationships with their family at home dropped 4% in the past year. The opinions vary, but they are needed to show how technology is affecting different people.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Sherry Turrkle The Flight From Conversation

    1734 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the article “The Flight from Conversation” which describes the effects of technology on human interactions, Sherry Turkle argues, “WE live in a technological universe in which we are always communicating. And yet we have sacrificed conversation for mere connection”. Many others would agree with Turkle; technology and its advances through new devices and social media takes away face-to-face conversation. Her idea of being “alone together” in this world is evidently true as many people can connect with one another through technology, altering relationships to adjust to their own lives. Despite Turkle’s opposition, I believe that technology makes our lives easier to manage. There are numerous forms of social media platforms and handheld devices

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Flight From Conversation

    1090 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to Turkle (2012), “We use technology to define ourselves by sharing our thoughts and feelings as we’re having them.” (Page 3). That’s an example of an over exaggeration. People are smart enough to know that expressing thoughts and feeling on the internet will not do you any good. People are willing to talk to someone when they’re going through something. They want to have face-to-face conversations to properly express their feelings and thoughts so that they can receive an immediate reaction. We don’t let technology define

    Read More

  • We Expect More from Technology and Less from Each Other

    1112 Words  | 3 Pages

    Life without technology, is that even possible? In today’s time, we as a society have become mentally and physically engrossed in technology. Whether it is an iPhone, iPad, or iMac, we are engaging in digital technology as an escape from the outside world. Sherry Turkle, a psychologist and professor at MIT, now the author of Alone Together: Why We Expect More From Technology and Less From Each Other, has been studying how people and digital technology get along for thirty years. She suggests that digital technology is seductive because it serves the purpose that we never have to be alone. We constantly have that ability to interact in a way that makes us feel comfortable. Turkle explains the paradox of technology well; how it can compare to some real life emotional bonds but on the other hand can just be too much.

    Read More

More about Carral's Argument Analysis

Open Document