Essay on You're Speaking My Language

Essay on You're Speaking My Language

Length: 1530 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Language; we use it everyday. From describing portraits to our family and friends, or calling out plays during a football game with our classmates, people utilize language every moment. But how did this “language” evolve? Daniel Dor, an Israeli linguist, created a theory of Language as a Communication Technology, which is “a new general framework for the description, analysis and explanation of language as a socially-constructed communication technology, designed by cultural evolution to allow for communication across the experiential gaps between its users.” Dor argues that language is related to it's function of communicating to others rather than being and “organ” as seen in Chomsky's argument. Dor's view also differs from the Functionalist viewpoint, though ever-so slightly; functionalists argue that language developed due to morphological changes such as larger brain size. Dor argues that language developed though cultural evolution, being learned and improved on by every generation. Utilizing Dor's language theory, Eva Jabonka and Marion J. Lamb argue that the “evolution of language [is] the outcome of continuous interactions between the cultural and genetic inheritance system, with both niche construction and genetic assimilation being important.” (pg 307) Although this argument is presented strongly by Jablonka and Lamb, it needs to be tested for validity. This argument will only be valid “... if and only if it is impossible for the premises to be true and the conclusion false.”

The first premise is that a language culturally develops from incoherent babble to a sophisticated linguistic system. Jablonka and Lamb show this idea in the introduction of their thought experiment. In this experiment, there are a group of early...


... middle of paper ...


...language to evolve, causing the conclusion to be true as well. Therefore, based on the definition of validity, this argument is valid.
Although the conclusion is inductively proven to be valid, that does not mean that the conclusion is sound. This idea of genetic and cultural systems is still relatively new, and it needs more evidence in order to become a sound conclusion. In addition to the evidence, there are other ideas that still seem relevant to the development of language. The Chomsky and functionalist views are still being debated over, so this interaction idea is not solidified as the “end-all” of how language developed. As stated before, the conclusion is valid, based upon the inductive reasoning presented by the thought experiment. However, the soundness of the conclusion cannot be proven due to the highly debatable ideas presented by thought experiment.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Importance of Teaching the Language Skill of Speaking in Classrooms

- Introduction Speaking is one of the four key language skills focused in the teaching of English Language in Singapore’s primary education. As specified in the English Language syllabus (2010: 46), developing a repertoire of speaking skills will “enable pupils to convey and express their thoughts and opinions with accuracy, fluency, appropriateness and succinctness”. Indeed, speaking is viewed as an essential skill in both scholastic and work arenas. However, teachers often perceive teaching speaking as less important than teaching reading and writing....   [tags: verbal, speaking, analysis]

Better Essays
2735 words (7.8 pages)

Speaking Different Languages Can Be Taught Essay

- Speaking different languages can be done by some, but may be very tough for others. When coming into a new culture, it is difficult to learn all the languages and beliefs all at one time. People that don’t speak the same vernacular as one who speaks a different language should and will be allowed in the future. We, blacks, whites, and all other races, need to be able to communicate whether it is the same language or different languages. I have been out of the country numerous times with my family....   [tags: Spanish language, English language, United States]

Better Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

Speaking And Speaking Chinese Mandarin Essay

- Sometimes I wish there is only one language in the world which all human speaks fluently, so that everyone in the world can express their own ideas clearly and can understand others thoroughly. If this was true, the world will certainly be a much better place. Because many wars probably could be avoided by a long and deep conversation between the leaders of the opposing countries. An interpreter might be able to translate what one is saying to another language, but without emotions and genuineness....   [tags: United States, English language, Chinese language]

Better Essays
870 words (2.5 pages)

The Power of Speaking More Than Two Languages Essay

- In chapter 12 “Language Diversity and Schooling” of Banks et al. (2012) talks about the US demographic changes in the last decade and the challenges this learners face in our educational system. They say that the new immigration waves are the primary sources of new linguistic diversity in the US. Additionally, they also state that immigration today is more diverse than ever, new immigrants are exhibiting a significant range in educational level, social class, and economic capital. Present immigrants are more likely than native-born populations to have family members who have graduated from college and “they are not just simply assimilated into mainstream society as was once assumed” (Banks e...   [tags: language diveristy, education, learners]

Better Essays
1792 words (5.1 pages)

Essay about The Power Of Public Speaking

- How has public speaking become so feared. “In a study [of 9,000 people] that concentrated on fears in a social situation, their top ranking fears were public speaking, speaking up in class, meeting new people, talking to people of authority, important exams or interviews, going to parties and talking to strangers”(Lucas, 2012, pg. 9). This question has always perplexed me, because I too suffer from a fear of speaking in public. But after reading chapter one of The Art of Public Speaking, I understand now that it is a blend of different subjects that make public speaking seem so unappealing....   [tags: Public speaking, Public speaker, Speaking fee]

Better Essays
1156 words (3.3 pages)

Speaking Spanish in the USA Essay

- As a child, I had to navigate from an English speaking classroom to a Spanish speaking home. From eight in the morning I was given instruction in English by my professors at school. After three in the afternoon at home I engaged in Spanish conversation with my mother, father, and siblings. When the summer vacation came around, it was back to speaking Spanish only, and then I regained the Mexican accent that had faded away during the school year. My experience learning English was different from what earlier Spanish speaking generations in the United States dealt with....   [tags: Speaking Spanish Essay]

Better Essays
1401 words (4 pages)

The Impact Of Bilingual Preschool Education On The Language Development Of Spanish Speaking Children

- In the second article The impact of bilingual preschool education on the language development of Spanish-speaking children by James L. Rodriguez. Rodriguez was the first to conduct a study on if Spanish speaking children attending a bilingual preschool impact their Spanish language background. Winsler was admired by Rodriguez’s study and wanted to test to see if what Rodriguez found was actually true. Well we already got a look at Winslers study, so now we can jump in and take a look at Rodriguez’s findings and see if what Winsler found was the same as Rodriguez results....   [tags: Spanish language, English language, Verb]

Better Essays
930 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Speaking And Perceiving Languages

- We all have the a gift of speaking and perceiving languages. Whether it is sound or soundless we use language to communicate with one another.There are many ways to approach someone when it comes to the word choice you use to communicate. Many languages contain different forms in where they can be comprehended. The readings “Does Your Language Shape How You Think?” by Guy Deutscher and “Lost in Translation” by Lera Boroditsky, discuss how the languages we speak can shape the way we think, and the way we perceive things differ from the aspects of language....   [tags: Linguistics, Grammar, Noam Chomsky]

Better Essays
1058 words (3 pages)

The Unfettered Language Essay

- The Unfettered Language In advancing through the stages of one’s life, one also advances through different levels and styles of speaking. One’s personal style of language is adapted to fit these distinct periods of life. In citing a language and using words that others are unfamiliar with, many can be left in a state of confusion. Over time there have been many styles of language that we find difficult to understand and relate to. In Keywords, Raymond Williams is able to take a certain language or group of words and show the reader the different forms of the word/language by giving examples and background, thus clarifying some of the confusion that new languages and words can have....   [tags: Speaking Language Essays]

Free Essays
1937 words (5.5 pages)

IELTS Speaking Tips Essay examples

- IELTS Speaking Tips These *IELTS Speaking* tips will make you aware of what is required of you during the speaking interview and what you can do to achieve your highest possible score. Before the interview Your speaking interview will take place at a different time, and probably on a different day, to the rest of the exam. Make sure you understand when and where your interview is to take place. Quite often the location for the Speaking interview is different from that of the main exam. As with the main exam, try to keep your stress levels low by making sure you have everything you need well before leaving for the interview....   [tags: Public Speaking Guide IELTS]

Free Essays
1256 words (3.6 pages)