Essay PreviewMore ↓
After my own presentation, I wanted to dig a little deeper and see how women travel writers were representing nature in the 18th century. I wondered if the women's descriptions differed far from the men that I studied in my presentation. I want to focus on Dorothy Wordsworth (William's sister), Ann Radcliffe and Helen Maria Williams. I'm curious to know if they were guilty of over-representing women in landscape and nature scenes. At the very end, I'll put in my two cents about the gendering of Nature.
First of all, Dorothy Wordsworth traveled with her brother a lot in the early 1800's; during this time she kept a journal and wrote, in rich details, about the landscape. Although she wrote predominately with a picturesque tone, she made an effort to pay attention to the sharp, jarring contrasts in nature, like crags, rough edges, and precipices. William Snyder's essay "Mother Nature's Other Natures: Landscape in Women's Writing, 1770-1830" suggests that it was Dorothy's intention to use the paradoxes in nature to focus on Nature's contrast. Snyder's source for his theory comes from his close readings of Dorothy's journals; he explains that her language and vocabulary are picturesque, but that she "presents Nature in need of care" (146). Snyder infers that for Dorothy, "maternal care flows out from the human heart, not to it from above or beyond" (146). Snyder comments that Dorothy made a point of highlighting the irregularities in nature and draws her inspiration on the irony of ordered chaos. Snyder concludes that Dorothy likens Nature to a dress-maker, the "female as pattern-maker" (148). He suggests that she places emphasis on what "the hands, not the breasts, do" (148). Snyder also points out that Dorothy usually referred to Nature with "the impersonal pronoun 'it,' and not with 'she' or 'her'" (147); Snyder believes that Dorothy deliberately "overlooks possibilities for maternal symbolism or personification" (147). Dorothy does not view maternality with fertility and bounty, but with "protection and intimacy" (148). However, she does use the feminine pronoun in some of her works, but Snyder explains that "she," the metaphoric woman, is a "craftsperson, not a mother" (147).
Unfortunately Snyder's argument does not convince me; how can Nature be a "pattern-maker" while being in need of care? I think the image of "pattern-maker" indicates originality and creativity, Nature as innovative and refreshing, not Nature in need of help, as Snyder indicates early in his argument.
How to Cite this Page
"Women Travel Writers." 123HelpMe.com. 04 Apr 2020
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- As all readers and writers know, transitions are an essential component to storytelling as they provide the physical shift from section to section. More importantly, if used in the right way a transition can advance the plot itself. Octavia Butler is a master of the transition device in her novel, Kindred as she physically shifts her characters through time and space as well as developing powerful changes in their individual characterizations. While there are a plethora of examples that can be used to demonstrate this, one of the most formidable transitions occurs simultaneously with and within Dana herself.... [tags: English-language films, Time]
1041 words (3 pages)
- ... “They believed I was so locked up in that machine, that it was not in my power to open it, which contrivance they attributed to my husband.” Here again she acknowledges the way other cultures differ from her own. Judith Still recognises the way in which she is; “concerned not to fall into the Orientalizing clichés of Early Modern men's travel writing, which typically represents Muslim women as imprisoned in harems, enslaved, starved of sex and sexually voracious...” Her uniqueness in character and behaviour is demonstrated from the start of her letters through to the very last ones.... [tags: prostitution, society, womanhood, attitude]
1407 words (4 pages)
- From the conventional Victorian dresses of the 1800’s to the rock-and-roll tee shirts of the 1980’s, American culture has experienced incredibly diverse trends in clothing. This ever changing timeline of fashion provokes the question: what is the cause of such differing styles. By considering the state of society throughout the eras, it can be seen that clothing directly correlates with the current way of life. Specifically, American women’s fashion of the 1920’s and 1930’s proves to not simply be a meaningless trend – rather an accurate reflection of the specific era.... [tags: women's rights movements, Great Depression]
1295 words (3.7 pages)
- INTRODUCTION Amitav Ghosh undoubtedly occupied an undefeatable position in the galaxy of Indian writers in English. He has contributed immensely to make Indian writings acclaimed worldwide. Most of his writings involve the themes of exile, cultural displacement, revolution, emigration, dislocation, loss of identity, uprooting that characterizes into historical novels. He recuperates the irony, disillusionment, dilemma and ambiguity of human condition of a bygone era through his language. He masterfully connects the complex flow of time with his researched narrative.... [tags: indian writers, malaya]
1315 words (3.8 pages)
- Especially in the letters to her sister she addresses the life that the women of the Orient lead. She criticizes the representation of women regarding sexuality, marriage, customs and liberty. By doing so she sets her travel account apart from the ones of other writers at that time, such as Jean Dumont, Aaron Hill, Robert Withers, George Sandys and John Covel (cf. Lowe, pg.1). She often remarks how male travelers have given wrong descriptions and depiction of the Orient. Jean Dumont is one of the travelers she criticizes: “[…] that worthy author Dumont, who ‘has writ with equal ignorance and confidence’”.... [tags: Western world, Orient, Far East, Gender]
991 words (2.8 pages)
- Evaluate and respond to the presentations of women in the Romantic period. Feel free to discuss presentations of women, by women (such as Austen’s Persuasion) as well as presentations of women by men (such as the “she” in Byron’s “She Walks in Beauty”). Consider the following questions: are these presentations problematic. What do they tell us about the values and briefs of the Romantic Period. Do any of these presentations subvert (complicate, or call into questions) the time’s notions of femininity.... [tags: femininity, marriage, beauty]
753 words (2.2 pages)
- Women have faced oppression in the literary community throughout history. Whether they are seen as hysterical or unreliable, women writers seem to be faulted no matter the topics of their literature. However, Anne Bradstreet and Margaret Fuller faced their critics head-on. Whether it was Bradstreet questioning her religion or Fuller discussing gender fluidity, these two women did not water down their opinions to please others. Through their writings, Bradstreet and Fuller made great strides for not just women writers, but all women.... [tags: Gender, Gender role, Puritan, Woman]
1025 words (2.9 pages)
- Introduction Geoffrey Chaucer’s “The Canterbury Tales” is a collection of stories written between 1387 and 1400 about a group of thirty people who travel as pilgrims to Canterbury (England) and on their way, they tell stories to each other about their lives and experiences. The stories constitute a critique of English society at the time, and particularly of the Church, while women seem to be presented in a different way than they are in other contemporary works. The aim of this essay is to present the ways in which the portrayal of women is different, and trace their role within Chaucer’s masterpiece.... [tags: stories, medial societies, stereotypes]
1276 words (3.6 pages)
- The role of women writers and women in society has changed drastically over the last two centuries. The women’s movement and female writers have worked hand in hand to pursue equality for women and to move their issues to the forefront of the nation. Writers such as Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Sarah Moore Grimké, Angelina Grimké Weld, Harriet Jacobs, and Sojourner Truth help bring to light the sensitive problems that need to be addressed in the women’s rights movement. Angelina Grimké Weld, in her Appeal to the Christian Women of the South, says, "It is through the tongue, the pen, and the press, that truth is principally propogated" (1948).... [tags: influential women writers, women’s movement]
2183 words (6.2 pages)
- Readers Interpretation of “A Dead Women’s Secrets” Guy De Maupassant was French writer who wrote many short stories. Maupassant was also a poet, novel writer, and travel book writer (Literature network). He is considered to be one of the greatest short story-writers in France. His biography describes the sense of emotion he puts in his stories related to his suffering in life. Many of his short stories, relate to everyday life in France during the 1800’s (Literature network). The way the author wrote his stories shows his humor, and good flow to the story which reveals a lot about his personality.... [tags: Guy de Maupassant, Short story, Boule de Suif]
1017 words (2.9 pages)
- Boundaries, Symmetry and Continuity in Radcliffe's The Mysteries of Udolpho
- The 'Natural' Feminine in Romanticism: A Commentary
- Male and Female Travelers
- Spirituality and Nature
- The Treatment of the Lower Class in Radcliffe's The Mysteries of Udolpho
- Goethe's Magical Philosophy and Possession of Nature
Ann Radcliffe wrote her travel journals a few years before Dorothy. The few short passages that I will be focusing on are from A Journey Made in Summer of 1794, which was published one year later. Her travel writings are significantly bold and exciting. Similarly while reading The Mysteries of Udolpho, her writings about nature evoke sublimity, create a warmth in the spirits of the characters, especially Emily. Radcliffe, on many occasions refers to the sublime and God when describing Nature, creating an intense and overwhelming admiration for the magnificence of God and Nature simultaneously: "[A]nd still more the mountain's stupendous recesses, where silence and grandeur of solitude impressed a sacred awe upon her heart, and lifted her thoughts to the GOD OF HEAVEN AND EARTH" (10). Radcliffe also uses Nature, the mountains in particular, to express healthiness. On several occasions Radcliffe describes the "healthy mountains" (32,39), contrasting St Aubert's declining health. She describes several contrasting images in both her work of fiction and in her travel writings. In Udolpho Radcliffe contrasts light and darkness: "The cheerful green of the beech and mountain-ash was sometimes seen, like a gleam of light, amidst the dark verdure of the forest" (42). A couple of pages later, while Emily and the travelers are heading to Rousillon, silence is violently interrupted: "The deep silence of these solitudes was broken only at intervals by the scream of the vultures…or the cry of the eagle sailing high in the air" (44). Similarly in A Journey, Radcliffe describes a most horrifying image of an opening between two mountains; the effect is reversed when she describes what is on the "still a miniature of the sweetest pastoral beauty on the banks of the river Derwent" ("The Jaws of Borrowdale" 465) on the other side of the pathway. But the most substantial effect of Radcliffe's travel writing is her unmistakable emphasis on the grandeur, and yet terrifying images:
Dark rocks yawn at its entrance, terrific as the wildness of a maniac, and disclose a narrow pass running up between mountains of granite that are shook into almost every possible form of horror. All above resembles the accumulations of an earthquake -- splintered, shivered, piled, amassed. (465)
Radcliffe's Nature is beautiful, but rough and jagged. Snyder should have used Radcliffe's travel writings to support his thesis. She stresses the images that do not have inherent associations with women. She is more concerned with the grandeur and the sublimity of Nature. For example, she describes the mountains as "great, wild, irregular" ("Grasmere" 470). When describing the approach to lake Ullswater from along the heights of Emont, she writes,
The approach to this sublime lake along the heights of Emont is exquisitely interesting, for the road (being shrouded by woods) allows the eye only partial glimpses of the gigantic shapes that are assembled in the distance and, awakening high expectation, leaves the imagination thus elevated to paint the 'forms of things unseen'. Thus it was when we caught a first view of the dark broken tops of the fells that rise round Ullswater, of size and shape most huge, bold, and awful, overspread with a blue mysterious tint that seemed almost supernatural, though according in gloom and sublimity with the severe features it involved. ("The Road to Emont" 407-8)
Besides one reference to Nature as mother ("[N]or suffered the charms of Nature's lowly children to abstract them form the observance of her stupendous works" (Udolpho 7).) Radcliffe writes about Nature in terms of size and splendor, magnificence and mystery, while still maintaining beauty and virtue. Nature is significantly associated with wisdom and knowledge, which has already been discussed in class, but I found the excerpts from Radcliffe's travel writings significantly determined and brilliant. I loved the way she draws fear from the grandeur of the images, the psychological horror found in the bosom of Nature! However, having already criticized Snyder, I feel that I have to address the fact that I am making assumptions based on very little evidence of literature. Having said that, I don't mean to suggest that all of Radcliffe's travel writings lead to the conclusion that her inspiration for writing about Nature is in part, motivated by fear and stupor.
Finally there is Williams who wrote around 1798, right in between the travel works published by Radcliffe and Wordsworth. We have looked at her closely in class, so I won't dwell too long on her writings, but I want to show how she too does not refer to Nature as a mother. Her travel writing may be identified with the stereotypical style of women's writing, characterized by sentiments and emotions, but she does not overtly participate in the gendering of nature. Like Radcliffe, Williams is inspired by how beautiful, yet frightening Nature can be. Williams, like Radcliffe, likes to refer to the sublime, characterized by mystery and ineffability:
That stupendous cataract, rushing with wild impetuosity over those broken, unequal rocks, which, lifting up their sharp points admidst its sea of foam, disturb its headlong course, multiply its falls, and make the afflicted waters roar--that cadence of tumultuous sound, which had never till now struck upon my ear--those long feathery surges, giving the element a new aspect--that spray rising into clouds of vapour, and reflecting the prismatic colours, while it disperses itself over the hills--never, never can I can forget the sensations of that moment! (A Tour of Switzerland 61)
Williams does refer to Nature as female, but only it's pronoun; it seems to me that Williams is not trying to ascribe female qualities to Nature, but she found it difficult to avoid the common pronoun practice: "[W]hile the imagination of the spectator is struck with the comparative littleness of fleeting man, busy with his trivial occupations, contrasted with the view of nature in all her vast, eternal, uncontrolable grandeur" (63). Instead of concerning herself with the qualities of a female Nature, she stresses the incongruity of the scene; sometimes man forgets that he or she is part of a much larger circle, and sometimes trying to find meaning at all in the experience is beyond rationality, it can only be described through our senses and emotions.
It seems to me that Williams and Radcliffe are comparatively different from Wordsworth. Wordsworth seems to be more concerned with the picturesque and the beauty of the landscape, whereas both Williams and Radcliffe appear to express the significance of Nature on one's psyche. Where Wordsworth seems to deliberately abandon the feminine pronoun for Nature, Radcliffe and Williams don't seem to be bothered by it because it is not the focus of their works.
As far as what I think when it comes to gendering Nature, I say go for it! I don't feel threatened or suppressed when I see Nature represented as female. I think it is important for women to celebrate their bodies and the metaphor of life, because that's what we are…givers of life. I realize that mother and woman are not synonymous, but you have to be a woman to be a mother. In that sense, it is essential that we see it such. I am not trying to say that it is a woman's duty to have children, but it is our responsibility to recognize the sublimity of the womb.
Radcliffe, Ann. A Journey Made in the Summer of 1794. Romanticism. Eds. David Miall and Duncan Wu. CD-ROM. Oxford: Blackwell, 1997.
---, The Mysteries of Udolpho. London, England: Penguin, 2001.
Snyder, William C. "Mother Nature's Other Natures: Landscape in Women's Writing, 1770-1830." Women's Studies, 21:2 (1992): 143-162. EBSCOhost. University of Alberta Library. Edmonton, Alberta. 8 Feb. 2005
Williams, Helena Maria. A Tour in Switzerland; or, A view of the present state of the Government and Manners of those Cantons: with comparative sketches of the present state of Paris, 2 vols. London: G. G. and J. Robinson, 1798. Home page of David Miall. 20 Feb. 2005. http://www.ualberta.ca/~dmiall/Travel/Coxe-Williams.htm