On June 6, 1919, after over a month of striking in Winnipeg, the federal government amended the Immigration Act “[allowing] officials to deport any alien or Canadian citizen not born in Canada for advocating the overthrow of the government by force.”1 Canada, as a democratic country, was/is based upon the idea of allowing the people to influence the decisions that impact their own lives2. However, the government’s eventual decision to deport strikers and strike leaders displayed a lack of adherence and respect for the democratic system. The government contradicted itself as a democracy by ignoring the people instead of intervening to reach a peaceful and fair solution. The government overturned the political freedom3 it was meant to promote and foster by threatening to deport anyone who opposed the status quo. Looking at the amendment carefully will reveal that the changes to the Immigration Act only allowed the deportation of ‘aliens’ and immigrant citizens, but not ‘true Canadians’. This particular change in the Immigration Act displayed bias towards foreigners. Although not on the government’s mind, this was extremely...
... middle of paper ...
...sary of the Winnipeg General Strike." In Defence of Marxism. 28 May 2009. Web. 21 May 2011.
23 Grant, Alex. "Canada: 90th Anniversary of the Winnipeg General Strike." In Defence of Marxism. 28 May 2009. Web. 21 May 2011.
24 Grant, Alex. "Canada: 90th Anniversary of the Winnipeg General Strike." In Defence of Marxism. 28 May 2009. Web. 21 May 2011.
25 Grant, Alex. "Canada: 90th Anniversary of the Winnipeg General Strike." In Defence of Marxism. 28 May 2009. Web. 21 May 2011.
26 "Winnipeg General Strike." The Canadian Encyclopedia. Historica-Dominion. Web. 11 May 2011.
27 Powell, John. "Winnipeg General Strike." Encyclopedia of North American Immigration. Facts On File, 2005. American History Online. Web. 7 May 2011.
28 Grant, Alex. "Canada: 90th Anniversary of the Winnipeg General Strike." In Defence of Marxism. 28 May 2009. Web. 21 May 2011.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Winnipeg General Strike The year of 1919 has been one of the most influential years of strikes in Canadian history. The event that occurred on this year still lingers in Canadian minds and continues to be one of the most meaningful and powerful effects of labor protest and the struggle of people to create trade union rights.... [tags: Papers]
1686 words (4.8 pages)
- At the beginning of school days in September 2015, teachers in Seattle public schools went on strike. It is the second time that teachers went on strike in the U.S. in recent years since 2012, when Chicago Teachers Union (CTU) was negotiating for a new contract that improves teachers’ salary, and evaluates teachers’ performance fairly. CTU has reached an agreement after a long negotiation period with the city. The pattern and goal of the Seattle teachers strike matched perfectly with what had happened in Chicago.... [tags: Trade union, Strike action, Collective bargaining]
1328 words (3.8 pages)
- At the time of the general strike at midnight on the 3rd of May 1926, you had a conservative government in power lead by Stanley Baldwin which lasted from 1924 to 1929. He led a government looking for peace and compromise. He wanted international conciliation and yearned for industrial conciliation at home. However, throughout the 1920’s, after a successful war period which saw overproduction in iron, steel, shipbuilding, coal and textile industries, these products were now not needed in such quantities, leading to a spiralling inflation and major fall in exports and profits.... [tags: Coal mining, Coal, Trade union, Winston Churchill]
1608 words (4.6 pages)
- The General Strike and How Revolutionary It Was Seventy eight years ago an earthquake shook the very foundations of British capitalism. In the greatest display of militant power in its history the British working class moved into action in the General Strike of May 1926. For 9 days not a wheel turned nor a light shone without the permission of the working class. In this essay I argue that it was not revolutionary or better it was not designed to be revolutionary. From one minute to midnight on Monday 3 May, the TUC called out the railwaymen, dockers, road transport workers, printers and gas and electricity workers.... [tags: Papers]
604 words (1.7 pages)
- The Events of the British General Strike Indeed it could be said that the failure of the general strike and resultantly any real change proves that Britain in 1926 was a conservative society, but others would argue that it wasn’t that the British people wanted change, it was just that the government and the elites didn’t. Before we can begin to answer this question firstly we have to understand the exact meaning of the word conservative. I have found the meaning to be as follows; “Tending toward maintaining traditional and proven views, conditions and intuitions, favouring the preservation of established customs, values etc and opposing innovation”.... [tags: Papers]
816 words (2.3 pages)
- The General Strike was An Attempted Revolution During the General strike there was true governmental concern about what seemed to be a revolutionary threat in the form of workers and TUC members who went on strike as part of their efforts to improve working conditions, reduce working hours and increase wages. Much evidence is available from around this time giving us a clear insight into the reasons for this concern and how it came about. Source 1, an article from the British Gazette (controlled by the Government) produced very early on in the strike highlights the key concern felt by the Government at the time supporting both the statement and introduction: '... [tags: Papers]
841 words (2.4 pages)
- Reasons for the General Strike of 1926 The General Strike took place as a result of short and long-term problems. Long term factors such as the increase in Trade Union members, the change of ownership in the mines, and the threat of Communism were all starting points. The price of coal fluctuating along with economic instability in Britain, the US and Germany and the adherence to the Gold Standard also contributed to the timing of the General Strike. The growth of the Labour Party and the threat of nationalisation made private mine owners feel insecure.... [tags: Papers]
923 words (2.6 pages)
- The General Strike of 1926 In 1926 the General Council of the Trades Union Congress (TUC) called out workers throughout the country on a general strike for nine days in an attempt to force the government to act to prevent the wages and conditions of coal miners being lowered. There is no one reason why the General Strike of 1926 took place, instead a large number of long and short term causes led towards the event, which was finally set off by a trigger cause. An example of a long term cause would be the history of bad relations between mine owners and their workers, a short term cause would be the Samuel Report and a trigger the Daily Mail article.... [tags: Papers]
1836 words (5.2 pages)
- Causes of the General Strike In this essay I will discuss the reasons for the start of the general strike, the long and short term causes. In the 1920's Britain was having a hard time on the industrial front. It had begun with the miners, the coal industry wasn't fairing to well and was declining rapidly and had been since 1918. This was because during the first world war the mines were run by the government and the conditions of the mines were good but also the wages were standardised which the miners had no problems with as the were very acceptable.... [tags: Papers]
1052 words (3 pages)
- The General Strike 1926 In 1925 the mine-owners announced that they intended to reduce the miner's wages. The General Council of the Trade Union Congress responded to this news by promising to support the miners in their dispute with their employers. The Conservative Government, decided to intervene, and supplied the necessary money to bring the miners' wages back to their previous level. This event became known as Red Friday because it was seen as a victory for working class solidarity.... [tags: Papers]
735 words (2.1 pages)