William Paley 's Watch Analogy Essay

William Paley 's Watch Analogy Essay

Length: 1185 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the branch of philosophy which focuses on the existence of God, there are three primary arguments: cosmological, design, and ontological. In this paper, I will be focusing on two of the most influential arguments by design, a simplified version of the fifth argument by Aquinas as well as William Paley’s watch analogy. I will also be outlining the strengths of the argument, but most importantly, criticizing the several flaws within both variations of the argument by design. I will also criticize against and argue that the argument from design is a weak argument in comparison it’s competing hypothesis, specifically, the theory of evolution due to the lack of testability or “novel” predictions within the hypothesis.
In Sober’s book: Core Questions in Philosophy: A Text with Readings, Sober provides an alternate, simplified version of the design argument by Aquinas (Sober, 2012, p. 59-60):
(P1): “Among objects that act for an end, some have minds whereas other do not.”
(P2): “An object that acts for an end, but does not itself have a mind, must have been designed by a being with a mind.”
(P3): “Hence, there exists a being with a mind who designed all mindless objects that act for an end.”
(C): “Hence, God exists.”
In other words, Aquinas believed there to have existed two different types of objects: those which are goal-driven and have minds, and those which are goal-driven and are mindless. However, it is crucial to the understanding of Aquinas’ design argument that Aquinas believed all objects were goal-driven and “acted for an end”. Sober provides the following example that in Aquinas’ teleological view, a rock would retain its hardness “in order to resist destruction” (Sober, 2012, p. 60). I disagree with Aquinas’ stance th...

... middle of paper ...

...and improve a large portion of our understanding in the field of genetics and physical anthropology. In contrast, the argument from design, a theistic and creationist theory, has accomplished nothing towards the advancement of current science and has been unable to provide any sort of testable or novel predictions at all. As a result, I must argue against Aquinas and Paley that the lack of testability with the argument from design is a significant weakness and detriment to the legitimacy of the argument.
In conclusion, in this essay I have described the basic components to both Aquinas’ and Paley’s argument from design. I have also criticized Aquinas’ use of the Birthday Fallacy in one premises of his argument. Lastly, I have identified several weak-points of the argument from design and creationism as a whole in comparison to modern-day hypotheses such as evolution.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Argument from Design, by William Paley Essay

- During the 1800th century, William Paley, an English philosopher of religion and ethics, wrote the essay The Argument from Design. In The Argument from Design, Paley tries to prove the existence of a supreme being through the development of a special kind of argument known as the teleological argument. The teleological argument is argument by analogy, an argument based on the similarities between two different subjects. This essay purposefully attempts to break down Paley’s argument and does so in the following manner: firstly, Paley’s basis for the teleological argument is introduced; secondly, Paley’s argument is derived and analyzed; thirdly, the connection between Paley’s argument and th...   [tags: Teleological Argument, Supreme Being]

Better Essays
1096 words (3.1 pages)

The Inadequacy of Paley's Argument from Design Essay

- ... Although this type of argument is practical at predicting patterns of re-occurring events, they are never legitimately sound. Consider the sunrise. It has risen every day for thousands of years on end. Therefore, it will rise tomorrow. Despite the odds of this happening being very high, there is not a one hundred percent chance that it will. Furthermore, consider the existence of the universe itself. Although the odds of life being created by a random amalgamation of forces are very low, the correct combination for life to exist only has to occur once....   [tags: teleological, creation, god]

Better Essays
1258 words (3.6 pages)

Theories Of The Universe Beginning Essay

- Theories of the Universe beginning Throughout history there has always been discussions and theories as to how the universe came to be. Where did it come from. How did it happen. Was it through God that the universe was made. These philosophies have been discussed and rejected and new theories have been created. I will discuss three theories from our studies, Kalam’s Cosmological Argument, Aquinas’s Design Argument, and Paley’s Design Argument. In this article, I will discuss the arguments and what these arguments state as their belief....   [tags: Universe, Big Bang, Redshift, Watchmaker analogy]

Better Essays
968 words (2.8 pages)

The Universe: The Design Argument by William Paley Essay

- In this paper I will present two differing views on the topic of the design argument. In particular, I will explain William Paley's view supporting the design argument and Bertrand Russell's view against the design argument. After a presentation of the differing views, I will then evaluate the arguments to show that William Paley has a stronger argument. There are several forms of the design argument. The general form of the design argument starts with the basic idea that certain parts of the universe are such that they indicate that they have been designed and have a purpose....   [tags: bertrand rusell, opposing views]

Better Essays
1139 words (3.3 pages)

The Argument from Design by William Paley Essay

- William Paley’s, The Argument from Design, talks a great deal about a being coming across a watch and questioning why the watch was there and how the watch was created there. He stated that there must have been a creator to the watch. Everything that has a design has a creator and that how nobody had ever seen the creator at work as he crafts this piece of art altogether to the point of where everything is put in place and has a purpose, that if even one thing was out of place that the watch would not tick, or for that matter, never work at all....   [tags: teleological arguments]

Better Essays
673 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on William Paley 's View On The Existence Of God

- William Paley presents a comparison between a stone and a watch to prove his remarks and beliefs concerning the existence of God. He introduces a scenario of himself walking on the beach and bumping into a stone then reflecting verses a scenario of stumbling upon a watch. Starting in Chapter One, Paley explains multiple arguments towards the examination of the watch while the stone would be neglected and believed to have preexisted. He says; “ ignorance of this kind exalts our opinion of the unseen and unknown artists’s skiff, if he be unseen and unknown, but raises no doubt in our minds of the existence and agency of such an artist” (I....   [tags: Existence, Ontology, Existence of God]

Better Essays
782 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Abortion Rights and the Acorn Analogy

- Introduction This essay will examine an often discussed pro-choice analogy. It will consider to what extent the abortion issue is still controversial if the terms of this analogy are accepted as true. This essay will first discuss the premises of the analogy in question. Then it will consider counter-arguments to the analogy. The objective of this paper is to make a determination on whether the controversial nature of the issue of abortion still pertains in light of the acorn analogy. It will be the argument of this paper that this controversy is not subdued by the acorn-fetus comparison....   [tags: legal issues, acorn analogy]

Better Essays
1090 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Socrates' Analogy of the Cave

- At the beginning of Book Seven, in an attempt to better describe the education of the philosopher Socrates begins to set up an analogy with an ascent and descent into “the cave”. In Socrates’ cave analogy there was a group of people who were from childhood held in a dimly lit underground cave. The people were kept there in bonds that were designed to allow them to only what was in front of them by depriving them of the ability to turn their heads around. Also present in Socrates’ cave was a certain wall or partition separating the prisoners from another group of people who simply walked along a path carrying statues shaped after all that of beings and occasionally uttering sounds as the othe...   [tags: Socrates, Analogy of the Cave, philosophy, ]

Better Essays
1029 words (2.9 pages)

Racial Barriers in Grace Paley's Short Story Samuel Essay

- Racial Barriers in Grace Paley's Short Story Samuel It is hard to distinguish the difference between which race is more important. One might ask themselves if white is superior over colored skin. There have been numerous struggles and much success in the fight towards equality between the races. Although many large steps have been made, there are still existing racial barriers. One particular struggle is whether or not people of different races should interact with each other. Should Caucasian adults interact with young children of color....   [tags: Grace Paley Papers]

Better Essays
820 words (2.3 pages)

The Role of the Watch in William Faulkner's A Rose for Emily Essay

- The Role of the Watch in William Faulkner's A Rose for Emily Even the casual reader of William Faulkner will recognize the element of time as a crucial one in much of the writer's work, and the critical attention given to the subject of time in Faulkner most certainly fills many pages of criticism. A goodly number of those pages of criticism deal with the well-known short story, "A Rose for Emily." Several scholars, most notably Paul McGlynn, have worked to untangle the confusing chronology of this work (461-62)....   [tags: A Rose for Emily, William Faulkner]

Better Essays
1194 words (3.4 pages)