William Muir 's Police : Street Corner Politicians Essay

William Muir 's Police : Street Corner Politicians Essay

Length: 1196 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Police Personalities: Analyzed and Compared
When analyzing and studying the criminal justice system, much attention has always been directed toward the federal court system as well as the Supreme Court; however, over the last few decades, more and more attention has been drawn toward the smaller criminal justice institutions, such as police officers. Political controversies arising from incidents such as those played out in Ferguson and Baltimore have resulted in the magnification in attention toward societies law enforcement officials, putting such institutions under the public scope. In a time littered with widespread mistrust between police officers and the communities the have sworn to protect, it is critical to understand the policeman’s personality in order to come to a better understanding of those officers society relies upon. This paper will analyze William Muir’s “Police: Street-corner Politicians” as well as evaluate Muir’s theoretical validity in opposition to the work of other scholars such as Jerome Skolnick and Ellen Hochstedler.
Muir
William Muir, in “Police: Street-corner Politicians” attempts to classify different typologies of police officers, beginning first with the two dimensions, Perspective and Passion, deriving, “from Weber’s (1946) work that offers a model of a mature professional-political man. Muir first argues that these dimensions are applicable generally to human beings in a variety of settings, then tailors his discussion of the dimensions to show that they apply to police work,” (Hochstedler, 303). Muir then goes on to recognize four viable types of police officers: the Professional, the Enforcer, the Reciprocator, and the Avoider. It is important to note that Muir’s methodology involved intervie...


... middle of paper ...


...thetic understanding of human motivation and suffering. This officer, then, is both uncomfortable with the tool of his trade (coercion) and unappreciative of the citizenry he serves,” (Hochstedler, 306). This leads to an apprehensive officer confused by his duties as an officer. Muir notes that this leads the Avoider to do exactly what his name means, and avoid his responsibilities. He explains that the attitude and personality of the officer often varies from rude to nervous and bumbling. Finally wrapping up his discussion of the Avoider, Muir iterates that, “Lacking the skills, the motives, the courage of public life, he pulls back within himself, avoiding power, hating much of his work, despising the diversity and challenges of the world, fleeing from the confusions to which much of his work exposed him, and suppressing the memory of obligations unmet,” (Muir, 35)

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Christmas Traditions By William Muir Auld

- According to William Muir Auld’s book Christmas Traditions, the Christmas tree found its way into the hearts and homes of Christian people with their thoughts and sentiment. Auld writes, “On the night in which Christ was born, all the trees in the forest, despite snow and ice, bloomed and bore fruit” (Auld 138). This story was first told by a geographer of the tenth century named Georg Jacob. This story was as highly believed as the birth of Christ. Christmas trees can be dated back through writing, specifically songs and are associated with the Church, specifically to post-Reformation times....   [tags: Christmas, Christmas tree, Santa Claus, Yule]

Strong Essays
1019 words (2.9 pages)

Edwin Muir's Poem The Horses Essay

- Edwin Muir's Poem "The Horses" "The Horses" is a poem by Edwin Muir. It tells the story of a world ravaged by nuclear war, where the few survivors live hopelessly in a desolate reality. Their outlook is changed by the arrival of the horses, a relic of the past which lets them rediscover humanity's bond with nature. "The Horses", as well as being a very beautiful and moving poem, has an important message to convey. The poet uses various methods to illustrate this. Throughout the poem, there are many biblical references....   [tags: Horses Edwin Muir Essays]

Strong Essays
626 words (1.8 pages)

Interpretation of Muir's Horses Essay

- Interpretation of Muir's Horses My interpretation of Edwin Muir's poem entitled "Horses" is one of a past memory and the conflict and anger brought about by this memory , a conflict between light and darkness, good and evil in the mind of a elderly dying man, fearing death as he gazes out across a field. The memory being that of a day from his past, where he as a child farm worker watched a team of horses ploughing the stubble back into the field during a rainy day which gets progressively more stormy....   [tags: Muir Horses Essays]

Strong Essays
595 words (1.7 pages)

Police Officers And The Police Officer Essay

- It is not right for one to abuse their powers especially when it harms other people, police officers have a lot of power in their hands and to some that power goes to their heads and they abuse of that power and use excessive force when needed or not needed, either way they do not have the right to use it. Because police officers are using excessive force they should change how police officers deal in certain situations, they should punish police officers who use excessive force and they should put body cameras on police officers....   [tags: Police, Police brutality, Police officer]

Strong Essays
1048 words (3 pages)

Essay on Police Enforcement And Police Department

- Police and Community Demographics “The police are the people and the people are the police” those words, said by Sir Robert Peel, the father of community policing, describe how a well ran city and police department should be. The people of the community should feel comfortable enough with its own police department to act as the police department’s eyes. A police department can only afford to pay so many police officers, that it is virtually impossible to bring justice to all the wrong doings in the community....   [tags: Police, Constable, Police officer]

Strong Essays
1007 words (2.9 pages)

The Police as Street Corner Psychiatrists and Their Effectiveness in that Role

- The Police as Street Corner Psychiatrists and Their Effectiveness in that Role The mentally disordered only come into contact with the police when their unusual behaviour is noticed by the public and with that call the police for help. Automatically the mentally disordered are labelled as bad or criminals instead of mad people who do need help. If someone who is suffering from a mental disorder gets into a dispute or is causing public disorder the police are called to the scene and it is there they have to look at the person and 'diagnose' if the suspect has a mental disorder....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
980 words (2.8 pages)

The Police Department And The Department Of Public Safety Essay

- Vernon Police Department The Vernon Police Department, formally the Rockville Police Department, was established in 1965 when the Rockville Police Department and the Vernon Department of Public Safety were combined (Vernon Police Department, 31). The Rockville Police Department was established in 1890 when Mayor Samuel Finch appointed three police officers and five supernumeraries to serve the City of Rockville (VPD, 4). Presently, the Vernon Police Department is made up of 61 sworn and civilian personnel, with 52 authorized officers protecting over eighteen square miles....   [tags: Constable, Police, Police officer]

Strong Essays
1505 words (4.3 pages)

Stop Police Brutality : A Police Officer Essay

- Stop Police Brutality On August 9, 2014, Unarmed 18 year-old Michael Brown’s life was taken by police officers. He was shot 7 times, the last shot to the back of his head is what took this young man’s life. He was a young unarmed black male. Just in 2014 over 1,000 people were killed at the hands of police officers. However, even though police say they are just doing their job, police should not be able to abuse their power, because more cases of police brutality are being captured on cell phones and innocent people are being killed....   [tags: Police, Constable, Police brutality]

Strong Essays
2032 words (5.8 pages)

Analysis Of The Poem ' Stickeen ' By John Muir Essay

- In the excerpt “Stickeen”, John Muir describes his experience of exploring the icy region of Alaska terrain in 1880. The author talks about his perils and hardships he encountered while trekking the Alaska region. He also recounts his relationship with the four legged companion named Stickeen, who was brought along by one of the author’s companion, Rev. S.H. Young, to the expedition. The author describes in detail of how he first met Stickeen and gives a brief description of his appearance, “He was short-legged and bunchy-bodied, and his hair, though smooth, was long and silky and slightly waved, so that when the wind was at his back it ruffled, making him look shaggy” (par....   [tags: Fear, Anxiety, Dog, Coming out]

Strong Essays
1303 words (3.7 pages)

The Structure Of Police And Police Essay

- The paramilitary structure links the military and police rather intimately because their foundation of power is identical- “the state sanctioned capacity to use physical force to accomplish respective objectives (internal and external security)” (Kraska 2007, 503). If their foundation of power is the same, then their structural adaptations will more than likely end up the same, especially with the introduction of police paramilitary units (PPUs) such as SWAT. This ideology also follows regional and municipal police agencies....   [tags: Police, Law enforcement, Community policing]

Strong Essays
772 words (2.2 pages)