James M. McPherson’s “American Victory, American Defeat” essay goes back and forth with internal and external descriptions. He encompasses a variety of conflicting views and also talks about the overwhelming numbers and resources argument. There is plenty of food for thought in the opposing views he discusses. He quotes a response from Gen. George Pickett early on in his essay which stuck with me. Pickett was responding to a question of who was responsible for the Confederate defeat at Gettysburg and General Pickett replied “I’ve always thought the Yankees had something to do with it.” (19) Valid arguments are represented supporting a full mix of possibilities leading the end results of the Civil War; not to just one reason of loss.
Archer Jones’ “ Military Means, Political Ends: Strategy” essay brought in more...
... middle of paper ...
...ough their battles were not as glorified in the public eye their efforts began before they took up arms in the war and they were a crucial part of the Union success.
This book was a great way to dissect the Civil War and look at much more than the common answers given for reasons of win or loss. The Authors of each essay were able to shed new light on the regurgitated arguments of old and cause a reader to look at other points, to see and consider MORE than the face value of the war. This book challenged you to acknowledge there were many, many contributing factors to Why the Confederacy Lost. It painted an intricate web of tactics both militaristic and political; pulling into consideration other activities, decisions, and reasons for the result of the Civil War. Had all of the pieces not been placed as they were the outcome could have been very different.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The dictionary understanding of the confederacy is a group of people, countries, organizations, etc., that are joined together in some activity or effort. The Civil War understanding of the confederacy is a group of states that chose to secede from the Union and start one of the deadliest wars in American history. The Confederacy as a whole symbolize a group of people who were for the use and torture of a community of people so much, that they fought their own state for a chance to continue importing and enslaving masses of people in the name of good crops.... [tags: American Civil War, Confederate States of America]
1015 words (2.9 pages)
- Why the Confederacy Lost the War Many historians have tried to offer their ideology on the outcome of the Civil War. McPherson in his “American Victory, American Defeat” writes about what other historians have decreed their answers to why the Confederacy lost. He tells us the reasons that could not be the explanation for the loss, and explains the internal reasons but leaves the true cause of the loss untold. Freehling explains the defeat by discussing what could have been and then gives reasons to negate some of the cases that he states for the outcome of the Confederacy.... [tags: Papers]
716 words (2 pages)
- The Civil War was one of the events that changed the course of American history forever. It tore the nation apart causing Americans to fight against each other, pitting brothers and friends alike against one another. The war was the bloodiest every to happen in American history. There are many possible reasons on why the Confederacy lost the Civil War to the Union. There were the differences of the economies between the North and the South, the Union’s blockade of Confederate ports, their military man power and leadership, and the government and its leadership.... [tags: civil war, american history]
1688 words (4.8 pages)
- There were several reasons for the defeat of the Confederacy which included no industrial base, (Donald 1996, p. 99) inadequate transportation net (Donald, 1996, p. 99), and bickering among the generals (McPherson & Hogue, 2009, p. 365) etc., but the overriding factor was that the Confederacy never became a nation (Donald, 1996, p. 100). That is, they seceded because the Southern states believed they had the right as independent States to do so (Donald, 1996, p. 7). The South lost because they never stopped believing this.... [tags: The Civil War]
1817 words (5.2 pages)
- Why the North Won "The art of war is simple enough. Find out where your enemy is. Get at him as soon as you can. Strike him as hard as you can, and keep moving on." (Ulysses S. Grant). The American Civil War was fought from the year of 1861 to the year of 1865. The war was fought between the Union (Northern states) and the Confederacy (Southern States). Informally, the Union can be referred to as the Yankees, and the Confederacy can be referred to as the Rebels. At this time, Abraham Lincoln was serving as the United States president.... [tags: American Civil War, Confederate States of America]
1096 words (3.1 pages)
- Though debated by many historians, the Civil War is often referred to as a “total war,” meaning that the conflict permeated every aspect of life in the United States. The home front of both the Union and the Confederacy played crucial aspects in supporting their armies; however, there were many issues that both sides faced. On both sides the respective home fronts faced a failing economy and inflation as well as shortages of material and labor. There was the controversial question of slavery and whether emancipation was approaching and the political tension that traveled with it.... [tags: American Civil War, United States]
1096 words (3.1 pages)
- Civil War and the not used advantages of the South The civil war was the deadliest war in American history, taking the lives of approximately 600,000 soldiers; so many people had to die just for a conflict over a particular style of life of some individuals. The Southern states depended upon the agriculture that their slaves worked for, including cotton production. When Abraham Lincoln became named President in 1860, his opposition of slavery was seen as a threat to the economic interests of most Southern states.... [tags: American Civil War, Confederate States of America]
1952 words (5.6 pages)
- ... The Confederates emerged victorious after the Unions looked like they held a considerable lead. 18. During the opening of the Battle for Bull Run, the North was shattering the lines of the Confederates, except for those of Stonewall Jackson who held strong and provided hope for the surrounding men. He was known as one of the greatest leaders of the Civil War. 19. The Peninsula Campaign was the first large-scale campaign in the Civil War led by George McClellan with the Army of the Potomac. It ended with the battle at Seven Pines in which McClellan lost most of his men.... [tags: The Civil War Essays]
2342 words (6.7 pages)
- Should the Confederacy have won the civil war. Looking at the American Civil War ones must also look at the economics of the 19th century in the U. S. Hand in hand one must also look at the politics and battle plans of the war. The slave plantation owners’ class was a minority in the Southern population but it controlled southern politics and society. Slavery being the biggest investment of the South, and the fear of slave instability ensured the allegiance of southern non-slave-owners to the economic and social system of the South.... [tags: essays research papers fc]
1407 words (4 pages)
- Abraham Lincoln once stated, "A House divided against itself cannot stand. I Believe this government cannot endure, permanently half slave and half free. I do not expect the house to fall. But I do expect it will cease to be divided. It will become all one thing, or all the other". More than anything else, differing interpretations about the Civil War drove the debate over the meaning of the Constitution and of the Union. These were, of course, not new issues. Indeed, as Professor Joseph Ellis has noted in Founding Brothers: the Revolutionary Generation both had been on the minds of the delegates to Philadelphia in 1787.... [tags: American History Civil War]
1192 words (3.4 pages)