An anonymous article published by the online newspaper, The Economist, explains the revolutionary experiments conducted by Paul Piff and makes the unconventional statement that it is the poor, not the rich, who are inclined to charity. The thought of poor people being more generous than the rich is something that wouldn’t make sense to most. Some may ask themselves, “Why would someone who has “less,” give more?” But this question is one that I have never had to ask myself. I come from a single-parent, lower-middle class household in one of the poorest sides of San Antonio, Texas, and I have been collecting direct evidence on why Paul Piff is right for my entire life, before I had even read about his experiments; the less you have, the more you give and, “empathy and compassion are the key ingredients.”
At the beginning of the experiments, the participants were purposely mislead and told to engage in activities that were really changing their impression of the purpose of the research. Then, they were given 10 credits and were told to choose to give away their credits to their partners from the bogus activities. Weeks before the game was conducted people were asked to rank themselves on a ladder of people of different education, income, and occupational status. The result of this experiment showed that kindness and generosity increased as participants’ assessment of their own social status fell. Piffs observations are consistent with the national survey results showing that lower-income people donate a greater percentage of their salary to charity than upper-income do. A second experiment expanded on this finding, suggesting that there’s something about the particular psychological ...
... middle of paper ...
...y people, but as a whole, the wealthy generally give less than the poor. Some give out of the kindness of their heart, but some give out of vanity, guilt, tax breaks, and some even give out of conviction that their success in business makes them equivalently expert in solving the planet 's problems. The rich simply give to feel better about themselves, keep up with the Jones’, and “satisfy the needs of white people and Oprah.” This can be directly tied back into The White-Savior Industrial Complex. “The White Savior Industrial Complex is not about justice. It is about having a big emotional experience that validates privilege,” says Teju Cole in the article, The White-Savior Industrial Complex. It is this point that makes the claim that rich people give more insignificant because their overall drive is self-motivated, rather than motivated by compassion and empathy.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- For truly I tell you, whoever gives you a cup o water to drink because you bear the name of Christ will by no means lose the reward. God is generous. I believe that this sentence can characterize one of the important themes present in today’s Liturgy of the Word. But what does it mean that the Almighty is generous and where can we see and experience this dimension of God’s love. I would like to begin this reflection with a personal question: When you hear the sentence: God is generous; what kind of thoughts come to your mind.... [tags: Jesus, New Testament, Islam, God in Christianity]
866 words (2.5 pages)
- Welfare and Government Assistance Policy Recommendations Being raised in a single-parent lower class home, I realize first-hand the need for welfare and government assistance programs. I also realize that the system is very complex and can become a crutch to people who become dependent and complacent. As a liberal American I do believe that the government should provide services to the less fortunate and resources to find work. However, as able-bodied citizens we should not become complacent with collecting benefits and it is the government’s job to identify people who take advantage of the system and strip benefits from people who are not making efforts to support themselves independently.... [tags: poor countries, too generous]
690 words (2 pages)
- In bell hooks’ “Seeing and Making Culture: Representing the Poor”, she discusses the portrayal and misrepresentation of poverty in our society and the methods behind the dilemma. In this excerpt, retrieved from her book Outlaw Culture: Resisting Representations (1994), hooks focuses on the negative effects of contemporary popular culture and its contribution to the negative societal views on poverty. hooks recalls from personal experience the lessons she learned when she was growing up in a poor family.... [tags: Poverty, Wealth, Popular culture, Culture]
1021 words (2.9 pages)
- ... Here, the person giving is illustrating sensitivity when we supply the poor person with the lavishes that they had in their previous life (ex. The horse and servant, fancy clothes, a significant other.) We are filling in what they lack and we need to be generous with our charity, showing kindness and sympathy towards the less fortunate. In halachah dalet (ד), we see an example of a particular circumstance. Rambam discusses an orphan who comes to your door wanting a woman to marry. He says that we must rent them a house/room and get him all the necessary household appliances that he will need.... [tags: charity, money, help]
2039 words (5.8 pages)
- The Working Poor in America The United States, a place where anyone can “pick themselves up by the bootstraps” and realize the American dream of a comfortable lifestyle. Well, for over 30 million Americans this is no longer possible. Though we live in the richest and most powerful country in the world there are many who are living under or at the precipice of the poverty level, “While the United States has enjoyed unprecedented affluence, low-wage employees have been testing the American doctrine that hard work cures poverty” (The Working Poor, 4).... [tags: Essays Papers]
1165 words (3.3 pages)
- Between 1450 and 1700, attitudes toward the European poor changed dynamically, roughly following a three-part cycle. In the late 1400's, the poor were regarded with sympathy and compassion; generous aid from both public and religious institutions was common. By the 16th Century, however, the poor were treated with suspicion and harsh measures, to ensure that they were not becoming lazy, using welfare as a substitute for labor. Beginning in the 17th Century, the attitudes toward the poor again shifted, returning to more sympathetic views and responses, though many members of the upper-class still retained the negative outlook on the destitute of the 16th Century.... [tags: European History]
675 words (1.9 pages)
- The french revolution was to help the French people gain freedom and their rights, but it came with repercussions. In the astounding novel of Les Miserables written by Victor Hugo, Victor Hugo expressed his concern on the poor people of France when he wrote a story about the life of a philanthropist. The philanthropist's name was Jean Valjean and the audience can see Victor Hugo's emphasization on his care for the poor through Jean Valjean. Even though Jean himself was enduring France's economic decline, he still gave to the impoverished.... [tags: Poor, Starvation, Riots]
759 words (2.2 pages)
- I personally think that there should be rich people in the world as well as poor people. This enables the rich to support the poor through Sadaqah and Zakah. Through a Muslim point of view, there can be rich people, but they must help the poor because the Prophet said: 'None of you believes until he wishes for his brother what he wishes for himself.' From the times gone by of the Muslims we know that there can be wealthy people, even if there is poverty in the world. Many of the companions of the Prophet were very rich, but they were very generous with their wealth.... [tags: Global Poverty Essays]
1901 words (5.4 pages)
- The Abuse of the Poor in Oliver Twist by Charles Dickens Charles Dickens shows notable amounts of originality and morality in his novels, making him one of the most well-known novelists of the Victorian Era and preserving him through his great novels and short stories. One of the reasons his work has been so popular is because his novels reflect the issues of the Victorian era, such as the great disregard of many Victorians to the situation of the poor. The reformation of the Poor Law in 1834 brings even more unavoidable problems to the poor.... [tags: Papers]
954 words (2.7 pages)
- Rich and Poor Theme in Charles Dickens' Great Expectations Throughout the novel, there are many themes, one of them being rich and poor. This theme is introduced by the background description in the opening pages. In this novel the attitudes of the rich relatives, (uncle Pumblechook), are a great contrast to those of lower financial class, - Joe and Mrs. Joe. Special food is reserved for when richer relatives come around; this is a motion of respect. For the duration of the novel, Pip pursues wealth and when he finally attains it he finds it’s useless as he sees its source as ‘tainted’, his wealth is acquired through Magwich.... [tags: Charles Dickens Great Expectations Essays]
836 words (2.4 pages)