Why do we give? First, there is the “humanitarian imperative”; we help because we can. The obligation to assist arises from our ability to do so. Second, we assist because we are conscious of belonging to a single community of mankind. Mortenson gave with no expectation of reciprocity. Third, we make these gestures because they show us in good light, both to ourselves and to others. Fourth, we make this effort because we believe that reinforcing economic and social basis of society promotes peace and stability. There is a whole philosophy of “functionalism” based on the idea that an educated, prosperous society is also a peaceful society. Fifth, Mortenson may not have been aware of this but gestures like his soon attract support from other sources whose motives may or may not be as pure as the original gesture. The motive might be national interest, economic interest, or security or political influence . . . etc.
Each of these five points is subject to serious questioning and doubt. Take the humanitarian imperative. We feel an obligation to help because we can help. If you cannot swim there is no obligation to dive into the water to save someone. But note, often our humanitarian impulse is seriously compromised or constrained by problems of access. The greatest need is in the most remote parts of the world and Mortenson’s achievement is th...
... middle of paper ...
...e Mortenson but unfortunately Pakistan will not be saved by such gestures. The book goes on to mention how the proliferation of Wahabi Madrassas vastly outstrip Mortenson’s efforts (p.243). Individual good deeds bless the doer but they rarely work on a scale that overcomes the problems of society.
Similarly, I am uneasy about the easy assumption of the book that education will bring peace. Let me make a more fundamental point. Giving should be disinterested. Once we assign a purpose, then we are giving not for the benefit of the recipient but to advance our ideas, our interests. In any case, education does not pacify, it incites new demands. Education liberates, it empowers. It is wonderful if we are ready to make the oppressed people of the world rise up, but we must not be surprised if they begin to agitate, to criticize and, who knows, point fingers at us.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Give a Boy a Gun by Todd Strasser Give a Boy a Gun by Todd Strasser describes school shootings by looking at one school, shooting that happened in Middletown, Colorado. This book is loosely based upon the real events at Columbine High School in Littleton. Two students were teased and harassed by their peers. Eventually, they take them hostage at a school dance. Gary and Brandon were very close friends and they both have something in common: they were both teased and harassed and teased and sometimes even physically and verbally abused.... [tags: Todd Strasser Give a Boy a Gun]
718 words (2.1 pages)
- ... Moreover, the results of the 2011 World Giving Index Report ranks the United States as the #1 most generous country in the world. These study findings clearly illustrate that, even in these hard economic times, the American spirit of generosity is alive and growing. What has changed and is currently evolving is the way individuals give. According to Matthew Bishop, co-author of the groundbreaking book Philanthropcapitalsm, wealthy families are beginning to give at an earlier age and their giving is more impact driven.... [tags: boy, branches, philanthropic]
718 words (2.1 pages)
- The quote, “Give me liberty, or give me death!” is attributed Patrick Henry from a speech he made to the Second Virginia Convention. In good times and bad, Americans look to the founding fathers for help. They are often attributed to using the bible and Plato as influence for the constitution. What many people do not know is exactly what they pulled from Plato, and why the Republic was relevant then and today. Plato’s Republic is relevant today because of its views on government, specifically, the role of families, human rights, and education of religion in the system of government.... [tags: Human rights, Government, Plato, Democracy]
1470 words (4.2 pages)
- Throughout his speech, Henry referenced a variety of Biblical themes. What are some of the most striking references Henry used. Why would these themes have resonated with his audience. This speech is timeless and would stir the patriotic spirit in many people. The message it contains can work for us today as well as it did for the colonists it was originally written for. Throughout time none of the power in this speech has diminished. It was a call for a young nation to say enough and stand up and fight for the liberty they so desired and deserved.... [tags: christianity, bible, god]
887 words (2.5 pages)
- In the spring of 1775 the settlers in the early American colonies were in a state of chaos. Protestant religious revivals, which subsequently became a permanent part of American culture, swept the colonies in the mid-eighteenth century. This Great Awakening preceded the American Revolution. Leaders of the Awakening caused a widespread call to a new spiritual birth in Christ to people of all backgrounds and social classes. This movement divided church congregations and caused people to rethink the authority of the church on society.... [tags: American Revolution, American History]
932 words (2.7 pages)
- What is the ideal age to give birth . . Is it in the 20s or in the 30s . . Couples get married and start thinking about the suitable time of having their first baby . Having a baby is not simply a quick decision , but a well prepared one . Parenting itself is a commitment that needs preparation and support . So , Parents have to think of everything before welcoming their coming child . Some people prefer starting a family in the 20s due to fertility , full energy and grandparents’ role .... [tags: Parenting, Childhood, Family, Mother]
1358 words (3.9 pages)
- Mentoring, in my understanding, is helping the person to achieve his /her goals using different methods. Mentor is somebody who knows the advantages and disadvantages of the person, and constantly encourages him /her to use the advantages in order to develop new skills, which can be used on the way to the main aim. Mentoring is a highly effective way to help the person to use the full range of his /her natural abilities. Usually people do not realize the real value of his /her possibilities and the possible ways to reach the needed results, thus, a lot of highly talented people live their lives without even realizing the real value of their talents.... [tags: relationship, responsibility, partnership]
960 words (2.7 pages)
- Three Cups of Tea, the story of Mortenson and his extraordinary school-building initiative in a remote part of Pakistan, provokes many interesting lines of inquiry. In this outline it is proposed to address the question of why we give. What compels someone like Mortenson to take on an enormous and selfless act. And how effective are the most effective individual acts of goodness. Why do we give. First, there is the “humanitarian imperative”; we help because we can. The obligation to assist arises from our ability to do so.... [tags: Literature Analysis]
1374 words (3.9 pages)
- How to Give a Lecture Lecturing is not simply a matter of standing in front of a class and reciting what you know The classroom lecture is a special form of communication in which voice, gesture, movement, facial expression, and eye contact can either complement or detract from the content. No matter what your topic, your delivery and manner of speaking immeasurably influence your students' attentiveness and learning. Use the following suggestions, based on teaching practices of faculty and on research studies in speech communication, to help you capture and hold students' interest and increase their retention.... [tags: essays papers]
2891 words (8.3 pages)
- Give Students a Break Students at Tech, and indeed at most colleges, eagerly anticipate holidays because they provide a welcome break from classes. Although some may say that breaks only take away valuable class time from students, they fail to see the educational benefits that breaks afford. Tech's sparse holiday offerings take little advantage of these benefits. Tech is harming students, who could greatly benefit from the time breaks offer for relaxation, family interaction, and studying. Despite criticism, breaks do not necessarily have to adversely affect students' education by taking away important class time.... [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays]
623 words (1.8 pages)