Why Do Good High School Students Struggle With College Level Writing? Essay

Why Do Good High School Students Struggle With College Level Writing? Essay

Length: 944 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Why Do Good High School Students Struggle with College Level Writing? Or Why Do They Sound So Smart and Write So Dumb?

They need to transition from seeing college writing assignments as different than high school homework.

“Why are you writing? Because I have a paper due tomorrow.” In college, students are expected to write because they have something to say on the topic, something worth communicating. First year students do not understand that most of the struggle and/or productive challenge of college-level writing is finding an approach/stance/position to the topic. We expect this level of engagement in college writing. In high school, students were either given topics or graded more on form and summary of content than on evidence and argument.
Authorship or “voice” becomes a problem. Unsuccessful college writers feel as if their writing has nothing to do with them; writing makes them feel depleted and exhausted. Because they often do not feel “expert” enough to write, they avoid the task altogether.
First-year students have little to no understanding of the time commitments necessary for various stages or parts of the writing process. In high school, they were used to teachers breaking writing projects down into discrete steps or tasks (e.g. outline, thesis statement, research evidence, rough draft, etc.) to be completed as homework and commented on usually at each step. In college, they need to learn to backwards plan from a paper due date and develop their own accountability for the developmental stages of a paper. In addition to this, they tend to vastly underestimate how long it will take to reread texts, organize notes or evidence, and rewrite sentences for clarity to meet all of the expectations at the co...


... middle of paper ...


...g a conversation with an invisible person. They disregard the need for internal structure—such as topic sentences, transitions, logical order of ideas, definitions attached to the words they are defining, etc. They just spill what they know, indenting where they might take a breath in a conversation. The reader is invisible to them and the belief that they are writing for a reader doesn’t make much sense. They are writing to show what they know; they are not writing a product to be read/interpreted. So most papers read like badly structured responses to blue book exam questions.
They apply the same simple writing process to all papers—whether it is a reaction/response paper or an analytic paper on a text. A first-year student’s view of a successful writing process:
Figure out what you want to say (with or without an outline)
Write the paper
Fix it up.
Turn it in.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Why Do Good High School Students Struggle With College Level Writing? Essay

- Why Do Good High School Students Struggle with College Level Writing. Or Why Do They Sound So Smart and Write So Dumb. They need to transition from seeing college writing assignments as different than high school homework. “Why are you writing. Because I have a paper due tomorrow.” In college, students are expected to write because they have something to say on the topic, something worth communicating. First year students do not understand that most of the struggle and/or productive challenge of college-level writing is finding an approach/stance/position to the topic....   [tags: High school, Writing, Writer, Writing process]

Better Essays
944 words (2.7 pages)

High Level Education At A University Essay

- I am writing in regards to my soon attendance of higher level education at a university. I plan on going to a four year university, this could be one in or outside of the state. I am not certain which college or even which major I want to attend. I am very elated about being able to attend and my acceptance into many different colleges. Going to college will constitute a new phase in my life which will open up many opportunities for possible future careers. I am dictating this letter to you to express my possible concern for my future plans....   [tags: Higher education, University, College, High school]

Better Essays
1233 words (3.5 pages)

Reading At A College Level Essay

- Throughout this semester, I’ve enhanced my knowledge of how to read and write more academically. I consider myself an average reader and writer, but reading at a college level is a lot different than high school level. For example, we were assigned to read several articles and write about them. What I had to do was write about what the authors was saying and what they meant of it. At first it was difficult for me because I thought all I had to do was to summarize the article, however, I had to write what is behind the story of the article....   [tags: Writing, Essay, High school, Teacher]

Better Essays
1241 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about My Plans For College At The Collegiate Level

- From the moment I entered high school, people were asking me my plans for college. This question of “What college are you going to?” began to loom above my head like a giant storm cloud. Freshman year I had no idea, and the same for my sophomore year. Playing softball at the collegiate level was the only thing that I knew at that moment in time. The beginning of my junior year was when I began to actively seek out specific colleges, and by the end of my junior year, I knew exactly what college I wanted to attend....   [tags: High school, College, Secondary school, Thought]

Better Essays
710 words (2 pages)

High School And College Education Essays

- School is an exceptionally important phase in our lives. Elementary, middle school, high school, and college are the places where besides our homes we learn most of our principles and moral values. I consider high school and college as the most important chapters in my life. However, high school and college education systems differ from each other in various aspects. Back when I was in high school, I thought that college would be just a follow-up, but slightly more complicated. Now that I am a college student, I realize that it is considerably more complex than high school....   [tags: High school, Education, College, University]

Better Essays
814 words (2.3 pages)

High School Vs. College Essay

- College is something that many high school students anticipate; A new transition between two very similar yet diverse worlds. This transition can be something very exciting but also very nerve raking and difficult. Students, Ready to leave behind high school, being researching to find the most prestigious schools and programs available, soon forgetting to remember that although the two, high school and college have their similarities such as doing classwork, and homework the differences are endless....   [tags: High school, University, College, Difference]

Better Essays
750 words (2.1 pages)

High School Vs. College Essay

- High School Compared to College This is my first semester in college and it its completely different than high school in many ways in my opinion. I think that college is going to be a challenge, so I hope i 'm prepared for what 's about to come. The difference between highschool and college is vast. The main ones I have experienced are greater expenses, independence, and overall seriousness of the education. The first difference to discuss is the matter of expense. College Board states that on average college students spend $1,200 every year in textbooks alone (College board)....   [tags: High school, College, Secondary education]

Better Essays
1077 words (3.1 pages)

High School Vs. College Essay

- High School vs. College Starting at the age of five, everyone begins their school career. Students all over go through numerous amounts of tests and homework throughout their time in elementary, middle, high school and college. Although high school and college may seem the same, there are much more that meets the eye. Students go through different amounts of stress, workload, and people. High school are the four years people want to remember and cherish for those years would be the last with the people you have grown up with....   [tags: High school, College, Teacher, Education]

Better Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)

High School Vs. College Essay

- High School vs. College Regardless of one’s level of education, the generation of today will be shaping the world of tomorrow. Civil Rights Activist, Nelson Mandela, put it best when he said, “Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world.” Many can interpret this quote as saying; the further an individual takes their education, the more opportunities in life they will be presented with to help develop the world into a safer, more logical place. In preparation for their future, not all, but most high school graduates choose to continue on the path to a higher education by either attending community college or a university....   [tags: High school, College, Higher education]

Better Essays
918 words (2.6 pages)

The High School Student Is Not Ready For College Essay

- The average high school student is not ready for college. Entering college as a freshman is a lot different from entering high school as a freshman. High schools tend to “think” they are preparing you for college when really students are physically and mentally not prepared. Student’s grades are inflated in high school, which is not always good. In order to succeed in college, some attribute you should have are study skills, time management, awareness of one’s performance, persistence, and the ability to utilize study groups....   [tags: High school, College, Advanced Placement]

Better Essays
1028 words (2.9 pages)