Why Diotima 's Speech Is Superior Essay

Why Diotima 's Speech Is Superior Essay

Length: 1293 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Explain why Diotima’s Speech is superior to those of both Phaedrus and Aristophanes
Aristophanes believes that two humans used to be combined as one, and we were separated by the Gods because they thought we had too much power together. He thinks the purpose of love is to seek out our other half and be with them. In his speech, however, he fails to think about whether or not our other half is good or bad. Diotima takes goodness into account. She says “…a lover does not seek the half or the whole, unless, my friend, it turns out to be good as well” (205E). Her speech is superior to Aristophanes’ because she states clearly that you are not supposed to love someone unless they are good. By good I mean having knowledge and wisdom.
Diotima’s speech is also superior to Phaedrus’ speech because his main point is that love will motivate people to not do shameful things in front of their lover. His argument does not address whether or not the love is actually good or bad between the beloved and the lover. By good I mean containing happiness. In his example, the individuals may not be happy at all. In fact, the feeling the lover gives the beloved is shame. Diotima expresses that the lover should be good and, “That’s what makes happy people happy, isn’t it – possessing good things” (205A). She holds happiness in higher regard than avoiding the feeling of shame. Phaedrus also does not say how the beloved should act when not in the presence of the lover. Diotima says that the purpose of love is not to feel shame when doing cowardice things in front of the lover, but instead, is to give “birth in beauty, whether in body or soul” (206B). When a person has a beautiful soul they will do good things whether they are in front of the...


... middle of paper ...


... a “soul that is beautiful and noble and well-formed” (209B). This means to be virtuous, and in most instances virtuous means having knowledge and having a beautiful soul. To actually ‘give birth’ to the ideas you have to sit with your lover and come up with them. Bounce thoughts off of each other. Then once you have a theory or new idea you spread your knowledge and teach others. Planting your knowledge into others is how you become immortal. Because even after you pass away your ideas will still exist, therefore, you exist. After giving birth to those ideas and loving a virtuous man who has educated you, you can move onto the next form of beauty. That is the Form of Beauty itself. So in short, our human function is to try and achieve the truest form of beauty by embracing wisdom and virtue. The result of reaching this true Form of Beauty is immortality.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Written Language as Being Superior to Speech

- Written Language as Being Superior to Speech English language has two main features; it can be presented in a written form or in the form of speech. Hence, the debate on the topic of which form of language is more significant than the other is becoming greater as time is passing. This is because more and more new technology is being created by the day to help people who are unable to speak or others who are unable to write. And, the use of these proves they can lead a normal life without the feature of English which they are incapable of using....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
600 words (1.7 pages)

Speech : Speech - My Speech

- For my “How to do” speech my goal was to share with the class an interesting and informative way to learn something new. Due to the speeches time limit, I knew I needed to be well prepared. I wanted to be less nervous before and during my speech. While presenting I was nervous, but I didn’t really have time for these feelings to sink in because I was focused on the information I wanted to share with the audience. I enjoyed presenting in the second group of speeches so I could see my peers different types of speaking style....   [tags: Graduation, Commencement speech, Speech]

Better Essays
969 words (2.8 pages)

Speech Note On Speech Disorders

- Introduction Thousands of children suffer from speech impediments every year, and schools have the responsibility to treat them. A speech impediment is “a condition that makes it difficult to speak normally” (“Speech Impediment,” n.d.). I decided to research and write about speech disorders in schools, because I suffered from speech disorders when I was young and spent every elementary school year trying to treat it. It took me seven years to finally speak like the other students in my classes, and there must be a better system to treat children faster and more effectively....   [tags: Speech disorder, Speech sound disorder]

Better Essays
1078 words (3.1 pages)

Why is Diotima a woman? Essay

- Diotima, Socrates' great teacher from the Symposium, a work by Plato was one of the most influential women thinkers of all time, whether she was a real person or a literary fictional character. She related to Socrates the theory of love that he described to the partygoers at Agathon's banquet, a celebration of Agathon's victory at the competition of Dionysis in Athens and of Eros. Before we search for the idea of why Diotima is a woman, we should first discuss a little about her. We know that, if she were an actual person, she would have been born around 470 BCE and died around 410 BCE....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
815 words (2.3 pages)

Speech Acts : Speech Act ( Speech )

- Speech Acts “Hey, can you reach that,” I asked pointing at a book on the top shelf. The boy standing next to me looked around before replying to ensure that I was, in fact, speaking to him. “Uh, yeah. The blue one?” He responded to confirm which book I had been pointing at. “Yep. Thanks, you’re a life saver.” “No problem,” he said as he handed me the book. I smiled at him before turning to walk back to the table I had been studying at. After reading that nothing about the interaction seems strange without understanding speech acts, particularly indirect speech acts....   [tags: Speech act, Pragmatics, Philosophy of language]

Better Essays
1132 words (3.2 pages)

A Speech On Stanford Commencement Speech

- Stanford Commencement Ceremony is a very prestigious, it is an honor to be asked to speak for it. In 2005 Steve Jobs was invited to speak at Stanford’s Commencement Ceremony and he delivered his speech where some of his most famous quotes came from, such as “Stay Hungry. Stay Foolish.” -Steve Jobs. When he steps up to the podium viewers can tell that the crowed has high expectations for his speech. For Steve Jobs the 2005 Stanford Commencement speech was a success because he had a clear and focused message and it was engaging in content....   [tags: Graduation, Commencement speech, Speeches]

Better Essays
1179 words (3.4 pages)

Graduation Speech : A Speech

- Graduation is not as glamorous as everyone thinks. Sitting in the bleachers for four hours in the scalding heat with your nicest clothes on is not fun (at least for me). I would’ve had no problem skipping my graduation, except for one part. There is one segment of graduation that makes the whole thing bearable, the speech. The graduation speech plays a pivotal role in making or breaking graduation ceremony. These speeches not only serve to inspire the public, but also shapes the values of the academic community....   [tags: Commencement speech, Graduation, Want]

Better Essays
1170 words (3.3 pages)

Commencement Speech : A Speech

- “Climb on one’s back and stand on their shoulders to reach the top” this is what the Coronel Colin Powell hints to recent graduate from the Howard University in 1994. The Commencement Speech was long enough to motivate the graduating students. Also, it was proper and formal. When the speech began, Powell was exciting by ending on sharing his own experiences and giving great advices for those future professionals. Powell´s Commencement Speech demonstrates his interest by sharing his thoughts, and its language was uplifting and captivating....   [tags: Graduation, Commencement speech]

Better Essays
804 words (2.3 pages)

Commencement Speech : A Speech

- Commencement Speech, Howard University, 1994. “Climb on one’s back and stand on their shoulders to reach the top” this is what the Coronel Colin Powell hints to recent graduating students from the Howard University in 1994. The Commencement Speech was long enough to motivate the graduating students. In addition, it was proper and formal. When the speech began, Powell was excited by ending on sharing his own experiences and giving great advices for those future professionals. Powell´s Commencement Speech demonstrates his interest by sharing his thoughts, and its language was uplifting and captivating....   [tags: Commencement speech, Graduation]

Better Essays
819 words (2.3 pages)

Superior Sociteys Essay

- Are some Societies or Cultures superior. First let examine the definition of the word ‘Egalitarianism', it is defined as: Egalitarianism (derived from the word égal, meaning equal or level) is the moral doctrine that people should be treated as equals, in some respect. Generally it applies to being held equal under the law, the church, and society at large. Perhaps in its theoretical form, Egalitarianism affirms, promotes, and believes in equal political, economic opportunity, social, and civil rights for all people....   [tags: Opinion]

Free Essays
857 words (2.4 pages)