Essay on Where Does Magical Thinking Stem From and How Is It Acquired?

Essay on Where Does Magical Thinking Stem From and How Is It Acquired?

Length: 2219 words (6.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Rituals associated with magical thinking are practiced by young children and adults alike in the face of uncertainty and during periods of stress or transition that pose a potential threat to either the self or selfhood; the fact that a belief and reliance on magical rituals can exist simultaneously with a rational cause-effect perception of reality in both adults and children reveals that while individuals may attain a more rational worldview with age, a system of non-rational thinking may be foundational to human cognitive functions.

Given all this, then where does magical thinking stem from and how is it acquired? Eugene Subbotsky (1997) argues that both magical and rational cause-effect reasoning are derived from a common source, that of phenomenalism. Magical thinking and scientific reasoning are often placed in diametric opposition, but by investigating causal reasoning through the lens of phenomenalism it is possible to conceive of magical and scientific thinking as two sides of the same coin—both linking the presence of a specific cause to a preceding effect and, hence, limited by the same basic principles of causality (Woolley, J. D., Browne C.A., & Boerger E.A. 2006). But phenomenalism itself anticipates these two forms of causal reasoning, and is defined by Subbotsky as “a purely empirical judgment about a causal connection between . . . events and lacks a theoretical foundation of any kind.” (14) Phenomenalism can also be thought of as an intermediary stage of uncertainty, in which an individual notices a cause-effect linkage but has not yet defined it within either the magical or rational context.

As research by Subbotsky (1997) reveals, children's interpretations of inexplicable events are given over to magi...


... middle of paper ...


...opious evidence suggests that children as well as adults appear to revert to magical thinking when compelled by anxiety-inducing or generally uncontrollable situations. Moreover, there are telling commonalities between the constraints placed on both ordinary and magical causal reasoning that suggest a precedent process is at work behind the scenes of human cognition. Subbotsky ties these similarities together in what is known as the “coexistence model”, wherein scientifically-based causal reasoning is not a usurper of the mind, as has been previously speculated, but merely a later-developed method of reasoning against a submerged background of alternate ways of reasoning. Magical thinking is one such causal reasoning process, and it can be spurred to the forefront as a way for the mind to regain control in distressful situations that threaten the self or selfhood.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Year of Magical Thinking by Joan Didion Essay

- ... Individuals grieve in different ways, and there is nothing wrong with that. During the book, she tried to do things familiar to her and her husband. In an attempt to keep him alive, that is perfectly normal. It felt like she wrote the book to justify her feelings on her husband’s death. People assume there is a right and wrong way to grieve, and that is not the case. I believe to book highlights on how individuals grieve differently. The author’s daughter had a different grieving experience than her mother, most likely....   [tags: grieving process, loss]

Better Essays
847 words (2.4 pages)

Essay The Year of Magical Thinking by Joan Didion

- The Year of Magical Thinking is Joan Didion’s account of the year following the death of her husband, writer John Gregory Dunne. The book shows how she attempts to cope with the grief of the death of her husband while tending to her daughter’s, Quintana, severe illness. In the book Didion does something, which might seem abnormal to some people. While Didion is cleaning out her husband’s closet at work she cannot find herself throwing away her husband’s shoes because “he would need shoes if he was to return” (Didion)....   [tags: memoir, story review]

Better Essays
533 words (1.5 pages)

Stem Cell Research : Stem Cells Essay

- Stem cells have several potential applications. Stem cells can be used to study development by helping us to understand how a complex organism develops from a fertilized egg. Some of the serious medical conditions such as cancer and birth defects which are lead by abnormal cell division and differentiation will have new therapy dealing with stem cell research. Stem cells have the ability to replace damaged cells and treat disease of extensive burns, leukemia (a cancer of blood forming tissues) and other blood disorders....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell]

Better Essays
1538 words (4.4 pages)

Mormon Irrationality or Magical Thinking Essay

- Mormon Irrationality or Magical Thinking I am regularly (such as last night) in conversation with well-educated Mormons who struggle when trying to deal with rational concepts related to things like science, investment strategies, politics and other purely secular matters. And I see in their struggles infections likely attributable to the magical thinking at the heart of what is required these days to be a literally believing Mormon. The conversation in which I participated last night that caused this essay had to do with an investment opportunity that a bright, successful young Mormon had been offered....   [tags: Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints]

Free Essays
1073 words (3.1 pages)

Magical Thinking And The Decline Of America By Richard Rapson Essay

- United States of America a country recently created have come a long way from being some small colonies of United Kingdom to become a major superpower in the world. American history of 240 years dominating other countries and the present decline of the US. Magical Thinking and the decline of America by Richard Rapson talks about the American history, rapid changes, and attitude of the Americans. The U.S began as colonies that revolted and broke apart from the British control by becoming their own independent country....   [tags: United States, Thirteen Colonies, Americas]

Better Essays
830 words (2.4 pages)

Magical Realism Essay examples

- To many critics of the genre, Magical Realism is nothing but updated children's tales being passed off as substantial literature, but if we look deeper, the essence of this movement is bared to the viewer. By looking at the history and origins of Magical Realism, as well as the term itself, we can begin to understand the importance of this writing style in today's society. The roots behind Magical Realism are found in many cultures, but the literature is mainly attributed to South American writers, such as Gabriel Garcia Marquez....   [tags: Magical Realism Essays]

Free Essays
583 words (1.7 pages)

The History and Theory of Magical Realism Essay

- The History and Theory of Magical Realism Magical Realism is one of today's most popular subjects in literature to discuss regarding its history and theory of Magical Realism. It began in the Latin culture and now is known word wide for its attributes. Magical Realism is even rivaling some of the great masterpieces of modern and past literature. Someday Magical Realism will be recognized and respected just as the classics are today. Magical Realism supposedly began in 1935 with its golden age occurring between 1940 and 1950.The Magical Realism of Spanish and Latin America can be somewhat attributed to the social, political, and European influence....   [tags: Literature Magical Realism Essays]

Better Essays
1041 words (3 pages)

Magical Realism: Theory and History Essay

- Magical Realism: Theory and History While reading Franz Roh, Angel Flores, Amaryll Chanady, and Luis Leal, I have learned many things about magical realism. I also learned that there are many different definitions for magical realism. I have learned that magical realism is not considered a fairy tale. Amaryll Chanady feels that magical realism is focused more toward reality. However, Luis Leal feels that magical realism is used to express emotions. While reading these essays and finding some research on magical realism, I found that many people have many different views on what magical realism is....   [tags: Magical Realism Literature Papers]

Free Essays
1746 words (5 pages)

Connecting Magical Realism and Psychology Essay

- Connecting Magical Realism and Psychology At first, German art critic Franz Roh used the term "Magical Realism" to describe a style of painting (Roh 15). Eventually, Arturo Uslar Pietri adapted the term in order to describe a type of literature (Leal 120). While the exact definition of Magical Realism is open to interpretation, it is certain that Magical Realism gives a deeper meaning to ordinary life by unearthing mysteries that hide behind the world (Roh 16-17). In order to uncover these mysteries, Magical Realism combines fantasy with reality (Flores 110-111)....   [tags: Magical Realism Psychology]

Free Essays
774 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Magical Realism

- Magical Realism The idea of a genre of art that is called magical realism is less a trend than a tradition, an evolving genre that has its waxings and wanings, where each evolving form expresses an idea that may overlap another, yet at the same time branches off and creates something very different. What began in the visual arts has become a contemporary literary genre due to divergences. Contemporary Latin American writers of this mode include Alejo Carpentier, Jorge Luis Borges, Isabel Allende, Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Octavio Paz, Pablo Neruda, and Majorie Agosin....   [tags: Magical Realism Essays]

Better Essays
1245 words (3.6 pages)