Essay about What Makes A Woman By Elinor Burkett

Essay about What Makes A Woman By Elinor Burkett

Length: 1252 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In her online article “What Makes a Woman” (2015), Elinor Burkett asserts that the trans society should not reduce being a woman down to the genitalia and that a woman is created through the experiences she endures in her lifetime. Burkett supports her claim about what creates a woman by presenting the reader with evidence taken from trans-genders who are fighting against women’s rights and goes to challenge them by sharing her view on the topic. Burkett’s purpose is to dissipate the undermining of women’s characteristics by silencing their experiences in order to generate awareness of what a woman’s identity is. She has a young adult audience that is aware of current events in the trans-gender movement in mind because she writes with a tone of assuredness and higher intellect levels.
The text that Elinor Burkett writes in is persuasive. She is giving her point of view on the trans-gender movement and trying to influence or persuade her audience. Burkett presents the audience with different points of view in order to give background information to the issue. She gives arguments and evidence from different trans-genders in order to sum up the opposing side. She then gives reasoning from her point of view or side in order to try and convince others to agree with her. She organizes her material by beginning with a statement that is sure to capture the reader. She then moves on to state her opinion and use evidence to show the contrary point of view. By using this type of organization, Burkett is portraying her opinion on the trans-gender movement and also supplying evidence to give justification to her beliefs. Statistics, facts, and real-life examples from the contradictory side create a firm foundation for Burkett to contest agai...


... middle of paper ...


... as a whole (Burkett). When Caitlyn Jenner came out to the public her life was instantly scrutinized by the public. Although it was a large issue, Jenner had many supporters, Burkett not being one of them. She believes that “Ms. Jenner’s experience included a hefty dose of male privilege few women could possibly imagine” and this pushed Burkett to write the article.
“What Makes a Woman?” summed up Elinor Burkett’s views along with many others’ on the trans-gender uprising movement. Burkett’s purpose is to dissipate the undermining of women’s characteristics by silencing their experiences in order to generate awareness of what a woman’s identity is. She does not want the trans-genders to undermine women by suppressing their experiences. Burkett’s article is one that can be read by any member of the population above 17 years old and who cares about current events.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis Of The Article ' What Makes A Woman? ' Essay

- ARGUING FEMALE On June 6, 2015, Elinor Burkett wrote a piece about how the transgender movement is affecting feminist movements in “What Makes a Woman?”. The article specifically targeted Caitlyn Jenner in response to the interview by Diane Sawyer, “I’m a Woman”. In the interview, Caitlyn Jenner speaks of her newfound womanhood and how she sees herself as a woman both in body and mind. Elinor Burkett, though, disagrees. In “What Makes a Woman?”, the author declares transgenderism does not equate feminism making a claim of definition on what feminism is....   [tags: Rhetoric, Logos, Critical thinking, Woman]

Better Essays
1078 words (3.1 pages)

What Makes A Man A Woman? Essays

- ... She subsequently dressed in “male” clothing, sustained her desires to cross-dress, and worked diligently on maintaining a toned body (Bussinger, 2015). Caitlyn’s, “acts, gestures, enactments… are performative in the sense that the essence or identity that they otherwise purport to express are fabrications” (Butler, 185). While Butler eludes that all identities are fabricated, Caitlyn, as Bruce, felt her constructed identity was uncorrelated with her sexual identity. Thus, Caitlyn as a man purposely performed her gender, not only to fit in the gender binary, but to hide her feminine yearnings....   [tags: Gender, Woman, Transgender, Masculinity]

Better Essays
928 words (2.7 pages)

What Makes A Woman? Essay examples

- On the list of things you must accomplish to truly be happy in this world finding the one person that you see as a potential soul mate is usually the most important. Due to lack of support or teaching from older family members there are individuals who simply can not treat their significant other properly. When a man truly loves a woman he seeks to be better than any competition he may have in the eyes of his possible relationship partner. The amount of effort a man can put into this task is extraordinary....   [tags: Love, Woman, Interpersonal relationship]

Better Essays
880 words (2.5 pages)

What Makes A Woman? Essay

- What Makes a Woman & What Makes a Man. Society has set up specific binary guidelines as to how men and women should act and behave, their gender roles masculine or feminine, and how they should look according to outward physical appearance, their sex male or female. There are two sexes which equal two genders, no gray area and nothing in-between According to society this is what defines an individual as a man or a woman. In the simplest of terms, women have an XX chromosome and men have an XY chromosome....   [tags: Gender, Female, Woman, Gender role]

Better Essays
1248 words (3.6 pages)

Essay about What Makes A Woman? Born Or Made?

- ... Body type. Or the way she dresses. Let 's examine the picture on the right side of your screen. This is Caitlyn Jenner (formerly known as Bruce Jenner). She presents herself fairly, collar bones and cleavage are showing which represents a feminine figure, and she is dressed in a corset. If femininity is defined by this, then yes, Caitlyn Jenner is a woman. But does everyone acknowledge her as a woman. No. Most people still see her as Bruce Jenner- the Olympian gold medalist, father of Kendall and Kylie Jenner, and former husband of Kris Jenner....   [tags: Gender, Transgender, Woman, Transwoman]

Better Essays
835 words (2.4 pages)

Essay about What Makes A Pregnant Woman?

- It was two days before my baby sister was born. The sky was a gray with a white dim and I was wearing my favorite Bruno Mars shirt. On my way to the local grocery store my mom had mentioned how she wasn 't ready for the baby and didn 't know what would be the outcome. She went on saying that no matter how unprepared she felt there was no way she could give up her child. I just sat in the passenger side wondering why the first time of me hearing of this baby was a month ago. Crazy right, my mom told me another member of the family would soon be around a month before they was born....   [tags: Mother, Family, Woman, Pregnancy]

Better Essays
796 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about Jane Austen's Characters, Elinor and Marianne

- Jane Austen's Characters, Elinor and Marianne Having a strong heart like Elinor and a latent sense similar to Marianne, Jane Austen displayed her characteristics through her characters. Elinor and Marianne were two main characters that Jane Austen used to display her true character. Elinor is very devoted to her family and tries to do everything she can to support them. Every now and then, when the family is in need of advice, they would all look to Elinor....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1945 words (5.6 pages)

Essay about The Power Of The Woman

- The Power of the Woman The Canterbury Tales by Gregory Chaucer are set around the time of Medieval England. Specifically, “The Wife of Bath’s Tale,” takes place during King Arthur’s rule in the 600s. In, “The Wife of Bath’s Tale,” Gregory Chaucer uses satire as a form of humor to point out the underlying power that women have in Medieval England. As the knight struggles to find out what women desire most, he stumbles upon this old woman known as Crone. After the knight grants his freedom he must answer to the old woman and do whatever she wants, thus leading her to take control over his life....   [tags: Woman, Wife, Marriage, Women]

Better Essays
1043 words (3 pages)

A Beautiful Woman Essay

- ...  She is sitting on what looks like a white sofa or bed.  At the bottom of the ad is the product with a large blackberry placed on side the jar, which is very big and noticeable.  In big bold text at the bottom next to the product it reads, “Want to look younger, longer. Take the right steps now.”  In smaller text under that it says, “New AVEENO ABSOLUTELY AGELESS Restorative Night Cream. Formulated with our exclusive ACTIVE NATURALS Blackberry Complex, it improves elasticity and firmness for healthier, younger-looking skin in just one week....   [tags: English-language films, Woman]

Better Essays
799 words (2.3 pages)

Syrian Woman Essay examples

- Syrian Woman Profile This portrait from the Riley collection is believed to have been taken off a funerary monument from Palmyra, Syria, in the early third century CE. Based on research of the lives of the Palmyrens and their funerary reliefs, a vague but somewhat accurate picture of the woman can be assembled. This woman was most likely a freeborn, although lower class, woman. Based on the known trends of Syrian art at the given period, it is likely that the woman had vey little monetary wealth upon her death, explaining the lack of any jewlery besides the headress being depicted in this statue....   [tags: Art Painting Syrian Woman Essays]

Free Essays
917 words (2.6 pages)