Essay about What is Wrong with Slavery?: Utilitarian Thought

Essay about What is Wrong with Slavery?: Utilitarian Thought

Length: 733 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Philosophical Ethics, Utilitarianism is the doctrine that our actions are right if the outcome of our actions generate the greatest happiness amongst the majority. However, in “What is Wrong with Slavery?” some objectors of utilitarianism have tried to dismiss this moral reasoning as to having any importance by blaming the awful actions of slave traders and slave owners on utilitarianism. They attack this doctrine by saying that utilitarianism is a belief system that can either praise or condemn slavery, and utilitarianism easily commend slavery if a majority of the people visualize a slave-owning society as the most beneficial and generate greatest happiness. In this matter, the slave owners and slave traders can say that slavery is the right action because it generates the greatest happiness amongst themselves, because they may be in the illusion that they represent the majority. In response to these anti-utilitarian’s, R.M. Hare defends Unitarianism through the rebuttal of the anti-utilitarian’s claims. Hare agrees that the nature of utilitarianism can either commend or condemn slavery, but a key factor that anti-utilitarians forget is that utilitarianism shows what is wrong with slavery through reasoning, instead of just bluntly saying slavery is wrong without any proof.
Throughout the paper, Hare reiterates the example of how sometimes people can claim that they face injustice by spouting out actions or events that they believe is an unjust to them, without providing any substantial evidence or reasons as to why these actions causes them injustice. He explains how this example construes as a bad argument with weak conclusions, providing unsubstantial ideas to society. Before Hare even goes into the rebuttal of the claim...

... middle of paper ... them this upper hand over another human being? Hare says even a good human will exploit the people who are under them just because they possess the power to do so. Not only that, but Hare and other utilitarians know for a fact that if both an animal and a slave are a man’s property, and both receive the same punishment, the damage is always much worst on a slave. This is because slaves have thoughts, feelings, and responsibility – he is the same species as his owner yet he cannot escape.
Hare says in order to show the wrongfulness of slavery, the world has to see slavery as what is actually is and he conveys this through examples of historical context. Hare’s defense of utilitarianism is that this doctrine is moral reasoning that can be used to show and prove what is wrong with slavery, instead of simply just showing dissent and spouting out cries of unjust.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Immanuel Kant 's Philosophy Of Knowledge, Reality, Existence And Thought Processes

- Philosophy is the study of knowledge, reality, existence and thought processes. Immanuel Kant from Prussia, (currently Russia) for whom was influential during the Enlightenment period; and John Stuart Mill from Great Britain whom was present during the Romantic era, explored ideas that they believed would create a more fair and just society, by trying to legislate morality. Morality cannot be legislated because it is a concept of right and wrong created by each different religion, region and culture; issues are not black and white....   [tags: Morality, Immanuel Kant, Ethics, Utilitarianism]

Better Essays
1799 words (5.1 pages)

Act, Utilitarian, Or Wrong? Essays

- Act Utilitarian The act utilitarian believes that an action is right if the results are good or wrong if the results are bad. A person who believes in the rule of utilitarianism will judge the doctors based on the results. An example is if the experiment is a success and the cure of cancer is found then, it is a correct. On the other hand, if the experiment fails, the action would be judged as wrong, since no good has come out of it .This will not only paralyze the patient’s health, but the hospital will also have to face punishment due to their unethical behavior (Shafer-Landau, 2014)....   [tags: Utilitarianism, Morality, Ethics, Physician]

Better Essays
1245 words (3.6 pages)

Utilitarian Vs. Utilitarian Ethics Essay

- All the ethical models look at this problem very differently. Utilitarian’s would turn to the principle of utility to try and find the outcome that offers the most happiness for the most people. While deontologists would try to find some metric to judge the actions, ignoring the consequences. Perhaps even finding a categorical imperative applied here. Virtue ethics can also judge the morality of this situation from the view on the individual. Delving deeper into each will give us a clearer view of which would be the biggest benefit for mankind to follow....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Virtue ethics, Immanuel Kant]

Better Essays
918 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Slavery : Slavery And Slavery

- Plantation owners in the south hunted for, captured, and enslaved African Americans to do a wide variety of work at the plantations. Even though these slaves would get regularly whipped for arbitrary reasons, the owners and masters believed that it was in the best interest of the slaves to be in slavery. A slave masters wife started teaching a slave by the name of Fredrick Douglass how to read because she believed he would not have gotten the chance to learn if he was not in slavery. Slave masters also knew the slaves had a better live because they had food to eat....   [tags: Slavery in the United States, Slavery]

Better Essays
1224 words (3.5 pages)

Is Cannibalism Wrong? Is Murder Wrong Essay examples

- Is cannibalism wrong. Is murder wrong. What about incest, flag burning, or polygamy. An easy answer to these questions for the average American is yes, those behaviors are morally wrong. For most people, the mere thought of these acts elicit a feeling of disgust and anger. But, as this chapter investigates, are there any circumstances in which consuming the body of another human, or taking the life of another human, or having a sexual relationship with a close relative, okay to do. To answer that question, there are quite a few ideas that must be considered first....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Slavery, Mores]

Better Essays
925 words (2.6 pages)

Using Utilitarian Ethicals to Determine Right From Wrong Essay example

- ... It is known that pacemakers have failed before, but it can be assumed that the aforementioned pacemakers did not have this company’s transistor in it or else they most likely would’ve already left the contract. That being said, there is the possibility that the other transistors that were being used were just poorly made (Shanks, 1996). As a result of this, the main Utilitarian issue being presented is does the company end the contract and not take the unnecessary risk associated, or do they continue the contract and potentially save countless lives....   [tags: dilemma, consequences, result]

Better Essays
1500 words (4.3 pages)

Enormity of Slavery Essay

- In the 1800s, many slave owners thought it fair for Africans to work without pay, because they believed that this particular group of people were made by God for this sort of work, and that slave owners were ever caring and conscientious of their slaves anyway, making slavery an easy life; truthfully, however, as both Frederick Douglass and Harriet Jacobs experienced in being slaves most of their lives, and then showed in their narratives, this cruel and unusual practice was the epitome of iniquity- notwithstanding the fact that they were created equal to their malefactors....   [tags: Slavery]

Better Essays
1612 words (4.6 pages)

Egoist and Utilitarian Responses to Terrorism Essay

- Terrorism was not a dormant issue in the media until the attacks on the USA. The organised use of violence to target non-combatants for political purposes, is one of the most effective ways to gain media attention. Mainly used by extremist groups in the hopes of gaining recognition for their religious or political cause. Several attacks on the US have recently made headlines The attack on the USS Cole (October 12, 2000), US Embassy bombings in Kenya + Tanzania (August 7, 1998), Oklahoma City bombing (April 19, 1995) , the World Trade Centre bombing on February 27 1993 and finally the World Trade Centre bombing on September 11, 2001....   [tags: Egoist, Utilitarian ]

Free Essays
848 words (2.4 pages)

Essay Slavery

- Slavery is an issue we may never be free of, we may think this is bad but the Romans including people such as Hammurabi and Aristotle believed that slavery was essential to life and would have thought that this wouldn't matter. This especially didn't matter since slaves were only seen as objects or tools. Although there are still people who probably believe in what the Romans did, but now we now classify all people as equal. Anyone could have become a slave if they either: 1. Committed a crime 2....   [tags: Slavery Essays]

Free Essays
833 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Slavery

- Slavery degusted northerners. Many people believed Slavery was morally wrong and wanted to do something about it. The book Uncle Tom’s Cabin and the newspaper The Liberator argued how wrong it was. In this, Slavery was a major cause in the outbreak of the Civil War. There were many things that led to the Civil War. One of which were the Missouri Compromise and the Compromise of 1850 in the Missouri Compromise, Missouri wanted to become a slave state and northerners demanded something be done....   [tags: Slavery Essays]

Better Essays
492 words (1.4 pages)