The Vs. Riel 's Speech Essay

The Vs. Riel 's Speech Essay

Length: 1590 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Ever since human civilization came into existence, people have been putting rules in place to determine who is behaving according to social norms and moral values and who is not. Because the majority of Western societies have historically been democratic, it makes sense that the public have a say in the enforcement of said rules. It is for this reason that the trial became a popular means of deciding upon punishment for those perceived to have broken the law, while also allowing them an opportunity to testify against their charges. Socrates underwent this process in 399 BC on charges of impiety and corruption of the youth of Athens , as did Louis Riel in 1885 on charges of treason for leading a Métis rebellion . Although they lived during vastly different time periods, both Socrates and Riel are known for the defence speeches they gave at their respective trials. By examining the various aspects of both speeches, in Louis Riel 's Address to the Court, 1 August 1885, as well as Apology, however, we are able to determine that Riel’s speech better meets the criteria of a strong argument, uses fewer rhetorical fallacies, and is more goal-directed than Socrates’; therefore, it can be feasibly argued that Riel makes a better case for himself than Socrates does.
An augment must be strong in order for the individual who is making it to be successful in doing so. For this to be achieved, certain criteria must be met. According to a BF299 lecture, weak arguments are those that fail to meet the non-technical criteria of acceptability, relevance, and/or sufficiency . By analysing Socrates’ and Riel’s trial speeches using these criteria, we are able to determine that Riel’s speech was better able to adhere to said criteria than Socrates’. Whi...


... middle of paper ...


...ch better fits the definition of a strong argument, has fewer errors and fallacies, and actually tries to make a defence rather than provoke the court. Overall, Riel’s speech flows more logically, is easier to follow, and makes more sense in general. It can be argued that Riel’s speech was simply better than Socrates’ for those reasons. However, it also must be considered that students still read both trial speeches as part of a course long after they were written. This does suggest, to some degree, that both were effective and had a strong impact on the societies of their respective locations and time periods, on the study of humanities, and on human beings as a whole. Overall, the quality of a speech is dependent on many things, so Socrates’ speech is not bad, per se, but in terms of making a good case for the individual and his community, Riel does a better job.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Louis Riel: A Summary of Man

- Riel A Summary of Man Author: J. A. W. The Canadian hero Louis Riel shows mankind that life is fraught with controversies and battle with establishment. Moreover, establishment is the very ruin of Mankind. Riel's live was in more ways parallel to the human life cycle than one would guess. From the birth to the death of the notorious Riel, we can see how little control an individual really has over life. Louis Riel started out life living in the sticks far from 'civilization,' caring parents, who taught him the basics of life, raised him....   [tags: Riel]

Free Essays
2925 words (8.4 pages)

Speech : Speech - My Speech

- For my “How to do” speech my goal was to share with the class an interesting and informative way to learn something new. Due to the speeches time limit, I knew I needed to be well prepared. I wanted to be less nervous before and during my speech. While presenting I was nervous, but I didn’t really have time for these feelings to sink in because I was focused on the information I wanted to share with the audience. I enjoyed presenting in the second group of speeches so I could see my peers different types of speaking style....   [tags: Graduation, Commencement speech, Speech]

Better Essays
969 words (2.8 pages)

Louis Riel: A Hero or a Traitor? Essay

- Was Louis Riel a hero or a traitor. Well, some individuals say that he was a hero, and others say that he was a traitor. Individually I believe that Louis Riel was a hero because he was the forefather of Manitoba, which is a province of Canada. The fact that he was a persuasive politician and spiritual leader made him a hero as well. Lastly, he stood up for Native rights. Others like the British had thought of him mostly as a traitor, because they were not able to understand that Louis Riel had just needed the Canadian government to treat his people fairly, and that he was willing to do everything for his people....   [tags: Canada, Manitoba, Native]

Better Essays
524 words (1.5 pages)

Louis Riel: Hero or Villain? Essay

- Louis Riel was one of the most controversial figures in Canadian history, and even to this day – more than a century after his execution – he continues to be remembered. Many believed him to be a villain; others saw him as a hero. So who was he really. Born in St. Boniface at the Red River Settlement of Canada (present-day Winnipeg, Manitoba) on October 22, 1844, Louis Riel hoped one day to follow his father’s footsteps and become a great Métis leader just like him. Eventually, Riel was seen as a hero to the French-speaking Métis....   [tags: Canadian History]

Better Essays
1723 words (4.9 pages)

Louis Riel as a Hero or Villian Essay

- Louis Riel as a Hero or Villian The story of Louis Riel began on October 28th 1844. He was born in a log cabin beside Seine Lake. The same priest who married his parents one year earlier baptized Louis on his day of birth. Many people view Louis Riel as the biggest pioneer of Metis in Canadian history. They base their decision on the fortresses he took and his position in Metis organizations. Others call him a joke and despise him. They base this on him being taken to trial for treason and eventually convicted and sentenced to death....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
566 words (1.6 pages)

Against Louis Riel's Execution Essay examples

- Louis Riel should not have been hung because he represented those who couldn't represent themselves. Louis Riel was disappointed with the way the Métis were, so he took it upon himself to represent the Métis and their rights. Even though the actions that followed, such as keeping the new governor out the colony, was illegal and very wrong. Riel risked it for the rights of the Métis. As for Thomas Scott, Riel has absolutely no legal right to have him shot, but Riel himself never touched a gun for that purpose....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
584 words (1.7 pages)

Louis Riel Essay

- There were many occasions in history wherein the French and English Canadians have clashed but the first major historical event to tear the relationship into pieces was the Northwest Rebellion. The French Canadians regarded the Northwest Rebellion a noble cause and Louis Riel a hero who stood up to protect the rights of the French-speaking Métis. The English saw the rebellion as a threat to Canada's sovereignty and Riel as a traitor. Louis Riel had taken up residence in the United States after the Red River Rebellion....   [tags: World History]

Better Essays
798 words (2.3 pages)

Louis Riel Essay

- On October 23, 1844, in Red River Manitoba, Louis Riel Sr and Julie Lagimodiere, devout Christians, brought a young Métis boy into the world. Little did they know, Louis Riel Jr. would grow up to become known to many as “the founder of Manitoba.” His life was filled with excitement, both political and personal. The question is, were his actions against the government acts of honor and truth, or deception and lies. Riel Jr.’s political adventures did not begin until he was 25. On November 23, 1869, Riel proposed the formation of a provincial government to replace the Council of Assiniboia because he did not believe that they were not doing their jobs well enough to improve the dull life in R...   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1189 words (3.4 pages)

Louis Riel Essays

- Patriote or Traitor. Louis Riel was born in 1844. He was captured and executed by Canadian authorities in November 16, 1885. He was a leader who gave up his life and time to fight for the right of the Metis, Indians and the western settlers. He was an well-educated young man fluent in both French and English. He was also selected as the Metis’s spokesman to negotiate with the Canadian government. During the 1869-70, he led the rebel when Canada purchases Manitoba from the Hudson’s bay company. Also, he organized and led a similar rebellion in 1885....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
998 words (2.9 pages)

Essay Louis Riel

- Louis Riel Louis Riel was the first child of Louis Riel Pere and Julie Lagimodière. He was born October 22, 1844 in St. Boniface. His mother was the seventh child of Jean-Baptiste Lagimodière and Marie-Anne Gaboury. Louis Riel Pere had been born at Ile-à-la-Crosse in 1817. He was the son of Jean-Baptiste Riel dit l'Irlande and Marguerite Boucher. Both of Louis Riel's parents were Catholics. Louis Riel spent his childhood on the east bank of the Red River, on the property of his Lagimodière grandparents....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
2030 words (5.8 pages)