Villalve Qualitative Article

Villalve Qualitative Article

Length: 930 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
I had some trouble determining which of the two articles that I read would be most beneficial for the class to read. The quantitative piece on Chinese learners of English fit very well with the course. It exemplified the word recognition view of reading that we have discussed and addressed themes and theoretical frameworks (common underlying proficiency, contrastive analysis, the monolingual perspective) that have come up on many occasions in our class. In the end however I chose the qualitative article from Villalve. My primary justification for this is that the article is so different from the readings we have done in class that I feel it has something more unique to contribute.
The primary focus of the article was to consider diverse literacy practices in detail and also to look at approaches to inquiry, learning, and meaning making. In order to do this, Villalve took a case study approach to look at two 17 year-old bilingual Latina students during their last year of high school. These students were involved in an ongoing senior writing project that entailed collecting information from a diverse set of resources, collaborating with other students and school faculty, and finally submitting a thesis and making a final presentation. From this it is clear that one of the primary ways that this article differs from much of what our class has read so far is the age of the students involved. Relatively little data seems to exist on literacy practices of high school bilinguals and this is one reason I feel this article has something to offer the class.
Another somewhat unique feature of this article relative to much of the other work we have looked at is the research paradigm and theoretical framework for the work. In terms of Mertens research paradigms, this article fits both into a constructivist and transformative frame. The reliance on the work of Fairclough (2001) and others and the concern with broad societal level discourse practices set this article apart from other pieces we have read. Also, in terms of the theoretical frames, Villalve utilizes an ecological approach to frame her data collection and analysis. For this she makes use of Barton (1994) in particular to define her 3-part framework for data analysis. Her 3 levels of analysis are hierarchical and start from the level of language as artifact (physical samples of writing etc.) From this she moves up to 2 larger frames of interaction and imagination and finally systems and contexts.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Villalve Qualitative Article." 26 May 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Critical Appraisal of Qualitative Journal Article

- Introduction Everyone possess critical thinking skills but when it comes to criticize a journal article it can be difficult for the first time, one of the best ways to develop critical thinking and reading skills is to use some strategies when reading and evaluating a research study (Wood & Haber,1998). The following essay it is going to focus in a critique of a qualitative journal article by giving its strengths and weakness, critical appraisal it is going to be done with support from different references and frameworks relevant to a qualitative study....   [tags: Article Review, Analysis, Informative]

Research Papers
2199 words (6.3 pages)

Qualitative Analysis : Qualitative Research Essay

- Qualitative Analysis Qualitative research presents academic information I manner that does not utilize numerical analysis of the findings. Research is depicted with non-statistical descriptors and according to (Wood, 2010, p. 56); “one important sense in which the term ‘qualitative’ is used is simply to refer to the use of data which yields a deep and detailed picture of the subject matter”. Analysis of qualitative research requires the reader to examine several aspects in order for the research to deemed high quality....   [tags: Focus group, Qualitative research, Research]

Research Papers
772 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about Quantitative and Qualitative Article Analysis

- Abstract In this paper I will analyze two articles, one is quantitative and the other is qualitative. I will describe the quantitative methods used including the research question addressed, the hypothesis, and variables. I will identify the population and sample. I will discuss the reliability and validity of the instruments used. I will then discuss the design of the article and how the findings were analyzed. For the qualitative article, I will identify the design of the article, the methods used and the strategies used for analyzing the data....   [tags: Methods in Educational Research]

Research Papers
1563 words (4.5 pages)

Qualitative Analysis : Qualitative Data Analysis Essay

- Overview of Qualitative Data Analysis Qualitative data analysis is the process of transforming data into information, information into understanding and understanding into knowledge (Davenport & Prusak, 1998). Furthermore, qualitative data analysis can be described as a blend of scientific studies and artistic style to create an innovative product. The research acts as the primary research tool, and must be able to sustain composer throughout the entire study. In addition, the researcher must be able to pay attention to the small details of the study, without losing sight of the big picture of the study (Chenail, 2012)....   [tags: Qualitative research, Scientific method]

Research Papers
1065 words (3 pages)

Evaluation Of A Quantitative And Qualitative Report Essay

- In everyday life, individuals, students, and professionals have been faced with a situation where they must make a decision or reach a conclusion. Many times this requires research of other studies, investigations, and/or articles in order to gain strong knowledge to reach a well-informed conclusion (Clark & Creswell, 2014). At the same time, these individuals must develop and understand the research process, gain the ability to decipher the reports, and apply the provided information (Veeramah, 2004)....   [tags: Research, Qualitative research, Scientific method]

Research Papers
1105 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Qualitative And Qualitative Research Methods

- 1. Introduction The structure of this essay will be describing empirical articles from Woywode (2002) and Jacoby et al (2005) in part 2, followed by the fundamental differences between quantitative and qualitative research strategy and the reflection of those differences in the articles. Part 5 will discuss about qualitative and qualitative strategy differences in research design and how these differences reflected in the articles. After that, there will be discussion of the contribution of these articles in comprehending research methods....   [tags: Scientific method, Quantitative research]

Research Papers
1822 words (5.2 pages)

Qualitative And Quantitative And Qualitative Research Essay

- There has been a debate over which tradition of methodology, qualitative or quantitative, can provide a better explanation while conducting social science research. Qualitative research provides in-depth case-by-case studies while quantitative, generates broader arguments accommodating a large number of cases. Many social scientists may be naturally qualitative analysts and their expertise could lie predominantly in such field (Mahoney and Goertz, 2006). Quantitative analysis, on the other hand, is preferred when the researchers want to observe common patterns among several different cases....   [tags: Qualitative research, Scientific method]

Research Papers
1281 words (3.7 pages)

Qualitative Article Review Essay

- The purpose of the article I reviewed by Hadley and Hanley (2011) was to investigate the experience of men that are involuntarily childless. Because existing research concerning infertility and childlessness is generally oriented around the female’s experience the researchers aim was to focus solely on the male’s issues and perspective. From the study the researchers hoped to learn more about men’s desire for fatherhood and issues childless men may be confronted with. This qualitative study utilized grounded theory....   [tags: Hadley, Hanley, Childlessness]

Research Papers
870 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about Review of Qualitative Literature

- Review of Qualitative Literature Qualitative methods use a different approach to scholarly research than quantitative methods. According to Creswell (2014), although similar in processes, qualitative methods rely on text and image data, have unique steps in data analysis, and draw on diverse designs in the qualitative study. There is now an increased publication of articles using qualitative methods as it became more acceptable, especially in the production of dissertations, as opposed to quantitative methods....   [tags: dissertations, qualitative methods]

Research Papers
1491 words (4.3 pages)

Qualitative Research for Instructional Technology Essay

- Qualitative Research Qualitative Research Defined: The simplest way to define qualitative research is to say that it is a type of research which involves interpreting nonnumerical data. The underlying belief of qualitative research is that "meaning is situated in a particular perspective or context, and, since different people and groups have different perspectives and contexts, there are many different meanings in the world, none of which is necessarily more valid or true than another" (Gay & Airasian, 1996)....   [tags: Qualitative Research in Education]

Research Papers
1845 words (5.3 pages)

In my opinion, Villalve utilized this framework well in terms of designing data collection methodology and finding themes in the data. Generally, the ecological framework itself, as well as the way Villalve utilized the framework in her writing, both make this article stand out from others we have read.
In my view, this article also exemplifies what it means to provide a detailed and accurate accounting of data collection and analysis procedures in qualitative work. I find that many qualitative studies break down in this regard, with poor reporting of coding schemes and often convoluted explanations of collection and analysis procedures. This article made good use of explanatory tables (see Table II, p. 96, Table III, p. 104, and Table IV, p. 105) to clarify the relationship between raw data and theoretical framework. And it also provided other appropriate detail in the appendices of the article.
Findings from the two cases were also quite interesting. The two women differed greatly in their approaches to inquiry but one commonality was the way in which they utilized personal social networks in their academic research. For Belinda, findings showed that she relied on repetition and patchwriting (at the text as artifact level) and sought consensus in her interactions with members of her social networks, incorporating little of her own voice. Leesa however, was involved and engaged in the process of actively integrating diverse voices into her work and ultimately making the product her own. Leesa also chose to link her academic research to a social project outside of the school thus showing that she was able to transform her project into something personally meaningful, essentially taking agency over the process.
In her discussion of these findings, Villalve came to the conclusion that there were hidden literacy practices at work with both of these women. Hidden in the sense that their approaches to inquiry and academic language development may be at odds with established and “acceptable” ways of conducting academic inquiry. Villalve felt that both women were making use of social networks in ways that maybe paralleled how other students might consult print materials as references and resources to support their work. Villalve’s broad concern seemed to be that the accepted discourse of research and academic study may be at odds with the ways in which Belinda and Leesa approached inquiry and academic language development, thus potentially disadvantaging them and devaluing their contribution. In her discussion of possible multiple forms of academic literacy, the author said, “Theories of multiple literacies can inform discussions of academic English by encouraging the consideration of a broader range of academic performance and by valuing culturally and linguistically based literacy practices of language minority youth” (121).
Overall I enjoyed the article and felt that it potentially had much to offer our class, particularly in terms of how different it was from much of what we have read so far. There were weaknesses in the article, especially relating to her lack of presentation of data on home literacy practices of the two girls, but generally this felt like sound qualitative research from within a well articulated research framework.

Return to