The Village of Skokie v. National Socialist Party of America

The Village of Skokie v. National Socialist Party of America

Length: 1275 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The Village of Skokie v. National Socialist Party of America

The National Socialist Party, a Nazi group lead by Frank Collin, proposed a march, in full uniform, to be held on May 1, 1977 through the Village of Skokie near Chicago, Illinois. Skokie was the home of thousands of Jewish Holocaust survivors. Shocked by the announcement, the survivors rose in protest against the march (Downs book cover flap). The controversial march that was planned to take place right in the middle of town would clearly have caused problems. If trouble was pretty much guaranteed in Skokie on the day of the march, then should the US Supreme Court have let the Nazis keep their plan to march through Skokie? The proposed Nazi march in the Village of Skokie tested the rights that are included in the First Amendment.
The First Amendment states, "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances." Essentially, the First Amendment is supposed to give citizens the right to have free speech, free choice of religion, and the right to assemble peaceably. There are limitations to the First Amendment because every person interprets the rights differently. The Nazis most likely assumed that it was all right to hate people and say it in public, but the Jewish people disagreed, believing that hatred is unacceptable. Where is the line drawn when it comes to people being able to speak their minds? Justice Murphy, a member of the Supreme Court in 1942, had a say on what is considered allowable under the First Amendment and what crosses the line, and he stated,
There are certain well-defined and narrowly limited classes of speech, the prevention and punishment of which have never been thought to raise any Constitutional problem. These include the lewd and obscene, the profane, the libelous, and the insulting or "fighting" words – those which by their very utterance inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of the peace (Downs 7).

The Jewish people that lived in Skokie believed that this planned rally was extremely disrespectful and unlawful. The many Holocaust survivors and Jews that lived in Skokie were offended by anyone that wore a swastika.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Village of Skokie v. National Socialist Party of America." 123HelpMe.com. 20 Jun 2019
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=157689>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Tragedy Of The National Socialist Party Essay

- In 1942 the National Socialist party in Germany came to an horrific decision in answering the 'Jewish Question ', they decided to mercilessly exterminate the whole Jewish race and, in what was termed the 'Final Solution ', in 3 years they murdered over 6 million (Langer, 1991). Who were the perpetrators of this order is a question that has troubled historians since the true extent of the horrors were realised. 'Either they were seen as Hitler 's henchmen kept on a short leash by their superiors, or they came to be regarded as faceless cogs in a gigantic machine driven by anonymous forces ' (Stone, 2005, p....   [tags: Nazi Germany, The Holocaust, Adolf Hitler, Jews]

Research Papers
1556 words (4.4 pages)

The Rise Of Socialist Thinking Essay

- The nineteenth-century played host to the rise of socialist thinking. Prominent socialist writers, such as Owen, Saint-Simon, Fourier, Simonde de Sismondi, and the Ricardian Socialist, rose to fame for their writings and, in the case of Owen, their actions. By no means accepted by economist, socialism was generally dismissed or derided by the brightest economic minds of the time. The notable exception, however, was John Stuart Mill, who was the most generous in his treatment of socialist among economist of the nineteenth century....   [tags: Socialism, Working class, Marxism, Robert Owen]

Research Papers
705 words (2 pages)

The Deadly Influence of National Socialism Essay

- The Deadly Influence of National Socialism National Socialism was a political movement that emerged in Germany after its defeat in World War I. This movement is more commonly known as Nazism. The National Socialist Party or Nazi Party was formed in Munich is 1919. Adolph Hitler was given all dictatorial powers as the result of the Enabling Act. By 1933 the party had gained control over the entire German state and the ideas, propaganda, and doctrines of National Socialism were written in Hitler's Mein Kampf (My Struggle) ....   [tags: National Socialism Hitler Nazi Essays Nazism]

Research Papers
1904 words (5.4 pages)

The National Socialist Of World War II Essay

- The National Socialist German Workers’ Party, or Nazi Party, was a massive movement that ruled Germany with an iron fist for over ten years during the time of World War II. The party was guided by various racist and authoritarian ideals which came to define the broad Nazi ideology. Although difficult to explicitly define, nazism can be expressed through a variety of influences and core tenets. Summary Nazi ideology was developed by intense nationalists whose interests were solely centered around the future of Germany....   [tags: Nazism, Nazi Germany, Adolf Hitler, Nazi Party]

Research Papers
1462 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Rhetorical Tools for Creating Unity in Rajiva’s The Globalized Village

- Globalization is a topic that has been debated for years. Two distinct sides have become prominent, pro-globalization and anti-globalization. Lila Rajiva argues in “The Globalized Village” a new position that seeks to reach out to both sides of the argument, a position she calls “humane globalization”. Rajiva gives first hand experience as she explains the affects that a new Hyundai factory has had in her home town of Vellore, India; explaining how it has brought jobs, industry, and “something more than the trundling old Ambassadors to drive around.” But with the good that has come with the Hyundai factory, Raijva highlights many of the damaging affects that factory has had on her hometown....   [tags: The Globalized Village]

Research Papers
1815 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on Fraus with Plows: The 19th Century Development of Skokie

- Fraus with Plows: The 19th Century Development of Skokie On the corner of Lake and Wagner Roads in Glenview, nearby an Audi dealership, the Glenview Tennis Club, and an Avon plant, nestled between rows of residential developments, is an 18-acre farm. As if its presence wasn’t anachronistic enough, the cows grazing in the field attest to the fact that the farm, which sits on the border between Chicago’s self-christened North Shore and its inner suburbs, is still in operation despite decades of efforts by developers to purchase it and convert the land into something more profitable for the north suburban niche....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Free Essays
3463 words (9.9 pages)

The National Socialist German Workers Party Essay

- The National Socialist German Workers Party In April, 1920, Hitler advocated that The German Workers Party should change its name to the National Socialist German Workers Party (NSDAP). Hitler had always been hostile to socialist ideas, especially those that involved racial or sexual equality. However, socialism was a popular political philosophy in Germany after the First World War. This was reflected in the growth in the German Social Democrat Party (SDP), the largest political party in Germany....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
708 words (2 pages)

Essay on Rage in Baldwin's Stranger in the Village

- Rage in Baldwin's Stranger in the Village The rage of the disesteemed is personally fruitless, but it is also absolutely inevitable; this rage, so generally discounted, so little understood even among the people whose daily bread it is, is one of the things that makes history. -- James Baldwin, ?Stranger in the Village. (130) In his essay 'Stranger in the Village' (1955), many of James Baldwin?s innermost feelings are exposed to the reader. One of the emotions I believe Baldwin feels most strongly is rage....   [tags: Stranger Village]

Research Papers
593 words (1.7 pages)

Essay about The Program of the National Socialist German Workers' Party

- The Program of the National Socialist German Workers' Party Germany under the rule of the National Socialist German Workers’ Party believed they were superior to the peoples of all other nations and all individual efforts were to be performed for the betterment of the German State. Germany’s loss in World War I resulted in the Peace Treaty of Versailles, which created tremendous economic and social hardships on Germany. Germany had to make reparations to the Allied and Associated Governments involved in World War I....   [tags: Nazi Germany Hitler Jewish Essays]

Free Essays
1402 words (4 pages)

Essay on Socialism

- What would happen if we all made the same amount of money. To understand what our society would be as socialist, we must understand the difference between socialist and capitalist ideas. The question becomes not so much as what is socialism, but how does it differ from capitalism, and what is wrong with capitalistic ideas to where we would need socialism. The problem becomes where do you draw the line between capitalism and socialism to where we have trust, sense of community and also competition....   [tags: socialist]

Research Papers
1750 words (5 pages)

They remembered all of the unexplainable horrible times that many of them had endured when Hitler was ruling Germany. Holocaust survivors told the Skokie Village Board,
We expect to show up in front of the Village Hall and tear these people up if necessary…we never thought in our wildest dreams that it could happen like that again, that whey would have a right to confront us…to say those obscene words without being punished. This realization brought back a terror…here we are again, in the same position… (Downs 1).

The debate was whether the Nazis had rights. The Jews felt that the Nazi march inflicted mental trauma, triggering painful memories (Downs 93). The Skokie Jews felt that the Nazis should not be protected by the First Amendment and stated, "Defenders of free speech who retain their good sense will realize the Nazis, saying what they say in the way they say it, do exceed reasonable limits" (Bartlett 139).
The Jewish citizens of Skokie had strong feelings on why the Nazi gang should be prohibited to come anywhere near their town in uniform and with swastikas. In their opinion, the entire idea of the Nazi's march, which symbolized hatred and murder of millions of Jews, had crossed the line of the First Amendment. The Jews believed that this event would not be a peaceful assembly, and they could not expect Skokie citizens to stay calm with all the past events that they remembered from the horrifying Holocaust.

The National Socialist Party of America had totally different views on its proposed march. The members followed after Hitler and had the same ideas as he did for "white power." Frank Collin, the leader of the Nazi group stated, "I used it [the First Amendment] at Skokie. I planned the reaction of the Jews. They are hysterical" (2). He didn't understand that what he was doing was immoral and that by being a Nazi supporter he was involved in one of the largest massacres in history, the Holocaust.
The Nazis had completely opposite opinions on the First Amendment and the march they were planning. The attorney on the case for the Nazis, David Goldberg, stated, "Your Honor, if this Court issues a preliminary injunction in the case, enjoining the demonstration of Mr. Collin and the National Socialist Party of America, I fear that the Village of Skokie will be dancing in the grave of the First Amendment" (Downs-front flap of book). The National Socialist Party of America believed that the First Amendment rights -- free speech and freedom to assemble, would back up their actions that would take place at the march in Skokie. What is the importance of walking in uniform and with swastikas through a town that the Nazi's know is full of Jewish people. A Nazi blocker came up with a statement that said,
The Nazis delight in creating fright and havoc among Jews. Recently in this country their demonstrations have several times actually resulted in a riot. Nazis understand full well how maddening their symbols are to their intended victims; they plan that abrasion…They will nevertheless be guilty of engaging deliberately in conduct designed to infuriate and calculated to result in a wholesale breach of the public peace (Bartlett 142).

They believed that it was all right to show their hatred in public for everyone to see. Are they right or wrong?
After Collin announced the date of the march, the Skokie Jewish community won a court injunction that prohibited the Nazis from displaying uniforms or swastikas or giving out literature promoting hatred. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), representing the Nazis, tried to get a stay of injunction from the Illinois Supreme Court, but the Court refused to hear the case. So, the ACLU took the case to the United States Supreme Court, and it ordered the Illinois court to respond (Bartlett 137). The ACLU said that freedom of speech was at stake, not Nazism. The Illinois Supreme Court finally responded in January 1978 and struck down the injunction.
At this point, the Skokie Village Council adopted three new ordinances to keep the Nazis from demonstrating. The first required that a permit would be necessary for a demonstration. The second banned political organizations from demonstrating in military style uniforms. The third banned the display of "symbols offensive to the community" (Bartlett 138). These ordinances were debated and finally ruled unconstitutional. Skokie then appealed the case, and it eventually went to the US Supreme Court for a decision, which upheld that the bans were unconstitutional.
Because the US Supreme Court chose to stand behind the law of the First Amendment, even under these circumstances, the Nazis were given the right to march and got what they wanted. Collin had planned a new date, June 25, 1978 for his march, but it never occurred in Skokie. The Nazis marched at another Chicago location in July. They had gained attention for sixteen months and challenged the court system to look carefully at the First Amendment.
Return to 123HelpMe.com