Essay PreviewMore ↓
In my initial study of Beowulf it seemed to me that the Christian references in it were overlaid onto the essentially pagan tale that makes up the bulk of the poem. So I innocently decided to investigate this incongruity as the topic of this paper. And so I found myself smack-dab in the middle of an argument that has evidently raged for the last one hundred years or so. I found sources that ran the gamut from the position that Beowulf was a quintessentially Germanic pagan work that had been corrupted by some revisionist monastic scribe (Mooreman 1967), to the assertion that the author intentionally created a Christian allegory along the lines of Book 1 of The Faerie Queen (McNamee 1960). I have chosen the middle ground in formulating my thesis, which after further study of the text and a wide range of criticism seems to make the most sense. The author of Beowulf is indeed the author of those Christian passages, but his intention is less to proselytize than to demonstrate that Christianity and his audience's Germanic heritage were not incompatible.
We know that eighth century Anglo-Saxon poets relied upon their native Germanic traditions and techniques to shape even overtly Christian poetry (i.e. The Dream of the Rood) and so it was with the Beowulf poet. The tales of Beowulf were already ancient legend when the poet began his work (whenever that was; dating the poem seems to be another of those old controversies with dates ranging from the 7th to the 11th centuries). The author skillfully uses this material to construct an entertaining tale while at the same time attempting to reconcile the concepts of the pagan wyrd (fate) and dom (renown or worth) with the Christian concepts of grace and final judgement. So it is that we have a poem that is overwhelmingly a pagan story, suffused with the old Germanic warrior culture ethos, yet sprinkled with many loosely Christian comments and a few explicitly Christian passages. However, it should be noted that while we refer to these passages as Christian, no reference to Christ is to be found within the poem.
The first of the Christian passages occurs when we are introduced to Grendal: God had condemned them as kin of Cain. The Eternal Lord avenged the murder in which he slew Abel.
How to Cite this Page
"Christianity and the Beowulf Poet." 123HelpMe.com. 17 Jul 2018
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Christianity vs. Paganism In the story of Beowulf, there is a noticeable struggle between Christianity and Paganism, and the characters personal battle between the two. Throughout the story the characters display actions that lead towards Paganism and Christianity. Contrary to Pagan belief Beowulf is seen as the epitome of good and beneficent to all of mankind. In Beowulf, the people showed their faith and love in God, however due to horrific events, paranoia caused them to look for a quick fix and turns them to Paganism.... [tags: Epic of Beowulf Essays]
672 words (1.9 pages)
- Beowulf, the hero of the epic poem, is not an ordinary man; he is the epitome of a true hero. With the strength of thirty men in one arm, the courage to fight monsters, and the knowledge to respect and consider others' feelings, Beowulf defines the word "hero." As a thane of the Geats' king Hygelac, and later as king of the Geats, Beowulf uses his courage and wisdom to help him win many battles and competitions against humans and monsters. Beowulf's list of victories consists of his swimming contest with Breca, the slaying of sea monsters, the dismembering of the monster Grendel, decapitating Grendel (or Grendel's mother), and killing the dragon.... [tags: Poem Poet Beowulf Essays]
1280 words (3.7 pages)
- Beowulf Beowulf is the main character in the poem, Beowulf. He is a member of the Geat tribe, a follower of Higylac, and the son of Edgtheo. In the poem, the author attempts to reconcile the human and the heroic sides of his personality. Beowulf's deeds and actions toward others reflect his heroic personality. He is described as "…greater/And stronger than anyone anywhere in this world," although there is no information as to how he has received this reputation. We learn about the main character more through the eyes of the Danish soldier patrolling the cliffs.... [tags: Poem Poet Beowulf Essays]
895 words (2.6 pages)
- Christian Sybolism in Beowulf Within the poem Beowulf, the poet utilizes the Christian religion to symbolize the elements of good and evil and Heaven and Hell. Beowulf is the oldest known English epic poem. The manuscripts date back to about 1000 A.D., when two scribes wrote it down for posterity. The poem was handed down from the Anglo-Saxon period, and through the retelling of the poem, it changed a little each time. The poem creates an oral depiction of an epic hero who strived to fight against the forces of evil.... [tags: Christianity epic Poem Beowulf Essays]
1609 words (4.6 pages)
- The Origin and Evolution of Beowulf The origin of Beowulf remains a mystery, as both the poet and the year of composition has eluded scholars for centuries. Although "[it] is now widely believed that Beowulf is the work of a single poet who was Christian . . ." (preface, Heaney 29), I see Beowulf as a mosaic of many poets. In this paper, I will argue that with each new translation of this Old English epic, a new author of Beowulf is born. The twenty-first century poet Seamus Heaney, who translated the Beowulf on which this paper is based, injects aspects of his world into this ancient poem. Published in the year 2 000, the inconsistency of this most modern text reveals the messy... [tags: Epic Beowulf essays]
1583 words (4.5 pages)
- Contradictory Christian Elements in Beowulf In Beowulf the Christian element, which coexists alongside the pagan or heathen, sometimes in a seemingly contradictory fashion, is many faceted. Certainly the Christian element seems to be too deeply interwoven in the text for us to suppose that it is due to additions made by scribes at a time when the poem had come to be written down. The Christian element had to be included by the original poet or by minstrels who recited it in later times.... [tags: Epic of Beowulf Essay]
1967 words (5.6 pages)
- Dating and Locating the Composition of Beowulf Dating and locating the composition of Beowulf is impossible to do with precision at this time because we do not have enough information about the poem’s specific historical context and because the poem is not constructed in such a consistently symbolic way to warrant a single allegorical-historical interpretation.. Estimates of the date of the poem’s composition “range from 340 to 1025, with ca. 515-530 and 1000 being almost universally acknowledged as the possible extremes” (Bjork 13).... [tags: Epic Beowulf essays]
931 words (2.7 pages)
- Vengeance and Revenge in Beowulf The oldest of the great lengthy poems written in English and perhaps the lone survivor of a genre of Anglo-Saxon epics, Beowulf, was written by an unknown Christian author at a date that is only estimated. Even so, it is a remarkable narrative story in which the poet reinvigorates the heroic language, style, and values of Germanic oral poetry. He intertwines a number of themes including good and evil, youth and old age, paganism and Christianity and the heroic ideal code, into his principal narrative and numerous digressions and episodes; all of which were extremely important to his audience at the time. Vengeance, part of the heroic code, was regard... [tags: Epic Beowulf essays]
1317 words (3.8 pages)
- Pagan Aspects in Beowulf Scholars have argued about the religious stance of the epic poem Beowulf for centuries. Although the man who put the poem down on paper, known as the Beowulf poet, was a devout Christian, the actual poem itself is pagan. There are many clues in the epic that lead us to this conclusion such as the numerous references to pagan symbols, namely the symbol of fate. Also, the central idea of revenge in the poem opposes the ideas of Christianity. The poem also contains many breaches of the Ten Commandments, which prove that the story is not Christian.... [tags: Epic of Beowulf Essays]
889 words (2.5 pages)
- It is common opinion that Beowulf was written by a Christian poet. This was probably true because at the time when it was written, most of the few people who knew how to read and write were in the clergy. There are various references within the poem to elements of the Christian religion. However, the story is about Pagan people and certain aspects of their culture are even glorified. The ambiguity of Beowulf’s religious content has caused confusion as to what significance religion had in inspiring the author and in what manner the author meant to inspire or influence his audience.... [tags: Epic of Beowulf Essays]
1466 words (4.2 pages)
With this passage, the poet explains Grendal and indeed an entire pantheon of Germanic bogie-men in a Christian mythological context and he does so in a way that adds to the effectiveness of Grendal as a monster, especially to a Christian audience. The author then continually describes Grendal as a descendant of Cain and states "he was at war with God" as an explanation of the monster's hatred of mankind. Thus the audience is instructed that the evil that is in the world works against God and man as opposed to the indifferent working of wyrd.
The next passage is the most likely to be an addendum at least in part to the original work. The passage has even acquired a name - the Christian Excursus - since it seems such a departure from the general tone of the poem (Irving 1997). At times they vowed sacrifices at heathen temples, with their words prayed that the soul-slayer (Satan) would give help for the distress of the people. Such was their custom, the hope of heathens; in their spirits they thought of Hell, they knew not the Ruler, the Judge of Deeds, they recognized not the Lord God, nor indeed did they know how to praise the Protector of Heaven, the glorious King. Woe is him who in terrible trouble must thrust his soul into the fire's embrace, hope for no comfort, not expect change. Well is the man who after his death day may seek the Lord and find peace in the embrace of the Father.
I find the first part of the passage to be entirely in keeping with the poet's explication of the Germanic past in terms of his Christian present. But when we reach "Woe is him…" the rest of the passage is a jarring departure from the style and structure of a poem that generally leaves any moralizing that is to be done to the characters themselves. I find it easy to imagine the monk-scribe whom is unable to restrain himself from adding a homily when he encounters such an open discussion of pagan worship.
The last Christian passage I will discuss was called by Tolkien (1936) "Hrothgar's Sermon". Since it runs for more than 40 lines, I will refrain from quoting it in total, but will examine some of its aspects. Just prior to this speech, Hrothgar has bestowed great praise and blessings upon Beowulf for his victory over the Grendal family. With this "sermon" Hrothgar maintains that "It is a wonder to say how in his great spirit mighty God gives wisdom to mankind, land and earlship - He possesses power over all things." He then warns Beowulf against the sins of pride and covetousness and advises him to "choose better, eternal gains" and thanks " the Ruler, the Eternal Lord" for deliverance from Grendal. Hrothgar is by far the most monotheistic of the characters in Beowulf. As an old man, he serves as the wise counter-point to the young Beowulf who clearly puts more faith in his strength and prowess than in the blessings of Providence ("Fate often saves an undoomed man when his courage is good."-Beowulf). Hrothgar, however, always credits good fortune and success to the good will of the Lord. As the story progresses into Beowulf's own kingship and old age in Geatland (wherever that may be, another controversy), we see him move toward Hrothgar's position. When he is informed of the destruction of his own hall by the dragon, Beowulf fears that he has somehow "bitterly offended the Ruler, the Eternal Lord, against old law."
It seems to me that the Christian elements in Beowulf are so integrated into the work as to be largely inseparable. While it is possible that some of the Christian references in the poem are expanded due to "scribal editing" during the production of successive manuscripts, it is the original author who is responsible for the vast majority of those references. Here the poet produced a work that takes pride in his Germanic heritage and explains that while the ancestors of legend may have been unsaved heathens, they were good men all the same.
Donaldson, E. T. Beowulf Translation The Norton Anthology. New York: W.W. Norton and Co., 1966 Mooreman, Charles. 1967. "The Essential Paganism of Beowulf." MLQ 28: 3-18
McNamee, Maurice B. 1960. "Beowulf - An Allegory of Salvation?" JEGP 59: 190-207
Tolkien, J. R. R. 1936. "Beowulf: The Monsters and the Critics." PBA 22: 245-295