Assisted Suicide as a Cure for Disabilities

Assisted Suicide as a Cure for Disabilities

Length: 645 words (1.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Supporters of physician-assisted suicide often claim to favor it only for cases of terminal illness. Yet some disability rights advocates, including the group "Not Dead Yet," have warned that this agenda threatens the lives of people with mental or physical disabilities. This debate has intensified in recent months, in part due to a December 1997 statement by Faye Girsh, executive director of Hemlock Society USA. In the context of a murder trial in Louisiana involving a man who had killed his father with Alzheimer's disease, Girsh issued a statement on euthanasia and assisted suicide for people with disabilities generally:


"Some provision should be made for a situation in which life is not being sustained by artificial means but, in the belief of the patient or his agent, is too burdensome to continue... A judicial determination should be made when it is necessary to hasten the death of an individual whether it be a demented parent, a suffering, severely disabled spouse or a child" [PR Newswire, 12/3/97].


Not Dead Yet vigorously objected to the statement and launched a protest at Hemlock's Denver headquarters, prompting a "clarification" in the latest issue of Hemlock's newsletter TimeLines. Hemlock says that the statement was "Girsh's own opinion" as an individual, and that "press reports" had omitted references making it clear that she was only citing a model proposed by a Canadian expert as one approach among others. In fact the original Hemlock press release, issued through PR Newswire and listing Hemlock's national public relations director as the contact for media inquiries, does not substantiate either point.


Clearly Hemlock sees this as a sensitive point, and has posted "An Answer to the Disabled" on its Web site. This "Answer" may itself raise new questions. It says that Hemlock "takes issue" with groups like Not Dead Yet regarding "the right of dying patients to seek help from their doctor in hastening their death." But it proceeds to blur this line -- "Indeed, having a chronic, terminal illness generally renders a person disabled" -- and declares that "it is up to each individual to determine for themselves when their quality of life is unendurable." The bottom line: "Disabled persons have every right to protect their interests -- but not at the expense of the rest of us" [].


Jack Kevorkian's recent assistance in the suicides of two men who were not terminally ill but rendered quadriplegic by accidents -- Roosevelt Dawson, 21, in February and Matt Johnson, 26, in May -- has sharpened the debate further.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Assisted Suicide as a Cure for Disabilities." 18 Aug 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Euthanasia- Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

- Let's say a close relative of yours has been lying on their hospital bed with nothing by tubes attached on their body and a dying heart for the past few months. Today seems to be their last day, doctors tell you, and all you can do is watch as their life slowly dwindles. Isn't there something you would want to do about their suffering that you would like to end. Well, killing isn't one of them,yet hospitals even allow such action to happen on a patient. Who in their right mind would even think of killing someone vulnerable....   [tags: persuasive essay, killing, life]

Research Papers
955 words (2.7 pages)

Assisted Suicide Essay

- Assisted Suicide Questions concerning the right to end one's life have long generated storms of controversy. These questions, involving intensely personal views on issues no less profound than the meaning of life and liberty, are unlikely to disappear any time soon. The conservative nature of the medical profession, and the organized opposition of the "right to life" movement, along with disagreement among disabilities rights organizations, perpetuate the controversy. The heat from the debate in turn only intensifies the difficult choices people with end-stage AIDS, and their loved ones, may face when life is overwhelmed by irreversible illness and unrelenting pain....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
809 words (2.3 pages)

Assisted Suicide And The Medical Field Essay

- Physician -assisted suicide has been a conflict in the medical field since pre- Christian eras, and is an issue that has resurfaced in the twentieth century. People today are not aware of what the term physician assisted suicide means, and are opposed to listening to advocates’ perspectives. Individuals need to understand that problems do not go away by not choosing to face them. This paper’s perspective of assisted suicide is that it is an option to respect the dignity of patients, and only those with deathly illness are justified for this method....   [tags: Death, Suicide, Euthanasia, Assisted suicide]

Research Papers
1130 words (3.2 pages)

Physician Assisted Suicide And Euthanasia Essay

- Over the last couple of centuries, new methods to deal with physical pain have risen, such as intensive meditation, complex forms of medication, and most controversially, assisted suicide. It’s specifically Physician-assisted suicide that has called for diverse opinions from all types of crowds, from religious to scientific points of view. Physician-assisted suicide, as defined in “Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia”, is the practice of a physician providing “the means, guidance, and information [to] enable a patient to end his or her own life, but does not directly administer the drugs themselves” (1)....   [tags: Suffering, Suicide, Death, Assisted suicide]

Research Papers
1031 words (2.9 pages)

The Right to Assisted Suicide Essay

- You’re visiting the hospice for the twenty-third day in a row; the soft squeaking of the linoleum and the gentle buzz of the fluorescents in the waiting room greet you as you walk in. You’re visiting your Grandmother, whose lung cancer has entered metastasis, and has been slowly spreading throughout her body; she has already lost movement in her arms. She is a hollow shell of the woman she once was; her once bright eyes have been fading steadily every day, and her bubbly demeanor has become crushed and gravelly, and every day before you leave, she will only say, “Kill me.” What would you do in this situation....   [tags: Assisted Suicide]

Research Papers
927 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Euthanasia and Doctor-Assisted Suicide

- Understanding Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide   This paper will address some of the more popular points of interest involved with the euthanasia-assisted suicide discussion. There are less than a dozen questions which would come to mind in the case of the average individual who has a mild interest in this debate, and the following essay presents information which would satisfy that individual's curiosity on these points of common interest.   Euthanasia and assisted suicide are legal in the state of Oregon and in the country of the Netherlands; these are the only two jurisdictions in the world where laws specifically permit euthanasia or assisted suicide....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]

Research Papers
1159 words (3.3 pages)

Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide are Murder Essay

- Assisted Suicide is Murder   "If suicide is a right, then it is one that has remained undiscovered throughout the ages by the great thinkers in law, ethics, philosophy and theology. It appears nowhere in the Bible or the Koran or the Talmud. Committing suicide wasn't a "right" a thousand years ago, and it isn't one now. That's why most societies, including our own, have passed laws against it" (Callahan, pg. 71). Assisted suicide is murder. In all of history, "there are only three circumstances that have been an acceptable way for taking a life: killing in self-defense or in protection of another life, killing in war, and in the case of capital punishment, killing by agents of the state....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]

Research Papers
1004 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on It's Time for Voluntary Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide

- America Needs Voluntary Euthanasia There are at least two forms of suicide. One is 'emotional suicide', or irrational self-murder in all of it complexities and sadness. Let me emphasis at once that my view of this tragic form of self-destruction is the same as that of the suicide intervention movement and the rest of society, which is to prevent it wherever possible. I do not support any form of suicide for mental health or emotional reasons. But I do say that there is a second form of suicide -- justifiable suicide, that is, rational and planned self-deliverance from a painful and hopeless disease which will shortly end in death....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]

Free Essays
1933 words (5.5 pages)

Assisted Suicide Essay

- Writing the fifth assignment for the English class was by far the hardest essay I have had to write. Constantly was I running into problems, and this ended up taking me much longer than I had originally planned. Writing about the opposing side of this topic was very hard, as I usually caught myself writing things that I couldn’t make work in my paper. The writing was very tough to keep on track because it isn’t actually how I feel. This essay helped me to better understand the argument that is presented from both sides....   [tags: Assisted Suicide Death Essays]

Research Papers
839 words (2.4 pages)

Assisted Suicide Essay

- Assisted Suicide I examine the ways in which our cultural expectations with respect to death may be transformed by the legalization of assisted suicide. I suggest the inadequacy of the philosophical framework currently taken as the basis for discussing the advantages as well as the dangers of legalizing assisted suicide. I do not believe that individual autonomy is any sort of possibility for dying patients, regardless of the social policies that surround death in a society, insofar as our individual agency in this situation is necessarily intertwined with that of various relevant others....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]

Research Papers
4614 words (13.2 pages)

Related Searches

Asked about the Johnson case, Ms. Girsh again provided a justification for assisted death in cases of disability: "Many people with severe, disabling chronic illnesses do suffer in many ways worse than people with terminal illnesses because there's no end in sight," she says [San Francisco Examiner, 5/10]. Another leading assisted suicide group, Compassion in Dying, has openly expanded its agenda to cover "incurable or terminal illness" [CID fundraising letter].


Hemlock's "Answer" also claims that "we have no evidence" that "health care professionals are too quick to assume that disabled people are 'better off dead'." But at the recent annual meeting of the American Academy of Neurology in Minneapolis, researchers released survey results indicating the opposite. The poll of 1000 neurologists showed that in considering whether to offer a risky, expensive but possibly life-saving treatment, 46% would take the patient's physical condition into account; 26% would be influenced by the patient's age, 20% would withhold the treatment based on ability to pay, and almost half would be influenced by the amount of brain damage the patient already had. Among those commenting on the survey was Dr. Kathleen Foley of Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, who said many studies show doctors assuming that patients with physical limitations have lives not worth living -- even when the patients themselves enjoy life [UPI, 4/28].

Return to