Too close for comfort

Too close for comfort

Length: 1046 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Too close for comfort
Yet the similarity between these two stories raises some interesting questions about how we read Carver. That he is adored as few late-century American writers are is not news -- as Bloom points out there's almost a cult of Carver. Readers treasure not only his taut, bleak, deeply moving short stories but the legend of his life, as well: unhappy, alcoholic, stifled by frustrating poverty and saddled with the overwhelming responsibilities of teenage parenthood ("[My wife and I] didn't have any youth" he told Simpson), Carver's singular talent didn't have room to develop until relatively late. His eventual triumph over adversity, a story of late, spectacular blooming against all odds, has given him a rare hold on his readers' affection. Carver chronicled the lives of the lumpen proletariat and the demoralized white working class with a sensitivity and eye for detail unmatched in his contemporaries and, many would argue, his followers. He is commonly thought of as a truly American writer, perhaps stylistically indebted to Sherwood Anderson, Stephen Crane and Ernest Hemingway (he himself suggested the link to Hemingway in his book "Fires"), but in a sense sui generis -- a talented, sensitive soul who rose up out of the deadening laundromats and strip malls of the great, dreary American suburban wastelands and wrote beautiful, sad stories in clipped, stripped prose. The minimalism and domestic realism of his short stories made his work read very differently from the cerebral literary styling of his contemporaries, the university-ensnared postmodernists. But perhaps Carver's work wasn't as unfettered or as American (in his literary influences, at least) as all that. It seems that he read (and taught) the European modernists very carefully. Bloom says that, "Carver was a very literary writer and his work is full of echoes of other writers, some of them unintentional. He's a derivative writer -- vastly overrated." Or, as Tobias Wolff wrote, admiringly, in the introduction to "The Best American Short Stories of 1994:" The picture of Gabriel Conroy [in James Joyce's' "The Dead"] watching his wife Gretta on the staircase above him as she listens to a tragic ballad ... has become for me ... the very emblem of that final distance which a lifetime of domestic partnership can never overcome. I wonder if there isn't an echo of this image in Raymond Carver's "Will You Please Be Quiet, Please?" when Ralph, returning from a walk on his honeymoon, sees his bride, Marian, "leaning motionless on her arms over the ironwork balustrade of their rented casita .

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Too close for comfort." 123HelpMe.com. 18 Jul 2019
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=94315>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Too close for comfort

- Too close for comfort Yet the similarity between these two stories raises some interesting questions about how we read Carver. That he is adored as few late-century American writers are is not news -- as Bloom points out there's almost a cult of Carver. Readers treasure not only his taut, bleak, deeply moving short stories but the legend of his life, as well: unhappy, alcoholic, stifled by frustrating poverty and saddled with the overwhelming responsibilities of teenage parenthood ("[My wife and I] didn't have any youth" he told Simpson), Carver's singular talent didn't have room to develop until relatively late....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1046 words (3 pages)

My Brother And I Were Very Close Essay example

- My brother and I were very close. We shared a certain type of bond; we did everything together. Our family situation brought us close as it appeared it was just the two of us against the world. I was almost four years older than he. As the big sister I felt it was my job to protect him. It was then at the age of 7 I realized it was not just strangers that I needed to be leary of. My brother and I were dropped off yet again at another person’s house. This time who knew for how long. My mother worked several jobs to provide for us is how she explained it, and she had to make sacrifices....   [tags: Family, English-language films, Father]

Research Papers
2285 words (6.5 pages)

Welfare and Government Assistance Policy Recommendations Essay

- Welfare and Government Assistance Policy Recommendations Being raised in a single-parent lower class home, I realize first-hand the need for welfare and government assistance programs. I also realize that the system is very complex and can become a crutch to people who become dependent and complacent. As a liberal American I do believe that the government should provide services to the less fortunate and resources to find work. However, as able-bodied citizens we should not become complacent with collecting benefits and it is the government’s job to identify people who take advantage of the system and strip benefits from people who are not making efforts to support themselves independently....   [tags: poor countries, too generous]

Research Papers
690 words (2 pages)

Essay about From the Comfort of Your Own School

- Somehow it seems that they are always the ones to win the spelling bees. They make other high school kids look E-L-E-M-E-N-T-A-R-Y. These students succeed because they were exposed to a better learning environment, were able to progress at their own pace, and had the freedom to choose their own studies. These kids are home schooled kids, and their style of education is more beneficial than public schooling. Home schooling is an educational system based at the home. Here, a child learns at their parents' hands, sometimes by a tutor, typically on a one-to-one basis....   [tags: Education ]

Research Papers
1637 words (4.7 pages)

Close Reading: An Invisible Sign of My Own by Aimee Bender Essay

- Close Reading: An Invisible Sign of My Own by Aimee Bender For much of her life, Mona Gray has lived a strange life after her father contracted an unknown disease. Mona soon becomes a quitter, and although she excels at many things, she always forces herself to quit. All of this changed when Benjamin Smith, the new science teacher, arrives. With his eccentric ways he is able to see through Mona when most people were not, including her family....   [tags: Book Report]

Free Essays
985 words (2.8 pages)

What is a Home? Essay

- ... Of course homes are not paid for in cash, but this shows that average American families are unable to purchase or build a home. So the market for used homes is great, not only is this cheaper, but it saves space, it produces less waste, and generally provides an adequate home. Because of this never ending cycle of home switching and the deterioration of materials homes eventually become structures in need of repair or in worst case scenarios structures awaiting demolition. Some homes are demolished even before the time comes to make way for newer, better-looking, and more efficient structures that some argue fulfill the needs of home owners better then the now demolished home....   [tags: construction, comfort, individuality]

Research Papers
1723 words (4.9 pages)

Too Often We Enjoy the Comfort of Opinion without the Discomfort of Thought

- The topic of essay – quote from John Kennedy seems to have remained as actual topic from the time of the J.F.Kennedy presidency to modern days. If we approach ourselves in everyday life, it seems that having an opinion comes more quickly, than having thought of it. In very foundations of Kant and Heidegger philosophy, philosophers approach concept of thought as fundamental part of existence, “to be” and “Being”. Introducing into determining what really is “thinking”, Heidegger has said “The most thought-provoking thing in our thought-provoking time is that we are still not thinking.” , as he further addresses, that indeed, the absence for thinking is the main thought provoker....   [tags: Kennedy quote analysis from Heidegger standpoint]

Research Papers
887 words (2.5 pages)

Exploring Culture in Ali's "Brick Lane" and Hughes' "I, Too, Sing America"

- Culture is something we have all heard in our daily lives. In literature, culture is used very well and analyzing it to get the true meaning of culture portrayed in a text can be very useful. Culture can mean various things from what you do and what you think to your general lifestyle. It defines the person you are and is present within everyone’s life. Culture is very important in texts and it is worth analyzing. You know a lot more about the text if you know the meaning of culture in that text....   [tags: Brick Lane, I Too Sing America]

Research Papers
1187 words (3.4 pages)

Carrion Comfort by Gerard Manley Hopkins Essay

- Carrion Comfort by Gerard Manley Hopkins Gerard Manley Hopkins was a talented poet, and he was also extremely devoted to his faith. He used his poetry as an avenue in which to express his love and praise to his Creator, and many of his poems are beautiful hymns of adoration. “Carrion Comfort,” however, is one of his “terrible sonnets.” Hopkins not only wrote about the beautiful part of faith, but also the questioning and suffering that inevitably comes during a person’s spiritual journey. The Petrarchan or Italian sonnet was one of Hopkins’s favorite forms of poetry and one that he employed frequently in his writing....   [tags: Carrion Comfort Hopkins Essays]

Research Papers
3427 words (9.8 pages)

Environmental Crisis Exposed in The World Is Too Much With Us and God's Grandeur

- Environmental Crisis Exposed in The World Is Too Much With Us and God's Grandeur  In his poem, "The World Is Too Much With Us," William Wordsworth blames modern man of being too self-indulgent.  Likewise, Gerard Manley Hopkins shows how the way we treat nature shows our loss of spirituality in his poem, "God's Grandeur."  We are ruthless by lacking proper appreciation for, being separated from, and abusing nature.   Man lacks proper gratitude for nature.  People often are blind to nature's great beauty.  "It moves us not," says Wordsworth.  Many people never see a sunrise or a sunset because we are too concerned with the hustle and bustle of our tiny worlds to appreciate the op...   [tags: World Is Too Much With Us Essays]

Research Papers
765 words (2.2 pages)

.. she was looking away from him, staring at something in the distance. But unacknowledged, unconscious "borrowing" or no, what does all of this matter when Carver's fiction has given so many people so much pleasure? All artists (from great to lousy) in all media from time immemorial have borrowed and stolen, reinterpreted and reworked the art and ideas of their predecessors and contemporaries. It's the nature of creativity. So who cares if Carver shoplifted some ideas? Isn't Lady Chatterly herself a descendant of Emma Bovary? Isn't the most famous blind man of them all Oedipus Rex? And, as Professor Cushman suggests, isn't Lawrence himself working closely with Sophocles' ideas in his story? Yet, in the end, isn't there a line between being influenced and knocking off someone else's work? Nevertheless, to suggest such an influence and to note Carver's denial of it can't fail to be seen as throwing down a gauntlet. Even in our era of sampling, of pastiche as high art and of the endless Hollywood remake, we still cherish originality as a cultural ideal, especially when it comes to the hallowed practice of literature. As recent events in publishing illustrate, the accusation of plagiarism or covert idea-theft can bring down a career and humiliate those involved with the accused project. It's all right if an author is up front about riffing on an earlier work, as Peter Carey was with his most recent novel, "Jack Maggs," or Michael Cunningham with "The Hours." But we feel fooled when something presented as original isn't. And we still see the history of literature (as well as those of art and architecture) as a narrative chronicling a series of innovations, starring the artists who shocked the world with the "new." Any writer striving for greatness, as Carver clearly was, worries that his claim on immortality may be tenuous. Carver's refusal to acknowledge the obvious similarities between his own story and Lawrence's speaks to the depths of his insecurity -- as a working class writer in a literary world run by an Ivy-League-educated elite -- about his own place in the canon. That "Cathedral" was hailed by no less than Anatole Broyard in the New York Times as "perhaps Carver's best work to date" would have made its provenance even more of a loaded issue. And while, to a more objective outsider, the debt to Lawrence might not seem like such a big deal, Carver could not afford to acknowledge that the centerpiece of his new book, the beating heart of his move "toward a greater ease of manner and generosity of feeling" (in the words of reviewer Irving Howe), was after all not solely and entirely his. As Professor Skenazy puts it, "'Cathedral' is one of Ray's trademark stories, and if you say, 'I borrowed [it] from someone else,' well, it seems less original." Near the end of his interview with Mona Simpson, Carver disparaged art, his own and literature in general, as essentially inconsequential: "After all, art is a form of entertainment, yes? For both the maker and the consumer. I mean in a way it's like shooting billiards or playing cards, or bowling -- it's just a different, and I would say higher, form of amusement ..." What then to make of this man who clearly saw himself as first and foremost a writer of literature, an art that he in turn claimed was of little more significance than bowling a rubber on a Saturday night? Nothing Carver himself didn't already identify and write in his stories for us: ambivalence, insecurity, ambition, need, cowardice and hope -- all the demons that beset the soul who wants to be Somebody. But judging from Carver's enduring popularity and beloved status with a whole new generation of short-story writers and readers, he needn't have worried.
Return to 123HelpMe.com