To Accept or Reject the Risk of Error

To Accept or Reject the Risk of Error

Length: 1255 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
“To accept anything as true means to incur the risk of error. If I limit myself to knowledge that I consider true beyond doubt, I minimize the risk of error, but at the same time I maximize the risk of missing out on what may be the subtlest, most important, and most rewarding things in life”. That was on page three of E.F. Schumacher’s A Guide for the Perplexed. It was included on the third page on the text because it is one of the most important reoccurring themes throughout the book.
     Schumacher means that if we only consider things of proven fact then we would be missing out on the rest of the world. If we only concentrate on what is proven then we will miss out on what is unproven thus far but could eventually be proven. Schumacher stresses his point by using the philosopher Renee Descartes. Schumacher says, “Descartes limits his interest to knowledge and ideas that are precise and certain beyond any possibility of doubt, because his primary interest is that we should become ‘masters and possessors of nature.’ Nothing can be precise unless it can be quantified in one way or another” (9).
     Descartes means that humans are the Supreme Being reining the earth and we should know everything about it. We should only accept the facts that are precise and clear cut. Everything has a reason, and it is our job as humans to know what that reason is. Schumacher takes this discussion further by analyzing the ideas of the philosopher Immanual Kant. In talking about Kant, Schumacher said, “Neither mathematics nor physics can entertain the qualitative notion of ‘higher’ or ‘lower.’ So the vertical dimension disappeared from the philosophical maps, which henceforth concentrated on somewhat farfetched problems, such as ‘Do other people exist?’ or ‘How can I know anything at all?’ or ‘Do other people have experiences analogous to mine?’” (11).

Vertical dimension is clarified on page 12 where Schumacher states, “The loss of the vertical dimension meant that it was no longer possible to give an answer, other than a utilitarian one”. Schumacher also discusses Plorinus’s Adaequatio philosophy. Schumacher said, “This is the Great Truth of “adaequatio” (adequateness), which defines knowledge as adaequatio rei et intellectus – the understanding of the knower must be adequate to the thing to be known” (39). By knowing just the things that are adequate for our understanding we are leaving so much behind.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"To Accept or Reject the Risk of Error." 15 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Theory Of Crime : Accept Or Reject Theory And Why Essay

- Theory of Crime Theory of Crime Accept or Reject Theory and Why Classical Theory I accept this theory because people make their own choices knowing the consequences to them. People sometimes also choose crime for the pleasure that may come out of it if they get away, like robbing a bank. As long as the person is rational they are They have free will and sometimes choose to commit crimes. Positive Theory I reject this theory because criminals are not born they are made. This theory is not true because not all criminals are born with chromosomal abnormalities....   [tags: Crime, Sociology, Criminology, Capital punishment]

Research Papers
1078 words (3.1 pages)

Inductive Risk Is The Risk Of Error Essay

- 5. Inductive risk is the risk of error. More specifically, it is the possibility of wrongly accepting a false hypothesis or falsely rejecting a correct hypothesis. For example, there is a new cancer drug on the market. There are two types of inductive risk in this scenario. The first, is that scientists presume that it is a safe, effective treatment when it is not, so it stays in the market. The second scenario is that scientists believe this treatment is ineffective and so it is pulled from the market, even though it is actually effective and could cure the cancer....   [tags: Scientific method, Science, Theory, Falsifiability]

Research Papers
946 words (2.7 pages)

Healthcare Error Assessment : Healthcare Errors Essay example

- Healthcare Error Assessment Healthcare errors have been a top priority in America for at least fifteen years. The article, To Err Is Human by the Institute of Medicine (IOM) increased the awareness of preventable medical errors and spearheaded the patient safety initiatives. However, the expected levels of improvement in quality of care and patient safety delivery have not been achieved (Daly, and Mort, 2014). Healthcare errors continue to negatively impact the desired patient outcomes and overall medical spending....   [tags: Surgery, Hospital, Physician, Medical error]

Research Papers
714 words (2 pages)

Essay on Questions On Risk And Risk Management

- No firm can be a success without some form of risk management. Risk are the uncertainty in investments requiring an assessment. Risk assessment is a structured and systematic procedure, which is dependent upon the correct identification of hazards and an appropriate assessment of risks arising from them, with a view to making inter-risk comparisons for purposes of their control and avoidance (Nikolić and Ružić-Dimitrijevi, 2009). ERM is a practice that firms implement to manage risks and provide opportunities....   [tags: Risk, Risk management, Actuarial science]

Research Papers
1881 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on Computer Error : Computer Errors

- 1. Computer Errors 1a. What is an error. In the computer world, another word for an error is “corruption. These corruptions happen when data, going from one source to another, is changed. [1] To understand the importance of this change, a more in-depth understanding is needed. Computers speak in their very own language called machine code or binary. This language is a stream of “1’s” and “0’s” is what every operation on every computer in the world depends on to operate. Since nothing in this world is perfect, errors are an eventuality....   [tags: Computer, Computer security, Technology, Error]

Research Papers
1956 words (5.6 pages)

Essay on Risk Management At Public Events

- Introduction The rising economic crisis and global terrorism in these years pushes the event organizers to place great emphasis on the health and safety risks at public events in order to avoid unnecessary risks to the public (Inspectorates request more attention for risks at public events, 2016). In general, any labour effort and material carries some unknown risks and potential opportunities which makes the risk management an essential part to the event management to guarantee the success of the event....   [tags: Risk management, Risk, Risk assessment]

Research Papers
1059 words (3 pages)

The Facility Will Provide Medical Error Insurance For Staff Members Essay

- The facility will provide medical error insurance for staff members, The facility will ban electronic devices for personal use in the work place The staff members if they would be allowed to join the union, the benefit would another layer of oversight for the staff members. The facility will notify staff members that non-licensed staff members administer the medication. Each area may need to be evaluated and address in the future with respect to the changes that do occur. Base on several of the interventions presented, it will impact the welfare of the residents in a positive way....   [tags: Health care, Medicine, Medical error]

Research Papers
1608 words (4.6 pages)

Essay about Risk Management

- Over the past decade, risk and uncertainty have increasingly become major issues which impact business activities. Many organizations are raising awareness to minimize the adverse consequences by implementing the process of Risk Management Framework which plays a significant role in mitigating almost all categories of risks. According to Ward (2005), the objective of risk management is to enhance a company’s performance. In particular, the importance of the framework is to assist top management in developing a sensible risk management strategy and program....   [tags: Business, Risk, Uncertainty]

Research Papers
2000 words (5.7 pages)

Human Error Essays

- To err is human. Throughout everyday life, human error is around every corner. Human error is defined as, “a mistake made by a person rather than being caused by a poorly designed process or the malfunctioning of a machine such as a computer.” (Encarta, 2009) To simplify this definition, people make mistakes. Human error may become apparent in the form of human behavior or conduct that can be categorized as undesirable, unacceptable, careless, inattentive, forgetful, reckless, harmful, a miscommunication, human performance that is extreme in variability or beyond the limits of that expected, or an inappropriate form of risk taking behavior....   [tags: Miscommunication, Shift Work]

Research Papers
2179 words (6.2 pages)

Risk Management Essay

- What is risk. "Simply put, risk is uncertainty. The more risk you take, the more you stand to lose or gain. You cannot expect high returns without taking substantial risks." Tossing a dice, is at basic level a risky endeavor. The outcomes are thrown open to uncertainty. You take risk everytime you act, from crossing the street; to buying a stock. Generally when people talk about risk, they focus on financial risk. In terms of finance, it is the risk that a company or individual could lose some or all of the original investment, possibly resulting in inadequate cash flow to meet financial obligations....   [tags: Investment Business Risk]

Research Papers
1550 words (4.4 pages)

All of these things being left behind have question marks surrounding them because it is beyond our Level of Being and furthermore our level of understanding. Schumacher later says,
It is claimed that only such knowledge can be termed ‘scientific’ and ‘objective’ as is open to public verification or falsification by anybody who takes the necessary trouble; all the rest is dismissed as ‘scientific’ and ‘subjective.’ The use of these terms in this manner is a grave abuse, for all knowledge is ‘subjective’ inasmuch as it cannot exist otherwise than in the mind of a human subject, and the distinction between ‘scientific’ and ‘unscientific’ knowledge is question-begging, the only valid question about knowledge being that of its truth (57).
     Schumacher continues to express his views by saying that the only question we should ask of knowledge is the validity of its truth. We should not classify knowledge in any of category except for true or false. Any other category could contain error because it could beyond a human’s capability of understanding. This quote is related to Schumacher’s level of being (17). Mineral can be written as m. Plant can be written as m + x. Animal can be written as m + x + y. Man can be written as m + x + y + z. A mineral does not live nor does it have consciousness. A plant is living but lacks consciousness. Animals live and have a sense of consciousness but lacks self consciousness. Man is living, has consciousness, and a sense of self consciousness. Each level has an increasingly important factor.
     Each level has a parameter of understanding with concrete boundaries, even humans. Humans do not even understand a higher being. Some believe that a supreme being exists but they are those who accept the risk of error. A supreme being whether it be Jesus Christ, Buddha, or any other deity adds an important dimension to most humans lives. Some people even live their lives for their God. If these people didn’t accept the risk of error then their lives would lack meaning and be completely different.
     Schumacher says, “The claim that ‘Science’ brings forth ‘Truth’ – certain, unshakable, reliable knowledge which has been ‘scientifically proved’ – and that this unique ability gives it a status higher than that of any other human activity (106). If something is scientifically proven then it means that is 100% free of error. That means that the fact in question will never change no matter what situation it is in. Schumacher goes on further by defining pragmatism. “Pragmatism is the philosophy which holds that the only valid test of truth is that it works. The pragmatist advises: ‘It is irrational to say: ‘When an idea is true, it works’; you should say: ‘When an idea works, it is true.’’ In its purest form, however, pragmatism has the relative sterility of a hit-and-miss method. All sorts of instructions, taken in isolation, may be found to work; but unless I have some idea of a principle of ‘law’ that makes a given system work, my chances of extending the range of instructional knowledge are slim” (107).
     Someone who doesn’t accept the risk of error wouldn’t consider a pragmatist’s view. As Schumacher said, you should say “pragmatism has the relative sterility of a hit-and-miss method”. Someone who embraces truth without error would say the same thing. A hit-and-miss method is just that, sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn’t. The best way to test truth is to see if it holds up in life experiences. One who would accept the risk of error in order to find more truth would welcome this idea. Schumacher said, “The idea of proof, and there with the idea of truth, in the instructional sciences is thus twofold: The instruction must work, i.e., lead to predicted result, and it must also be intelligible in terms of established scientific principles” (107). If the instruction does not lead to the predicted results every time then it is not truth and does have a risk of error. As Schumacher also stated it should be understood and defined by science. If it is really truth, then is has an explanation.
I believe that sometimes we have to take chances in order to get an accurate view of the world. If I limited myself to things that are only 100% true then my life would be very empty. Take religion for example, I am Catholic. Do I believe in God? Yes, but am I sure that a man named Jesus will come again and resurrect from the dead? No, I am not but I personally still believe in him. Religion is pretty important to me and it would be something that I would not be able to embrace if I did not risk the chance of error. To limit ourselves to truth without error is stunting our personal growth. What in life are we actually even sure of? Most of the things have no meaning whatsoever but they make us happy. It’s the things that could contain some error that we hold deep because it gives us something to believe in.
Return to