The Spanish Debate On The Americas

The Spanish Debate On The Americas

Length: 957 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

Juan Ginés de Sepulveda, Bartolomé de las Casas, and

Francisco de Vitoria arguments pertaining to the settlement and

colonization of the native people of America, while presented in

different manors, are all the same. All three Spaniards believed

that the barbarians had to accept the rule of the Spanish because

the Spanish were mentally superior, and divine and natural laws

gave the Spanish the right to conquer and enslave the native

people of America.

The foundation for Spanish conquests was their

interpretation of the bible. Ironically, it was the teachings of

the bible they were all trying to bring to the newly found

infidels. Sepulveda stated that the Spanish conquests were

sanctioned in divine law itself, for it was written in the Book

of Proverbs that "'He who is stupid will serve the wise man.'"

In propositions one and two, Bartolomé de las Casas stated that

he believed that Jesus Christ had the authority and the power of

God himself over all men in the world, especially those who had

never heard the tidings of Christ nor of His faith. Las Casas

also stated in his second proposition that St. Peter and his

successors(that being missionaries located in the New World) had

the duty by the injunctions of God to teach the gospel and faith

of Jesus Christ to all men throughout the world. What is

interesting is that Las Casas thought that it was "unlikely that

anyone [would] resist the preaching of the gospel and the

Christian doctrine..." While being a bishop and a Dominican

missionary in the New World, he had the task of spreading the

holy faith, expanding the area covered by the teachings of the

universal Church(that being the Christian religion), and the

improvement of the natives' souls as his ultimate goal. As

stated in proposition ten however, the Indians sovereignty and

dignity and royal pre-eminence should not, in his belief

disappear either in fact or in right. "The only exceptions are

those infidels who maliciously obstruct the preaching of the

gospel... ." In proposition eleven though, he continues by

contradicting himself by saying that "He who persistently defends

it[that being the preaching of the missionaries] will fall into

formal heresy." Sepulveda also thought that if infidels

rejected the rule of Christianity, it could be imposed upon them

by force of arms. Sepulveda's justification for the use of force

was, after all, justified according to natural law, and that just

and natural noble people should rule over men who are not

"superior". War against the barbarians, according to Sepulveda,

was justified because of their paganism and also because of their

abominable licentiousness. Sepulveda and Las Casas both thought

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Spanish Debate On The Americas." 05 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

De La Casas : Friend Or Foe Of The Indigenous? Essay

- Fray Bartolome de La Casas: Friend or Foe of the Indigenous. If you are studying the colonization of the America’s, the majority of the stories you will hear are about the great Spanish conquistadors. These explorers acted more so as military leaders, but are shown in a light of heroism when looking at history. When the conquistadors came across new lands in the America’s the only thing they were concerned about was their own fame and accomplishments. If anything or anyone got in their way of achieving greatness they would often destroy it....   [tags: Indigenous peoples of the Americas, Latin America]

Research Papers
1479 words (4.2 pages)

The First Presidential Debate Over Police Brutality Against The Black Community

- In the first presidential debate the two candidates used an ideograph to communicate with a certain population. The ideograph that they used were “Latino” and “Hispanic.” Each of these ideographs has a different target demographic. Furthermore both of these ideographs are problematic. The debate was on the major challenges that the future president would have to face. This specific section of the debate was on how the President would deal with police brutality against the black community. They started off talking about only the black population but then incorporated all the people that lived in the impoverished cities....   [tags: United States, Hispanic and Latino Americans]

Research Papers
787 words (2.2 pages)

The Colonization Of The Americas Essay

- The colonization of the Americas by the Spanish, starting in the late 15th century, was marked by the violent suppression and exploitation of the indigenous populations. Legitimized by royal support and proselytizing papal decree, the colonists expanded territory by force and enslaved natives for the purpose of labor. The colonists had differing views on the practices involving the natives and produced varying descriptions of them. The way in which these men and other settlers viewed the native cultures, practices, and achievements provided the justification or condemnation of the actions that unfolded around them....   [tags: Colonialism, Spanish colonization of the Americas]

Research Papers
1337 words (3.8 pages)

Columbus Day Debate Essay

- The spirit and values of a nation are reflected in the nation’s heroes. Christopher Columbus has been regarded as an American hero since 1792. Every year Columbus Day is held on the second Monday in October to honor the man and his legacy. However, many people debate whether or not Columbus Day should be celebrated. I believe that Columbus Day should be celebrated in the United States because he opened up the New World to Europe, inspired a spirit of exploration and adventure that still lasts today, and he showed the importance of diversity and understanding of different cultures....   [tags: Christopher Columbus Essays]

Research Papers
683 words (2 pages)

Essay on The, American, And American Culture

- “American” Me. Descending from minority-driven ancestries, it’s hard to truly call myself an American, ethnically at least. Scratch that. I’m going to dispel the notion that being an American is a way of describing someone. No one is truly American, not even natural born citizens. We are all descendants of either Natives, Africans, Asians, or Europeans, and even those ethnic groups were derived from even earlier ancestors. The point is: the suggestion that an American identity exists, is a myth....   [tags: United States, Latin America, Americas]

Research Papers
1522 words (4.3 pages)

European Colonisation Of The Americas Essay

- How did European colonisation of the Americas affect the society and culture of the continent’s indigenous people up to 1650. Focus on colonial region of Mexico The European colonisation of the Americas is often portrayed as a definitive turning point in which the culture of the natives was instantly driven to extinction (or at least altered beyond recognition). While this is certainly true in some cases, such as for the natives living on Caribbean islands, in other cases it is fair to say that native culture saw relative continuation....   [tags: Colonialism, Spanish colonization of the Americas]

Research Papers
1502 words (4.3 pages)

The Colonization Of 19th Century America And Jacksonland Essay

- Although A Land So Strange focuses on 16th century America and Jacksonland focuses on 19th century America, both works feature men who were willing to sacrifice Indigenous lives for the acquisition of land and resources. However, Indigenous peoples did not simply let this occur. In A Land So Strange, multiple Indigenous groups told Narváez embellished tales about prosperous lands in order to prevent him from intruding on their settlements. In Jacksonland, the Cherokee created their own constitution to participate in American politics....   [tags: Indigenous peoples of the Americas, United States]

Research Papers
1207 words (3.4 pages)

Spanish Missionaries Served As Conquerors For The Spanish Empire Essay

- Spanish missionaries served as conquerors for the Spanish empire because they overpowered the natives through their brute force and superior technology to expand their empire territorially as well as increase their faith. The Spanish had one and only objective: to control the new world and take from it whatever number wealth as could be allowed with a distinctly less vital objective was to christianize the natives. The Spanish had various innovative preferences which permitted them to rapidly overpower the natives, despite the fact that the natives were prevalent in number....   [tags: Colonialism, Spanish colonization of the Americas]

Research Papers
714 words (2 pages)

Spanish Colonization And The New World Essay example

- Starting in 1492 with Columbus and continuing for 350 years, Spain settled and conquered almost all of South America, the American Southwest, and the Caribbean. The Spanish empire grew to be the largest European empire since ancient Rome, and it used the wealth that it obtained from the Americas to support nearly endless warfare in Europe, which protected the Americas with a large navy and a very powerful army and brought Catholicism to the New World. At this time, Spain saw the New World as unruly and uncivilized because most of the people there were pagan....   [tags: Colonialism, Spanish colonization of the Americas]

Research Papers
1257 words (3.6 pages)

The Spanish-American War Essay

- THESIS : “ The United States didn’t want to get involved in the Spanish-American War, but was dragged into it due to yellow journalism, they wanted to control the seas, and wanted complete control over Cuba.” For 113 days during the summer of 1898, the United States was at war with Spain. Neither the president of the United States, nor his cabinet, nor the the queen of Spain, nor her ministers wanted the war wanted the war. It happened eventhough they made their best efforts to prevent it. It happened because of ambition, miscalculation, and stupidity; and it happened because of kindness, wit, and resourcefulness....   [tags: Spanish-American War Essays]

Free Essays
1517 words (4.3 pages)

Related Searches

that under no circumstances should the Indians be governed under

their own rules. The Spaniards took the initiative by

establishing several municipalities, which where governed by

local nobles. The single fact alone that "no one individual owns

anything,..." was enough for the Spaniards to establish a formal

overseas administration for the infidels. Las Casas states "[we]

are obliged by divine law to establish a government and

administration over the native peoples of the Indies..."

Sepulveda thought that those who were 'dim-witted' and mentally

lazy, although they may be physically strong are by nature

slaves, therefore they should serve and be lead by humane

(superior)and cultured men. The fact that the Spaniards assumed

that the natives were slaves(inferior) by nature is absolutely

amazing. Francisco de Vitoria also thought that they were

incapable of self-government and their weak minds left no choice

but for them to be governed by those who had more knowledge,

namely, the Spanish nobles. "The aborigines in question seem to

be slaves by nature because of their incapability of self

government... ...[therefore] it is permissible to seize their

patrimony and enslave them..."

According to Juan Ginés de Sepulveda the "perfect should

command and rule over the imperfect, the excellent over its

opposite..." The Spaniards justified their conquests by arguing

that they conquered and enslaved only those people who were

unwilling to admit to Christian missionaries and therefore were

rejecting divine law. As Sepulveda contemplated, the more

perfect directs and dominates, and the less perfect obeys their

commands. He stated that all of this derived from divine and

natural law, both of which demanded that the perfect and most

powerful rule over the imperfect and the weaker. He thought,

along with several other people of the times, that it was just

and only right to conform with the dictates of natural law,

barbarians had no other course but to submit to the rule of the

more cultured and humane princes and nations. The princes and

nations of Spain held the beliefs that virtues and practical

wisdom could destroy the barbarism of their nature and in turn

educate the 'inferior' people to a more humane and virtuous life.

"The Spanish Right of Conquest" gave them the 'right' to acquire


Sepulveda saw the infidels as people 'for the taking', and

that they should be made to submit to the Spanish rule, and by

force if necessary. The Dominicans, however, on the 'outside',

preached that the infidels should "be preached peacefully, with

love,... ...and affection,..." However, Las Casas does say

that the infidels could "be punished by any judge... ...[if they]

obstruct the preaching of the gospel and who refuse to desist

after they have been sufficiently warned" It is clear then

that Las Casas and Vitoria were not true 'friends of the

Indians.' Both the Dominicans and Sepulveda were intent on

achieving any gain possible for their country and themselves, and

they didn't truly care what happened to the natives of America.

Their achievements of converting the infidels further proved and

backed that their justifications for imposing Christianity upon

the natives was good, and just.

Return to