Magical Elements in The Day We Were Dogs

Magical Elements in The Day We Were Dogs

Length: 1326 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Magical Elements in The Day We Were Dogs

    The short story "The Day We Were Dogs", first published in 1993, was written by Elena Garro. She was born in Pueblo, Mexico, on December 15, 1920. I feel that the story definitely has to deal with magical realism. "The Day We Were Dogs" has too many magical elements that are treated as normal not to be magical realism. However, I also felt that the story has some unreal elements that are not treated as normal. Therefore, I feel that the story may also fit into the genre of fantastic literature, which creates questions about the unreal elements. Given this fact that the story hovers between magical realism and fantastic literature, it can not be absolutely defined as an example of magical realism.

After reading "The Day We Were Dogs", I felt that some things were treated as normal. One of the characteristics of magical realism is the fact that the girls might be dogs. To me, this is an obvious magical element. A human can not turn into a dog in any way, shape, or form. Also, a magical realist characteristic is when one of the girls touched a worm with her fingertip and it became a red ring (208). If she is a dog, I find myself asking: Why is he touching the worm with his fingertip? In addition, Eva rested her head on her fore paws and closed her eyes (209). The fact that the girls are switching from a human back to an animal seems magical to me. Most importantly, these magical elements are treated as normal by the characters, a necessary criteria for magical realism (Faris 172).

The sun beating down, the earth burned, and the dogs' food was heavy as bags of rocks (209), however, in my opinion, is an example of an unreal element that is questionable. Dog food is heavy, but I do not think that it is as heavy as rocks. I felt that it was somewhat an exaggeration. Therefore, I feel that it is a fantastic element, one that is questioned (Todorov), rather than an example of magical realism in which the unreal is treated as normal.

Grounding the magical elements in reality is also a characteristic of magical realism. I found some realistic elements in the story "The Day We Were Dogs" as well.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Magical Elements in The Day We Were Dogs." 13 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Sublime and Fantastic Elements in The Day We Were Dogs Essay

- Sublime and Fantastic Elements in The Day We Were Dogs      "The Day We Were Dogs" is a short story written by an author born in Puebla, Mexico, in 1993. Elena Garro's major themes revolve around the concepts of time and memory. I do not believe this story is a true example of magical realism; however I do see the sublime and the fantastic used in this story. I think that this story is really a misidentification of magical realism. To start out, I was moved by the way the author talked about a day with two days inside of it....   [tags: Day We Were Dogs Essays]

Free Essays
934 words (2.7 pages)

The Misidentification of The Day We Were Dogs Essay

- The Misidentification of The Day We Were Dogs      "The Day We Were Dogs," published in 1993 by Elena Garro, illustrates the common error of misidentification of Magical Realism. The fact that Garro is a Mexican author and that fantasy is so closely related to Magical Realism often causes the reader to associate this particular work with Magical Realism. However, this work also contains fantastic elements as well as sublime characteristics, which make it difficult to classify as a strictly Magical Realist work....   [tags: Day We Were Dogs Essays]

Research Papers
1008 words (2.9 pages)

Identifying The Day We Were Dogs Essay

- Identifying The Day We Were Dogs        Whether or not "The Day We Were Dogs" (1993) is a magical realist story is questionable. Often stories are misidentified because of the closeness of literature such as magical realism, the fantastic, and the sublime. The story leaves a lot to one's imagination instead of presenting it in the text. Elena Garro blends two days and two completely different worlds together in this story. The magical elements depend on how one uses his or her imagination throughout this story....   [tags: Day We Were Dogs Essays]

Research Papers
1006 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Characteristics of Magical Realism in If Dinosaurs Were Cats And Dogs

- Characteristics of Magical Realism in If Dinosaurs Were Cats And Dogs       "If Dinosaurs Were Cats And Dogs" is a short story written by Colin McNaughton. "If Dinosaurs were Cats And Dogs" was published in 1981. It is classified under the fantastic sublime. However, based on the analysis of "If Dinosaurs were Cats And Dogs" one would believe that magical realism is a genre of the sublime.   While reading "If Dinosaurs Were Cats And Dogs", one comes upon the illustrations in the book. Through out all of the illustrations, the people are on a smaller scale then the animals....   [tags: Dinosaurs Were Cats And Dogs Essays]

Free Essays
1022 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Narrowing the Defining Boundaries of Magical Realism

- Narrowing the Defining Boundaries of Magical Realism Latin American author Elena Garro wrote works such as "Recuerdos del porvenir," "Andamos huyendo Lola," "Testimonios sobre Mariana," and "The Day We Were Dogs." The short story "The Day We Were Dogs" (1964) uses events that are questionable to the reader even though the characters do not question. Because these events are questioned by the reader, it is not a Magical Realist story. This story might have been miss identified because it was written by a Latin author....   [tags: Latin American Literature Essays]

Free Essays
883 words (2.5 pages)

Misunderstanding The Day We Were Dogs Essay

- Misunderstanding The Day We Were Dogs       Writers as well as many people make or mislabel stories. Magical, unreal, real, fantastic, and the sublime are just a few types of different labels that a person can use. The different types of stories are amusing and fun. The world is made up of all types of different labels of material for stories that people like to read and enjoy. Elana Garro is one of the Spanish authors who has written stories that have been mislabeled and put with other stories that were listed under the magical and the unreal....   [tags: Day We Were Dogs Essays]

Free Essays
1133 words (3.2 pages)

Magical Realism as Applied to the Field of Psychology Essay

- Magical Realism as Applied to the Field of Psychology Throughout time, one finds many different categories of literature. Magical Realism, a relatively new category, seems to be one of, if not the most, controversial category of the last century. Magical Realism combines a magical, often grotesque, element with a reality based background and allows the reader to view life in a more profound way. The field of psychology, specifically the case of the Wild Child known as Genie, parallels very closely with the ideals of Magical Realism....   [tags: Magical Realism Literature]

Research Papers
665 words (1.9 pages)

Therapy Dogs Essay

- As the saying goes, a dog is a man’s best friend. The dog is a loving companion to a man. He is happy to go everywhere with his master. He shows his affection for his master by wagging his tail and licking his hand or face. This timeless relationship continues to evolve into new kinds of human-dog interactions that increasingly benefit society. This has led to the belief that dogs can provide company, affection and support to people who are going through a difficult time or who feel lonely. Dogs have aided humans in tasks such as hunting, livestock herding, and guarding....   [tags: seizure dogs, dogs, service dogs]

Research Papers
1017 words (2.9 pages)

Magical Realism Essay examples

- To many critics of the genre, Magical Realism is nothing but updated children's tales being passed off as substantial literature, but if we look deeper, the essence of this movement is bared to the viewer. By looking at the history and origins of Magical Realism, as well as the term itself, we can begin to understand the importance of this writing style in today's society. The roots behind Magical Realism are found in many cultures, but the literature is mainly attributed to South American writers, such as Gabriel Garcia Marquez....   [tags: Magical Realism Essays]

Free Essays
583 words (1.7 pages)

Dogs Essay

- The results of the study scaled the dogs on five dimensions of behavior temperament: playfulness, curiosity/fearfulness, chase-proneness, sociability, and aggressiveness (De Palma et al., 2005). Dogs living in rescue shelters were assessed as demonstrating a low degree of playfulness, showing distraction by the environment when being enticed to play. The sheltered dogs also scored low on curiosity but, high on fearful behavior. The cortisol levels for the sheltered dogs were significantly higher than the cortisol levels of canines living in households, indicative of stress and anxiety associated with shelter lifestyle....   [tags: Shelter Dogs]

Research Papers
1148 words (3.3 pages)

Related Searches

The fact that the girls might be pretending to be dogs is real in my opinion. A person can pretend to be or do anything, and it is still real because it is life. Also, the fact that the girls decided that their names were going to be Christ and Buddha is a realistic element in my opinion (208-209). Christ and Buddha are actual names that are used and talked about everyday. In addition, they were pretending to be dogs or were dogs, they had real dog actions in the story. Although a human being a dog could never happen, their actions relate to reality. Worms also truly crawl into their holes, while black beetles look for the moist places underneath the stones (209). These details were mentioned in the story and are things something that a worm and black beetles actually do.

I feel that the story does include some defamiliarization. In the story, the dogs do not do anything all day; however, in this story, we see how a dog's day usually goes, which is familiar. In my opinion, that instance is defamiliarization (Simpkins 150), something that we are familiar with, then view in a whole new way.

A problem with this story as an example of magical realism is that the reader does question the story and plot. The fact that the girls were humans and then they are dogs makes a person wonder what is really going on. Are they dogs or pretending to be dogs? Do they switch back and forth? The reason for asking this question is because one minute they mention the girl is using her finger, and the next minute she is using her fore paw (208-209). This questioning upsets the harmonious balance between the real and unreal that is required for magical realism (Todorov).

While reading "The Day We Were Dogs", I found that the characters themselves did not have any hesitation in the story. However, the readers hesitate because they are unsure if the girls are dogs or if they are pretending to be dogs. The reason the reader wonders about this occurrence is due to the fact that the story goes back and forth about them being human and a dog (208).

I felt that the story might have included elements of the magical grotesque, though. Also, I felt that the story had some strangeness to it, as well, in the form of Grotesque elements. One example was the excessive blood when the man was shot (210).

After reading "The Day We Were Dogs," I felt that it did treat some unreal elements in a way that placed it more in the fantastic genre than in magical realism. The reason I feel this story is because the girls as dogs were having to question what was happening to them. It was very obvious at times they were not sure who they were. They even had to ask themselves if they were dogs. Also while reading the story, I found another unreal element that was not treated as normal. The fact that the dogs were next to ants with their green sunshades seemed to be fantastic. There is no way that ants could wear green sunshades, and while I was enjoying that part, I felt that it would definitely be considered as an element of fantastic literature because of its questionable relationship with reality.

This story may also include some sublime elements. I felt that the two horizons and two different days , would be related to sublime. Also, the blurred horizons and the fact that the girls were always mentioning that they awoke determined not to repeat the preceding day seemed to be sublime elements. They would also look at two parallel days that glowed like two lines drawn in the water (207). For example, Rutilio yelled at the girls from the other day. He yelled, "Where are you going, you wretched little brats (209)?" The story also mentioned how they would listen to the other afternoon.

Therefore, because this story does in some ways include characteristics of fantastic literature and even some characteristics of sublime literature, it can not fit comfortably into a magical realism category. This story is an example of how easily fiction could be misidentified as magical realism if a person does not closely evaluate it according to the criteria for magical realism. After reading "The Day We Were Dogs," I found that there were magical realist elements along with elements of fantastic literature and even a few realist elements and sublime elements. The magical realism elements can also be fantastic as well. I felt that this story was very interesting to read. If a person is having trouble understanding what all of these different elements mean, I would suggest he or she read things on Scott Simpkins, Wendy B. Faris, and even Tsvetan Todorov. Reading what they have to say about magical realism, fantastic, and realistic, may help others understand what all of these issues mean.

Works Cited

Garro, Elena. "The Day We Were Dogs." Latin American Writers. N.Y.: St. Martin's Press, 1993. 206-212.

Faris, Wendy B. "Scheherazade's Children: Magical Realism and Postmodern Fiction." Magical Realism. Theory, History, Community. Ed Lois Parkinson Zamora and Wendy B. Faris. Durkham, N. C. : Duke UP, 1995. 172.

Simpkins, Scott. "Sources of Magic Realism/Supplements to Realism in Contemporary Latin American Literature." Magical Realism. Theory, History, Community. Ed Lois Parkinson Zamora and Wendy B. Faris. Durkham, N. C. : Duke UP, 1995. 150.

Todorov, Tsvetan. The fantastic: A Structural Approach to a Literary Form. Cleveland: The Press of Case Western Reserve University, 1973. 4.

Return to