Essay PreviewMore ↓
Clive Ponting's The Green History of the World and Daniel Quinn's Ishmael both critique the dominant paradigms of modern human civilization-especially where its relationship with environment is concerned. Both feel strongly that we are in trouble. Neither are quite willing to make final connections and present us with a systematic method for getting out of our impending ecological crisis, but they both do spell out what has been wrong, what is wrong now, and what will happen should we choose not to take evasive action.
In the absence of similar works "in the canon" it is hard not to feel as though, (as the character Ishmael promised), if you accept their premises you are doomed to isolation for, those who see the future most clearly are usually outcasts, lost as to what power they may have to change minds and directions.
Enlightenment almost always comes at a price, often steep.
In the interest of exploring the necessity of dissent, let's follow that line of environmental thought a little further. Ponting presents us with the scientific/cultural evidence that backs up what Quinn is saying: that we as a species are destroying our foundations even as we proclaim our creation-Civilization-a success. If this massive breakdown and foreboding future are certainties, then we must ask-as Quinn does-who or what is telling us lies to make us believe otherwise? His character Ishmael calls it "Mother Culture" and insists that its pervasive voice acts to keep us on course even when large portions of the population have every reason to lose hope in Her tenets. This all-powerful entity would, presumably, include most educational establishments and media outlets, and so information to the contrary would rarely be funded or reported, and probably never directly emphasized.
Which leaves us with a challenge: using Thomas Kuhn's model for change in the social sciences, we must endeavor to see if the Ponting/Quinn paradigm for all civilization is merely a shift in attitude or-as would be difficult for Kuhn to imagine-an entirely new realization that carries with it remedies for the penalties it warns of. If this is a shift back in paradigm, to hunter-gatherer or Noble Savage imagery, then the potential for civil disruption is great. With the stakes of annihilation as high as they are presented, such a shift could justify sweeping political/economic reform that-in the absence of the believed-in reality-would only place more of the Earth's population in positions of subsistence and subservience.
How to Cite this Page
"Unwinding the Spool of Civilization in Ponting's The Green History of the World and Quinn's Ishmael." 123HelpMe.com. 21 Aug 2018
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- We are destroying the earth in order to survive. What is our Moral Responsibility. Daniel Quinn has written a book about how things have come to be the way they are. He looks at the meaning of the world and the fate of humans. Ishmael the main character is a teacher of vast wisdom, as well as being a Gorilla. Being no ordinary Gorilla, Ishmael recognises the failing of human kind in relation to their moral responsibilities. He ultimately directs use towards a solution to the problems we have created for the planet.... [tags: Ishmael]
731 words (2.1 pages)
- The Message of Ishmael Quinn gains a unique perspective on humanity through the main character of the novel, Ishmael. Ishmael is a gorilla. And Ishmael is a teacher who communicates with humans telepathically. On the surface, this hardly seems to be a character who would appear in a serious book; more likely a children's story, a fable, or perhaps a bad science fiction novel. Yet Ishmael is none of these, and Ishmael is a strong character, with a powerful intellect and a serious purpose.... [tags: Quinn Ishmael Essays]
968 words (2.8 pages)
- The Lesson of Quinn's Ishmael There are some books that you can just sit back and enjoy, just let the authors words wash over you and, most importantly, you don't have to think. And then there's Daniel Quinn's Ishmael. The novel Ishmael, "an adventure of the mind and spirit," opens with a disillusioned and depressed man in search of a teacher, and not just any teacher. He wants someone to show him what life is all about. And so he finds Ishmael, a meiutic teacher (one who acts as a midwife to his pupils, in bringing ideas to the surface), who turns out to be a large telepathic gorilla of extraordinary intelligence.... [tags: Quinn Ishmael Essays]
872 words (2.5 pages)
- Mistakes of Mankind Exposed in Quinn's Ishmael Most humans are confused. Some know what the problem is, but most haven't even realized something is wrong. The novel Ishmael by Daniel Quinn is an attempt to bring about awareness of the mistakes that people have made and have continued to repeat through the course of human history. At its core, the story has two main characters: a teacher and a student. The teacher represents a solution to the destructive road that mankind has been traveling down and the student represents us: eager to mend our ways but apprehensive about the changes that will occur.... [tags: Quinn Ishmael Essays]
1298 words (3.7 pages)
- Ishmael: Horrifying Among the people of your culture, which want to destroy the world. Which want to destroy it. As far as I know, no one specifically wants to destroy the world. And yet you do destroy it, each of you. Each of you contribute daily to the destruction of the world. This truth was stated by a gorilla named Ishmael who, through his experiences of being taken from the jungle, placed in a zoo in the 1930's, put in a menagerie, and bought by a private owner named Mr. Sokolow, had all the time in a world to think about the world around him.... [tags: Quinn Ishmael Essays]
1394 words (4 pages)
- Tradition and Ancestry in Ishmael Reed's Mumbo Jumbo In the Western industrialized world, time is seen as a progression of events, the present building on the past as civilization becomes more "advanced." However, in the African conception of time, "the human being goes backward ...he is oriented toward the world of the ancestors, toward those who no longer belong to the world of the living" (Zahan 45). Ishmael Reed's Mumbo Jumbo problematizes the relationship between past and present.... [tags: Ishmael Reed Mumbo Jumbo Essays]
2229 words (6.4 pages)
- Mumbo Jumbo by Ishmael Reed Mumbo Jumbo is a novel about writing itself . not only in the figurative sense of the postmodern, elf-reflexive text but also in a literal sense. [It] is both a book about texts and a book of texts, a composite narrative of subtexts, pretexts, posttexts, and narratives within narratives. It is both a definition of afro American culture and its deflation. Henry Louis Gates, Jr. Author of The Signifying Monkey Mumbo Jumbo is Ishmael Reed?s third novel and by many critics, it is considered as his best.... [tags: Mumbo Jumbo Ishmael Reed Essays]
3620 words (10.3 pages)
- Desconstruction of the Moderinistic Myth in Ishmael When I read Daniel Quinn’s works, Ishmael, Providence, The Story of B, and My Ishmael, I find a common theme woven throughout which is to desconstruct the moderinistic myth that we are apart from nature and therefore not subject to natural law. I don’t find Quinn’s ideas to be much different from what I read into David Orr’s Earth in Mind or David Ehrenfeld’s books Beginning Again and The Arrogance of Humanism. I doubt that Quinn, as a writer, thinks for one minute that we are no different from other species who inhabit Earth.... [tags: Quinn Ishmael Essays]
455 words (1.3 pages)
- Ishmael: Paradigms of Yesterday "Come with me if you want to live," was all that Arnold Schwarzenegger said in his movie Terminator 2: Judgement Day, and after reading Daniel Quinn's masterpiece Ishmael, one might well receive the impression Quinn echoes such sentiments. Few books have as much relevancy in this technological, ever-changing world as Ishmael. In the beginning, according to Ishmael, God created Man to live peacefully on Earth, sustained by the fruitful bounties of Earth and subject to God's control.... [tags: Quinn Ishmael Essays]
1068 words (3.1 pages)
- Ishmael Daniel Quinn’s Ishmael is the story of one man’s quest for knowledge and his desire to “save the world”. Answering a simple ad in the paper of a teacher looking for students (p4), the narrator is sent on an incredible philosophical journey. The teacher our narrator expects is not that which he finds, however, as our titular character Ishmael, so aptly named by Walter Sokolow (p18) as he sensed the gorilla’s almost divine presence, is that teacher. This teaching is made possible by Ishmael’s miraculous telepathic way of communication (p21).... [tags: Literature Review, philosophy, analysis, quinn]
1599 words (4.6 pages)
In other words, if environmental science is right we must act immediately. But if we act immediately, and the science is not right or complete, then we put great populations at risk to the whims of authoritarian political/economic systems. Because there is so much at stake, dialogue is crucial.
Time, too, becomes paramount, for there seems to be only a limited window of opportunity in which to choose correctly and act decisively. But, if Ponting, Quinn, and a growing body of like-minded thinkers, are right, then we must begin to change our direction now. So, we are faced with a decision: should we change in the face of compelling but not yet complete data, or should we go on in a direction that has no other explanation (or even acknowledgment) of that compelling data?
Common sense is informative when we consider the stakes: if we begin to enact environmental legislation that respects the laws of ecological/biological diversity and gives room for alternative patterns of existence, then we can and should expect an improvement in ecosystems that, by its very definition, should translate into improvements for all human populations. If we let current practices continue unabated, then we should expect still-increasing profitability, but with two caveats: that the rich will continue to enjoy the lion's share of it, and that limited resources will eventually catch up with their consumption. And while modern economics in theory teaches that no such limitation can occur due to changing technology, it neglects the fact that the resources in question really do become scarce or extinct in reality.
So, really, we have the opportunity to perform a massive experiment that will serve to answer questions of hard resource supply, environmental impacts, even competing paradigm wars. But, such experimentation must be entered into by the majority of the population: of the United States at least (by virtue of its #1 position in global impacts), if not the world as a whole. If Ponting and Quinn are wrong, we will know after a time, and will have lost only a small amount of "productivity" that can easily be regained. But if they are right, then we will have taken the first steps in a long "unwinding" of the spool of Civilization.
Which brings me back to the startling realization that those who must step up to suggest such a course of action are not being allowed access to express their dissenting views. Willfully or out of ignorance, the powers that be often allow their misplaced vested interests to dictate the educational priorities for hearts and minds that have increasingly little to gain in prosperity and everything to lose in existence and soul if, to paraphrase a modern prophet, "we are living outside our means."
But in a democracy, We the People are as much to blame for our own ignorance-especially to the extent that it is a result of apathy. If we are not creating a market for truths or at least a forum dedicated to their discovery, then we deserve our fate. Perhaps, we say, it is the university that is to serve this function in our society, but I am uncomfortable with such a rigid specialization-especially when colleges and universities so often trade that role for profits and prestige themselves. No, before we assign such a crucial role as dissenter to any one institution, we must learn the art for ourselves. Sometimes we will find in the malaise of dissenting opinion, truth, which makes the time spent in difficult, often troubling, subject matter, worthwhile.