Planck V. Indiana

Planck V. Indiana

Length: 1000 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Planck v. Indiana

     In the reviewing the case of Planck v. Indiana, many complicated issues
arise. Included in those, individual rights conflicting with the public good
are among the most difficult. According to Mr and Mrs. Planck's attorney, John
Price, the Planck's religious beliefs prohibit them from accepting professional
medicine practice, as they practice alternative medicine and home school their
children. After a complaint from an older Planck daughter, who did not embrace
or respect her family's lifestyle, the state was called in to investigate the
health of the Planck children. In a preliminary check by the state of Indiana
for eyesight, Lance Planck was found not to be in need of any service. Despite
this finding, the Madison County Superior Court ordered that all of the Planck's
children's eyes be examined by the state. One month after the Court ordered
this, twenty armed officers with guns drawn came to the Planck's residence and
commanded Mr. and Mrs. Planck to give up their children. Mr. Planck told the
officers that he did not know why they were there, was pushed to the ground and
had loaded rifles pointed at him. The children were then forcibly removed from
their parents custody, and at no time was any identification shown by the
officers. Curt, Lance Planck's younger brother, resisted this removal from his
house, and was threatened by an officer that he would be "dragged out of here."
After this scene, Emily, Stephen, and Curtis Planck were loaded into a van and
driven to an eye doctor in Anderson, Indiana. The examining doctor, Dr. Joseph
Woschitz, came to the conclusion that no treatment was needed for any of the
children. How can the state justify this type of behavior? Is ripping a child
unwillingly from his mother's arms in the best interest of the public good?
What does society have to benefit from this? In short, this does not affect the
public good per se, but does affect the Plancks and any other family that
practices a religion that is not widely accepted.
     Following the above events, Mr. and Mrs. Planck were subsequently
arrested, had their First Amendment rights violated, and had their home invaded
by armed SWAT team members who fired a CS tear gas canister into their house.
Simply, Mr. and Mrs. Planck and their children were targeted by the state
selectively because of their religious beliefs which they manifested in home
education and the practice of alternative medicine. The fundamental argument
here is that the Planck's rights have been violated, and the State of Indiana
has overstepped its duty of caring for the Planck's children.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Planck V. Indiana." 19 Jan 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Fountain Made by J.P. Victor Andre in Madison, Indiana Essay

- In the downtown area of Madison, Indiana, sits an extraordinary structure that seems to capture attention from all walks of life. The Broadway Fountain was created by a French artist named J.P. Victor Andre. Andre obviously knew what he was doing when he was asked to construct this fountain because of the impressive composition it has and with its mesmerizing size. “Some have suggested that Andre’s neo-classical design was inspired by the famous fountain in Place-de-la-Concord in Paris, or by a fountain exhibited at the Crystal Palace Exhibition in London in 1851” (Wright)....   [tags: indiana, broadway fountain, victor andre]

Research Papers
876 words (2.5 pages)

Analysis Of Matthias Meyer Of Germany 's Max Planck Institute For Evolutionary Anthropology

- Matthias Meyer of Germany 's Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, stated in an article for “Nature” that stable temperatures in the cave helped preserve the mitochondrial DNA. This allowed it to be unraveled by advances in gene-sequencing technology. Paleoanthropologist john Hawkes of the University of Wisconsin, Madison, urges caution about regarding the Spanish genes and younger Denisovan ones as being closely related. "The difference between Sima and Denisova [gene] sequences is about as large as the difference between Neanderthal and living human sequences…It would not be fair to say that Denisova and Sima represent a single population, any more than that Neande...   [tags: Human, Human evolution, Blombos Cave, Africa]

Research Papers
1414 words (4 pages)

Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom Essay

- Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom As I sat and watched “Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom,” the version of the “Orient” we get in this film is quite clear. Played and acted out by Harrison Ford, he was the all-knowing, adventurous, witty, “save the day” kind of guy, who just happens to be a professor and archaeologist as well. He knew throughout every scene, how to handle a particular situation even though parts of this country were foreign to him. What makes this “Orient” stand out even worse is his side kick, “Willie”, whom he met at the beginning of the movie in a Chinese night club....   [tags: Action Movies Film Indian Culture Racism Essays]

Free Essays
695 words (2 pages)

Essay about The State Of Indiana

- The state of Indiana has also created laws to help prevent and intervene in elder abuse. One of these laws includes making everybody in the state of Indiana a mandated reporter. This means that if any Indiana resident witnesses or suspects elder abuse, they are legally required to report it to the proper authorities. Failure to report can result in class B misdemeanor charges being brought against this person (Family and Social Services Administration, 2016). It is a class A misdemeanor to financially exploit a person in Indiana and if the value exceeds $10,000 or the person is 65 or older, the charge becomes a level 6 felony (Adult Protective Services, 2016)....   [tags: Sociology, Social work, Social justice, Abuse]

Research Papers
841 words (2.4 pages)

Gambling in Indiana Essay

- GAMBLING IN INDIANA Almost 9 out of 10 adults will gamble in their lifetime. Although gambling can be in many forms, such as lottery, sports betting, and illegal gambling, casino gambling remains one of the most popular gambling activities. With 12 casinos in Indiana, the state revenue can lead to big business. Over the past decade, Indiana has brought in a large amount of revenue from its 12 river boat casinos. In fact, Indiana is third in the nation in gambling revenue - only trailing Las Vegas and New Jersey (Walker, 2013)....   [tags: loterry, sports betting, casino gambling]

Research Papers
1642 words (4.7 pages)

Max Planck Essays

- Max Planck On April 23, 1858 Max Karl Ernst Ludwig Planck was born in Kiel, Germany. He was the sixth child of a law professor at the University of Kiel. At the age of nine his interest in physics and mathematics was developed by his teacher Hermann Muller. When he graduated at the age of seventeen he decided to choose physics over music for his career. Although he is know for physics he was an exceptional pianist who had acquired the gift of being able to hear absolute pitch. His favorite works of music were known to be Schubert and Brahms....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
896 words (2.6 pages)

The Indiana Amber Alert System Essay

- In an attempt to acquaint readers with the Indiana Amber Alert System’s technology, this report will review its source, users, funding and relationship with the Emergency Alert System, sometimes called the Emergency Broadcast System. History and criteria of the system will be examined, as well as collaboration, sharing and program funding. Local information will be discussed from the perspective of an area law enforcement officer. Statewide information will be touched upon from the perspective of the director of the Indiana Amber Alert Clearinghouse in Indianapolis....   [tags: Criminal Justice]

Research Papers
3338 words (9.5 pages)

Planck’s Constant Experiment Essay

- Planck’s Constant Experiment IMPLEMENTING Before I started the experiment, the battery was disconnected with the circuit because I needed to check that the LED is connected in the right direction in the circuit. However the apparatus I set up for the experiment was correct since I followed the diagram and method on the plan step by step. The circuit worked and there was no accident happen during the experiment. Before the experiment I prepared a result table for recording voltages for each different type of LED....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1551 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on Popular Distribution Centers in Indiana

- Indiana is a beautiful state located in the Great Lakes and Midwestern areas of North America. The state has Indianapolis as its capital, which is the largest city in Indiana. The state has abundant work force who are satisfied with job opportunities offered by various industries such as the Iron and Steel manufacturing, producing medical devices and pharmaceuticals, electrical equipment, automobiles, rubber, petroleum and coal products, chemical products and transportation. Popular companies that provide distribution center jobs in Indiana KeheEstee Lauder Companies KeHE Lids Sports Group Gordmans Whole Foods Market GENCO ATC Oshkosh Corporation Princeton One DICK’S Sporting Goods Patter...   [tags: production, jobs, applications]

Research Papers
526 words (1.5 pages)

Landfills in Indiana Essay

- Dear City Council, The purpose of this letter is to ensure that the City Council has the most current information regarding municipal landfills. This information is critical in our efforts to maintain the integrity of our city. As the mayor of this fine town, I feel it is my duty to keep the citizens of Sullivan up to date with the most current information with regards to our city; as such I have researched landfills and compiled my findings here for your consideration. First and foremost, the construction of a new landfill is a decision which must not be entered into lightly....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1836 words (5.2 pages)

Related Searches

     Thomas Jefferson described our fundamental rights as "life, liberty, and
the pursuit of happiness," however, the Planck's exercise of these rights have
been violated by the State of Indiana. The Plancks seem to have been happy
before this fiasco started, but since they state has interfered and then raided
their house with tear gas and pointed a rifle at Mr. Planck, that happiness has
seem to been withdrawn.
     The State of Indiana should have the right to look after the children's
health in an emergency, but it needs to be done in a reasonable way that still
respects the Planck's religious beliefs. On the other hand, it is imperative
that the state does not infringe upon the individual's beliefs by intervening
for the sake of the public good. Where is the line that says the family has
exceeded its rights, or that the state has exceeded theirs? There is no line,
and that is why this argument is so difficult.
     While the state is responsible for a child's health, education and
welfare, why do we not see the state swarm into a house with a SWAT team that
home-schools their children? If those children do not learn as much as their
counterparts in public schools, is the state justified in ripping them out of
home-school and pushing them into a public school? In a sense, this is what
has happened in the Planck case, however, the end result was the unfortunate
death of their son Lance.
     The other side of this argument, that the state is justified in taking
the Planck's children, is also difficult to argue because of the effect it has
on the public good. The outcome of this court case will have repercussions that
will echo to groups, religious and otherwise, that the line between individual
rights and state responsibilities has been redrawn. The State of Indiana's duty
and responsibility is to make sure the welfare, health, and education of its
children is satisfactory. But in doing so, especially in this case, it is
problematic to assume that the Plancks should not be treating their own kids
with alternative medicine. Since no parent would want their own child to die,
the state has stepped in to serve as the care giver to Lance Planck. But when
Mr. and Mrs. Planck decline this care, should the state defy the parent's right
to decide what is best for their child, or should it comply with the parents
wishes of letting Lance continue untreated? The Planck's religion instructs
them that professional medical treatment should not be accepted, and that any
sickness that affects them should be treated by the family, at home. This
involved the public good because while the majority of parents would allow
medical treatment to their children, there is still a small percentage that does
not want it. As a state, and for the public good, we must respect their
beliefs--within reason--so that their rights as Americans, especially the First
Amendment, are not violated. Since the Planck's religion is such that medical
care should not be accepted, when the state steps in to assist Lance, they are
inadvertently violating the Planck's First Amendment rights. Since this case is
still pending in the courts, it will be interesting to see the outcome of its
decision and its effects on us as Americans, and as individuals.
Return to