Pres. Bush's service int he Texas Air National Guard

Pres. Bush's service int he Texas Air National Guard

Length: 1270 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Mass Comm.     

     On September 8, 2004 60 Minutes hosted by CBS Evening News anchor Dan Rather aired a show questioning President Bush’s service in the Texas Air National Guard. Rather interviewed Ben Barnes a former Texas House Speaker and Lt. Governor who testified that George W. Bush received special treatment by being admitted in to the Texas National Guard to avoid being drafted for the Vietnam War. Barnes a Democrat who was an active supporter in the Kerry campaign said Sid Adger a close friend to the Bush family asked him if he would recommend young George Bush to the Aired National Guard in order to prevent him from being shipped overseas. Barnes believed his actions were of preferential treatment because there was a list of hundreds of names who wanted to enter the Air National Guard.
     Dan Rather claimed following the Barnes interview that 60 Minutes had obtained a number of documents from Col. Jerry Killian who was commander at Texas Air National Guard during Bush’s tenure. One of the documents was from May 1972, where Killian wrote that Lt. Bush had asked him if he can get out of coming to drills from May through November in order to work on his campaign in Alabama. The memo also stated that Bush said he may not have time to take his physical. In a memo from August 18, 1973, Col Killian wrote that Col. Buck Staudt, the man running the Texas Air National Guard was pressuring him to “Sugar Coat” the evaluation of Lt. Bush. The document that brought up the most controversy was a memo written by Col. Killian put in his own personal files stating that Bush was failing to perform to U.S. Air Force and Texas Air National Guard standards. Since Killian died in 1984, 60 Minutes hired a team of individuals with expertise in handwriting analyst and document authentication claimed the memorandums were authentic.     
     Immediately following the 60 Minutes episode aired on September 8, 2004, the documents used for the program became under heavy scrutiny. The information from the documents used by 60 Minutes did not comply with the military records of Texas Air National Guard. For instance, the official record of the Air National Guard shows that Mr. Bush was suspended from flying on Aug. 1, 1972. That date contrast to a memo given to CBS News, ordering that Mr. Bush be suspended on Aug.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Pres. Bush's service int he Texas Air National Guard." 06 Apr 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Private Security Guard Business Essays

- Introduction Taiwan is considered to be one of the safer countries in Asia as Hebenton, Jou, & Chang (2010) have discussed that it is due to its heavy emphasis on education and law enforcement leading to lower levels of poverty and crime rates, although it is a sovereign state both the culture and the law can still reduce and enforce crime and violence similar to that of some democratic countries. However as Swaine (2004) mentions due to an increased frequency of cyber-attacks and white-collar crime over the years and with China just looming over the horizon, many wealthy business men in Taiwan have become more cautious by hiring more private security for both their companies and for themsel...   [tags: Security guard, Security, Police]

Research Papers
1452 words (4.1 pages)

Bush: the National Guard, Tennis, and Sacrifice Essay

- Some now decry the way George W. Bush served our country during the Vietnam era. They point out that when he was obligated to serve, April 1972 to May 1973, he apparently did not show up. They are overlooking the quality of W's service. Why, he served our country then every bit as well as Dan Quayle, his father's vice-president. Quayle did his best to protect the golf courses of Indiana from military invasion from abroad. W, we know, did no less. In fact, he did more. He volunteered. He extended himself beyond the exertions of Dan Quayle's golf sorties....   [tags: Politics]

Free Essays
378 words (1.1 pages)

Military Service, Investigation, Or Work As A Guard Essay

- * supported survey information from a 2000 study revealed within the Journal of Quantitative sociology,[17] U.S. civilians use guns to defend themselves et al. from crime a minimum of 989,883 times each year.[18] * A 1993 nationwide survey of four,977 households found that over the previous 5 years, at least 3.5% of households had members World Health Organization had used a gun "for self-defence or for the protection of property reception, work, or elsewhere." Applied to the U.S. population, this amounts to one,029,615 such incidents each year....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States, United States]

Research Papers
1543 words (4.4 pages)

The United States Coast Guard and National Defense Essay

- The Coast Guard (CG) is the nation’s smallest armed service and most misunderstood armed service. Most Americans know the Coast Guard is the nation’s premiere lifesaving service. Some may even know that the Coast Guard is the nation’s oldest continuing sea going service. While the Coast Guard falls under the UCMJ just like the other four branches, and often works side by side with them especially the Navy; The Coast Guard is usually trained for a very different mission than their DOD counterparts in times of peace....   [tags: Missions of United States Coast Guard]

Research Papers
2948 words (8.4 pages)

Essay on George Herbert Walker Bush and George Walker Bush

- Like Father Like Son - George Herbert Walker Bush and George Walker Bush Although all individuals are unique no matter how closely related they might be, sometimes their similarities over shadow their differences, and yield a very interesting combination of events that almost have a deja vu effect on its audience. The Bush family serves as the perfect illustration for this phenomenon. From their family history and business life, to their life as the Presidents of the United States, Bush Senior and Junior have led quite parallel lives....   [tags: George Bush Father Son Essays]

Research Papers
3220 words (9.2 pages)

Job Responsibilities : A Security Guard Essay

- Job responsibilities need to be precise because someone’s life could be in danger. “There are many different jobs and careers out there in the world. Some jobs require skills and training and others require an educational background. The career I am focused on would be a security guard. Being a security guard is something that challenges you to the extreme sometimes. This job isn’t something you can just pick up and want to do without thinking about how much you are risking your life for the sack of others....   [tags: Security guard, Security, Surveillance]

Research Papers
1019 words (2.9 pages)

President George W. Bush Essay

- Enter the 43rd President of the George W. Bush, the son of 41st president George H. Bush. Now this name here will absolutely be looked at in the past regarding his legacy. Other than Barack Obama, this is easily the most notorious talked about president of my generation. It was the election of the year 2000, which was also my first year of voting, that W. as he if affectionately called beat out Al Gore in a controversial presidential election which saw Gore win the popular vote, but Bush win the Electoral College vote after a divisive situation in the state of Florida....   [tags: George W. Bush, President of the United States]

Research Papers
1146 words (3.3 pages)

The Bombing Of George W. Bush Essay

- 9/11 was one of Osama’s biggest and most deadly attacks that he was able to carry out on American ground. Millions of people and family had to watch and see their family members die from this disaster. Having 9/11 happen which had also caused the U.S. into having to invade Afghanistan and Iraq to dismantle or stop any production of mass weapons. Doing this has our troops in high danger of not coming back due to being blown up or shot. After this terrorist attack airports had begun to higher the security checks and have the captain cockpit secured, while also having an officer on the planes as well....   [tags: Al-Qaeda, Osama bin Laden, George W. Bush]

Research Papers
1458 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Like Father, Like Son: A Deeper Look into the Bush Legacy

- Like Father, Like Son: A Deeper Look into the Bush Legacy Although all individuals are unique no matter how closely related they might be, sometimes, their similarities over shadow their differences and yield a very interesting combination of events that almost have a deja vu effect on its audience. The Bush family serves as the perfect illustration for this phenomenon. From their family history and business life, to their lives as the Presidents of the United States of America, George Herbert Walker Bush and George Walker Bush have led quite parallel lives....   [tags: George Bush Son Father Contrast Essays]

Research Papers
3230 words (9.2 pages)

Bush's Agenda Essay

- This analytical article is simply giving a list of the new agenda the re-elected president has. The war on terrorism, Iraq, Social Security, Tax code, medical malpractice, and guest worker program are the highlights. His inaugural speech was filled with ideas of “freedom” and “liberty”. Bush sets out on 2nd term with ambitious plans President Bush today set forth on an ambitious second-term agenda of reshaping Social Security and sparking democracy in the Middle East after wrapping up his inaugural today with moments of prayer and reflection....   [tags: US President's responsibilities]

Free Essays
823 words (2.4 pages)

Related Searches

1, 1972. Another example of conflicting reports was discovered by The Dallas Morning News. The memo reported that the officer Staudt, the man named in a previous memo as exerting pressure to "sugar coat" Mr. Bush's record had left the Texas Air National Guard 1½ years before the memo was dated. The Dallas Morning News said it obtained an order showing that Walter B. Staudt, former commander of the Texas Guard, retired on March 1, 1972 so therefore could not have pressured Killian to promoting Bush, on the date given in the CBS document dated August 18, 1973. The L.A. Times reported that handwriting analyst; Marcel Matley hired by CBS did not vouch for any of the typography in the memos used by 60 Minutes.
     Following the testimony of Marion Carr Know the secretary of the late Lt. Col. Jerry Killian she confirmed she did not type the memos regarding President Bush’s failure to fulfill the responsibilities of the Air National Guard. Along with the testimony of Bill Burkett, a retired lieutenant colonel of the National Guard who supplied the documents admitted he deliberately misled CBS News and 60 Minutes by giving false account of the documents’ origin. Two weeks after the controversial 60 Minutes episode aired Dan Rather admitted the documents’ authentication can not be proven.     
     In addition to the false documents Senior White House Correspondent John Roberts added that there was not truth or evidence that President Bush received preferential treatment to enroll in the Texas Air National Guard. Roberts spoke out to say that this is the same recycled garbage by the Democrats used against Bush every time he runs for re-election.
     Media biases in the news have become an unwanted and unpopular aspect in broadcasting. News reporting shows carry an underlying slant in journalism in attempt to change to mood of the country. Republicans have spoken out about the liberal media in attempt to ratify change. In the United States, of the four major entertainment networks (Foxs, NBC, ABC and CBS) three are consider being liberal media outlets. The one company of the quartet to report on a conservative view is the Foxs network. Between Peter Jennings for ABC, Tom Brokaw for NBC, and Dan Rather for CBS of the three, Rather has gone through the most criticism for his bias liberal slant on the news.
      Dan Rather has become a lighting rod for strife with his colorful language to compliment his witty and sharp tongue. Over the years Rather has evolved in to a target for Republicans with his clashes against conservative politicians. In 1974 at the height of the Watergate scandal, Rather asked a question towards President Nixon at the National Association of Broadcasters convention. In his quick reply Nixon said “Are you running for anything?” Rather shot back, “No, Mr. President are you?” In 1988 Mr. Bush Sr. the Vice President under Reagan agreed to do an interview with Rather to discuss his aspirations to run for president. Vice President Bush became heated during the interview because Rather was asking questions about the Iran-contra scandal and not about his future goals to become president. Mr. Bush claimed he was tricked in to accepting to do the interview under false pretences. Dan Rather took a lot of heat from Republicans when he was spotted at a Democratic fundraiser in Texas supporting his daughter. As a key news figure for the country his lack of objectiveness in reporting news has been felt by the American people.
     Dan Rather addressed the charges of his liberal slant in the media and his feeling in reporting news saying he is not politically inclined, except that he loves to report on politics. An internet website has been created by the Media Research Center to voices its opinions of disproval about Rather’s role in the media on “ The website is devoted to exploit Dan Rather’s lack of neutrality in reporting news. Dan Rather’s remarkable resume’ as a professional journalist for the last 35 years has become tarnished in the final leg of his career.
     The mood of the American people voiced out in disgrace in the poor integrity of the media. In an editorial by The Detroit News on the CBS documents a reporter wrote: “When the media outlet hollers ‘gotcha!’ as CBS did with President Bush, it had better know exactly what it’s got or it will pay the price.” In another editorial from the Seattle Post-Intelligencer a reporter declared “It seems like poetic justice that the discredit has fallen on those who tried to discredit [President Bush and John Kerry on their military history.] Conservative activist Bill Bennett voiced his disapproval on his radio show, said that “bias isn’t the point. This is corruption. Corruption is when you don’t adhere to a basic fundamental standard.” CBS News, 60 Minutes and Dan Rather all took a big hit by the other media outlets questioning the credibility. This severe accident by the CBS trying to discredit a republican politician will reap heavy consequences to the network and other liberal news outlets. This story echoes a theme in the media of liberal biases trying to swing the mood of the country against conservatives.
Return to