Social and Spiritual Energy in Middlemarch

Social and Spiritual Energy in Middlemarch

Length: 2140 words (6.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Social and Spiritual Energy in Middlemarch  

I do not believe that it is sufficient to say that Middlemarch explores the ways in which social and spiritual energy can be frustrated; it would be more appropriate to say that Middlemarch explores the ways in which social and spiritual energies (ideals if you will) are completely destroyed and perverted. One need only look to Lydgate to see an example of idealism being destroyed by the environment in which it is found. At the start of the novel, we are introduced to the "young, poor and ambitious" and most of all idealistic Doctor Lydgate, who has great plans for the fever hospital in Middlemarch. Throughout the novel, however, we see his plans frustrated by the designs of others, though primarily the hypocritical desires of Nicholas Bulstrode. The second example of the idealism of the young being destroyed by the old is that of Dorothea. This can be seen by her continuing desire to "bear a larger part of the world's misery" or to learn Latin and Greek, both of which are continually thwarted by Casaubon, though this ends after his death, with her discovery of his selfish and suspicious nature, by way of the codicil.

The character who has their ambitions and ideals brought most obviously low is Lydgate. The earliest example is when he has to make the choice between Fairbrother and Tyke. Both of these characters are rather poor examples of the clergy (Fairbrother because of his gambling, and Tyke because of his rather lazy attitude). Our sympathies are clearly with Fairbrother for a number of reasons; he doesn't gamble because he wants to, but because the wage he receives from running his parish alone is too small to support him and the various members of his family that rely on him. Lydgate has to make the choice between some one he likes as a person (Fairbrother) and someone who he needs help from (Bulstrode). It is clear that Lydgate is very similar to Fairbrother in a number of ways; both are scientists, and both have great hopes for the future. It would therefore seem to be the case that Lydgate would automatically support Fairbrother. However, Bulstrode uses his money and his influence to ensure Tyke's success.

Bulstrode is another example of a character that has had his idealism and destroyed, though not by Middlemarch.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Social and Spiritual Energy in Middlemarch." 24 May 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Social Norms of Energy Sving Behaviors Essay

- Research Outline The Social Norms of Energy Saving Behavior and the UK Energy Market Introduction: Several studies have been carried out to investigate the power of social norms and how they could be used to activate energy conservation behavior. According to Dietz et al. (2009), behavioral interventions could reduce household direct emissions by 20%. However, some are quite skeptical of the sustainability of behavioral change achieved through social behavioral interventions rather than policy changes or more efficient technology production....   [tags: social research, United Kingdom, Energy Market]

Research Papers
2415 words (6.9 pages)

The Motifs of Furniture and Yoke in George Eliot's Middlemarch Essay

- The Motifs of Furniture and Yoke in George Eliot's Middlemarch "'You have not made my life pleasant to me of late'-'the hardships which our marriage has brought on me'-these words were stinging his imagination as a pain makes an exaggerated dream (667)." On the list of life's complexities, marriage, perhaps, reigns at the top. George Eliot's Middlemarch exhumes many of the complicated facets of marriage from a Victorian England milieu. Although the character spectrum in Middlemarch includes diversity in social class, the bulk of players are members of the aristocracy....   [tags: Eliot Middlemarch Essays]

Research Papers
1586 words (4.5 pages)

Middlemarch Essay

- Middlemarch, a Victorian novel written by George Elliot, depicts a realistic view of a conventional society in the eighteenth century. Middlemarch, the town in England where the setting of the novel takes place, embodies many provincial characters who are affected by the social world where they live and interact with each other. The novel focuses on many of the characters and their relationships as part of a whole in a human social web. Among the many characters, the main ones include: Dorothea Brooke, a beautiful, good, and caring young woman, but very naïve and idealistic; Edward Casaubon, a boring old scholar who marries Dorothea; Rosamond Vincy, a gorgeous young woman, but very egoistic...   [tags: Literary Analysis, Elliot]

Research Papers
2349 words (6.7 pages)

Middlemarch by George Eliot and Jude the Obscure by Thomas Hardy Essay

- Middlemarch by George Eliot and Jude the Obscure by Thomas Hardy The Victorian era brought about many changes throughout Great Britain. Man was searching for new avenues of enlightenment. The quest for knowledge and understanding became an acceptable practice throughout much of the scientific community. It was becoming accepted, and in many ways expected, for people to search for knowledge. Philosophy, the search for truth, was becoming a more intricate part of educating ones self; no longer were people holding on to old-fashioned ideas....   [tags: Middlemarch eliot Jude Hardy Essays]

Research Papers
1445 words (4.1 pages)

The Theme of Marriage in Middlemarch Essay

- The Theme of Marriage in Middlemarch     One of the central themes that runs through Middlemarch is that of marriage. Indeed, it has been argued that Middlemarch can be construed as a treatise in favor of divorce. I do not think that this is the case, although there are a number of obviously unsuitable marriages. If it had been Elliot's intention to write about such a controversial subject, I believe she would not have resorted to veiling it in a novel. She illustrates the different stages of relationships that her characters undergo, from courtship through to marriage: A fellow mortal with whose nature you are acquainted with solely through the brief entrances and exits of a few imag...   [tags: Eliot Middlemarch Essays]

Research Papers
2260 words (6.5 pages)

Marriage as Slavery in Middlemarch Essay

- Marriage as Slavery in Middlemarch One of George Eliot's challenges in Middlemarch is to depict a sexually desirous woman, Dorothea, within the confines of Victorian literary propriety. The critic, Abigail Rischin, identifies the moment that Dorothea's future husband, Ladislaw, and his painter-friend see her alongside an ancient, partially nude statue of the mythic heroine, Ariadne, in a museum in Rome as the key to Eliot's sexualization of this character. Ariadne is, in the sculpture, between her two lovers....   [tags: Eliot Middlemarch Essays]

Research Papers
2440 words (7 pages)

Use of the Epigraph in George Eliot's Middlemarch Essay

- Use of the Epigraph in George Eliot's Middlemarch The epigraph is an unusual, though not uncommon, form of citation. It is a part of the text yet distinct from it. White space and specialized formatting, such as italics, separate the epigraph from the main text, thereby challenging the reader to determine the relationship between the two. Unlike a typical quotation, which dwells in the midst of the text, illuminating one point in the argument, the epigraph's unique positioning prior to the body of the text highlights particular ideas, words, or images and thereby guides the reading of the entire argument....   [tags: Eliot Middlemarch Essays]

Research Papers
605 words (1.7 pages)

Your Spiritual Jouney Essays

- If you ask yourself the questions like Who am I, and what is the purpose of my life persistently, then it is an indication that time has come to head start your spiritual journey, and you have ripened enough emotionally and spiritually to partake this path. Whether you are going to make it till the end is not really important, the most significant point is your choice of treading this pathway. You may have to overcome many hurdles in this lane, but once the choice is made then there is no going back, and interestingly, you are not going to lose anything, it is a win -win situation both ways....   [tags: chakra, pathway, spiritual]

Research Papers
2509 words (7.2 pages)

Philosophy of Spiritual Gifts Essay examples

- The area of Spiritual gifts is one which holds great interest for me. The thought that the different areas of effectiveness and skills are from God is interesting. I grew up with the teaching that we had God given abilities but never equated these with "spiritual gifts". They were just skill that we had been born with. I felt that our genetics and social conditioning had as much to do with these "gifts" as the Holy spirit did. Since there are non-Christians who exhibit these same abilities and gifts and when I was not a Christian I still had the desire to encourage others (encouragement is my spiritual gift)....   [tags: Christian Spiritual Gifts]

Free Essays
1601 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on Middlemarch

- In her novel Middlemarch, George Eliot’s job is to compare different types of existence and their relevance to one another—where each character is faced with a struggle to resolve his/hers desires with the realities of life. In the novel, both the character of Dorothea Brooke and Dr. Lydgate share a similar form of imagination, where both create an image in their mind of the ideal marriage. Such images can be seen as illusions and it is through these illusions the characters must surrender to reality, as they must make an effort to understand the desires that sparked their imagination from the start, and must attempt to make peace with their existing situations....   [tags: Literary Analysis, George Eliot]

Research Papers
1557 words (4.4 pages)

Related Searches

He was once a great and trusted minister, but the lure of money from the pawn shop, and the possibility of inheriting all of Ladislaw's mother's money proved too great for him. He is no longer the honourable and trusted man, but something all together darker and more sinister:

There are many coarse hypocrites who consciously affect beliefs … for the sake of guilling the world, but Bulstrode was not one of them. He was simply a man whose desires had been stronger than his theoretic beliefs, and who gradually explained the gratification of his desires into satisfactory agreement with those beliefs.

He does not lie to others, but to himself; he continues to try and justify his desires, though puts them in such ways that they appear to be morally sound and justifiable. Indeed, Bulstrode could well represent the devil in this book. It would be unlikely for Eliot to create a devil surrounded by fire and brimstone, so she looks for a more contemporary image; Bulstrode is so obsessed with money, power and influence that he becomes the contemporary incarnation. Playing on his given name, Eliot refers to him as "old Nick" (519), which was a common allusion to the devil. It is therefore the case that Lydgate metaphorically and thematically sells his soul to the devil.

It can be said, therefore, that it is not, in Lydgate's case at least, solely Middlemarch that leads to the decline of ambition and idealism, but money. Indeed, both Lydgate and Dorothea are faced with people who wish to use money as a weapon, or an instrument of terror. In Lydgate's case, he has to support Bulstrode in order to guarantee support for his hospital. In Dorothea's case, Casaubon attempts to keep Dorothea and Ladislaw apart, through the stipulation found in his will that if she were to marry him, she would loose everything. This attempt at control, however, fails. Despite having been married to her for approximately two years, Casaubon does not realise that Dorothea is almost completely selfless in nature, and would like nothing better than to be poor. It is Lydgate's concern for material things that leads him into debt and dishonour. Eliot portrays Lydgate as being a materialist, both through his profession (Lydgate is a doctor and biologist, so cells and tissues are his stock and trade), and through his involvement with Rosamond. Had it not been the case that Dorothea had married Casaubon, I believe that Lydgate and Dorothea would have been well suited for each other. They would both have been young and idealistic, both wanting to help their fellows. However, it is a combination of the fact that Dorothea is already married, and that Lydgate is more concerned with outward appearances that he chooses Rosamond. He has turned away from the "Gift of the Gods" (Dorothea), and chosen the "Rose of the World" (Rosamond). This represents the choice between, as John Stuart Mill would have put it, higher and lower pleasures. The choice of Lydgate can almost be equated with the choice of Paris between Athena, Aphrodite and Hera. He chooses beauty over wisdom, choosing the pleasures of the flesh (Rosamond with her blue eyes, fair complexion and delicate neck) over the pleasures of the mind (Dorothea). Had Lydgate chosen Dorothea then there would have been no question of buying the most expensive clothes, furniture and cutlery, as Dorothea would have been more concerned with helping at the hospital than with material possessions. In this way, we can see that both Dorothea's desire to be useful, and Lydgate's desire to help are frustrated due to Lydgate's choice of wife. This is however impossible, as neither Lydgate nor Dorothea has much choice in who they marry: Dorothea sees Casaubon as the father she never had, and so feels attracted towards him, and it is only after finding out how mean and selfish he was that she seeks a husband rather than a father. Lydgate, because of his intense kindness, and his desire not to hurt anyone has no choice but to marry Rosamond, as he doesn't want to see her sad, and she has manoeuvred both herself and him in such a way that to reject her could only cause this.

Dorothea, the heroine of the novel, is another example of frustrated idealism. Throughout the novel, there are numerous references to her desire to help the poor, though this is more often than not frustrated by her surroundings. The first example is her designs for the cottages; they are dismissed by her sister as being a "fad", and by her uncle as being too expensive. It is only when Sir James Chettam attempts to woo her, and builds the cottages in an attempt to gain favour with her, that her designs are actually carried through. Her idealism is arguably destroyed through her association with Casaubon. She is often likened to the virgin Mary, or to Saint Theresa ("Her hand and wrist were so finely formed that she could wear sleeves not less bare of style than those in which the Blessed Virgin appeared to Italian painters" (Chapter 1), and the prelude). These characters are supposed to represent life and hope, meaning that Dorothea is characterised by these qualities. Indeed, she is so full of hope that she wishes for things that all others can see to be hopeless (The completion of "The Key To All Mythologies"). Her idealism, just as these characteristic qualities, are crushed through the association with Casaubon, who is characterised by death. To Mr Brooke, he is "buried in books" (447), to Sir James he seems a "mummy" who has "not a drop of red blood in him". The very thought that Dorothea has come to be engaged to him causes Celia to start to "grieve" (48). Everything about Casaubon issues from this basic metaphor. His appearance - a pallid complexion, deep eye sockets, iron-grey hair (16) - makes his head look like a skull. Indeed, his proposal to Dorothea - in which his affection is introduced in brackets - shows that he is emotionally dead. Eliot could not have been precise on such matters, but he may be sexually impotent, for Dorothea is found "sobbing bitterly" on her honeymoon in Rome, and it may not simply be his deficiencies as a scholar that account for her disappointment (190). It is not love that attracts Dorothea to the corpse-like Casaubon, rather her sense of duty; her desire to be like one of Milton's daughters. Dorothea, orphaned at a young age, would seem to long for a husband who can fill the role of the father she lost. Casaubon's age is no deterrence, indeed she would rather marry a teacher / father figure than a romantic person at the beginning of the novel. She learns, though, that this is a bad idea, and so finds herself attracted to Ladislaw. She is so possessed with the idea of contributing to the good of humanity through the assistance she can offer Casaubon, she does not even notice how patronising and self centred he is. Celia, however, in the same situation, has no illusions, and can see that Casaubon is entirely unsuitable, even if she expresses her objections to him in terms of his soup-eating technique. If Dorothea fails to see Casaubon for what he is, it is not due to circumstances (Her short-sightedness is a metaphor for her inability to perceive what everyone else can see clearly, in favour of the transcendent. Could the glasses she requires to correct her normal sight represent Celia, who is the lens through which she can see what others perceive as normal reality?), but due to her mind seeking to go beyond their earthly constraints. Celia seeks only to be happy, while Dorothea wishes to contribute something to the common good of humanity, hence her misguided desire to help Casaubon. When Casaubon proposes marriage, she sees herself not as a bride to be married to a groom, more the Saint Theresa of the prelude preparing to take her holy vows as a nun - as a "neophyte" on the verge of a "higher initiation" (43). She presumably sees Casaubon as the "lamp" to light her darkness (84), but fails to notice that he lives at Lowick (Low wick).

The possession of knowledge, and the use of that knowledge is highly praised by Elliot. She makes a distinction between the dead and irrelevant knowledge of Casaubon, and the very much living and useful knowledge that Lydgate, Fairbrother and Mrs Garth posses. The knowledge that these three characters display is a reflection of Elliot herself; she could speak with authority on history, music, art, theology, anthropology, philosophy, sociology, psychology, mathematics, physics, geology, chemistry, astronomy, entomology and biology. It was Elliot's desire to better her mind and extend her knowledge that brought her to this knowledge, so she treats characters who seek to do the same in a favourable light.

There is one family that would seem to be the moral standard and centre of the novel - the Garth family. Mrs Garth is introduced to us teaching Latin to the children while cooking dinner. This is portrayed as being a very worthwhile activity, and is contrasted with the somewhat silly parenting attitude of both Celia and the Vincy's. Mary Garth's insistence that Fred find a worthy profession before she will marry him is also held in high esteem - she is putting the good of others above her own desires. The only trouble that the Garth family goes through is a result of their virtue rather than their vice; Caleb, out of kindness and of love, backs Fred, and so when the creditors want their money, the future of one of the Garth children is put in jeopardy.

To conclude; all the major characters, in some form or another have their ambitions and ideals crushed and perverted due to a number of reasons, ranging from the situation in which they find themselves, to the people with which they associate. In all her characters, Eliot, it would seem, shows that this destruction will lead to something better, though unfortunately not Lydgate - he cannot overcome his problems, and is in the end destroyed by them. It is almost as if she is writing a tragedy, in which the heroes and heroines undergo some horrendous cataclysm, and emerge from it, though scarred. It is as if the novel starts in moral twilight, and goes through the deepest night, and emerges into the sunlight of a new, though worse day.

Return to