A Psychoanalytic Reading of Hedda Gabler

A Psychoanalytic Reading of Hedda Gabler

Length: 786 words (2.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓


A Psychoanalytic Reading of Hedda Gabler  

Attempting a psychoanalytic reading of a given text is a bit like attempting to understand a city by examining its sewer system: helpful, yet limited.

There are several reasons for using psychoanalysis as a critical literary theory; the critic might be interested in gleaning some sort of subconscious authorial intent, approaching the text as a "cathartic documentation" (my own term) of the author's psyche; the method might be useful in judging whether characters are well-rendered, whether they are truly three-dimensional and, therefore, worth our while as readers (thus satisfying the pleasure principle); finally, in a larger sense, the psychoanalytic approach can be employed to actually tell us something about our own humanity, by examining the relative continuity (or lack thereof) of basic Freudian theories exemplified in written works over the course of centuries.

If we are indeed scouring the text for what I call "cathartic documentation," we must, at the outset, look at the period in which the work was written. Pre-Freudian works, that is to say those poems, plays, short stories, and novels written before the late 19th century, are the major candidates for success with this approach. However, 20th century works, beginning with the modernist authors, pose a problem. How are we to be sure that the writer is not consciously playing with Freud's theories, perhaps even deliberately expanding and distorting them for additional effect? Herein lies the problem with Hedda Gabler: The play was written at roughly the same time that Freud was just beginning to publish his theories. The question is "who influenced whom?" Obviously Freud was taken with Ibsen's realizations of certain fundamental ideas which were to be the foundation of his (Freud's) work: repression, neurosis, paranoia, Oedipal complex, phallic symbols, and so on; all of these factors are present in Hedda Gabler. The question remains, however, whether Ibsen had caught wind of Freud's work and decided to utilize it in the play. Perhaps I am wrong, but having read A Doll's House and An Enemy of the People, both earlier works by some ten years, Hedda Gabler seems to embody Freudian concepts to so much farther an extent that the possibility of a conscious effort to create Freudian neurotic types and set them loose on one another does not seem altogether outside the realm of possibility.

Whether consciously or unconsciously, however, Ibsen has created extremely well-developed characters.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"A Psychoanalytic Reading of Hedda Gabler." 123HelpMe.com. 21 Feb 2020
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=7717>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Hedda Gabler By Henrik Ibsen Essay

- ‘Hedda Gabler’ is a play written by Norwegian writer Henrik Isben. Ibsen was born on March the 20th 1828 in Norway to a merchant father and a painter mother. After working as a pharmacist and then rejecting the idea of studying in University, Ibsen turned to writing. His first few pieces did not do too well, but a lot of his later plays were a huge success, in particular ‘A Doll’s House’ (1879) and of course, ‘Hedda Gabler’ (1890). Hedda Gabler is the story about a woman named Hedda who is ultimately trapped in a loveless and meaningful marriage....   [tags: Hedda Gabler, Henrik Ibsen, Woman, KILL]

Research Papers
2078 words (5.9 pages)

Hedda Gabler : A Unique And Extraordinary Person Essay

- The character of Hedda Gabler in Ibsen’s play is a unique and extraordinary person. There has been a lot of public dislike towards her and seen as a very manipulative, cold and even masculine portrayal of a woman. As stated by Jones “has imagination, and an intense appetite for beauty, she has no conscience, no conviction: with plenty of cleverness, energy, and personal fascination she remains mean, envious, insolent, cruel in protest against others ' happiness, fiendish in her dislike of inartistic people and things, a bully in reaction from her own cowardice." (2)....   [tags: Hedda Gabler, Henrik Ibsen, Psychoanalysis, Woman]

Research Papers
1815 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on Ibsen's Hedda Gabler

- Ibsen’s Hedda Gabler portrays the societal roles of gender and sex through Hedda as a character trying to break the status quo of gender relations within the Victorian era. The social conditions and principles that Ibsen presents in Hedda Gabler are of crucial importance as they “constitute the molding and tempering forces which dictate the behavior of all the play's characters” with each character part of a “tightly woven social fabric” (Kildahl). Hedda is an example of perverted femininity in a depraved society intent on sacrificing to its own self-interest and the freedom and individual expression of its members....   [tags: Hedda Gabler]

Research Papers
1925 words (5.5 pages)

Hedda Gabler By Henrik Ibsen Essay

- Life is unpredictable and we are the one who make it. It is up to us if we want to have a good or bad life or just chose to end it. Hedda Gabler is a naturalism type of dramatic writing, written by Henrik Ibsen who narrates Hedda Gabler as a scandalous, coward, egotistical and a deceiving character who wants to have freedom to do something and achieve it. However, all the things that she wants to happened always failed. Starting from having an unwanted marriage with George out of sympathy; disappointment of failing her aspiration of seeing a vine leaves on Lovborg’s head; disappointment of not witnessing braveness from Lovborg’s death; black mail from judge Brack regarding to her scandal tha...   [tags: Suicide, Suicide methods, Hedda Gabler]

Research Papers
2105 words (6 pages)

Hedda Gabler By Henrik Ibsen Essay

- During the 1890s, females were expected to accept the idea that men had more power in society (Spacks 155-156). Hedda Gabler is an example of a female character who deliberately refutes this idea, and does this in an unconventional way. Instead of attempting to gain power within society through politics or academic achievement, Hedda’s lust for power is satisfied by exerting control over the people around her. Tessman, Hedda’s husband, is defenseless to Hedda’s control throughout the play, however Hedda finds little enjoyment in controlling him (Spacks 157)....   [tags: Hedda Gabler, Henrik Ibsen, Control]

Research Papers
1179 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on Hedda Gabler By Henrik Ibsen

- Hedda Gabler, the main character in Henrik Ibsen’s 1891 play titled Hedda Gabler, presents a unique role that many aspiring young actresses have been drawn to for decades. She was a woman before her time, her repellent personality can be argued as evil incarnated or simply due to a misunderstood and misplaced life. Regardless of the motives, it is no doubt that Hedda’s actions throughout the play are fascinatingly malevolent. This seemingly unmerciless character can be portrayed on the screen or stage in many styles because of her mysterious nature (Isherwood)....   [tags: Hedda Gabler, Henrik Ibsen, Andreas Wilson]

Research Papers
2041 words (5.8 pages)

The Character of Hedda Gabler in Ibsen's Hedda Gabler Essay

- The Character of  Hedda Gabler       Hedda Gabler is perhaps one of the most interesting characters in Ibsen.  She has been the object of psychological analysis since her creation.  She is an interesting case indeed, for to "explain" Hedda one must rely on the hints Ibsen gives us from her past and the lines of dialogue that reveal the type of person she is.  The reader never views Hedda directly.  We never get a soliloquy in which she bares her heart and motives to the audience.  Hedda is as indifferent to our analysis as she is to Tesman's excitement over his slippers when she says "I really don't care about it" (Ibsen  8).  But a good psychologist knows that even this indifference is t...   [tags: Hedda Gabler Essays]

Research Papers
1400 words (4 pages)

Themes in Hedda Gabler Essay

- Hedda Gabler According to John T. Shipley, Hedda Gabler "…presents no social theme" (333). He asserts this argument with evidence that the themes that are presented in the play are of no importance with relevance to the time period it was written. Although John R. Shipley might have a prevalent argument, the social topics that are presented in Hedda Gabler are timeless and are present even in today’s world as they were long before the time of Hedda Gabler. Therefore, Mr. John T. Shipley is mistaken when stating that there is a lack of social themes in Hedda Gabler because issues such as “bourgeoisie” versus aristocracy, social class, public image, scandal, and gender sexuality flood the ent...   [tags: Hedda Gabler]

Research Papers
1650 words (4.7 pages)

Social Issues in Hedda Gabler Essay

- Social Issues in Hedda Gabler It has been suggested that Hedda Gabler is a drama about the individual psyche -- a mere character study. It has even been written that Hedda Gabler "presents no social theme" (Shipley 333). On the contrary, I have found social issues and themes abundant in this work. The character of Hedda Gabler centers around society and social issues. Her high social rank is indicated from the beginning, as Miss Tesman says of Hedda, "General Gabler's daughter. What a life she had in the general's day!" (Ibsen 672)....   [tags: Hedda Gabler Essays]

Research Papers
1613 words (4.6 pages)

Oppression in Ibsen's Hedda Gabler Essay

- Oppression in Ibsen's Hedda Gabler One of the social issues dealt with in Ibsen's problem plays is the oppression of women by conventions limiting them to a domestic life. In Hedda Gabler the heroine struggles to satisfy her ambitious and independent intellect within the narrow role society allows her. Unable to be creative in the way she desires, Hedda's passions become destructive both to others and herself. Raised by a general (Ibsen 1444), Hedda has the character of a leader and is wholly unsuited to the role of "suburban housewife" (1461)....   [tags: Hedda Gabler Essays]

Research Papers
832 words (2.4 pages)

Related Searches

Psychoanalytic criticism shows us this fact more clearly than we might "consciously" have recognized from a mere casual reading or viewing of Hedda Gabler. By applying Freudian theories to the characters, we discover that they are manifesting pre-defined behavior patterns that we can go on to compare to our own, thus establishing a connection between fiction and reality. The more a reader or an audience can relate to, or at the very least recognize, a given character via familiar neuroses, the more impact, the more "meaning" that character provides. In this way, psychoanalysis is a positive boon, both for writer and reader.

In my opinion, the most important feature of psychoanalytical criticism is what it does for us when we expand its theories. Freud himself was ultimately concerned with applying the same approaches used in relation to the individual to the society as a whole. This aim can be taken up in literary criticism by utilizing Freudian and post-Freudian psychology to look at literature over the course of history, as well as applying it to various world societies. Admittedly, Freud's theories are specialized and limited, pertaining mainly to western, patriarchal, industrialized societies, and clearly there will be instances in which, due to differing cultural norms, they simply don't work. Yet this, too, is beneficial. The chief aim of the scientific method is to, as it were, disprove itself; that is to say, to question continually the validity of a given scientific approach until every hole is found and mended, every inconsistency recognized and accounted for. So even when psychoanalysis fails, it still teaches us something. Any theory that succeeds in shedding some light, even when it fails, is worthy of consideration as far as I am concerned.

Therefore, in summing up, it should be stated that psychoanalysis, although it has its problems, has much to recommend it as a mode of literary criticism. While it may be at times vague, limited, untestable, and not applicable in all situations, yet it provides insight into the mind of the author, can contribute to the fleshing-out of characters, and can point to larger societal issues. The use of psychoanalysis in moderation, avoiding rigorous dogmatism, is an effective method of finding meaning, deep, dark, subconscious, perhaps neurotic meaning, in the pages of what we call sublimated mother-lust...er...that is, literature.

 

 
Return to 123HelpMe.com