• Length: 1197 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

2.4 There can be differences between the knowledge people access through school and that they feel to be really useful. Interview two members of your family about their views of school knowledge and what they have found to be really useful for them. Drawing on the reading for this Unit, analyse these interviews and discuss how what factors might have impacted on their view of what constitutes really useful knowledge.

The concept of knowledge in any society is a fluid, ever-changing notion which has different connotations depending on time and place. Typically what is thought of as knowledge in any given society is greatly influenced by the demands of the work that society most commonly carries out. Today, for example, in Western twenty-first century society it is claimed that we are now living in a ‘post-industrial’ society or have ‘entered into an information age’ and as such what we define as knowledge has altered in as little time as three decades.
Knowledge can be gained independently at one’s own free-will or from life experiences but it is via school that nearly all of British people gain the foundations of their own personal knowledge. What makes education such an interesting subject for scholars is that it is governments who define what knowledge should be taught in schools and what knowledge is ‘useful’ despite what pupils themselves may think.
For the purpose of this essay I have interviewed two former students who both studied in state schools in Edinburgh albeit a generation apart. I wish to analyse what both these individuals thought constituted ‘useful’ and ‘useless’ knowledge taught during their schools lives and if the fact that one was at school in the 1960’s and the other attended school in the late 1990’s/early 21st century resulted in any differentiation in their opinions.

Knowledge at school can be taught in three ways; Academic knowledge, practical knowledge and radical knowledge. Each of these systems has their own unique method of delivering knowledge to the pupil and have varying degrees of ‘usefulness’.
Academic knowledge could also be known as the ‘traditional’ form of delivering information to school pupils. Proponents of such methods would claim that it is not the actual information which academic knowledge presents to the pupil, rather the methods in which this information is delivered that is beneficial. In this sense then it could be claimed that academic knowledge is merely knowledge for knowledge’s sake or ‘useless’.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"knowledge." 20 Jun 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
The Importance of Communities of Practice Linked to Knowledge Management Activities - After developing and testing a research model (See Figure 2-3), concerning the effects of KM activities supported by organisational and technological initiatives have on individual, team, and organisational levels. The results provide some potential valuable insights for theories and practice on knowledge management. First, the study provides empirical support to the argument inherent in social capital theory, the knowledge-based theory of the organisation, and the theory of knowledge management that the impacts of knowledge management move up from individuals to teams and then to the entire organisation....   [tags: Knowledge] 964 words
(2.8 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Essay on Knowledge Management Research - The findings of this research cleared conceptualization of KM activities and a guide to using social capital to support those activities within organisations. This study made significant contributions across multiple areas of knowledge management research. This section demonstrates the significance of this study through giving further details about the contributions that it makes to theory, transference, and practice. 9.2.1 Contribution to social capital theory For the first time, this research combines seventeen factors in an integrated model that includes social capital theory, information technology support, and knowledge work management and work performance....   [tags: Knowledge] 1055 words
(3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
The Pursuit of Knowledge Essay - Ever wonder how the world would be today only if our great researchers implemented a different attitude towards their experiments. It is possible that the results would remain same. However, some argue that the consequences may be altered. Nonetheless, this does not make the earlier learned knowledge valued less or false, just supplementary. Abraham Maslow’s theory challenges nearly all ways of knowing, suggesting that if we limit our thinking, the outcomes remain homogenous, therefore, limiting the amount of knowledge we acquire....   [tags: Theory of Knowledge] 1040 words
(3 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Knowledge Sharing Essay - Knowledge sharing: Knowledge sharing occurs when an individual is genuinely interested to have or to give knowledge to someone then this process is successful and effective, if a person provided with wrong or vague knowledge that’s mean the knowledge sharing process is stuck over there. Goh (2002) proposes that knowledge sharers should always share the full circumstances of a case, not selected circumstances. Bornemann and Sammer (2003) say: Knowledge as a resource of value creation, allows for exceptional marginal rates of productivity....   [tags: Knowledge ] 875 words
(2.5 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Essay about Knowledge Management - One of the primary reasons for the heightened interest in knowledge management is owing to the advances in information and communication technologies. But why have these technologies created such interest in how people can manage knowledge. Grover and Davenport (2001) highlight that the computing technology evolves in business to the point where it generates interest in managing knowledge. It starts by enabling processes at the level of transactions at the point of work. These systems were collecting amount of data which need to be processed to make sense out of it, and hence, the advent of data processing systems....   [tags: Knowledge] 745 words
(2.1 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Knowledge Management in Academic Libraries Essay - Introduction Knowledge has become a key resource in the present information and knowledge era. Knowledge management is a concept that has emerged explosively in business organizations during the 20th century. The application of knowledge management has now spread to other organizations as well including academic libraries. Knowledge management has been regarded as strategically important for organizations to gain a competitive advantage over their competitors, to add value to their products and to win greater satisfaction from their customers....   [tags: Knowledge Management ]
:: 5 Works Cited
1930 words
(5.5 pages)
Term Papers [preview]
Essay on Knowledge and Technology - Digital technology has opened new horizons for the human art of thinking and creating knowledge. However, there are risks for humanity in terms of access and human development. Universal sharing and access of knowledge is facilitated by the use of digital technology. For example, the content of rare and unique books and manuscripts such as those held in The Library of Congress, Washington D.C. are now uploaded to the internet (The Library of Congress, Washington D.C. n.d.). This knowledge no longer restricted to those able to visit the library nor in the case of rarer literature only available to curators, academics and others within the ranks of the privileged few....   [tags: Digital Technology, Human Thinking, Knowledge]
:: 13 Works Cited
1364 words
(3.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Managing Codified Knowledge Essay - Managing Codified Knowledge – A Review Knowledge has long been considered an intangible asset that can only be passed on from a teacher to his pupils through years of teaching and knowledge transfer. However, present day technological advancements and the increasingly dynamic nature of knowledge have led to the dissolution of the “sacred” teacher-pupil affiliation. Knowledge, now, is more of an entity that can be codified, stored, mined and retrieved as and when required, by any one and anywhere around the world....   [tags: Organizational Knowledge] 1759 words
(5 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
The Chemistry of Knowledge Essay - The Chemistry of Knowledge Hippeas thought he had all the answers. “I have never found any man who was my superior in anything,” he boasted. Then he meets Socrates. Though he had made thousands of public speeches about virtue, a dialogue with the wisest of Athenians leads Hippeas to confess that he “cannot even say what [virtue] is” (Hippeas 70). Lesser Hippeas discredits Hippeas but offers little more than a negative definition of knowledge. Meno, Phaedo, and the Republic provide a more comprehensive discussion of the definition, the good and the teaching of knowledge....   [tags: Philosophy Knowledge Knowing Plato Essays]
:: 2 Works Cited
1891 words
(5.4 pages)
Term Papers [preview]
The Synthesis of Knowledge Essay - The Synthesis of Knowledge "Society values mental labor more highly than manual labor." This is a claim that Ruth Hubbard makes in her essay "Science, Facts, and Feminism." This claim suggests that those who are the thinkers, the innovators, the inventors, and the great minds are highly valued by society; however, those who are the doers, the laborers, the hand-crafters, and the workers are not valued as greatly. Hubbard implies that society regards mental labor as more important than manual labor because it requires more specifically human qualities....   [tags: Mind Mental Knowing Knowledge Essays] 1059 words
(3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]

Related Searches

There is no doubt, though, that academic knowledge does provide the pupil with analytical, critical and methodical skills that may prove to be useful in later life in certain occupations. Critics would claim that the only people that would find such knowledge useful in later life would be those whom are in the ruling classes or positions of power. That is, the purpose of delivering academic knowledge to pupils is to stream children into groups according to ‘ability’ in the skills which the ruling classes deem to be most important. This results in future ruling classes retaining the status quo of academic knowledge being taught in mainstream education as those at the top believe meritocracy has took them to their position of power and not the bias of the countries education system.

Practical knowledge is a denunciation of academic knowledge. It is the teaching of ‘useful’ knowledge in the school. For example, instead of teaching Pythagoras’ Theorem in Mathematics pupils would learn about mortgages, tax or credit card repayments, as these are practical pieces of knowledge that can be used in later life.
Further Educational institutions such as colleges are a good example of practical knowledge in action. Colleges offer diplomas in professions as varied as plumbing, hairdressing, dentistry and social care. Typically a week will involve practical activities, vocational work and academic learning offering a varied range of knowledge.
This knowledge is sometimes known as ‘merely useful’ but as with academic knowledge it still has its critics. Primarily the most obvious criticism would be - who is actually benefiting from such a system? Employers in such aforementioned industries as the ones mentioned above who currently require formal training before starting employment would obviously benefit but there are other sectors of industry in which it is not entirely necessary or feasible to offer practical knowledge at all.

Academic knowledge, according to those who advocate radical knowledge, is merely a tool used to maintain the status and power of those people who currently hold positions of status and power. Radical knowledge is a quasi-Marxist concept that politicises education to the extreme. Advocates of this concept of knowledge wish to enlighten pupils about subjects such as social injustice, equality and the impact of power in society.
The major concern about a curriculum based on radical knowledge would be the fear of propaganda in the classroom. Teachers of an extreme right or left wing persuasion can manipulate this system to fill the heads of their pupils with extremist beliefs and concepts. Furthermore, this system calls for the overthrowing of the ruling hierarchy but fails to offer any explanations or suggestions as to what this system should be replaced with.

These three concepts of knowledge illustrate the diverse views that exist concerning what actually constitutes ‘really useful knowledge’.

To gauge the opinion of former pupils as to what they believed ‘really useful’ knowledge was and what ‘really useful’ knowledge they learnt at school, if any. I achieved this by conducting a qualitive, semi-structured interview with two members of my family, a female who attended St Augustine’s a Catholic faith school in Edinburgh from 1965-69 and a male who attended Leith Academy a multi-faith school in Edinburgh from 1997-2002. To respect their anonymous I’ll refer to the interviewees as ‘F’ and ‘M’ respectively.

'F' attended school in the era when pupils spoke only when spoken too and teaching was extremely formal. She claims that ‘Teachers saw us as empty vessels. It was like [The Teachers] thought we were blank slates that had to be filled in with their knowledge.’
When asked if she thought that the subjects that she was taught gave her ‘really useful knowledge’ which she has took with her into later life she responded with an unequivocal ‘Definitely’. When prompted why she replied ‘Well I done Latin at school. You might think that is useless and not helped me in life but it definitely has – it helps you with the roots of English language so if a word comes up today I don’t understand, I’ll break it down and work out its meaning…Also maths and science theory has been really helpful even though at the time I thought it was useless. It has trained me to study things I don’t like, and in real life you have to do this all the time.’ I found the last sentence particularly interesting as it may actually give credence to the radical knowledge approach. Apparently here is an adult saying that school taught her to do things she did not like doing and without any complaint. A critical commentator may suggest that this was her being socialised into accepting a career in which she will be devoid of power and teaching her not to complain about this fact.

Return to