Length: 990 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
the native american indians are very spiritula people. They hunt bison and buffalo In Indian Blood II, I incorrectly stated that Allan W. Eckert started "the Blue Jacket War."  He did not.  It seems clear now that Robert Van Trees did.  In fact, to call it a war is to mischaracterize this mindless tirade by Van Trees and some of his ardent supporters over a simple academic question:  Was Blue Jacket white?

     Blue Jacket was a Shawnee chief and it is not really important whether he was adopted or native--any more than it makes a difference whether one of his wives was white, which Van Trees does not dispute.  According to the information on Carlyle Hinshaw's website, Hinshaw called for a "crusade," using his word, to protest and suppress the republication of Eckert's The Frontiersmen. Thereafter, Eckert's publisher was bombarded with letters and phone calls from the dozen or so people involved.  Letters were sent and some were posted on the site. Several people wrote Allan Eckert directly.

     When asked for comment, Eckert said that some of the letters he received in this "crusade" were actually hate mail, personally attacking him and calling him names. Pointless harassment.  I should point out that none of the responsible Shawnee scholars--neither Randy Noe nor John Sugden--would join in this disgraceful display of lynch-mob mentality.

     I was given Hinshaw's web address by another Shawnee researcher.  Hinshaw's website  at first favorably impressed me, but after I came upon a page of protests led by Van Trees‘s article entitled "Bluejacket and Swearingen Families Declare War on Eckert," I was taken aback. "Declare War," he says, in such strong language that makes you think of terroristic attacks, some kind of crazy holy war for, in his words, our "honored dead."  This strikes me as unfair and bizarrely un-American, like shouting down the opposition.

    This is, after all, a simple and rather silly academic issue. If someone--Rev. Jesse Jackson, say--should write a book claiming that Blue Jacket was actually black and that historians had been wrong in their account of him all these years, would there be a similar protest?  I hardly think so.  Why not just write your own book and let the other fellow write his?

    When I asked Mr. Van Trees about this, he said that the tirade against Eckert was justified and by US Mail he sent copies of the rabid hate mail that Robert Denton Bluejacket and others had sent to Eckert--as if that explained everything.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"indians." 15 Aug 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Ten Little Indians (And Then There Were None) by Agatha Christie

- Ten Little Indians, published as And Then There Were None when it débuted in America brought a wonderful sense of mystery into the life of the American. Written by Agatha Christie, it was published in 1939 as a fiction murder mystery. The story is set on the coast of Devon, England during the thirties. Ten Little Indians is a classic murder mystery, which involves ten unsuspecting average people. While it seems that one of these people would be the main character, everyone is equally important in shaping the story....   [tags: Ten Little Indians]

Research Papers
688 words (2 pages)

Navajo Indians See the Importance of Supporting their Families and Communities

- The Navajo nation is the largest U.S Indian tribe. It has more than 250,000 people. They are located in Northern New Mexico, a portion of southern Utah, and part of northern Arizona. They first descended from the Apaches, who came from the Pueblos. Their native language is Athapaskan. “Navajo” came from the word navahu’u meaning “farm fields in the valley.” The Spanish chroniclers first referred to the Navajos as Apaches de Nabajo’ meaning Apaches who farm in the valley. Then the name was eventually shortened to the Navajo....   [tags: Native Americans, American Indians,]

Research Papers
609 words (1.7 pages)

The Saga of the Tigua Indians Essay

- The Saga of the Tigua Indians The Saga of the Tigua Indians is an amazing one. By all reasoning they should have been wiped out long ago. There quiet defiance to change, however, has carried them through. From the height of civilization to near extinction the Tigua have remained. They endure imprisonment by the Spanish, oppression and manipulation by everyone that followed. This is the story of a people thought to extinct, that are once again learning to survive. Early histories of the Tigua Indians are conflicting and largely untrue....   [tags: Tigua Indians Native Americans Essays]

Research Papers
5041 words (14.4 pages)

Location and Description of the Algonkian Indians Essay

- Location and Description of the Algonkian Indians - Algonkian lived in Quebec and Ontario; starting from the Ottawa valley, beneath Hudson Bay and above lower Ontario - the areas in which they lived in were dense woodlands with trees, such as, birch and evergreen; and snow covered the land most of the year. Adaptation to the physical Environment Home - Algonkian homes were called Wigwam, there frames were built out of saplings of tall, young tree trunks which were tied together with narrow strips of bark or root fibers, to form a dome shape - the frame was covered with woven mats or barks, then was firmly tied to the frames - light birch bark were used as covers in the summer and heavy e...   [tags: Algonkians Indians Native Americans Essays]

Research Papers
1219 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about Yanomamo Indians

- This paper looks on Yanomamo Indians traits and describes their actual way of life; the basic question that might be asked will be answered: who they are, where do they live, how do they gather food to survive and what are their skills in this domain; also how these Indians are organized politically and how are the social relations among the families and between neighboring tribes. Then, how the devastation of the scientists and journalists have changed the Yanomamo Indians way of life in the current and past century, and if they kept the same aspects of their current religion of they ancestors even thought modern world have reached them....   [tags: Yanomamo Indians Culture]

Research Papers
883 words (2.5 pages)

Review For The Woodlands Indians In The Western Great Lakes Essay

- The Woodlands Indians in the Western Great Lakes. Robert E. Ritzenthaler and Pat Ritzenthaler. Prosper Heights, IL: Waveland Press, Inc. 1993. 154 pp. In each of the ten chapters that comprise this book, the authors address important features of the Woodlands Indians’ way of life that ensure their survival. They address such important issues as how they are able to find enough food to subsist and what exactly they do eat to subsist; as well as going into topics such as their religious beliefs, traditional ceremonies, their beliefs regarding shamanism and curative techniques, their material culture, games, music, and folklore that is important to them and influences who they are as a people....   [tags: Indians Book Review]

Free Essays
1520 words (4.3 pages)

Cherokee Indians Essay examples

- Cherokee Indians The Cherokee Indians were one of the civilized tribes in the United States. They were located in the southeastern part of the U.S. This includes the western parts of North and South Carolina, The northern parts of Alabama and Georgia, Southwest Virginia and the Cumberland basin of Tennessee. It appears the Cherokee settled in 1000 A.D. to 1500 A.D. Their development took place in two stages or phases. The Pisgah which took place 1300 A.D. to 1540 A.D. and the Qualla which took place 1540 A.D....   [tags: History Indians Native Americans Essays]

Research Papers
2181 words (6.2 pages)

Essay about indians

- “James Luna, A Native American Man,” is an insightful, cut the bullshit, view of the modern Indian culture. I identify with Luna’s viewpoints as I have seen many of the situations he describes with his art to be true to life. I have spent a lot of time in Northern Canada fishing with my brother and father. The areas we visit are predominantly Indian reservations. Having spent quite a bit of time getting to know these types of towns and people, I have grown aware of some of the many problems that surround the modern day reservation lifestyle....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
437 words (1.2 pages)

Essay about Indians

- Mohegans and Comanches Different or Similar Long ago, the Earth was formed atop the back of a giant turtle. From the earth the Great Spirit put life into all things: trees, plants, animals and people. An Indian was created named Gunche Mundo who developed a Mother Tribe, and divided it into three clans--Turtles, Turkeys and Wolves. The Wolf People, known as Mohegans, separated from the Turtles and Turkeys, and headed east toward the rising sun. While the Mohegans headed east to find land, a tribe called the Comanches headed south....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
642 words (1.8 pages)

Essay about indians

- the native american indians are very spiritula people. They hunt bison and buffalo In Indian Blood II, I incorrectly stated that Allan W. Eckert started "the Blue Jacket War."  He did not.  It seems clear now that Robert Van Trees did.  In fact, to call it a war is to mischaracterize this mindless tirade by Van Trees and some of his ardent supporters over a simple academic question:  Was Blue Jacket white.      Blue Jacket was a Shawnee chief and it is not really important whether he was adopted or native--any more than it makes a difference whether one of his wives was white, which Van Trees does not dispute....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
990 words (2.8 pages)

Related Searches

Richard L. Pangburn said:  This is now Hinshaw's "crusade," but you're the one who called the dogs on this, and hence the one responsible.  How can you associate with people who deal in hate mail, who infer that a book showing Blue Jacket to have been white is "racist?"  The story is certainly not racist, and that irresponsible charge is racist in itself. To charge that Eckert was racist is to charge that Chief Charles Bluejacket was racist, for he believed in this story wholeheartedly. Eckert heard it from Shawnees as well as Swearingen descendants. How can you associate with people who send hate mail and go around irresponsibly yelling racist?.

Robert Van Trees replied:  "I applaud Robert Denton Bluejacket and Gaylord Carlyle Hinshaw's efforts. . .I have no idea where you were from 1941 to 1946 but I, along with a lot of others, were pretty busy supporting the objectives of our country and do not appreciate anyone referring to my thoughts and actions as 'un-American."

Richard L. Pangburn said: There is no use trying to wrap yourself in the American flag and calling yourself righteous.  That is both insulting and irrelevant.  My father was in the landing on Iwo Jima.  I served four years during Viet Nam  Whatever else you have done, here you are Un-American:  You adhere to the same lynch-mob mentality of intolerant holier-than-thou fanatics everywhere.  

     Eckert's attitude was: "I don't see it that way; go write your books, plays, reviews, newspaper articles, etc., and I will write mine."  Review his books with venom.  Or write more of your own denouncing his views.  But don't send publishers and authors hate mail, harass their wives, or intimidate them with irresponsible charges of racism in order to suppress their books.

     As with the Taliban, just having your own freedom of expression is not enough--you want to stamp out all opposing views too, to stop all plays and books that do not conform to your holier-than-thou brand of political correctness---your own flawed opinions.

      In America, we live and let live.  In America, we still have freedom of speech--you can write your own version of history, and you even have the right not to conform to consensus.  History is arguable, and no one family nor cult owns it---it belongs to us all.  The Van Trees/Hinshaw fanatical war to shout down any other account of your vainglorious historical obsession is at the expense of your own character.

     The DNA evidence is hardly conclusive, and you know it.  I still have your E-mails on this matter, as when I asked for your own research on the Blue Jacket lineage--and I have your replies.  You also know that John Sugden left out some of the primary evidence in his biography of Blue Jacket, as he has admitted to me, and when everything is looked at by someone without an alternate agenda, a picture of different Shawees named Blue Jacket emerges.  The self-righteousness of this crusade is not only blind to freedom of speech, it is basing its historical argument upon highly subjective premises.    

     This haggling over an academic argument is merely silly, but the suppression of freedom of speech is a serious matter.  I hope Eckert sues for damages.  For whatever the final estimate of the historical data, Allan Eckert's freedom of expression in the present is not trumped by your own self-righteous version of the past.  A crusade that advances by intimidating publishers and bombarding them with letters and phone calls in order to stamp out opposing views is un-American and I'm saying so.
Return to