Genetic Engineering and Genetic Cloning

Genetic Engineering and Genetic Cloning

Length: 2185 words (6.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
A controversial issue is the possible application of new techniques in genetic engineering to produce human clones. Up until now genetic engineering and cloning has been used to clone plants, unicellular organisms, amphibians and simple mammals. This has led to significant advances in agriculture, industry, and medicine. Newer techniques in genetic engineering have enabled scientists to clone more complex mammals and opened up the possibility of cloning humans. Although there are many potential benefits to this technology, the prospect of cloning humans has raised many practical, ethical and religious dilemmas that are currently being debated by society. As of now, the actual cloning of humans does not seem likely to occur in the foreseeable future.
Genetic engineering is the changing of an organism’s DNA, genetic material to eliminate unwanted traits or to produce desirable traits. The earliest form of genetic engineering dates back to the scientist Gregor Mendel who did experiments with peas. He bred only the peas with the most desirable traits in order to achieve a healthier and stronger pea (McCuen 8). This method, called selective breeding, is still used today with plants and animals in order to increase food production. Corn plants are selectively bred in order to produce a larger tastier kernel. Another type of genetic engineering called hybridization or crossbreeding involves breeding animals of different species in order to obtain the most desirable traits of both. Male donkeys are crossbred with female horses to produce mules, which are good work animals (Levine 1).
In 1938, Hans Speman proposed cloning a mammal by transplanting an adult cell’s nucleus into a fertilized egg. This process is called nuclear transfer and was initially used to clone a frog in 1952 (Sinha 59). Using this process, nuclear DNA from the body cell of a donor frog was injected into the egg cell of a recipient frog whose nuclear genetic material was removed. The fused cells divided just like a normal fertilized egg and formed an embryo that was genetically identical to the donor frog. In 1980 mice were successfully cloned using a similar procedure. The nucleus of a body cell of an embryo removed from a pregnant mouse was placed into a fertilized egg of another mouse whose own nucleus was removed. The cell was grown in vitro until it divided and became an embryo. It was then implanted into another mouse and allowed to grow to term.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Genetic Engineering and Genetic Cloning." 24 Sep 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Genetic Engineering and Genetic Cloning

- A controversial issue is the possible application of new techniques in genetic engineering to produce human clones. Up until now genetic engineering and cloning has been used to clone plants, unicellular organisms, amphibians and simple mammals. This has led to significant advances in agriculture, industry, and medicine. Newer techniques in genetic engineering have enabled scientists to clone more complex mammals and opened up the possibility of cloning humans. Although there are many potential benefits to this technology, the prospect of cloning humans has raised many practical, ethical and religious dilemmas that are currently being debated by society....   [tags: Cloning Essays]

Free Essays
2185 words (6.2 pages)

Genetic Engineering and Cloning Essay

- Genetic Engineering and Cloning What are the principle, ethical issues and experimental procedures used in genetic engineering and cloning. Should Cloning be allowed to continue. In the 1970's, scientists discovered that strands of DNA could be cut using special enzymes, which could cut out genetic combinations. DNA contains information about genes particular organisms hold. Duplicates of genes are also possible through genetic engineering and are very useful for medical purposes. Advances in technology have raised issues such as animal and human cloning....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]

Free Essays
1368 words (3.9 pages)

Genetic Engineering and Cloning Essay

- Genetic Engineering and Cloning On February 24, 1997 news broke globally that Ian Wilmut of the Roslin Institute in Scotland had successfully cloned the genetic material of an adult sheep and had created the infant Dolly. The discovery instantly caught the world's attention because Dolly had only one parent; Dolly had been formed by transferring the genetic material of an adult female into one of its own embryos. This process, known as "somatic cell nuclear transfer", refers to removal of genetic material from an adult cell and then implantation of that material into an embryo that has had it's original genetic material removed....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
827 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Genetic Engineering: Cloning: Dolly and Eugenics

- Cloning is vital in American society because it will help us further our knowledge in genetics. Also cloning will make us realize how much scientists can actually accomplish knowing how to clone. Scientists were able to clone an animal in 1997. That accomplishment made all the scientist’s theories about cloning possible. It gave the scientists hope that one day they will maybe be able to clone a human because they were able to clone a mammal. Eugenics is also vital to American society. Eugenics is the practice of improving human’s genetic quality of the human population as a whole....   [tags: dna, science, god]

Research Papers
1691 words (4.8 pages)

Ethics of Human Cloning and Genetic Engineering Essay

- INTRODUCTION When the Roslin Institute's first sheep cloning work was announced in March 1996 the papers were full of speculation about its long-term implications. Because of this discovery, the media’s attention has focused mainly on discussion of the possibility, of cloning humans. In doing so, it has missed the much more immediate impact of this work on how we use animals. It's not certain this would really lead to flocks of cloned lambs in the fields of rural America, or clinically reproducible cuts of meat on the supermarket shelves....   [tags: Genetic Engineering Essays]

Research Papers
1845 words (5.3 pages)

Essay on The Reality of Human Cloning

- The Reality of Human Cloning As aptly put by Rosa Beddington, the word “clone” has become one of the most emotive of all the terms coined by scientists which have entered popular vocabulary. I shall add another, and that will be the phrase “Dolly the sheep”. The conception of Dolly, the “baby” of scientist Ian Wilmut and his team has opened the possibility of cloning humans. The mention of Dolly brings to average the person, haunting connotations of “future replicas of living megalomaniacs and the resurrected dead”....   [tags: Genetic Engineering Cloning Essays]

Research Papers
671 words (1.9 pages)

Informative Essay: Cloning and Genetic Engineering

-    Unlike so many issues, much of the debate about cloning and genetic engineering is about acts that have never been committed. They are unique in the fact that we have never before had the technology to perform these acts. We do not know the consequences of cloning a human being. We do not know the damage we can do by altering someone's genes. We do not know what disease we can cure. We do not know the limits of the evil we can unleash. Since we have not reached the full potential of the power we wield, we can only speculate on the outcomes of our actions....   [tags: Informative Essay]

Research Papers
1395 words (4 pages)

We Must Educate Ourselves Before Passing Laws Restricting Cloning and Genetic Engineering

-      Biotechnology and genetic engineering involve the cloning of animal cells and organisms, but they also involve the alteration of an organism in an effort to make it more perfect, whether it is a crop, an animal, or even a human being. Obviously the cloning of humans or the cloning of human cells is much different than the cloning of genetically superior livestock or a better quality, higher yielding food crop, and people throughout the world realize this. The cloning of human beings has become one of the worst fears in our society today and for that reason many laws have been passed throughout European countries and North America in an effort to ban human cloning....   [tags: Genetic Engineering Essays]

Research Papers
1937 words (5.5 pages)

Essay on Cloning Humans

- Cloning Humans Ian Wilmut’s foray into cloning Dolly has proved to be an appetizing entrée to mankind, with the next step being the cloning of endangered species, and eventually, humans. Although his team of researchers had qualified to the public that it is unethical to clone humans1, the very prospect of being able to replicate creatures of our own kind is nevertheless enticing. Think of all the possible benefits that make many scientists prepared to cross those ethical boundaries: Firstly, couples who have tried a long time for identical twins, triplets (or even quintuplets!) may now be able to have them by producing clones from a single embryonic cell....   [tags: Genetic Engineering Cloning Essays]

Research Papers
709 words (2 pages)

We Must Stop Cloning Now! Essay

- We Must Stop Cloning Now. Did you know it took 277 tries to finally create the first mammal clone, Dolly. The process of cloning is not even close to being perfected to be used on animals or humans. It would also cause many different problems in the world if we did start cloning. We should stop this practice because it has to many flaws, it destroys individuality and uniqueness, will cause over population, and is against many religious and moral beliefs. Cloning started off with farmers cloning plants thousands of years ago in very simple ways, like cutting a plant and letting the roots combine to make another plant....   [tags: Cloning Genetic Engineering Essays]

Research Papers
589 words (1.7 pages)

Related Searches

Mammalian clones of sheep were reproduced in this fashion as well in 1984. This type of cloning needed to use embryonic cells. Almost all of an animal’s cells contain the genetic material needed to reproduce that animal. However, as cells differentiate into different tissues and organs, they only keep the genetic material needed to reproduce that organ. Therefore, only embryonic cells can be used for cloning because they have not differentiated into a specific type of tissue and still retain all the genes needed to make a copy of themselves (From Year in Review 1997 1). Although this method of cloning has been successful, most nuclear transfers do not result in live offspring. In addition, there have been a lot of objections raised regarding the use of embryos to clone mammals. Many people object based on religious grounds that the embryo has a soul from the moment of conception and therefore it should not be tampered with. Scientists were hoping that they could clone mammals without the use of embryos (Beddington 3).
In 1996, Ian Wilmut, at the Roslin Institute, accomplished this feat. He was able to successfully clone a sheep without the use of embryonic cells. Dolly the sheep was successfully cloned by transferring the nucleus of a non-reproductive cell, a mammary cell, into an unfertilized sheep egg from which its own genetic material had been removed. Dolly was an exact clone of the sheep that donated the mammary cell. Using a mammary cell was unique since until now only embryonic cells could develop into a full organism. Ian Wilmut was able to reprogram an adult cell to dedifferentiate and therefore the cell retained the genetic material needed to produce an entire organism and not just a mammary cell. The key to this new procedure was to time the cell cycle of the mammary cell with that of the egg. In order to do this nutrients were withheld from the mammary cell, which stopped it from dividing. The nucleus of the mammary cell was transferred into the recipient egg. An electrical current was given to the egg, which provided the energy that was needed for fertilization to occur. The egg began to divide and when it became an embryo it was placed into another sheep. The lamb that was born, Dolly was a clone of the donor of the original mammary cell (Kolata 27). This type of cloning is very exciting. This technique may be used to mass-produce animals that mimic human diseases for research purposes or to create animals with genetically modified organs that could be safely transplanted into humans. It could also be used to mass-produce animals for drug production or to improve livestock (Clone 1).
This new technique can theoretically also be used to clone humans. However, there are technical difficulties in cloning using a human egg. The unfertilized egg of a mammal has a supply of proteins that is used by the embryo until the embryos own genes can make the proteins for itself. Sheep embryos rely on their own genes after four cell divisions which is apparently enough time for the foreign nucleus to take over and reprogram the egg. However, human embryos begin producing proteins at an earlier stage so there is not a lot of time for the egg cytoplasm to reprogram the nucleus that was transplanted. This makes it harder to clone humans than it is to clone sheep. However, mice also begin producing proteins at an early stage and they were successfully cloned in 1998. This shows us that human cloning is theoretically possible even though they produce proteins at an early stage (Beddington 4).
There is currently a great debate going on concerning human cloning and the continuation of cloning research in general. People in favor of human cloning argue that human cloning would be useful in many ways. It would make it possible for infertile couples to have children of their own who are biologically related to them. Instead of having to use donated embryos, the couple could use their own adult cells to fertilize the egg. In addition, if a woman only has one egg, cloning could be used to make many copies of that egg. This would significantly increase her chances of getting pregnant. It would also enable couples who were at risk of having children with a genetic defect able to have perfectly healthy and normal children. For example, defective genes located in the mitochondria of the cell cause some diseases. If a woman carries a defective gene in her mitochondria she could still produce a healthy child by using nuclear transfer. The nucleus of one of her body cells could be placed into an enucleated egg cell from a woman without a defect in her mitochondria. The embryo can then be put back into the womb of the women who donated the nucleus then she can have a healthy child who is biologically related to her (Uses of Cloning 2). Another practical application of human cloning could be used as insurance for a person or his children’s health. Humans might be able to clone their own organs for autologous, self-transplantation. In addition, you could clone a woman’s fertilized egg. Then you could put one egg back into the woman and freeze the other eggs for transplants. If her child ever needed a bone marrow transplant, one of the eggs could be taken out of storage, implanted in her womb and allowed to mature into a baby. The new baby’s bone marrow could be used for to treat the other baby who is genetically identical to it. Human cloning might also be the miracle cure for spinal cord paralysis. Damaged nerves in adults do not regenerate on their own. Stem cells from a paralyzed person could be used to differentiate into his own nerve tissue. Since a large number of stem cells are required to create enough nerve tissue to repair the damage, cloning could be used to create enough stem cells. In addition, human cloning could lead to the understanding of cancer growth. The human egg divides at a similar rate as cancer cells. If information obtained from cloning research allows scientists to stop a human egg from dividing, a technique for stopping the growth of cancer might be
found (Robinson 6).
However, despite the many potential benefits of human cloning many people have raised strong objections to human cloning based on practical, ethical and religious grounds. Some of the practical objections to human cloning are that it is very expensive, technically demanding and inefficient. It took three hundred tries and many years of research to clone Dolly, which means that it will take even longer and many more tries to clone humans. In addition when attempts were made to clone Dolly, many lambs with abnormalities were born. One does not know how many abnormal humans will be born before the technique is successful (Beddington 3).
Numerous ethical objections have been raised as well. This scientific discovery is new and not proven to be safe in humans because we do not know the possible risks associated with manipulating the genes of a fetus or mature person. In addition, since the process is inefficient, many human embryos would be destroyed in the attempt to make one clone. People fear cloning may be used to eliminate a specific gender or to produce babies with certain desirable traits. Many ethicists believe this is tampering with “Mother Nature.” Another concern is that an amoral country could use cloning to create “perfect people.” To some people this is reminiscent of the horrible beliefs of Hitler who tried to create a perfect Aryan race. Alternatively, cloning could be used to create humans with subnormal intelligence to be used as slaves and workpeople. Another ethical concern is that the clone’s life span might be shorter because it was created from an adult cell. Cloning might also have a harmful effect on family relationships. If a child was born from adult DNA cloned from one of his parents he could be considered a delayed twin of one of his parents. This could lead to emotional problems between the parents and the child and parenting problems. In addition if the parent has a disease the child might worry that he will get the same disease as his parent. Many people argue that genetic cloning will decrease genetic diversity making large portions of a population prone to the same diseases (Robinson 7).
Many organizations and religious groups are opposed to cloning humans. The World Health Organization, The American Society of Reproductive Medicine and the three major religions, Judaism, Christianity and Islam do not condone human cloning. The underlying religious concern is that cloning is not natural and interferes with god’s work. The Catholic Church prohibits all types of cloning whereas the Muslims and Jews feel that some aspects of cloning may be permitted if cloning produces ways to counteract infertility or to produce better food or medication (The Cloning Debate: people and organizations 1).
     In light of all of the practical, ethical and religious issues, former President Clinton banned federal funding for human cloning. He also asked the National Bioethics Advisory Committee to form an opinion on human cloning. The committee focused its attention on the use of somatic cell nuclear transfer techniques to create children, such as was used in the creation of Dolly. The committee examined issues of safety of the procedure, possible psychological harms to the clone including a diminished sense of individuality and self worth, possible harm to parenting and family life and religious issues. The commission recommended to continue a ban on the use of federal funding for cloning and requested all scientists and firms to listen and abide to this ban. It further recommended that there should be a law to prohibit anyone from trying to create a child through somatic cell nuclear transfer cloning. However, they recommend that Congress review this law after approximately three to five years in order to decide if this ban needs to be continued. This ban only relates to funding for public research. There are no written laws regarding private research (Executive Summary 3).
     The current scientific state of the art of cloning indicates that actual cloning of a human being is achievable. We can be sure that many of the processes leading up to the ultimate cloning of a human being will be used to benefit the people of the twenty first century. This will include the use of nuclear transfer and cloning for gene therapy and reproductive medicine. However, ethical and religious dilemmas as well as practical difficulties will not allow the cloning of a human to proceed for the foreseeable future.
Return to