Critique of a Study; Muscle Dysmorphia - excellent paper

Critique of a Study; Muscle Dysmorphia - excellent paper

Length: 1079 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
     Last year a study was performed to examine a model for the development of muscle dysmorhpia among male college athletes. The model is known as the Lantz, Rhea, and Mayhew Model and it describes the relationship between pre-disposing factors for the development of muscle dysmorphia and the negative consequences paired with the disorder. The study concentrated on male college athletes falling into three different categories: weight lifters, non-contact sports athletes, and contact sport athletes. The study was to determine which of the expected negative behaviors, if any, prevailed among the separate categories.
     Over the past decades the media has been the primary blame of creating body image disorders among both females and males.
“Similar to females, men have been inundated with distorted pictures representing the ideal male physique from TV, fitness magazines, and the toy industry (e.g., bulging superhero, G. I. Joe). While most researchers suggest that a multitude of factors may play a role in creating body image disorders (Pike & Striegel-Moore, 1997), Levine and Smolak (1998) are among a growing number of researchers who blame the media's glamorized body blueprint messages for men and women unrealistically judging themselves. (Page 120)”

Men with body image disorders are usually afraid of being too small rather than too large. They tend to have the desire to gain muscle mass at the same time as cutting down the waist line. Along with this desire, an obsession can occur to compulsively lift weights as a way of life. The compulsive weight lifting and consumption of dietary supplements describes the term “muscle dysmorphia”. This disorder is more mental than physical and may also be a type of obsessive-compulsive disorder.
“In a manner similar to MD, OCD is manifested by obsessions (e.g., constant thoughts about being too small) and compulsions (e.g., repeated behaviors of weight-lifting). (Page 120)”

Muscle dysmorphia can also create other mental disorders. It may actually be genetically impossible for some to reach their ideal body. This creates an individual who obsesses over a goal which is non-existent, creating possible depression and perhaps impairing social and occupational functioning.
The model of muscle dysmorphia has yet to be tested and this study is to determine if the psycho-behavioral characteristics proposed by the model are present, and to what degree, in the selected weight lifters compared to other athletes. A sample student body of 106 students was selected as the participants. This group contained 29 weight lifters, 24 non-contact sport athletes, and 53 contact sport athletes.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Critique of a Study; Muscle Dysmorphia - excellent paper." 12 Nov 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Use Of Volumetric Muscle Loss ( Vml ) Essay

- Although skeletal muscle tissue has a strong mechanism for tissue repair, sometimes major circumstances impair these regenerative efforts. This condition, called volumetric muscle loss (VML) us the main clinical need driving the development of skeletal muscle tissue engineering (SMTE) VML can results from a number of injuries or disease. For example is the complex skeletal muscle injuries suffered by military personnel on the battlefield. Although the mortality rate has dropped to 10% in Iraq and Afghanistan (Holcomb et al., 397-410), there has been an increase in the number of soldiers surviving with severe injuries to the extremities, head, and neck (Mazurek and Ficke, S18-S23)....   [tags: Skeletal muscle, Muscle, Acetylcholine]

Research Papers
1518 words (4.3 pages)

Skeletal Muscle And The Human Body Essays

- Skeletal muscle is a muscle that is connected at either one or both extremities of the skeleton to form part of the mechanical system that moves the limbs and other parts of the body. The human body contains more than six hundred skeletal muscles, which establish forty percent to fifty percent of the total body weight. Nevertheless, skeletal muscle performs three important functions which include: force generation for locomotion and breathing, force generation for postural support, and heat production during cold stress....   [tags: Muscle, Skeletal muscle, Myosin, Muscular system]

Research Papers
1606 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on Physiology Of Frog Skeletal Muscle

- BIOL: 1412: 0A07 Physiology of Frog Skeletal Muscle Jerzy Twarowski Group Members: Jerzy Twarowski, Nikki Youd, Liu Ziwei Introduction The skeletal muscle tissue is a tissue found in the muscles that is controlled by the somatic nervous system. This means that the muscle is under the conscious control. It is also called a striated muscle, because of its appearance under the microscope caused by the parallel and regular positioning of two different proteins –actin filaments and myosin filaments (Sadava, 2014)....   [tags: Myosin, Muscle, Muscular system, Skeletal muscle]

Research Papers
1931 words (5.5 pages)

Essay about Muscle Strain ( Tear )

- ANIEKEME EDET BIOL 2541K MUSCLE STRAIN (TEAR) The muscular system makes up about 44% of the body weight. There are 700 skeletal muscles in the human body. They consist of; axial muscle which supports and positions axial skeleton, and appendicular muscle which support, move and brace limbs. The functions of the muscular system includes: movement, maintaining body position, support of tissue, regulating entrances and exits, and maintaining body temperature. The muscle cell had many nuclei. This helps to produce adequate protein....   [tags: Muscle, Cardiac muscle, Muscular system, Glycogen]

Research Papers
1384 words (4 pages)

Essay on Muscle Pharm

- The supplement industry is saturated with companies that claim to enhance your muscles and performance. In this field there is one company that stands out among consumers and athletes alike. Muscle Pharm does not make promises it cannot deliver, their unique marketing approach makes them stand out compared to other supplement companies. The Muscle Pharm website first starts out with Colin Kaepernick, 49’ers Quarterback, and a picture of how Muscle Pharm has helped him achieve his NFL dream. It then goes on to ask “what athlete are you?” The website design is strategic in that it shows all their athletes, partnerships, events, retailers, and even diet plans all in one spot; essentially everyt...   [tags: Muscle Pharm Case Study]

Research Papers
1052 words (3 pages)

Essay about Muscle And Its Effect On Tissue Stress

- Muscle activity, including generating force and moving limbs through lengthening and shortening, is an important influence on beneficial tissue stress. Muscles adapt quickly to periods of lower or higher stress and demonstrate obvious visual and functional changes. At a tissue level, the Physical Stress Theory (PST) states that muscle adaptations are consistent with other high and low strain tissue adaptation models. Low stress/activity associated with immobilization results in decreases in contractile protein, fiber diameter, peak tension and power....   [tags: Muscle, Muscle contraction, Muscular system]

Research Papers
776 words (2.2 pages)

The Effect Of Exercise On Skeletal Muscle Essay

- The hypothesis in Ca2+–calmodulin-dependent protein kinase expression and signaling in skeletal muscle during exercise is that skeletal muscle Ca2+–calmodulin-dependent kinase II signaling would be modified by endurance, training was tested to further these thoughts. The author had done 2 tests prior to the final result explaining and testing his theory. He had 8 men, who were relatively of young age, train and exercise continuously for 3 weeks. He took muscle samples from the men before and after doing the experiment....   [tags: Adenosine triphosphate, Muscle, Protein kinase]

Research Papers
895 words (2.6 pages)

The Effects Of Strength Training On Muscle Strength Essay

- However, free weight exercises including squats can, in fact, have positive improvements on those with joint-degrading diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and osteoarthritis (OA). People who suffer from rheumatoid arthritis have chronic inflammation of the joints, whereas wear-and-tear of the ligaments causes osteoarthritis. A two-year randomized study documented the effects of strength training on muscle strength, disease activity, functional capacity, and bone mineral density in early rheumatoid arthritis....   [tags: Muscle, Bodybuilding, Strength training]

Research Papers
1166 words (3.3 pages)

How Dehydration is Correlated with Muscle Fatigue Essay examples

- When muscle power output is decreased, the effect is a decrease in the generation of muscle force and velocity that results in muscle fatigue (Powers, 2012). Factors that may contribute to muscle fatigue include the following: exercise intensity, muscle overuse, and in anaerobic exercise when lactic acid (a waste product that causes muscle pain, soreness, and fatigue) is respired from cells because of oxygen deficiency. A major factor that can trigger muscle fatigue is dehydration. It is important to hydrate before intense exercise in order to regulate muscle fatigue because without electrolytes the muscles will tighten and cramp at a faster rate, which results in muscle fatigue....   [tags: muscle power, electrolytes, cramp]

Research Papers
973 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on The Effect Of Protein On Muscle Soreness And Recovery

- Many studies have been done on the effects of protein on muscle soreness and recovery. It is already known that protein is an important building block of muscles, bones, cartilage, etc. It is also known that eccentric exercise, which is a type of exercise that lengthens muscles, induces the most amount of muscle damage, causing more soreness (Dahlstrom, Olson, Sharp, Baier & Alekel, 2010). With this knowledge, it is easy to infer that a protein supplement would decrease muscle soreness and promote faster muscle recovery after doing an eccentric exercise routine....   [tags: Muscle, Physical exercise, Exercise physiology]

Research Papers
1462 words (4.2 pages)

Related Searches

The procedures were as followed:
“Participants agreed to complete two self-report measures, the first a brief survey including questions on steroid use, nutritional supplement use & frequency, exercise regimen frequency, intensity and duration, concerns about body symmetry, physique protection behaviors, and concerns about body size or weight. The second measure was the modified Messer & Harter (1985) Adult Self-Perception Scale (ASPS). The modified ASPS questionnaire contains sub-scales including: global self-worth, obsessive-compulsive behavior, athletic ability, intimate relationships, sociability, physical appearance, depression, perfectionism, and intelligence. The surveys were administered in relatively small groups of 20 - 30. (Page 122)”

The weight lifting category did reveal significant differences in behaviors compared to the other athletes. Weight lifters reported much higher in the field of diet and supplement use than did the other athletes. They were also more apt to constantly check their weight and body size. No differences were shown between the groups for the use of steroids or worrying about weight loss. There was no clear data in the study that showed that weight lifters prevailed in the pre-disposing factors that were proposed by the model. The predictions of the expected behaviors performed by weight lifters were not found in the study making the study somewhat of a failure. There were simple differences found between the groups of participants, but none that could help prove the model.
There are obviously many ways to critique this study since it was unsuccessful. The critique could start with the participants. The study consisted of only 106 participants, which is difficult to assess significant data of an entire category of athletes on such a small portion of the group. Of these 106 participants, only 29 were weight lifters, with weight lifters being the primary focus. The remaining participants were divided between 24 non-contact sport athletes and 53 contact sport athletes. It would be assumed that if a study took place focusing on weight lifters, that the majority of the participants would be weight lifters not contact sport athletes. If another study took place this is one thing that should be thought about changing. Perhaps gathering 106 participants who are weight lifters and comparing them to the same number of participants who fall under the remaining categories would be considered.
Another criticism of the study is the subject background. The age and area an individual lives in usually has a great impact on the way they think of themselves and how they act. These samples were all college students who were on varsity athletic teams and sports clubs at a northeastern university. Some of the pre-disposing factors proposed by the Lantz, Rhea, and Mayhew Model may not apply to the selected subjects. Factors such as low self-esteem and pharmacological abuse would most likely not be a factor with varsity athletes. If an athlete has made his way to become a varsity level competitor, his self-esteem would most likely be very high. Reaching this level of athletics is quite an accomplishment and most athletes are very aware of that. Things such as pharmacological abuse and supplements are usually monitored very closely in college athletics. In many cases pharmacological abuse violates the rules and the athlete would be subject to suspension.
The procedure of the study can also be easily criticized. The study consisted of two self-report measures. The first was a brief survey completed by the participants. Participants are by no means obligated to answer all of the questions truthfully. Some participants may not be answering truthfully, which would add a margin of error into the study.
Considering these criticisms, changes should be made in case of another study. It is definite that more research needs to be done to help prove the model. Without more valid research providing explicit significant results, the model of muscle dysmorphia is nothing more than an idea. Using the results found in this study may also encourage changes within the model, perhaps making it more general until the specifics can be proven.

Excellent Paper; got a 93 on it.
-Dan Jennings
Return to