Robert Sirico's Samaritan's Dilemma

Robert Sirico's Samaritan's Dilemma

Length: 979 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

In the essay Samaritan’s Dilemma, Robert Sirico claims that charity is not always helpful to society. He implies that some people take advantage of others kindness, in this case, soup kitchens.
To support his claim, Sirico told a story of when he was training to be a priest. He states that each Friday he would help set up and serve a free meal to those in need, usually 200 to 500 people. One Friday after the meal, he and a friend cleaned up then went to a seafood pub just down the street. While eating the two men realized that the soup kitchen they had just finished working at was competition to the seafood pub and other surrounding restaurants. They realized that their charity was making it harder for other entrepreneurs to make a living and provide for their families.
Sirico basically states that when people are waited on “hand and foot” they become more dependant on others, therefore, making it even harder for them to get out of poverty. He also implies that giving “handouts” to people encourages laziness. He says, “When charity creates a disincentive for an able-bodied person to work, it leads this person down the wrong path. It encourages indolence. Real work provides the individual with the vehicle for a productive and virtuous life. It gives a person self esteem and a role to play in society.”
The support he uses does not help his case, though. For example, the comparison Sirico makes of the soup kitchen to a seafood pub is irrelevant. He states, "Just a block away we provide a product and a service that make this man's effort to provide for his own family more difficult.” A soup kitchen and a seafood pub are not comparable. The pub has the intention to make money, whereas a soup kitchen is not interested in money. Soup kitchens are there for the purpose of people who cannot afford to eat at other places. The speaker never states the prices or quality of food at the pub. This information would help the reader recognize the similarities and differences between the two. Sirico fails to mention the other restaurants that are also the pub owner's competition. Surrounding restaurants may be taking business from the pub, not the soup kitchen. In addition, Sirico uses insufficient personal experience to suggest that people are taking advantage of charity. After observing people coming to the soup kitchen, Sirico noticed a couple that "told me they needed to eat quickly because they were planning to go shopping after dinner.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Robert Sirico's Samaritan's Dilemma." 20 Oct 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Question and Answers: Destructive Behaviors, Prisoner's Dilemma and GRIT

- 1. Describe how being in a crowd can lead people to engage in destructive behaviors When people join a large crowd, often they find themselves losing their individuality. Some people may feel a strong desire to conform to fit into the crowd (Changing Minds, 2013). People in crowds may undergo deindividuation, which is a loss of individual identity to gain the social identity of the group. This can result in a loss of the normal constraints that a person may have to guard against deviant behavior (Kassin, Fein, & Markus, 2010)....   [tags: large crowd, resource dilemma]

Research Papers
1102 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Blood is Thicker than Water in Ethical Dilemma

- ... Without airing too much, I will say there are two sides to my brother; the side he shows my family and the other side which I consider to be his true side. I have reason to believe that once my parents pass away; my relationship with him will be non-existent. I became aware of underhanded behavior concerning him during the divorce. He was hiding large quantities of money, alleging to give up his business so his income would be less resulting in less child support owed, and there were numerous accounts of him manipulating my sister-in-law into an uncontested divorce that would be detrimental to her....   [tags: dilemma, relationship, brother]

Free Essays
673 words (1.9 pages)

Meaning in Robert Frost's The Road Not Taken Essay

- “Two roads diverged in a yellow wood and sorry I could not travel both and be one traveler” (Page 756 Stanza 1). This is the beginning of an iambic tetrameter by Robert Frost in which he expresses the thoughts of the speaker as they come to a fork in the road. The speaker faces a dilemma of deciding which path to take. Frost uses a closed form with a rhyme scheme of “ABAAB.” The speaker reaching the fork in the road is symbolism for a particular decision that he must make in life. The first stanza is setting up the situation in which the speaker must observe both choices and make a decision and stick with it....   [tags: Road Not Taken, Robert Frost]

Research Papers
769 words (2.2 pages)

A Good Samaritan Essay

- Have you ever been scared for the safety of a complete stranger. Have you changed somebody’s outlook on life just by being a Good Samaritan. Well, I have. It was a late Thursday night and I was in a bad part of town informally known as “The Knob.” I had been at a friend's house when we decided to leave to find somewhere to eat. On the way, my friend got a call from his mom telling him he had to be home. His house wasn’t really out of the way. As I pulled down Belle Avenue, towards his house, another friend of mine shouts out “Hey, pull over that guy just knocked that girl out” I instantly questioned this absurd accusation....   [tags: Personal Experience]

Research Papers
756 words (2.2 pages)

Jealousy in Cantor's Dilemma Essay

- Jealousy in Cantor's Dilemma The beast hides in the shadows. Its presence is all around us; its existence denied by all. It moves stealthily from one body to the next, peering with its infinite, green eyes into the deepest thoughts of all, a merciless predator seeking out those who least expect its attack. It strikes without a sound, paralyzing its prey. The monster's bite drives its victims into behaving rashly. It injects a poison strong enough to cause one to distrust one's best-friend....   [tags: Cantor's Dilemma Essays]

Research Papers
712 words (2 pages)

Free Essays: Destructive Competition Exposed in Cantor's Dilemma

- Destructive Competition Exposed in Cantor's Dilemma Competition is often useful as a means of motivation. However, in the scientific world, competition has the potential to cause many scientists to forget their main purpose in research. The main goal of scientific research is to develop knowledge that will better society. When scientists work together to help each other reach a common goal, science is working as it should. However, with so much competition to be the best scientist, make the most money, and possibly win the Nobel Prize, it is difficult for scientists to share ideas....   [tags: Cantor's Dilemma Essays]

Free Essays
545 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on Fame in Djerassi’s Cantor's Dilemma

- Dreams of Fame in Djerassi’s Cantor's Dilemma       Opportunistic scientists, the most hypocritical deviants of the modern age, revolve around the scientific method, or at least they used to. The scientific method once involved formulating a hypothesis from a problem posed, experimenting, and forming a conclusion that best explained the data collected. Yet today, those who are willing to critique the work of their peers are themselves performing the scientific method out of sequence. I propose that scientists, or the "treasure hunters" of that field, are no longer interested in permanent solutions, achieved through proper use of the scientific method, and rather are more interested in so...   [tags: Cantor's Dilemma Essays]

Research Papers
1063 words (3 pages)

Essay on Discrimination Against Women as Addressed in Cantor's Dilemma

- Discrimination Against Women as Addressed in Cantor's Dilemma   In his novel, Cantor's Dilemma, Dr. Djerassi uses female characters to address sexist issues arising from women integrating into the predominantly male science world. The characters, Celestine Price and Professor Arderly, are used to show examples of how women have little voice in the field of science. The female characters suggest how women are often looked upon as sex objects rather than co-workers and they are given little opportunity to balance a scientific career with raising a family....   [tags: Cantor's Dilemma Essays]

Research Papers
1132 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about a Man For All Seasons - By Robert Bolt: Mores Moral Dilemma

- "A Man for All Seasons" by Robert Bolt: More's Moral Dilemma During the English renaissance in the 1500's, King Henry VIII wants a divorce from his wife for various reasons, but divorce is against the Catholic religion. This is why he wants Sir Thomas More's consent, because More is a highly respected Catholic, but he is such a good Catholic that he goes against divorce. In the play, A Man for All Seasons, by Robert Bolt, King Henry VIII applies pressure on Thomas More to support the divorce in many ways....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
1220 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Robert Nozick’s Experience Machine

- In his 1975 book Anarchy, State, and Utopia, Robert Nozick introduced a now famous thought experiment he entitled "The Experience Machine." Nozick believes that this intuition pump successfully demonstrates that hedonism is false and that human beings do value things other than happiness and pleasure as goods in themselves, namely "authenticity" and the like. In this paper, I will offer a thorough exegesis of the Experience Machine thought experiment and attempt to show that it fails to establish that something like authenticity could serve as a potential normative foundation....   [tags: Robert Nozick Anarchy State and Utopia]

Research Papers
3406 words (9.7 pages)

Related Searches

” But what he does not say is that the couple may have been going shopping at the Salvation Army or Goodwill. He never states the appearance of the people and does not investigate deeply enough into their intentions. Readers are likely to feel angry with Sirico for making generalizations. They may think that he does not care enough about the people who need the services; he is only caught up in those who he thinks do not need it. Although he is a priest, references to the Bible do not supply adequate support. Sirico says, "God gave Adam and Eve the Earth and its wonders as a gift, but He expected them to mix their labor with the resources he provided". This is strictly his interpretation of what God expected of Adam and Eve. Readers may disagree with this statement, and others may feel offended. Readers who do not believe in God may feel that Sirico's beliefs are being forced upon them. Therefore, some readers are less likely to believe what he is stating and will not back him up. The overall manner in which Sirico uses support weakens his argument.
     Sirico also uses many logical fallacies that make his claim even less convincing. For example, he creates a false dilemma in stating, "When charity creates a disincentive for an able-bodied person to work, it leads this person down the wrong path.” He makes it sound as if charity is making the otherwise capable people too lazy to provide for themselves. Sirico believes this is the only reason an able-bodied person would need charity. Yet even people who are physically able to work may need soup kitchens. People go to soup kitchens because they are hungry and most often have no other way to get food. Also, people who receive charity frequently would much rather provide for themselves than have to rely on the kindness of others in order to get a simple meal. Another fallacy that Sirico uses is a hurried generalization. At the soup kitchen, he "…witnessed one person arriving in a taxi.” Through this one person, Sirico assumes that people are all taking advantage of charitable services. However, one person is insufficient evidence to draw such a conclusion. It suggests the idea that anyone that can afford a taxi does not truly need a soup kitchen. He never considers that it may be less expensive for a taxi ride to the soup kitchen than an inexpensive mean in a real restaurant. And some people have a disability that allows them no other mode of transportation.
The author suggests making the people wash dishes or help prepare meals in exchange for food. The obvious question that should be asked here is: is that a drastic enough measure? Is washing dishes a big deal, donating five minutes of ones time is a small price to pay for a free meal, is it not? And when it comes to preparing the food; most people would rather eat the food that they prepared, at least they would know what was in it.
What people need to realize is that even if a few people are taking advantage of the system, the others who do need the services are very grateful. They should not be denied service because of a small portion of selfish people.
Return to