Comaparison of The Crucible and Sommersby

Comaparison of The Crucible and Sommersby

Length: 796 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

Sometimes two things may seem like they have nothing in common but when analyzed more critically one may find many similarities. A good example of this would be between The Crucible and Sommersby. These two stories may seem like they have nothing in common; one, The Crucible, is about the Salem witch trials, the other, Sommersby, is about a POW returning home after six years. These two stories may appear to be totally different but they do in fact share many similarities.
     Three of the characters in The Crucible are very similar to three characters in Sommersby. The three characters The Crucible are John Proctor, his wife Elizabeth Proctor, and Abigail Williams. The three characters in Sommersby are Jack Sommers by (Horace Townsend), Laurel Sommersby, and Orin Meecham. John Proctor is like Laurel Sommersby in the sense that they have both committed the sin of adultery. Jack Sommersby is much like Elizabeth Proctor because they both have their reasons to believe their spouse is cheating on them, but don’t have the concrete evidence to confront their spouse. And the relationship between the two couples can be described in the same way; they are very uncomfortable around each other. Orin is similar to Abigail Williams because they are the ones that are having the affair with either Laurel or John. Both of them also try very desperately, with no success, to maintain their relationship with the person they are committing adultery with. Some of the characters in these two stories have something similar to the character in the other story.
     Jack Sommersby and John Proctor made similar decisions prior to not confessing or denying the crimes they were accused of committing. Sommersby did not try to deny the charges brought up against him for the murder of a man in a nearby town that he did not kill nor does he sustain the idea that he is not really Jack Sommersby. Proctor does not formally confess to being a wizard nor did he try to deny the charge. They both had similar reasons for making the decisions they did. They did it to help other people, not for any personal benefit. Sommersby did not try to back up the idea that he was Horace Townsend and not Jack Sommersby, because if he did that many people in town would lose all the land they have purchased from him.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Comaparison of The Crucible and Sommersby." 123HelpMe.com. 15 Jul 2018
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=59351>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Examples of Crucibles in Aurthur Miller's "The Crucible" Essay

- A Crucible is a container that can withstand great amount of heat, such as one required for refining gold. It can also mean a severe trial. In the play “The Crucible” by Arthur Miller, severe trails occur throughout the play, not just in the courtroom but also in people’s homes and souls. I believe Arthur Miller named his play “The Crucible” because it shows the trials and hardships people face within themselves, the courtroom and Puritan society. An example of a Crucible is a trial or battle someone faces; it could be within themselves or with others....   [tags: Aurthur Miller, Crucible, titles,]

Research Papers
665 words (1.9 pages)

Fear in Salem, Massachusetts and "The Crucible" Essay

- What do you fear in our twenty-first century society. Terrorism, inequality, losing your home, or injustice. Salem, Massachusetts during the seventeenth century feared injustices among the government. Individuals hid and lied to keep safe from being condemned as witches. This era of history is known as the Salem Witch Trials. Arthur Miller’s The Crucible explores the Salem Witch Trials while following the lives of several individuals. The fear and mistrust among the seventeenth century Salem society can be directly related to today’s twenty-first century society....   [tags: Salem Witch Trials, Crucible, ]

Research Papers
732 words (2.1 pages)

The Crucible Essay

- Introduction The Crucible – It can withstand extreme conditions. While heating metals in it, the impurities come up to the surface and the pure substance can be obtained. It basically helps in separating pure and impure substances. Link – In Miller’s play, the character of John Proctor is tested. Eventually he decides to sacrifice his life, rather than betray his beliefs. In 1953, at the time the book was written, the Second World War had just ended but still there was a clash of democrats ands communists....   [tags: Essay on The Crucible]

Research Papers
911 words (2.6 pages)

Comparison of Abigail Williams and Elizabeth Proctor in Miller's The Crucible

- Comparison of Abigail Williams and Elizabeth Proctor in Miller's The Crucible The Crucible is play that helps to show human nature through a series of events linked through the Salem witch trials. In this play, a group of young teenagers would undermine the religious government and make a mockery of the Salem judicial system. Miller also shows human nature through the development of characters. Abigail Williams and Elizabeth Proctor are foils of each other and have many differences; they would also develop many similar traits....   [tags: Crucible Arthur Miller Plays Salem Essays Papers]

Research Papers
561 words (1.6 pages)

Comparison of Elizabeth Proctor with Abigail Williams in Arthur Miller's The Crucible

- Comparison of Elizabeth Proctor with Abigail Williams in Arthur Miller's The Crucible Abigail Williams and Elizabeth Proctor, the leading female characters in 'The Crucible'. Both show determination in order to get what they want. Abigail, a cunning girl that is out for revenge, feels she has superiority over many of the other characters even though she is only a young girl. Elizabeth's character portrays a wife in distress after she finds out about her husband's affair, yet she still has courage throughout the play....   [tags: Abigail Williams The Crucible]

Research Papers
710 words (2 pages)

Comparison Between The Crucible by Arthur Miller and Vinegar Tom by C. Churchill

- Comparison Between The Crucible by Arthur Miller and Vinegar Tom by C. Churchill We are currently performing a piece of drama called 'The Crucible' and have studied a play called 'Vinegar Tom'. 'The Crucible' was written by Arthur Miller in 1953 and was set in Salem, Massachusetts USA in 1692. 'Vinegar Tom' was written in the 1970's and was set in the 17th century. Although 'Vinegar Tom' was written about the 17th century, the ideas parallel those of the issues of the 1970's. The issue was feminism....   [tags: The Crucible Vinegar Tom Drama Essays]

Research Papers
613 words (1.8 pages)

A Comparison of Repression in The Crucible and Black Ice Essay

- The Crucible and Black Ice – Repression Within the small and somber courtroom, wandering eyes search for their victims; fingers of vengeance fly at the innocent with sufficient speed to free themselves of the accusations. Hear the anguishing voices of the dead, feel the fury of the falsely accused, see the pain of the convicted, smell the scent of a paradox authority, and taste the bitterness of societal repression. John Proctor devotes himself to saving his wife and bringing justice to the backward court that rises in his society....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Research Papers
1189 words (3.4 pages)

The Crucible by Arthur Miller Essay

- The Crucible was based in 1692 in and around the town of Salem, Massachusetts, USA. The Salem witch-hunt was view as one of the strangest and most horrendous chapters in the human history. People that were prosecuted were all innocent and their deaths were all due to false accusation of people’s ridiculous belief in superstition and their paranoia. The Puritans in those times were very strict in personal habits and morality; swearing, drunkenness and gambling would be punished. The people of Salem believed in the devil and thought that witchcraft should be hunted out....   [tags: Essay on The Crucible]

Research Papers
965 words (2.8 pages)

A Comparison of The Crucible and Nazi Germany Essay

- The Crucible and Nazi Germany Arthur Miller's portrayal of Salem, Massachusetts can be juxtaposed with Adolf Hitler's Nazi Germany. While the motivations differ, societal similarities exist and both teach us that when a whole society of people have a fear so great that it can be used against them, the society will try to do anything and everything in their power to prevent this from happening. Even when the means of prevention involves innocent people dieing and the judiciary system becoming corrupt, the society will act upon this fear of wickedness and the devil....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
629 words (1.8 pages)

The Crucible Essay

- Long Essay - The Crucible q How is language used in The Crucible to express the emotional intensity if characters in conflict with each other and/or society and to convey the abstract ideas that emerge through that conflict. The Crucible is a play written by Arthur Miller in 1953. It is a prime example of dramatic theatre using powerful language to express emotional intensity of the characters in conflict with each other and their society. The language used also helps to convey the abstract ideas that emerge through that conflict by providing insights into the characters’ personality and values through their dialogue....   [tags: Essay on The Crucible]

Free Essays
957 words (2.7 pages)

Related Searches

If he had confessed to being Horace Townsend he would have been able to live but that was not what was important to him. What was though was the happiness of the people in his town. Proctor refused to sign the document that would officially submit his confession, because if he confessed then it would prove to the town that the accusations of witchcraft were legitimate. All the other people that had confessed to witchcraft were not good Christians so their confession did not really mean much to the town. Had Proctor confessed to practicing witchcraft he would have lived but then the town could have confirmed the accusations of witchcraft and all the people that have hung would have hung for a good reason. But since he did not confess the good name of all the people hung were not defiled and the town cast even more doubt upon the accusations of witchcraft. In making these decisions the characters in both stories made decisions based on the good of their town and not for the good of themselves.
     In both stories the wives were brought up to testify during the trials. In both stories the wives do almost the same thing. In Sommersby Laurel says that she knows the person impersonating Jack is not really him. She says this because she knows if she does then the court cannot try Jack for the murder. Elizabeth Proctor does the same thing when she is brought into court and asked if she ever suspected that her husband had been having an affair with their housekeeper, Abigail. Trying to keep John from prosecution, she says no she had no idea that john had any relationship with Abigail and that she fired Abby because she was doing a poor job. Both Laurel and Elizabeth lie to keep their husbands alive, even though Laurel was telling the truth the she at the time had not confirmed this suspicion.
     These two stories may appear to be totally different but they do in fact share many similarities. The Crucible and Sommersby both shared many similarities in characters and their decisions. Some of the characters are almost identical in both stories. This may have been so because of the way great writers and great producers think, or maybe it is just that both of these great literary pieces of work depict what conscience tells one to do.
Return to 123HelpMe.com