Case Study Review - Reviving an Ancient Therapy to Manage Chronic Pain

Case Study Review - Reviving an Ancient Therapy to Manage Chronic Pain

Length: 792 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Title: Reviving an Ancient Therapy to Manage Chronic Pain
Reference: Podiatry Today, December 2003, pg. 46-53
Author: Nicholas A Grumbine, DPM
Rating: 4/5

Abstract

Objective: This article was written to increase people’s awareness of leech therapy in healthcare to manage chronic pain. Case studies on were designed to determine whether leeching would improve chronic pain in a safe and effective manner.

Background: Chronic pain results when there is delayed healing. Grumbine claims that chronic pain ‘produces a fear in the patient and a panicked feeling that the pain will
return or increase’.

Grumbine also explores other biological treatments like leech therapy, and the effects that medical leeches have on their patients. Usually, medications were used to control chronic pain, such as sleep medications and antidepressants. Now it has been observed that leeching prevents blood clotting and severe burning pain. The ingredients of leech saliva help stabilize cellular membranes and the overall well-being of the skin and body functions improve. As blood flow increases and improves circulation, the arteries, veins and capillaries dilate, and there is a reduction of oedema, shunting and congestion.

Study Design: Case studies were designed to determine whether leeching procedures would affect patients with chronic pain, and by what amounts. These were patients aged from 13 to 96 that were defiant to usual tradition procedures. Five case studies were made. The case studies were performed on two elderly patients; one diagnosed with RSD , and the other patient suffering from burnings, oedema and hyperesthesia. Three other patients were also treated; a 16-year-old adolescent also with RSD and a severe hypertrophic scar, as well as a patient with Berger’s disease and a war veteran with ‘scrape metal wounds’.

Results: Preoperatively, patients’ levels of pains were at an average of 8.6 out of 10. After leeching procedures, pains were significantly reduced to an average of 3.5 out of 10. Not only did the pain dramatically decrease, but there were dermatological signs of improvement.

Leech therapy aided all of the patients that were case-studied. One of the elderly patients, a 53-year-old with RSD, had oedema reduced from her foot and her pain controlled with medication and fitted orthotics. The 16-year-old patient recovered well from her severe painful hypertrophic scar, after having 10 leeches ‘engorged 3 to 5 cc of blood’ and having 50 percent of the incision faded and 80 percent reduction of pain which allowed her to walk again ‘pain-free’. The third patient, a 52-year-old, had reduced swelling of her feet from severe burning, hyperesthesia and ‘forefoot oedema’ after the application of 12 leeches.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Case Study Review - Reviving an Ancient Therapy to Manage Chronic Pain." 123HelpMe.com. 18 Jan 2020
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=57465>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Literature Review for Plantar Heel Pain and Cupping Essay

- Plantar heel pain is a commonly seen condition by healthcare providers (Crawford et al., 2001, Hossain and Makwana, 2011, Radford et al., 2007, Renan-Ordine et al., 2011, Saban et al., 2013). 10 % of the adult general population experience plantar heel pain during their life. About 2 million American athletes and non-athletes are affected annually (Riddle et al., 2003). 15% of adult foot complaints seek professional care for plantar heel pain(Irving et al., 2006). Although it is a common condition, its etiology is poorly understood and remains controversial (Crawford et al., 2001, Irving et al., 2006, Rome et al., 2001)....   [tags: Plantar Heel Pain]

Research Papers
1082 words (3.1 pages)

Chronic Heel Pain Case Study Essays

- Chronic heel pain is the most common condition, accounts about 15 percent in population (Rome, 2005). Chronic plantar heel pain likely present in conditions plantar fascitis, subcalcaneal bursitis, neuritis, subcalcaneal spur (Narvaez et al, 2006). The common cause of chronic plantar heel pain is plantar fascitis.pain may occur along the entire attachment of the plantar fascia or limited usually on the inferior medial aspect of the calcaneum,the bony prominence act as the origin for the plantar fascia and the weakest point of the fascia in which the fibres themselves are in highly tensile stress....   [tags: Case Study, analysis, solution]

Research Papers
1052 words (3 pages)

Essay about Pain Assessment And Treatment Of Pain

- The most common reason that people seek medical care is pain, and pain is the leading cause of disability (Peterson & Bredow, 2013, p. 51; National Institute of Health, 2010). Pain is such an important topic in healthcare that the United States congress “identified 2000 to 2010 as the Decade of Pain Control and Research” (Brunner L. S., et al., 2010, p. 231). Unfortunatelly, patients are reporting a small increase in satisfaction with the pain management while in the hospital (Bernhofer, 2011)....   [tags: Pain, Suffering, Pain management, Perception]

Research Papers
1646 words (4.7 pages)

Symptoms And Treatment Of Pain Essay

- Pain is universal and personal to those who are experiencing it. It is subjectively measured on a scale of 0-10 with zero being no pain and 10 being the worst pain ever. This can be problematic for patients and doctors because this score can be understated or overstated. Doctors will make quick decisions based on this score. Patients might feel not believed because only they can feel the pain. However, untreated pain symptoms may be associated with impaired activities of daily life and decreased quality of life....   [tags: Pain, Nervous system]

Research Papers
1403 words (4 pages)

Effective Pain Management Essay

- Effective Pain Management Table of Contents 1. Introduction 2. Case study 3. Anatomy and pathophysiology of pain 4. Anatomy and Pathophysiology of Chronic Pain 5. Pain management 6. Conclusion Introduction Much of our standard of care today, seems to be centered on patient satisfaction. So, it is important now, more than ever before, to understand pain management. Pain management is one of the primary goals in nursing care and is often misunderstood by many nurses....   [tags: Anatomy, Pathophysiology, Pain, Chronic Pain]

Research Papers
1169 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Pain Pathways And Theories Of Pain

- Pain Pathways and Theories According to the International Association for the Study of Pain (IASP), (2016), pain is described as an undesirable sensory and emotional exposure related to actual or potential tissue injury. Pain is a subjective experience and is the most common reason for a person to seek medical help. Pain is a conscious sensation that is picked up by specialized nociceptive neurons and conducted to the Central nervous system (IASP, 2016). Pain is a physiological, emotional, and a behavioral phenomenon (Bordi, 2014)....   [tags: Pain, Nervous system, Central nervous system]

Research Papers
1283 words (3.7 pages)

Nerve Stimulation : An Effective Method For Reducing Pain Essay

- Transcutaneous nerve stimulation (TENS) forms one of the procedures that have been proposed by various medical providers as an effective method for reducing pain in labor (Mello et al., 2011). In most cases, the application and use of transcutaneous nerve stimulation (TENS) tools involves the emission of low voltage electrical impulse and can vary in frequency as well as intensity. During labor, the transcutaneous nerve stimulation (TENS) electrodes are specifically piled on the lower back in order to reduce pain and other complications (Bedwell et al., 2011)....   [tags: Pain, Suffering, Pain management, Childbirth]

Research Papers
1500 words (4.3 pages)

Pain Management Is Recognized As An Essential Aspect Of Patient Care Essay

- Pain management is recognized as an essential aspect of patient care by The Joint Commission and the World Health Organization along with other national professional organizations and health agencies. The International Association for the Study of Pain (IASP) has the best known and accepted pain definition: Pain is an unpleasant sensory and emotional/affective and cognitive experience that is associated with actual or potential tissue damage or is described in terms of such damage [1]. Pain is always a personal, subjective, unique [2], and multidimensional experience and is affected by the patient’s gender [3], age, culture, previous pain experiences, and emotional factors, such as joy, grie...   [tags: Pain, Suffering, Nursing, Pain management]

Research Papers
1314 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Understanding Family Experiences And Barriers Of Pain Management

- All three of the chosen articles are qualitative in research with a small sample size. This is beneficial because qualitative studies allow individuals to gain an understanding of how phenomena occur and provide in-depth analysis of experiences which is critical in understanding family experiences and barriers in cancer pain management. Although small sample sizes can be less generalizable to populations, the findings have been consistent. In addition, a commonality between these papers is that the authors conclude and stress upon the significance of educating families on pain management and methods, as well and reassessing pain with the assistance of family....   [tags: Pain, Patient, Pain management, Nursing]

Research Papers
872 words (2.5 pages)

The Gift of Pain Essays

- At some point in our lives we all experience suffering. Whether it’s pain caused by an emotionally abusive partner, a narcissistic mother, a neglectful guardian, mental illness, the pain of a separation, or physical ailments; all of us at some point in time will be scarred by the act of living. When we’re faced with these challenges often the pain can feel like it’s too much to bear. We wonder if we’ll ever be whole, if the pain will ever subside, or if we can continue to live at all. It’s difficult to see the big picture when you’re so close to the canvas....   [tags: pain in poetry, art and in politics]

Research Papers
871 words (2.5 pages)

Related Searches

The patient with Berger’s disease and the war veteran also both responded very well after leeching procedures. Overall, all patients’ cases showed significant changes and they reacted equally well to leech therapy.

Conclusions: According to the numerous case studies and researches made by Dr. Grumbine, using biological treatments such as leech therapy in healthcare decreases chronic pain in a more safe and effective manner.


Commentary

This is a very well designed and carried out study. The article is clear and concise. The before-and-after images and extra guidelines all help in understanding leeching procedures for chronic pain management. While leech therapy is an ancient method, it is not an obsolete one.

I was amazed when I found an online paper reporting that leeching procedures (to reduce pain) surpass topical anti-inflammatory treatments. However, the author does not provide enough substantiation. There is no mention of what some of the topical anti-inflammatory treatments are. The author only states that patients had leeches attached ‘70 minutes a day for up to 90 days’.

A similar paper by the Jackson Health System reports that ‘in some cases’ leeches do a better job by removing clotted blood and reduce severe pain than any other medical healing. In Grumbine’s article, he is quite certain that ‘in fact’ leech therapy is ‘much more effective than other traditional chronic pain treatments’.

Evidently, papers comprise of vague and different details on how much leech therapy surpasses topical treatments. Further research should be performed on leech therapy. As Grumbine claims, comparative studies are still required to confirm the effectiveness of leeching procedures for chronic pain management.

We know there are many advantages; leech therapy is cost effective and it can save ‘lives and limbs’. Yet for the moment, the biggest problem is that many people are afraid of these creatures crawling in packs on their bodies.

In summation, I find Grumbine’s article a very well done informative study, and hopefully we will see further studies on this procedure.





Related References

(2004, February 5). Patient Education: Jackson Memorial Hospital. Retrieved April 2, 2004 from http://umjmh.org/HealthLibrary/ORN/Leeches.html

(2004, January 22). About, Inc. Retrieved April 2, 2004 from http://biology.about.com/b/a/059439.htm

(2003, December 21). PBS NATURE. Retrieved April 13, 2004 from http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/bloodysuckers/leech.html

Word Count: 752
Return to 123HelpMe.com